From TT
Various refs have been made to the WS of SR, founder of a trans activist charity. And is self serving.
J just like MF
TC yes, if we are not allowed to rely on MF WS they we shouldn't rely on SR WS.
J what do you say on can there be a ss service that is trans inclusive
TC in my submissions, you can have an inclusive service but you can't call it ss. The final points I need to make, the rejected mixed option, is that many want to preserve the current rules, in other words they want to preserve the current rules, it is circular. n
On timing of J Phoenix report, please look at our reply, there was a change of position, they wanted to reject MF evidence
J but we're talking about Jo Phoenix
TC in the detailed grounds of resistance, they criticised MF for giving expert evidence but not an expert, so we sought
sought expert evidence. On the timing point, there is no shield for the prior acts.
J I think I've got a point, they don't trigger 158 for the June decision
TC they use it as a defence
J if I make a decision about liability on ground 1 and 3, why do I need to go on to the
2025 decision.
TC the 2025 decision has not been rendered academic,
J it doesn't add to the sum of human knowledge
TC that's not the test
J is this the point that at the moment the earlier decisions have not been addressed, is it that
TC Ds chose not to enter a substantive
defence to those earlier decisions, the detailed ground of resistance were not rec'd until after June 2026.
J I could find that you lost on 2026 but you want me to consider 2025 as well. So I understand that. Its not academic because why? If you succeed on 2026 why is 2025 not
academic.
TC so its not academic, you need to look at Smith vs Northumbria Police, it is important for the court to decide on the signs, it is not just to quash the access policy, the signs needs to go as well. The last thing I need to address.
is the alternative remedy decision, it is in the decision of Lady Justice Liene, paras 7 and 8. She says that prior decision was wrong on standing and alternative remedy. Both aspects are wrong.
J right
TC LJ Liene says both the standing argument and remedies argument are
related. I'm sorry to have taken so long but I invite SS to reply to certain points.
J please shortly
SS the disadvantage to women is serious, it is in JFS, that disadvantage is set out in 5 WS, you will find references to a number of occasions and a number of indivs did not