Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sex Matters Hampstead Heath Ponds - Thread 2

182 replies

rebax · 04/11/2026 15:21

Next thread on second day in court

Continuation from
Sex Matters - Hampstead Heath Ponds - | Mumsnet

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Wishesandhorses · 04/11/2026 16:06

'you're submitting that what women feel about a bio man coming into the changing room can't be generalised'

dealt with by providing the mixed sex facilities for those fine with it, and single sex for those not.

It just is repeated 'the women unhappy and discriminated against are a minority who shouldn't have equality'

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 16:08

And the benefit to many women, who won't be questioned on their gender, if they don't meet the feminine ideal of beauty. A horrible knock effect of the current environment is that we have female rugby players, politicians wives and women out of the public eye. All of these women benefit from a lighter touch policy that doesn't question. A bio woman who didn't have a conventional appearance, would face that intrusion even with timed sessions

The subtext here is 'if you are a woman and you don't meet conventional beauty standards everyone thinks you are a man but they are just tolerating you to be kind'. It's a school bully insult.

Also obviously untrue, because if women could easily pass as men, they would have taken more advantage of it.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:08

From TT

of Cole it is not direct discrim. And the secondary attack is that it cannot be justified under sec 158 because schedule 3 has filled the space and 158 is not available.
J so you're saying that if that is the position, the convention is not settled

HS indeed and its a human rights problem if that is what the law says
HS the Ds have selected an additive policy, including bio men plus trans men.
J I'm not following the point, where is it going
HS they could have worded the policy another way, they've layered two groups

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:14

From TT

together, they could have said mixed gender,
J what is the alternative
HS the alternative is providing access to people who live as women, that option was very alive in this discussion, if your judgment was that there needs to be a change in policy, I invite you to state in

your decision, the boundaries of your conclusion
J what do you mean before I commit to doing it
HS there is ambiguity, between the written policy and how it is actually applied, it will be very important for service providers to understand the boundaries so would all lived gender

policies are unlawful.
J well, let see what I'm being asked by TC.
HS you are in the unenviable position of being asked to say if people are being discriminated,
J that's not what I'm being asked, I'm being asked to consider the legality of the rule
HS but if its a direct

discrim claim it can't be held to be discriminating if its not following the rule
J I'm being asked by TC to rule on the legality of the rule as written, not on how it is being applied.
HS My 3rd submission is that I would ask you to answer the question that a single rule lived

BiologicalRobot · 04/11/2026 16:22

Thank you for the new thread and for @Ereshkigalangcleg for posting TT. It's really fascinating how different it is from an employment tribunal.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:25

From TT

gender policy would never give rise to direct discrim.
J I will think about whether I'm prepared to do that. It might not be direct discrim in law, but I'm not prepared to do that on a hypothetical.
HS it would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going

to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes anyone who lives as a woman and excludes anyone who lives as a man.
J you want me to find that is never direct discrim on a hypothetical
[TC reminds on time]
HS, I'm aware, the reason its important is that it is

intensely important to transpeople. And finally we would ask you to adopt the language from the SC FWS decision on TW/TM rather than the SM language where they avoid those terms.
J I was just checking if my meeting is going ahead, it's not an invitation to exceed your 45 minutes

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:25

TC responding now for Sex Matters

Slothtoes · 04/11/2026 16:27

Cheering them on!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:35

From TT

TC on ground one, the rule differentiates on the bases of sex, it relies on it's own articulation of the issue, what is clear is the aim is lived gender. Whether you call it an aim, a purpose or a motive, it is impermissible. He said that whatever they call it that it is lived

gender.
Further I do not base my submissions on merely segregation, but rather on the lack of choice that individuals have. On the evidence of individuals that persons of either sex might want to go to either pond, there is correspondence that a witness might want to swim in

the men's pond. DS alleged not genuine, the Ds themselves said there would be many who would want to go to the opposite sex ponds.
J can I interrupt you, do you want me to decide on the legality of the rule as written not as practice
TC yes, I will get to that when I get to the

stewards handbook. On to positive action, a policy that would favour advancement of a particular group, could provide something extra to that group, not to others, extra sessions. The point of 158 is to render lawful what is otherwise not lawful, sec 158 cannot render any

defence to direct discrimination.
The approach of this court on JR is to determine if the rule is lawful, there is not any requirement for deference in this case. So did they consider and apply 158 appropriate, the legal authority is also relied on by DS, there is no

suggestion that the court cannot decide this. The way we break it down in this case is that there is not normally oral evidence in this case and that is true. And that speaks to how you consider evidence. It is also the case that the decision maker is also a local authority.

rebax · 04/11/2026 16:36

HS it would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going
to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes anyone who lives as a woman and excludes anyone who lives as a man.
J you want me to find that is never direct discrim on a hypothetical?

I'm reading this as involving raised eyebrows.

OP posts:
Datun · 04/11/2026 16:45

DS the ponds have been TI for more than a decade, no woman can reasonably expect this to be a same sex space.

How did that work then, when Man Friday showed up and were hustled out, not just by the person connected to the ponds, but by the police, and the men swimming in it.

