Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 20:47

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 18:52

I believe women have rights. I am a woman. I don't think their privacy is something to be negotiated away- my privacy is important to me.

Equally trans people have exactly the same rights to dignity and privacy

the question is how to manage services/ facilities accommodate everyone's needs/ privacy/ dignity.

That isn't answered by pp's demanding that their personal "boundaries" are the only ones that matter and that they can dictate who is and isn't entitled to use a facility based on providing or refusing their personal consent- that's not how it works.

@Lacksie, women are saying no to sharing female-only intimate spaces with males. Why are you not addressing what those women are telling you?
I have explicitly distinguished individual permission from a justified sex-based eligibility rule. Repeating the individual-permission argument does not answer that.
Women are equal human beings with rights, privacy and dignity of their own. Recognising that must mean accepting that a justified boundary can limit male access.
You say everyone’s needs matter. Then answer directly: when, in your proposed balance, can female-only provision remain female-only, including excluding trans women?

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:49

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 20:44

No @Transperson

Firstly you are deceiving yourself. You are a man. You are not being yourself.
Secondly you have not ‘attacked’ anyone? You have been very confrontational.

There are many posters on here who are very clear you have violated spaces and seem to revel in it. Please consider that this thread has clearly hit a nerve for many contributors.

You seem oblivious.

That's quite rude claim actually. You can call it a delusion if you wish but again my lived experience isn't for you to agree on.
I mean I'm listening and responding. Although I feel like I have been responding for the exact same messages now for a while, maybe it's time to call this quits.

OP posts:
Moondropmum · 10/11/2026 20:50

TheHereticalOne · 10/11/2026 20:46

I have plenty of male friends and they are the most lovely of people also just living their lives being who they are. Should they also be able to come into women's single sex spaces on that basis? If not, why not?

Personally I wouldn't care less who was in the bathroom as long as they were just there to do their business which the over whelming majority of trans people are and I'm sure men would be. You could even be attacked by another women in the bathroom if we're going to be scared of everyone existing in the same space as us.

Moondropmum · 10/11/2026 20:50

TheHereticalOne · 10/11/2026 20:46

I have plenty of male friends and they are the most lovely of people also just living their lives being who they are. Should they also be able to come into women's single sex spaces on that basis? If not, why not?

Personally I wouldn't care less who was in the bathroom as long as they were just there to do their business which the over whelming majority of trans people are and I'm sure men would be. You could even be attacked by another women in the bathroom if we're going to be scared of everyone existing in the same space as us.

CreativeGreen · 10/11/2026 20:50

Moondropmum · 10/11/2026 20:47

But trans women aren't "males" they are trans women 🙄 and by dealings how well do you actually know them because I've been room mates with my trans friends and I would trust my trans woman friend in a changing room, in the same bathroom as me as much as I would ANY of my biological friends. I've seen her struggles, I've seen her have to take medications just to live her life as who she is on the inside. People like you are ignorant and rude. "Oh they're trying to sneak into my toilet cause they're actually men!" No, no they are not. They're trying to use the womens bathroom because the males bathroom is as if not more dangerous for them. Men wouldn't go through the process of transitioning just to sneak into a bathroom they would just do it.

I’d trust my male partner in any space. Does it mean he should be allowed in the women’s loos? Or that all men should?

anecdotes don’t mean much

Scout2016 · 10/11/2026 20:51

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:38

I'm just being myself, not deceiving anyone, I'm not here to attack anyone.

Of course you are! You are pretending to be a woman, you are deliberately misleading everyone around you. You decieve other people to think you are something you are not! That's exactly what passing or trying to pass is.
People treat you the way they do because, according to you, they think you are a woman. They think that because you tell them that, you maintain the pretence and you change your appearance to decive people into thinking you are a woman. You take away their option of making an informed choice about how to behave around you.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 20:51

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:45

If we share single sex space and you see me, lmk. Otherwise the internet doesn't really count.

