Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sex Matters Hampstead Heath Ponds - Thread 2

182 replies

rebax · 04/11/2026 15:21

Next thread on second day in court

Continuation from
Sex Matters - Hampstead Heath Ponds - | Mumsnet

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Justabaker · 05/11/2026 11:37

I've had a message asking for some visual description....I wish I could draw but if I drew an animal you would struggle to decide if it was a giraffe or a sparrow.

Courtroom - it looks like Rumpole at the Bailey but more run down and cluttered. Wood panelling, benches that look a lot like pews for spectators, slightly wider bench at the front for the barristers - although Crash relegated to second row as not enough room in front. Those pews are the least comfortable public seating I have ever encountered.

Admin clerk on the lower bench, he was running the video conference for the JR. You know that one that almost no one got access to. Admin clerk got a 10 minute break morning and afternoon, someone came into spell him. Above him the judge's bench. At either side a 'box' seating area, one usually a press box and the other a witness box. No witnesses in a JR.

Top bench the judge, nice comfy chair (I observe with a tinge of envy).

Overlay the very Victorian court with two big video screens, microphones hanging from the ceiling for transcription and the CVP, leads snaking everywhere as the barristers engage in a polite bunfight for the few power points. The many law books on the bookcases lining the walls have not been touched in some time - dust reigns supreme.

Judge - robes, no wig
TC, SS, DS, KE - all in robes and wigs, they carry their wigs around like little pets.

HS, CS - robes no wig.

The freelance journo gave me Crash's name and I said 'what' thinking I misheard, she said 'I think it's a great name'. Me, 'well my husband calls me Sid when we're doing DIY together'. Poker face.

Judge and DS

My assessment is he went through his judicial gears with DS. He has an admirable ability to sit and listen and is obviously concentrating because any observations he makes or questions he asks are absolutely on point. Will note down page numbers and make the odd note but he is not transcribing.

Started out listening, asking the occasional question, or for a reference, etc.

[Both male barristers were inclined to flatter and make jokes with the judge, there were a number of references to a decision he gave on Michaela School, another case where he was counsel for the winning side, and a fair amount of 'of course My Lord would be familiar with that....' Not so much the women].

As DS went on, the judge became more actively engaged and was asking questions, making comments and interjecting. I think these were in the main captured by TT. His comments and a couple of aside remarks indicated he had been reading overnight. DS has a habit when referred to things that support his case, to give a page reference then gabble out the text very quickly. Think TT gave up trying to get those down in any detail. Judge's questions got increasingly uncomfortable for DS if his response time and demeanour were any indication.

Back to bread, will return.

MyAmpleSheep · 05/11/2026 11:39

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 07:24

Surely on the face of it, even if it had nothing to do with trans issues, that would be bog standard sex discrimination, if you assume that more women 'live as women' and more men 'live as men'?

The only way it wouldn't be sex discrimination would be if you assumed that men lived equally as men and women and women lived equally as men and women and the different modes of living had nothing to do with sex? A bit odd, but all fine as long as you don't actually want to exclude anyone and the facility is just mixed sex.

My understanding of the law is that a policy that affects “more women than men” or “women more than men” or similar is indirect discrimination, which can be lawful if it’s a PMOAALA. If it’s simply a proxy for only women, then it’s direct discrimination which can’t be justified in law at all.

Example: you can’t work here because you are Sikh: direct discrimination, and unlawful.

You can’t work here because you (genuinely) have to wear a special helmet which won’t fit over the turban you have, which is more likely to affect Sikh men - lawful.

The question is, “you can’t enter because you don’t live as a woman” - is that so close to “you can’t enter because you’re a woman” that it’s really the same thing and therefore direct discrimination? Or is it not the same thing, it’s indirect discrimination, and therefore capable of being justified (by being the least intrusive measure etc. etc.) And if so, is it actually justified?

I think we will get a judicial answer to some of these questions in the judgement.

I think I have that right but happy to be corrected.

