Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

746 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
YerWot · 13/11/2026 16:50

Thinking of you, @AbsentFriends .

It is like standing on the beach, watching family members get swept out to sea.

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 16:52

AbsentFriends · 13/11/2026 16:42

I really appreciate that, thank you.
I do feel reassured by the replies as always on these threads. I was here for a long time (mostly silently) before this happened. None of my core beliefs have changed. But now I feel the extra pain of having to apply what is said here to my child - mostly I try to avoid that as you can imagine.

You don’t need to say thank you @AbsentFriends just understand there are so many of us, men as well as women who are absolutely furious at what has happened.

This is a cult - and as people who have seen contagions and cults before we know we will have to sit things out patiently. When the house of cards falls - which it will - we decent people will welcome our loved ones back into reality with open hearts and open minds.

You sound lovely if not sad. 💐There is no joy in trans ideology as you probably know more than others.

Some great people on here. Lean in to us and our rants.

Courage calls to courage.

Misogynistic bullying to erase women’s rights, indoctrinate children about the gender nonsense doesn’t quite have the same ring to it. 💐

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 16:53

YerWot · 13/11/2026 16:50

Thinking of you, @AbsentFriends .

It is like standing on the beach, watching family members get swept out to sea.

Absolutely @YerWot But we can and will hold hands on the beach and when they need the lifeline there will be many more of us to pull them back, hug them and rebuild them. As we will with @AbsentFriends 💐

YerWot · 13/11/2026 17:20

Thank you so much @BlueLegume that is such a kind and beautiful thing to say. I am deeply touched by your generous words.

CarobBean72 · 13/11/2026 19:00

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:37

There is no such thing as

You could say the same about belief in god & yet people base their whole identities around it. This is no different.

There are beliefs in God / gods.

This is not proof of the existence of god.

There are people who would swear blind they have a gender identity & that it’s VERY important.

Doesn’t mean gender identity exists, or that everyone has one, or that anyone should take claims about it more seriously than the objectively-establishable fact that every human and most species have a sex.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 13/11/2026 19:14

YerWot · 13/11/2026 17:20

Thank you so much @BlueLegume that is such a kind and beautiful thing to say. I am deeply touched by your generous words.

Agreed. Such a lovely reminder of the community of women that's at the heart of this board. So much stronger than the sour, self absorbed blokes mansplaining all over the place.
Flowers Flowers Flowers

CarobBean72 · 13/11/2026 19:17

Transperson · 13/11/2026 02:06

"I am in NZ and the theme is "peoples feelings- no matter how delusional they are- are the reality" and if anyone disagrees they are "bad" people." Rejecting people's lived reality isn't really a nice thing to do yk

There is NO reality in which men can be women, women can be men, or that any mammal is non-binary.

You are allowed to believe in it if you really must, but no sane society should elevate this delusion to the status of rules anyone else must pay lip service to, lose their jobs over, or lose our rights ti single SEX spaces.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 13/11/2026 19:29

CarobBean72 · 13/11/2026 19:17

There is NO reality in which men can be women, women can be men, or that any mammal is non-binary.

You are allowed to believe in it if you really must, but no sane society should elevate this delusion to the status of rules anyone else must pay lip service to, lose their jobs over, or lose our rights ti single SEX spaces.

However, trans identities very clearly reject other people's lived realities, reducing fully realised humans of both sexes to some sort of protected assumptions about a mysterious shared "gender".

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 19:33

CarobBean72 · 13/11/2026 19:00

There are beliefs in God / gods.

This is not proof of the existence of god.

There are people who would swear blind they have a gender identity & that it’s VERY important.

Doesn’t mean gender identity exists, or that everyone has one, or that anyone should take claims about it more seriously than the objectively-establishable fact that every human and most species have a sex.

NB Talking about belief in God specifically,
not religions per se, especially not fundamentalist ones, or factions of them.

I wish people would stop the comparison between belief in a trans self and a person’s belief in God, understandable though that is at first glance on the grounds that “God does not really exist”.

That belief in God is private and can remain that way, or be shared among other individual believers without coercion of others who do not share the belief.

(Fundamentalists obviously are coercive but I am not talking about belief in them.)

Belief in God involves looking outwards from the self to an idea of a higher, infinitely creative and loving goodness beyond, and without limits. Who is to say this does not exist? But if it doesn’t, belief in it can bring hope and inspiration and does no harm.

On the other hand genderism seems to be about the self. A ‘self’ transformed to another sex/gender which other people are expected to endorse.
Also belief in God does not generally lead to dangerous body modifications.

kitex · 13/11/2026 19:44

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 19:33

NB Talking about belief in God specifically,
not religions per se, especially not fundamentalist ones, or factions of them.