So far from being a woman, you don't even give a shit about them or what they think.

callmeLoretta1 · 10/11/2026 20:51

Moondropmum · 10/11/2026 20:47

But trans women aren't "males" they are trans women 🙄 and by dealings how well do you actually know them because I've been room mates with my trans friends and I would trust my trans woman friend in a changing room, in the same bathroom as me as much as I would ANY of my biological friends. I've seen her struggles, I've seen her have to take medications just to live her life as who she is on the inside. People like you are ignorant and rude. "Oh they're trying to sneak into my toilet cause they're actually men!" No, no they are not. They're trying to use the womens bathroom because the males bathroom is as if not more dangerous for them. Men wouldn't go through the process of transitioning just to sneak into a bathroom they would just do it.

All transwomen are male. That is literally the PREREQUISITE to being a transwoman. They don't change their male chromosomes or DNA, they remain as the male sex. Even they themselves, admit this.

So because you know them, you expect everyone to trust them to? No, you are the ignorant and rude one.

The male toilets are NOT dangerous for transwomen, they themselves have said the worst they get is a smirk. It's about VALIDATION, it never was about safety. Otherwise they would have advocated for third spaces/gender neutral spaces, in addition to male/female. Even if they were at risk, women are not HUMAN SHIELDS for males who are being picked on. They need to sort their own male attacking male problems out themselves. You do not put a picked on fox in the hen house.

Less than 8% of men have the surgery. With self-ID, they don't need to do ANYTHING.

CreativeGreen · 10/11/2026 20:52

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:49

That's quite rude claim actually. You can call it a delusion if you wish but again my lived experience isn't for you to agree on.
I mean I'm listening and responding. Although I feel like I have been responding for the exact same messages now for a while, maybe it's time to call this quits.

maybe it's time to call this quits

it isn’t quits.

TheHereticalOne · 10/11/2026 20:52

Moondropmum · 10/11/2026 20:47

But trans women aren't "males" they are trans women 🙄 and by dealings how well do you actually know them because I've been room mates with my trans friends and I would trust my trans woman friend in a changing room, in the same bathroom as me as much as I would ANY of my biological friends. I've seen her struggles, I've seen her have to take medications just to live her life as who she is on the inside. People like you are ignorant and rude. "Oh they're trying to sneak into my toilet cause they're actually men!" No, no they are not. They're trying to use the womens bathroom because the males bathroom is as if not more dangerous for them. Men wouldn't go through the process of transitioning just to sneak into a bathroom they would just do it.

The mens bathroom is also dangerous for my slight, gay friends. Should they also be able to use womens single sex spaces? If not, why not?

I would also trust my husband, brother, male friends in a changing room or loo as much as I would any of my female friends. Should they also be able to use womens single sex spaces? If not, why not?

Also, the objection is not, "they're trying to sneak into the women's bathroom because they are men" it's "they're trying to sneak into the women's bathroom while being men".

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:52

Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:40

So says the guy who has a heartfelt belief we should up the speed limit a bit - it works in Germany, he's done the research.

This is the schoolkid's defence on being called out on any transgression: "But I was just..."

It's best summed up as, "My case is different. Because it's my case."

Edited

I already articulated in the other post the main reasons why trans people are their own category. Tldr there are biological differences between non trans men and trans women

And there are biological differences between trans women and non trans women

OP posts:
SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 20:53

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:01

@Transperson
I’m a man and the father of a daughter. I’m not speaking on behalf of all women, but I have a responsibility to look out for my daughter and take women’s concerns about privacy, dignity and safety seriously.

OP, your respectful tone is appreciated, as is your agreement about words such as mother and breastfeeding. But listening also means accepting that women’s answer may be no.

You ask why people dislike trans people.
I do not dislike people for being trans. I object when women’s boundaries are crossed and their objections are treated as hostility. Live and let live includes respecting women’s privacy, dignity and female-only intimate spaces. These are legitimate interests, not evidence of hatred.