And I am fairly sure the losing side will appeal. Or both sides on a cross appeal.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 11:56

MyAmpleSheep · 05/11/2026 11:39

My understanding of the law is that a policy that affects “more women than men” or “women more than men” or similar is indirect discrimination, which can be lawful if it’s a PMOAALA. If it’s simply a proxy for only women, then it’s direct discrimination which can’t be justified in law at all.

Example: you can’t work here because you are Sikh: direct discrimination, and unlawful.

You can’t work here because you (genuinely) have to wear a special helmet which won’t fit over the turban you have, which is more likely to affect Sikh men - lawful.

The question is, “you can’t enter because you don’t live as a woman” - is that so close to “you can’t enter because you’re a woman” that it’s really the same thing and therefore direct discrimination? Or is it not the same thing, it’s indirect discrimination, and therefore capable of being justified (by being the least intrusive measure etc. etc.) And if so, is it actually justified?

I think we will get a judicial answer to some of these questions in the judgement.

I think I have that right but happy to be corrected.

And I am fairly sure the losing side will appeal. Or both sides on a cross appeal.

Yes, this case seems relatively trivial on the face of it to the casual observer, I imagine, but I agree it will be appealed because the issues raised are pivotal.

Peregrina · 05/11/2026 12:14

Will this then lead to someone defining in law, what 'living as a woman' actually means?

It's not just wearing make up and a dress, plus long hair, whatever the Beth Uptons and others of the world would have us believe.

CatProcrastinator1 · 05/11/2026 12:22

@Justabaker Thank you so much.
Has Sex Matters been able to comment on the methodology of the survey anywhere?

Tears0fTheMushroom · 05/11/2026 12:22

Peregrina · 05/11/2026 12:14

Will this then lead to someone defining in law, what 'living as a woman' actually means?

It's not just wearing make up and a dress, plus long hair, whatever the Beth Uptons and others of the world would have us believe.

I shouldn't think so as there can't BE a definition of such a nebulous concept.
How long have we been asking for one now?

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 12:25

Tears0fTheMushroom · 05/11/2026 12:22

I shouldn't think so as there can't BE a definition of such a nebulous concept.
How long have we been asking for one now?

I think it might have something to do with changing your name, but what if your name is Taylor?

Justabaker · 05/11/2026 12:29

CatProcrastinator1 · 05/11/2026 12:22

@Justabaker Thank you so much.
Has Sex Matters been able to comment on the methodology of the survey anywhere?

I think Jo Phoenix's WS explored the methodology of the survey.

Szygy · 05/11/2026 12:36

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 12:25

I think it might have something to do with changing your name, but what if your name is Taylor?

Or Crash…

MyAmpleSheep · 05/11/2026 12:39

spannasaurus · 05/11/2026 12:37

Crash Krylova was previously known as Crash Wigley. He's been discussed on this board previously but I can' remember whether it was connected to a tribunal/legal case or the article on FWS

https://ukconstitutionallaw.org/2025/05/06/crash-wigley-for-women-scotland-a-case-of-significant-silences/

He wrote a widely disseminated critique of the FWS judgment that Naomi Cunningham burnt to a cinder on the Legal Feminist website. That’s where I first heard his name.

CatProcrastinator1 · 05/11/2026 12:48

Justabaker · 05/11/2026 12:29

I think Jo Phoenix's WS explored the methodology of the survey.

Thank you.

MyAmpleSheep · 05/11/2026 12:54

MyAmpleSheep · 05/11/2026 12:39

He wrote a widely disseminated critique of the FWS judgment that Naomi Cunningham burnt to a cinder on the Legal Feminist website. That’s where I first heard his name.

Sorry - it was Michael Foran. Apologies to both of them:

knowingius.org/p/for-women-scotland-is-legal-recognition?utm_source=publication-search

Tears0fTheMushroom · 05/11/2026 13:00

AngleofRepose · 05/11/2026 08:29

sideline... I love Mushroom Cat! ❤😻

...as you were...

Mushroomcat thanks you for your appreciation. But he's come over all bashful now 🙀

Sex Matters Hampstead Heath Ponds - Thread 2
BiologicalRobot · 05/11/2026 13:05

MyAmpleSheep · 05/11/2026 12:39

He wrote a widely disseminated critique of the FWS judgment that Naomi Cunningham burnt to a cinder on the Legal Feminist website. That’s where I first heard his name.