There seems to be a lot of lying going on.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:53

From TT

In this case the Ds are making the decision based on being the sole trustee of the Heath Trust. Our case is whether the arrangements give rise to a statutory tort - discrimination. We happen to be in this court, because my client is not an individual rights holder and not the

county court is available.
J on the possibility of alternate dates, or sessions you're not arguing that and it's an area where I wouldn't have expertise
TC the fact that they have considered options, does not drive us towards deference. The decision needs to be justified on

other grounds. And ML cannot consider proportionality in this case, to said that they considered options is wide of the mark, they did nothing like what ML is required to do, when applying the laws.
Is the action they took a proportionate action to remedy the disadvantage

The only possible use of 158 is to rescue the direct discrimination of excluding men. They are not using it in that way, they are using it to justify the admission criteria. Consider a mixed sex pond, that occasionally has women only sessions. 158 defends the service provider

from men who come along and say you've excluded men from these session.
Parliament did not intend for 158 to be a defence for direct discrim. It is when something extra is offered.
J what they need to show is that the action of excluding men from the pond is proportionate

Slothtoes · 04/11/2026 16:54

Lying and double standards meaning total freedom for men, and budge up and shut up women

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:54

From TT

TC what if I'm wrong about that, one needs to balance and consider a number of factors, need to look at the disadvantage in relation to that service. And secondly would need to consider if there was any disadvantage that could be reduced by actions taken. DS did not refer to

one line of evidence that they looked at any other approach. It is a 3 fold approach, the women who use the ponds, the women who self exclude with other pcs, and the men who are excluded from the ponds. They admit in practice somebody that they want to exclude without

questioning.
J on that I need to know where you want me to come down on
TC the reality of the operation of the arrangement in that case, is in practice that organisations must accept a practice of self id. Its not an irrelevant consideration. It renders it difficult to justify

the exclusion of the people they seek to exclude. It is not good enough for the service provider to help reduce barriers to gender nonconforming people to access the service. The submission from the other side is that nothing but treating TP on self id basis will do.

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 16:54

rebax · 04/11/2026 16:36

HS it would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going
to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes anyone who lives as a woman and excludes anyone who lives as a man.
J you want me to find that is never direct discrim on a hypothetical?

I'm reading this as involving raised eyebrows.

Again, where are gender fluid and non binary people fitting into this?

RedToothBrush · 04/11/2026 16:58

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:42

DS the ponds have been TI for more than a decade, no woman can reasonably expect this to be a same sex space.

So if I go to the pond and see a sign saying 'women only' it's up to me to understand the subtext that it is actually mixed sex?

Doesn't pass the 'ordinary woman on the street' legal convention sniff test does it?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 17:01

From TT

Various refs have been made to the WS of SR, founder of a trans activist charity. And is self serving.
J just like MF
TC yes, if we are not allowed to rely on MF WS they we shouldn't rely on SR WS.
J what do you say on can there be a ss service that is trans inclusive

TC in my submissions, you can have an inclusive service but you can't call it ss. The final points I need to make, the rejected mixed option, is that many want to preserve the current rules, in other words they want to preserve the current rules, it is circular. n

On timing of J Phoenix report, please look at our reply, there was a change of position, they wanted to reject MF evidence
J but we're talking about Jo Phoenix
TC in the detailed grounds of resistance, they criticised MF for giving expert evidence but not an expert, so we sought

sought expert evidence. On the timing point, there is no shield for the prior acts.
J I think I've got a point, they don't trigger 158 for the June decision
TC they use it as a defence
J if I make a decision about liability on ground 1 and 3, why do I need to go on to the

2025 decision.
TC the 2025 decision has not been rendered academic,
J it doesn't add to the sum of human knowledge
TC that's not the test
J is this the point that at the moment the earlier decisions have not been addressed, is it that
TC Ds chose not to enter a substantive

defence to those earlier decisions, the detailed ground of resistance were not rec'd until after June 2026.
J I could find that you lost on 2026 but you want me to consider 2025 as well. So I understand that. Its not academic because why? If you succeed on 2026 why is 2025 not

academic.
TC so its not academic, you need to look at Smith vs Northumbria Police, it is important for the court to decide on the signs, it is not just to quash the access policy, the signs needs to go as well. The last thing I need to address.

is the alternative remedy decision, it is in the decision of Lady Justice Liene, paras 7 and 8. She says that prior decision was wrong on standing and alternative remedy. Both aspects are wrong.
J right
TC LJ Liene says both the standing argument and remedies argument are

related. I'm sorry to have taken so long but I invite SS to reply to certain points.
J please shortly
SS the disadvantage to women is serious, it is in JFS, that disadvantage is set out in 5 WS, you will find references to a number of occasions and a number of indivs did not

Datun · 04/11/2026 17:05

The submission from the other side is that nothing but treating TP on self id basis will do.

Although I don't think any man at all should be considered, this is one of the arguments that sway people.

It's the come one, come all argument.