You say nobody has noticed or objected.
You cannot know that. Women may remain silent because they are frightened, embarrassed or unwilling to risk confrontation—particularly while undressed. The power imbalance matters. A woman may hurry, leave or avoid returning rather than challenge you. No confrontation does not mean no objection. Assuming otherwise overlooks precisely the vulnerability women are explaining.

You say you behave respectfully and wear a swimsuit.
The boundary concerns your presence as a male in a female-only intimate space, not your clothes or intentions. Covering yourself does not protect another woman’s privacy while she changes. She does not have to prove you dangerous before her privacy matters. Respecting a boundary includes accepting that it applies to you.

You argue that medical transition changes your phenotype.
Medical treatment can change sex characteristics; it does not change reproductive sex. Appearance cannot provide a consistent basis for female-only provision. The Supreme Court confirmed that “sex”, “woman” and “man” in the Equality Act refer to biological sex, while trans people retain protection against gender-reassignment discrimination. Protecting one group does not erase the other’s protections. Supreme Court summary

You use small Scottish prisoner numbers to dismiss offending concerns.
Dividing trans prisoners by Scotland’s entire population does not calculate the imprisonment rate among trans people. A small population percentage is not a confidence interval, either.
The recent England and Wales figures deserve attention. On 31 March 2024, 151 of 245 recorded transgender prisoners whose legal sex was male had sexual-offence convictions: 61.6%. That category included people identifying as women, non-binary or gender-fluid. Ministerial answer
The corresponding sentenced-male prison table recorded 14,138 sexual-offence prisoners out of 68,204: 20.7%.61.6 ÷ 20.7 ≈ 3. That is the arithmetic behind the “three times” comparison. These differently defined prisoner groups cannot establish offending rates in the wider population, but the figures warrant serious scrutiny of prison safeguarding. MoJ table 1.Q.5

You argue that individual offenders should not determine access rules.
Safeguarding considers foreseeable risks, vulnerability and opportunity before harm occurs. Sex is relevant: men accounted for 97% of sentences for sexual offences in England and Wales in the year ending June 2024. Women cannot reliably assess each stranger’s intentions while undressed, and should not have to. Ministry of Justice
Failures have real victims: Karen White sexually assaulted female prisoners. Isla Bryson was convicted of two rapes committed before transition.
Where female-only provision meets the Equality Act’s conditions and is proportionate, it can exclude all male service users, including trans women, without proving each individual dangerous. Personal assurances of good behaviour do not override a justified sex-based boundary. EHRC guidance

You cite research as settling the safety question.
The Massachusetts study found no detectable increase in police-recorded incidents following inclusive access policies. That finding should be acknowledged. But incidents were rare, some locality data were incomplete, and the records could not distinguish trans from non-trans perpetrators. It did not measure women remaining silent, avoiding facilities or losing ordinary bodily privacy. Those limitations restrict what it answers; they do not reverse its finding. Original study
A Swedish cohort covering 1973–2003 found criminal-conviction rates among male-to-female participants higher than female controls and not statistically different from male controls. That historical finding cannot establish present-day UK risk either. Neither paper settles whether women should have female-only intimate provision.Original Swedish study

You describe trans people’s vulnerability and your own experiences of harassment.
Those experiences deserve sympathy and practical protection. Harassment should be addressed. It does not establish entitlement to female-only facilities or require women to surrender their privacy, security and dignity. Additional private and unisex provision can address competing needs. Women should not automatically bear the cost of resolving somebody else’s vulnerability.

You say you want to understand women.
Then what happens when women explain their boundary and their answer remains no? Do you respect it, or continue regardless?
Entering a female-only intimate space leaves objecting women to tolerate it, confront you or leave. That puts the burden on women. Taking access and then expecting women to justify their objections gives your wishes priority over theirs.

Treating women as equals means giving women’s privacy and autonomy real weight—including when that limits what you want. Are you listening to the boundaries women are explaining, or only for an answer that permits you to cross them?

Live and let live must work both ways. Women’s boundaries do not become hatred because somebody dislikes being bound by them.