I wish people would stop the comparison between belief in a trans self and a person’s belief in God, understandable though that is at first glance on the grounds that “God does not really exist”.

That belief in God is private and can remain that way, or be shared among other individual believers without coercion of others who do not share the belief.

(Fundamentalists obviously are coercive but I am not talking about belief in them.)

Belief in God involves looking outwards from the self to an idea of a higher, infinitely creative and loving goodness beyond, and without limits. Who is to say this does not exist? But if it doesn’t, belief in it can bring hope and inspiration and does no harm.

On the other hand genderism seems to be about the self. A ‘self’ transformed to another sex/gender which other people are expected to endorse.
Also belief in God does not generally lead to dangerous body modifications.

“Also belief in God does not generally lead to dangerous body modifications.”

Male circumcision and female genital mutilation.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 19:50

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:37

There is no such thing as

You could say the same about belief in god & yet people base their whole identities around it. This is no different.

My aunt basing her entire identity around her adult conversion to Roman Catholicism doesn't make the Christian god objectively real and doesn't mean that everyone else has to start going to Mass.

Civilised societies are characterised by the following features concerning religion:

  • Disbelief in gods, aka atheism, is tolerated in law and policy.
  • Differences in religious belief and practice are tolerated in law and policy.
  • Believers and non-believers alike are protected from harassment.
  • Discrimination on the basis of belief or disbelief is unlawful unless a service provider or employer can justify it.
  • Compelled worship is unlawful.
  • Compelled professions of faith are unlawful.
  • Accommodating people's religious practice is limited to accommodating practices that do not infringe upon the rights of others.

Applying those features to the belief in gender identity allows those who feel uncomfortable with their sex to crossdress and call themselves a different name. It doesn't allow them to harrass dissenters, walk into opposite-sex spaces, or insist upon inaccurate pronouns.

Yet, until Forstater, Phoenix, Peggie, the Darlington Nurses, FWS, et al came along and fought back through the courts, we had workplaces where men were walking into women's spaces and forcing use of inaccurate pronouns, with dissenting women victimised in the Equality Act sense of the word.

The Church of England could not obtain a change in ny employer's policies to force me to pray at work. The Roman Catholic church could not obtain a change of policy to force me to say a rosary at work. All the Christian denominations in the UK acting together were not able to block the legalisation of Sunday supermarket trading, and they tried!

Yet the trans lobby was able to influence policies in companies the world over to get men allowed into women's loos, compelled use of inaccurate pronouns, and silencing of dissenters.

When a lobby has more political power globally than the Roman Catholic church, the people it represents are not oppressed in the slightest.

When a lobby has more political power in the UK than the State church that literally has bishops sitting in the Lords, the people it represents are not oppressed in the slightest.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 13/11/2026 19:52

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 19:33

NB Talking about belief in God specifically,
not religions per se, especially not fundamentalist ones, or factions of them.

I wish people would stop the comparison between belief in a trans self and a person’s belief in God, understandable though that is at first glance on the grounds that “God does not really exist”.

That belief in God is private and can remain that way, or be shared among other individual believers without coercion of others who do not share the belief.

(Fundamentalists obviously are coercive but I am not talking about belief in them.)

Belief in God involves looking outwards from the self to an idea of a higher, infinitely creative and loving goodness beyond, and without limits. Who is to say this does not exist? But if it doesn’t, belief in it can bring hope and inspiration and does no harm.

On the other hand genderism seems to be about the self. A ‘self’ transformed to another sex/gender which other people are expected to endorse.
Also belief in God does not generally lead to dangerous body modifications.

I'd like to endorse this to a certain extent. I think it is a slightly lazy analogy and won't help to win the argument with anyone who does have a belief in God or who is maybe just agnostic. When phrased well it can work, but quite often it just comes across as a bit 'smug atheist'.

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 19:52

kitex · 13/11/2026 19:44

“Also belief in God does not generally lead to dangerous body modifications.”

Male circumcision and female genital mutilation.

Yes I agree but that linked to religion.
I specifically mentioned belief in God not a religion.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 19:55

kitex · 13/11/2026 19:44

“Also belief in God does not generally lead to dangerous body modifications.”

Male circumcision and female genital mutilation.

FGM is geographically correlated, not religiously correlated.

You're not wrong about circumcision.

kitex · 13/11/2026 19:57

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 19:52

Yes I agree but that linked to religion.
I specifically mentioned belief in God not a religion.