Crashed and burned?

I must say Mushroomcat is adorable 😍

Tears0fTheMushroom · 05/11/2026 13:05

Szygy · 05/11/2026 12:36

Or Crash…

The only Crash I am familiar with is Crash Bandicoot.
Showing my age now.

(Oh and Crash Override from Hackers) Goddess I'm old 😭

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 13:10

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 19:08

I was correct in my thought that Daniel Stilitz KC had worked with GLP, he led the unsuccessful EHRC challenge so not surprising to see some of the same arguments here. At times he was up against Tom Cross KC acting for EHRC, just like he’s up against him now!

https://www.11kbw.com/knowledge-events/news/judgment-handed-down-on-ehrc-interim-update/

Naomi Cunningham reposted this yesterday - I haven’t listened to the podcast and will do so but she calls out that in the podcast Stilitz is using activist language and repeating TRA talking points as if factual or neutral. He’s particularly critical of the Darlington Nurses, and the judgment.

Conclusion

I will end where I started, with the question of neutrality.
Stilitz uncritically uses activist language, referring to men who say they are women as “she” and those who do not claim a gender identity at odds with reality as “cis”. He frames the conflict as one between unqualified “trans rights” on the one hand and “what are perceived to be the competing rights asserted by… gender critical feminists” on the other. He betrays a disdain for the female claimants in the Darlington case, whom he frames as guilty of a kind of bigotry that would be less charitably treated if it were focused on a different protected characteristic (by which he also implies that the tribunal was “transphobic” in its indulgence of them).
But most worryingly, as I hope I have shown above, his legal analysis is repeatedly flawed; and flawed every single time in a way calculated to maximise the claims of trans-identifying men and sideline the concerns of women.
This is men’s rights activism dressed up as legal analysis. It does no credit to the (usually excellent) 11KBW employment podcast

https://www.legalfeminist.org.uk/2026/03/25/podcasting-and-partisanship/

Podcasting and partisanship -

I listened to the 11KBW Employment Podcast in which Katherine Taunton and Dan Stillitz KC discussed four recent cases on single-sex spaces: Peggie v NHS Fife and Beth Upton, Kelly v Leonardo UK Ltd, Hutchinson and Others v County Durham and Darlington...

https://www.legalfeminist.org.uk/2026/03/25/podcasting-and-partisanship/

Tears0fTheMushroom · 05/11/2026 13:11

spannasaurus · 05/11/2026 12:37

Crash Krylova was previously known as Crash Wigley. He's been discussed on this board previously but I can' remember whether it was connected to a tribunal/legal case or the article on FWS

https://ukconstitutionallaw.org/2025/05/06/crash-wigley-for-women-scotland-a-case-of-significant-silences/

He appears to be a right tit

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 13:12

MyAmpleSheep · 05/11/2026 12:39

He wrote a widely disseminated critique of the FWS judgment that Naomi Cunningham burnt to a cinder on the Legal Feminist website. That’s where I first heard his name.

Like Stilitz, Slarks etc he’s worked for GLP on some trans cases I think

Tears0fTheMushroom · 05/11/2026 13:23

BiologicalRobot · 05/11/2026 13:05

Crashed and burned?

I must say Mushroomcat is adorable 😍

Awww. He's so overwhelmed he doesn't know where to put his face 🤗

Sex Matters Hampstead Heath Ponds - Thread 2
Justabaker · 05/11/2026 13:33

Final installment of barrister report.

On to HS for Translucent.

She's a small woman, judging by the lectern, she looked a bit like a someone peering over the wheel of a very large car.

No wig. She was limited to 25 minutes and only went slightly over, especially considering the barrister space time continuum.

Judge was leaning back in his chair - it had already been a long day. I do not think he was prepared for her 'ask'. He reminded her that he had the witness statement of SR at least once. She had the most stilted delivery - reading from a script. Claims about how a bio sex basis would disadvantage inter alia women rugby players, politicians wives and other women who don't meet the standard of femininity. Gave this short shrift and said 'what is your legal point'. This was consistent with his approach throughout, he did not enjoy the barristers attempting to give evidence.