@Transperson - still waiting for your response to these.

brownbootsandhats · 10/11/2026 20:54

Their own category

at long last !

yes their own category

transowmen are not women they are their own category

trabsowmwn therefore don’t need women’s spaces they need they own spaces

yes yes yes ! Get the party started

Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:55

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:45

If we share single sex space and you see me, lmk. Otherwise the internet doesn't really count.

Congrats on being the arbiter of all that counts. That's quite something.

I agree with the comment about OP likely being very young. It would be endearing if the context weren't so distressingly serious from both perspectives.

Just before I go, in line with earlier posts, a sympathetic helping hand to a struggling Lacksie.

That isn't answered by Pp's are presumably demanding arguing that their personal "boundaries" are the only ones that matter and that they can dictate who is and isn't entitled to use a facility based on providing or refusing their personal consent- represent the component parts of a wider social contract which, without said personal boundaries, wouldn't even exist. that's not how This is, of course exactly how it works! However, the real question is, which group's personal boundaries should be given more weight? I would argue strongly that transpeople's right to self-definition outweighs women's visceral fear at males' 150+% strength and 98% higher rate of sexual offending, because...

I'll leave the rest to Lacksie.

Frankly, I've not got a bloody clue how it ends.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 20:55

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 20:51

So far from being a woman, you don't even give a shit about them or what they think.

Its bizarre why do transwomen think they are acting like a women when they mansplain to women what a women is? It's literally demonstrating a very male trait.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 20:56

Moondropmum · 10/11/2026 20:50

Personally I wouldn't care less who was in the bathroom as long as they were just there to do their business which the over whelming majority of trans people are and I'm sure men would be. You could even be attacked by another women in the bathroom if we're going to be scared of everyone existing in the same space as us.

That’s nice, maybe you can use the third spaces then too to make the men who identify as women feel better and keep them company, most women do care and we don’t want men in the ladies’. Hope that helps.

OldCrone · 10/11/2026 20:57

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:41

"The whole ‘women must like long hair, make up, skirts, pink, gentle games, caring careers’ is a toxic stereotype of gender" agreed.

"Trans ideology is trying to drag us back to the bad old days where boys couldn’t play with dolls or wear pink/skirts/long hair/make up, and girls couldn’t play ‘rough’ sports or be mechanics."

Not really, I care about not enforcing this stereotype. I wear trousers quite often, I sometimes don't wear makeup, etc etc

I definitely would enforce it upon others

But you said this earlier.

Being trans is already breaking a social contract, as not limiting myself to a box that was arbitrary put on me in terms of how I meant meant to present myself in society.

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

If you weren't talking about not wanting to comply with male stereotypes, what were you talking about?

Why couldn't you just be a man who didn't define himself by outdated stereotypes?

How can you be yourself when you're constantly pretending to be something you're not?

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 20:58

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:49

That's quite rude claim actually. You can call it a delusion if you wish but again my lived experience isn't for you to agree on.
I mean I'm listening and responding. Although I feel like I have been responding for the exact same messages now for a while, maybe it's time to call this quits.

Think of it like when everyone thought the world was flat. The lived experience of those who believed the earth was flat was that it was flat. They had no visual evidence to the counter. That didn't stop the objective reality being that they were wrong.

Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:58

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:52

I already articulated in the other post the main reasons why trans people are their own category. Tldr there are biological differences between non trans men and trans women

And there are biological differences between trans women and non trans women

If you mean brains, I think the commonly cited studies didn't control for homosexuality (other posters are better on this than me). If you mean bodies, you appear to be excluding self-ID. Regardless, this misses the point with what would be endearing naivety, if the context weren't so important.

Put simply, anyone and everyone can say they're "a different category", and many do. The epithet "a law unto themselves" tells us exactly why society can't function that way.

TheHereticalOne · 10/11/2026 20:59

Moondropmum · 10/11/2026 20:50

Personally I wouldn't care less who was in the bathroom as long as they were just there to do their business which the over whelming majority of trans people are and I'm sure men would be. You could even be attacked by another women in the bathroom if we're going to be scared of everyone existing in the same space as us.