And no amount of banging on about marginalised groups and vulnerability and all that bollocks, makes any difference to that argument.

If you let the marginalised, vulnerable, really sweet, harmless transwoman in, you let the hulking, six foot four, raging predator in, too.

CriticalCondition · 04/11/2026 17:11

it is important for the court to decide on the signs, it is not just to quash the access policy, the signs needs to go as well.

I'm pleased that this is being sought specifically.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 17:14

From TT

know that it admitted bio men. The disadvantage is also set out in D's survey evidence. Only one passage I will take you to, I will read while you are finding the page
J I'm not sure why it's going to be helpful for you to read whilst I'm trying to find the page.
SS reads out

report responses of women, these respondents answered female, 96.3% of people who gave their sex and complained of discomfort were women. This is not a small problem. And the reliance on safety incidents and reports
J I've got that point and I've read the evidence

SS it doesn't matter that there are 4 changing cubicles but they don't make a difference, because women need to go to and from the showers naked. And the additional changes, do they reflect the privacy needs of women, at the bottom of the page, different provision is made for

J can you tell me what pages you want me to look at
SS 297, sorry I'm talking about something different now,
at 494
J of what
SS of the WS bundle, you can see 'increased provision for peak periods at the LP' and then ML can see that more private provision being made for women

than men despite the fact that there is more private provision already for women.
J yes, I think we've been over this.
SS we can see that there is a recognition of the concerns expressed in the consultation focused on the LP. And on a similar point, on provision at the

mixed pond, its the same point that the privacy norms are asymmetric. That sets out the provision of the mens compound in the mixed pond and the ladies compound in the mixed pond - more privacy provision in the ladies.
And there are many mixed sex natural swimming facilities

this is the one single sex facility, women are saying this is just one place for women.
J but its just one place for TW as well
SS one of the alternatives would have open to Ds, there is nothing to prevent id as a TW in a mixed sex pond. Once a TW joins a single sex pond, it

becomes a mixed sex pond. This is not a situation where there are no other facilities, there are other facilities.
J they can swim elsewhere
SS The proposal that we make would also address the concerns about the policing of women's bodies. The suggestion that women would be at

Datun · 04/11/2026 17:19

The other thing that infuriates me is they say women don't mind. What women? When their entire premise relies on the fact that men can say they are women, it's a nonsense claim.

Wishesandhorses · 04/11/2026 17:23

Datun · 04/11/2026 17:05

The submission from the other side is that nothing but treating TP on self id basis will do.

Although I don't think any man at all should be considered, this is one of the arguments that sway people.

It's the come one, come all argument.

And no amount of banging on about marginalised groups and vulnerability and all that bollocks, makes any difference to that argument.

If you let the marginalised, vulnerable, really sweet, harmless transwoman in, you let the hulking, six foot four, raging predator in, too.

It is an interesting question and they were just getting to it.

What is the actual disadvantage to a TW in having access to the mixed sex pond but not.... the other mixed sex pond?

Unless it's women only, then it's two mixed sex ponds but one has a fictional label on it, and it's all solely about the label. The actual disadvantage is what? Not being able to have two mixed sex facilities one of which is falsely labelled women? They have an accessible non sex based facility.

What is the comparable actual disadvantage to a woman who can only access a single sex pond? No access at all.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 17:28

From TT

more risk of being excluded by a bio sex policy is simply dealt with by an inclusive approach to NB and TM. Now on to vulnerability, there is no evidence that suggests that TW are vulnerable at the mixed sex pond, the Ds evidence is the reverse of that.

J I hope that we're not going to go over old ground, what specifically that you want me to take notice of
SS there is no authority that people with pc of GRA have the right to access services for the opposite sex. We think ML is being asked to develop the law. You are being

asked to develop an Art 8 right to be recognised as the acquired sex.
J I'm not sure that is what I am being asked to do.
SS I will give the page reference, the point that I draw from it, is that it is not open for the court to find that convention right without full

consideration
J I don't think I'm being asked that all
SS the submissions from TL, is asking ML to recognise a convention right to be recognised on the opposite sex,
J I will re-read that submission
SS the fourth aim is to listen to users, that is not a legitimate aim, in the

segregated school, parents preferred the segregation, it was extremely popular but it was found to be unlawful. The rights of children could not be offset by preferences of parents. In any event one should treat with a great deal of caution the opinion that is expressed in the

consultation document.
J I did say 45 minutes
SS I'm very nearly finished
J I did read the material and both sides had the opportunity to campaign for people to complete it
SS Phoenix report that discusses the demographics, the outcome and there is a discrepancy between a

2025 survey when 58% of women said they preferred single sex provision.
J thank you
SS I did race through
TC only one final matter, there was a document submitted on Monday without an application,
DS it was in relation to Jo Phoenix report,
J so I'll give you to 4:30 next

Wednesday to make any submissions on that document.
J thank you will reserve my judgment.
Court rises, session ends.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 17:29

That’s all folks!

Wishesandhorses · 04/11/2026 17:30

Thank you Ereshkigalangcleg

Swipe left for the next trending thread