It turned into a bit of a sparring match; he rejected her characterisation of the C's position, refused to be drawn into opining on a hypothetical question that no one had asked, corrected her several times on what the C's request actually was. I'm not saying I saw a change in facial expression but there was a faint air of something during this exchange.

HS I would ask you to answer the question that a single rule lived
gender policy would never give rise to direct discrim.
J I will think about whether I'm prepared to do that. It might not be direct discrim in law, but I'm not prepared to do that on a hypothetical.
HS it would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going
to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes anyone who lives as a woman and excludes anyone who lives as a man.
J you want me to find that is never direct discrim on a hypothetical
[TC reminds on time]
HS, I'm aware, the reason its important is that it is
intensely important to trans people. And finally we would ask you to adopt the language from the SC FWS decision on TW/TM rather than the SM language where they avoid those terms.

Okay that's it.

ItsCoolForCats · 05/11/2026 13:55

Thank you, as ever @Justabaker. Your insight is so useful. That exchange you posted above really was extraordinary.

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 13:58

Justabaker · 05/11/2026 13:33

Final installment of barrister report.

On to HS for Translucent.

She's a small woman, judging by the lectern, she looked a bit like a someone peering over the wheel of a very large car.

No wig. She was limited to 25 minutes and only went slightly over, especially considering the barrister space time continuum.

Judge was leaning back in his chair - it had already been a long day. I do not think he was prepared for her 'ask'. He reminded her that he had the witness statement of SR at least once. She had the most stilted delivery - reading from a script. Claims about how a bio sex basis would disadvantage inter alia women rugby players, politicians wives and other women who don't meet the standard of femininity. Gave this short shrift and said 'what is your legal point'. This was consistent with his approach throughout, he did not enjoy the barristers attempting to give evidence.

It turned into a bit of a sparring match; he rejected her characterisation of the C's position, refused to be drawn into opining on a hypothetical question that no one had asked, corrected her several times on what the C's request actually was. I'm not saying I saw a change in facial expression but there was a faint air of something during this exchange.

HS I would ask you to answer the question that a single rule lived
gender policy would never give rise to direct discrim.
J I will think about whether I'm prepared to do that. It might not be direct discrim in law, but I'm not prepared to do that on a hypothetical.
HS it would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going
to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes anyone who lives as a woman and excludes anyone who lives as a man.
J you want me to find that is never direct discrim on a hypothetical
[TC reminds on time]
HS, I'm aware, the reason its important is that it is
intensely important to trans people. And finally we would ask you to adopt the language from the SC FWS decision on TW/TM rather than the SM language where they avoid those terms.

Okay that's it.

HS it would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going
to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes anyone who lives as a woman and excludes anyone who lives as a man.

Again what is being asked here?

Following the theory that TWAW, it sounds as though the request is the equivalent of:

"It would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes all men and excludes all women".

Did I misunderstand? It sounds as though the request is for the judge to rule that sex discrimination is always lawful?

Also:

"the reason its important is that it is intensely important to trans people."

How is that a legal argument?

My confusion here is less about the actual case, and more about the kinds of argument a barrister might suggest to convince a judge. Is it usual to suggest this kind of thing?

Wishesandhorses · 05/11/2026 14:01

In essence: we'd love it if you'd ignore the SCJ.

MyAmpleSheep · 05/11/2026 14:02

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 13:58

HS it would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going
to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes anyone who lives as a woman and excludes anyone who lives as a man.

Again what is being asked here?

Following the theory that TWAW, it sounds as though the request is the equivalent of:

"It would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes all men and excludes all women".

Did I misunderstand? It sounds as though the request is for the judge to rule that sex discrimination is always lawful?

Also:

"the reason its important is that it is intensely important to trans people."

How is that a legal argument?

My confusion here is less about the actual case, and more about the kinds of argument a barrister might suggest to convince a judge. Is it usual to suggest this kind of thing?

I think it's very very unusual for a professional barrister to say something so trite in front of a High Court Judge.

Swipe left for the next trending thread