Cool. You have just made all spaces mixed sex and a) increased the rate of sexual crime against women and b) caused a further tranche of women to self-exclude from public services. Because time and again that is the statistical consequence of mixed space as compared to single sex spaces for women due to the thoroughly disproportionate number of male offenders as compared to female offenders.

Personally, I would require people who make the Cool Girl arguments you do to sit down with victims of it and explain exactly why you removed the proven safeguard that reduces it and whether you intend to continue to argue against it being reinstated.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 20:59

Moondropmum · 10/11/2026 20:47

But trans women aren't "males" they are trans women 🙄 and by dealings how well do you actually know them because I've been room mates with my trans friends and I would trust my trans woman friend in a changing room, in the same bathroom as me as much as I would ANY of my biological friends. I've seen her struggles, I've seen her have to take medications just to live her life as who she is on the inside. People like you are ignorant and rude. "Oh they're trying to sneak into my toilet cause they're actually men!" No, no they are not. They're trying to use the womens bathroom because the males bathroom is as if not more dangerous for them. Men wouldn't go through the process of transitioning just to sneak into a bathroom they would just do it.

They are males. They literally are just a group of men, who have persuaded you of their dubious claim to be women. They haven’t persuaded me or most of the population.

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 20:59

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 20:02

Recognising the distinction between someone’s mere presence and an actual assault does not mean waiting until an assault occurs before taking preventive action.

My objection was to the claim that this distinction is irrelevant. By treating the difference between someone who has violated another person’s consent and bodily autonomy and someone who has not as inconsequential, you are fundamentally devaluing the very concepts you claim to be safeguarding.

That you apparently cannot see why a survivor of sexual violence might find this profoundly disturbing, and to dismiss it as "ignorance of facts", is extraordinary.

Edited

@Lacksie, presence and assault are plainly different. I am not treating them as equivalent.
But the absence of assault does not settle whether women should have female-only intimate provision. Women can reasonably object to male presence while undressing without accusing anyone of a crime. The Code recognises privacy and dignity as legitimate reasons for single-sex services. Paragraphs 13.107–13.116.
Women’s privacy matters in its own right. Explaining that nobody has been assaulted does not answer their objection to losing it.

Equality Act 2010: Code of Practice for services, public functions and associations, 2026

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/equality-act-2010-code-of-practice-for-services-public-functions-and-associations-2026/equality-act-2010-draft-code-of-practice-for-services-public-functions-and-associations-2026

TheHereticalOne · 10/11/2026 20:59

Cool. You have just made all spaces mixed sex and a) increased the rate of sexual crime against women and b) caused a further tranche of women to self-exclude from public services. Because time and again that is the statistical consequence of mixed space as compared to single sex spaces for women due to the thoroughly disproportionate number of male offenders as compared to female offenders.

Personally, I would require people who make the Cool Girl arguments you do to sit down with victims of it and explain exactly why you removed the proven safeguard that reduces it and whether you intend to continue to argue against it being reinstated.

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:59

OldCrone · 10/11/2026 20:57

But you said this earlier.

Being trans is already breaking a social contract, as not limiting myself to a box that was arbitrary put on me in terms of how I meant meant to present myself in society.

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

If you weren't talking about not wanting to comply with male stereotypes, what were you talking about?

Why couldn't you just be a man who didn't define himself by outdated stereotypes?

How can you be yourself when you're constantly pretending to be something you're not?

By transitioing I broke the social contract for men and society opted the other gender role on me.

OP posts:
womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 20:59

I mean I like to at least think we're saving some poor mother somewhere from having the same tedious 'but I want to' tantrum for the eleventy billionth time. Or listening to some tedious word salad when she's trying, on her own naturally with no help from the word salader, to cook dinner, or do the washing or something useful.

I've posted twice on this thread and I have actual stuff to do so won't be posting again. The key thing about these threads is that the OP clearly isn't doing his own washing or housework. But I do think he should tidy his room.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.