God and religion are intertwined, but you are right, they represent two fundamentally different concepts.

Catiette · 13/11/2026 20:03

caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:44

Are you familiar with William ‘ Lia’ Thomas

Both my son & daughter played in mixed football teams when they were between the ages of 5 to 7 where the girls were bigger, stronger & more talented than the boys until they weren't so no biggie. Context & nuance matters that extremists always seem to miss.

Edited

Context & nuance matters that extremists always seem to miss.

This would come across so much better if it weren't for the unconscious irony (or maybe paradox, even 🤔?)

Catiette · 13/11/2026 20:08

Also, the science in fact shows, I think, that boys have the advantage even at that age, if only very subtly indeed and on average. As with adult women, superior size doesn't correlate to superior strength, although this difference is obviously more pronounced after puberty. With regard to which, gently, I think it's worth noting in relation to your analogy that the physical difference between the sexes expands from a mere sliver to an almost insurmountable gulf between childhood and adulthood. I'd say nuance matters, but this bit isn't so much nuance as... common knowledge?

kitex · 13/11/2026 20:08

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 19:55

FGM is geographically correlated, not religiously correlated.

You're not wrong about circumcision.

FGM is practised in a lot of Muslim countries though. I know it predates major religions.

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 20:32

Remember I was not talking about religions or their practices.

GriseldaandMike · 13/11/2026 21:11

Both my son & daughter played in mixed football teams when they were between the ages of 5 to 7 where the girls were bigger, stronger & more talented than the boys until they weren't so no biggie

Children being mixed in sport at an age when they can barely retain the rules of the game and all chase the ball like bees on flower works OK, then it didn't because the boys were bigger, stronger and faster but if we ignore that it stopped being safe or fair we should do it all levels. OK so women would leave sport in droves and those that didn't would risk serious injury and no woman would ever win an Olympic medal ever again but hey the 6 year old were happy.

🙄

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:16

Catiette · 13/11/2026 20:08

Also, the science in fact shows, I think, that boys have the advantage even at that age, if only very subtly indeed and on average. As with adult women, superior size doesn't correlate to superior strength, although this difference is obviously more pronounced after puberty. With regard to which, gently, I think it's worth noting in relation to your analogy that the physical difference between the sexes expands from a mere sliver to an almost insurmountable gulf between childhood and adulthood. I'd say nuance matters, but this bit isn't so much nuance as... common knowledge?

Edited

The logical flaw here is averages say nothing about individuals nor does it say anything about how grading in sports works to mitigate physical advantages & risks that also occurs within a sex.

If any of this were a real problem mixed teams would cease to exist in practical reality but instead they continue to flourish for many reasons including a desire for parents to socialise their children with the opposite sex that's ironically completely lost on gender critical 'feminists'.

Most sport played isn't at the elite level & isn't just about 'winning' but is motivated by character building, social & health reasons. Sport teaches children valuable psychological skills that translate to real world personal & social benefits in their day to day lives that a reductionist 'winning' approach ignores.

I do wonder if people actually have parental experience commenting on this forum.

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 21:23

Being gender critical is like being trapped in the corner of the room with a solipsistic teenager who has just finished their first term of school debating club, and no-one noticing your frantically darting eyes silently begging for an escape route.

More of these just keep occurring to me for some reason. I can't imagine where they're coming from.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 21:27

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:16

The logical flaw here is averages say nothing about individuals nor does it say anything about how grading in sports works to mitigate physical advantages & risks that also occurs within a sex.

If any of this were a real problem mixed teams would cease to exist in practical reality but instead they continue to flourish for many reasons including a desire for parents to socialise their children with the opposite sex that's ironically completely lost on gender critical 'feminists'.

Most sport played isn't at the elite level & isn't just about 'winning' but is motivated by character building, social & health reasons. Sport teaches children valuable psychological skills that translate to real world personal & social benefits in their day to day lives that a reductionist 'winning' approach ignores.

I do wonder if people actually have parental experience commenting on this forum.

Edited

Children above the age of puberty are generally prohibited from mixed-sex formal competition in sports where sex is relevant to performance or safety.

We routinely segregate sporting competitions by age and weight as well.

We practice this segregation at all levels, even Parkrun.

Your comments are not reflective of the reality of amateur competitive sport.

GaIadriel · 13/11/2026 21:27

I just don't want to shower with dudes.

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 21:32

GaIadriel · 13/11/2026 21:27

I just don't want to shower with dudes.

Outrageous. Just take your soma and repeat after me: Everyone belongs to everyone else.

Being gender critical feels like stepping into an immersive theatre of all your favourite dystopias.