Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

JKR response to Stonewall CEO comments

398 replies

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 17:03

Just posted on X by JKR in response to Stonewall CEO comments re wanting to take the ‘heat’ out of the debate around trans …..even though their slogan was ‘ no debate’.

A lot of us were very willing to have a debate without heat, @stonewalluk, and the reason that never happened wasn't because gender critical feminists didn't want one.
While we were trying to get you to listen to our concerns, your former CEO was telling a BBC boss that gay people not wanting to include the opposite sex in their dating pool was 'sexual racism'. While we were pointing out the homophobia inherent in gender ideology, Stonewall ambassador Alex Drummond (a bearded, heterosexual man who'd had no surgery and taken no cross-sex hormones but liked wearing skirts), was going into schools to talk to students about his 'lesbian' identity. @BluskyeAllison, who actually is a lesbian, was subject to unlawful discrimination at her place of work for tweeting: ‘Stonewall recently hired Morgan Page, a male bodied person who ran workshops with the sole aim of coaching heterosexual men who identify as lesbians on how they can coerce young lesbians into having sex with them. Page called [it] “overcoming the cotton ceiling”.’
When the UK Supreme Court upheld women's right to single sex spaces, you issued a statement expressing your unhappiness about the ruling. In her report on your unhappy influence at the University of Essex, you were found by barrister @akuareindorf to have misrepresented the law as it related to women's rights: '[Stonewall have] stated the law as Stonewall would prefer it to be, rather than the law as it is’.
In 2018, you publicly advised schools to shred a research pack saying there were risks to puberty blockers, in spite of the fact that you aren't a medical charity and that there was already credible evidence that puberty blockers are neither irreversible nor harm-free. Meanwhile you produced your own educational packs, recommending a children's book, for ages 5-9, in which the parent 'is neither a man, nor a woman – they’re non-binary.' In July 2022, Stonewall sent out a tweet that read ‘Research suggests that children as young as two recognise their trans identity'.
^@thetimes has reported how you've sought to control the language used by NHS trusts and government on their social-media accounts. Organisations would get points from you for replacing commonly understood words with ideologically approved terms, eg, 'birthing parent' instead of 'mother'. thetimes.com/uk/society/art…^
In short, you took a maximalist position on gender identity ideology, which you attempted to enforce by diktat. You refused to acknowledge that you'd hitched your wagon to a cause that, unlike civil rights, gay rights or women's rights, sought to strip rights from others. You sought to curtail everyone's right to freedom of speech and belief by controlling what it was permissible to think and say, through the management and political class. You have argued against women's and girl's rights to their own spaces, their sports and to assemble without men. Your CEO tried to shame gay women/men into dating the opposite sex if the latter claimed to be female/male.
Your mantra was 'no debate' because, like all totalitarians, you preferred slogans, bullying and infiltration of powerful institutions to talking to opponents. You appear to have had no concern for the lowly people your ideology was harming: gender confused kids, female rape victims, female prisoners, regular people hounded and investigated at their places of work for refusing to accept the new mandates on sex and gender issued from on high.
Your 'activism' has been a disaster for those trans-identified people who really do just want to get on with their lives in peace. You have besmirched the name of an organisation many of us were once proud to donate to, the charity that was partly responsible for securing the legal right of gay people to marry, which a lot of us thought would never happen in our lifetimes. The milquetoast words quoted below do not erase a decade of gender activism that has been disastrous not only for individuals but for society as a whole.
There was once a debate to be had, but until you acknowledge the direct harm you've caused, it is no more possible to debate you than to persuade a person in the throes of a drug-induced psychosis that they are not, in fact, the reincarnated Christ.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:46

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 07:39

Thank you @Barbie222 better articulated than my post.

Yes @CoolforKats I know where I am. I am on the Feminism board of Mumsnet.

I have at no point suggested this is a ‘fanclub’. You did that and you did it in a tone familiar on many of the threads around this subject. The tone being you dislike any dissent about gender identity.

As I say I started this thread in good faith to hear reactions to the actual post by JKR not particularly to stimulate another circular discussion about gender ideology which just repeat the same old list of word salads including nonsense never quite getting the gotcha moment they hope for.

Edited

"As I say I started this thread in good faith to hear reactions to the actual post by JKR not particularly to stimulate another circular discussion about gender ideology which just repeat the same old list of word salads including nonsense never quite getting the gotcha moment they hope for."

Translation: I started this thread to confirm my own biases.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 07:47

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:44

Firstly, the supreme court has clarified no such thing other than to say special exemptions apply to cis/ natal women not trans women that a legitimate aim justification is required. As yet there's no case law to confirm whether this applies to all contested spaces like public toilets other than employment law.

Secondly, talking out of both sides of your mouth by saying you have 'no issues with trans people' but at the same time implying harmful stereotypes is hardly 'having no issues'. You can't have it both ways.

Lastly, social media isn't the real world. Have you seen X recently?

Yes I have seen X recently. I started this thread off the back of JKRs post re Stonewall. Did that pass you by?

I have also seen the responses to the post.

OP posts:
BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 07:49

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:46

"As I say I started this thread in good faith to hear reactions to the actual post by JKR not particularly to stimulate another circular discussion about gender ideology which just repeat the same old list of word salads including nonsense never quite getting the gotcha moment they hope for."

Translation: I started this thread to confirm my own biases.

No I started the thread to hear people’s reactions to JKRs post on X re Stonewall CEO comments. Please refrain from ‘telling me’ what I think. That is coercive and you are wrong. Very wrong.

OP posts:
Theeyeballsinthesky · 02/11/2026 07:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 07:54

Stonewall are facing the reality of focusing on trans rights over lesbian and gay rights. Ruth Hunt knew this was a gamble but soldiered on because the funding was there. She even admitted as much.

Then we saw children being given puberty blockers and cross sex hormones. However open minded you are crossing that boundary was immoral.

Thank you for the responses to the original post which was simply JKRs X post.

OP posts:
OldCrone · 02/11/2026 07:55

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:44

Firstly, the supreme court has clarified no such thing other than to say special exemptions apply to cis/ natal women not trans women that a legitimate aim justification is required. As yet there's no case law to confirm whether this applies to all contested spaces like public toilets other than employment law.

Secondly, talking out of both sides of your mouth by saying you have 'no issues with trans people' but at the same time implying harmful stereotypes is hardly 'having no issues'. You can't have it both ways.

Lastly, social media isn't the real world. Have you seen X recently?

talking out of both sides of your mouth by saying you have 'no issues with trans people' but at the same time implying harmful stereotypes is hardly 'having no issues'. You can't have it both ways.

I have no issues with people who choose to identify as trans, but people can't change sex.

It's not a "harmful stereotype" to say that a man who chooses to dress as a woman is still a man. A "harmful stereotype" would be saying that such a man is a woman, as it would imply that women have to conform to those stereotypes.

Phoenix1Arisen · 02/11/2026 08:12

In my view, JKR is the embodiment of Lord Byron's message in Don Juan "a small drop of ink...produces that which make thousands, perhaps millions, think"

seconded by the centuries old concept that 'the pen is mightier than the sword.'

EmmyFr · 02/11/2026 08:22

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 06:34

There are LOTS of theories, lots of cultures/religions with different gender patterns

You could say the same thing about the multitude of religious beliefs.

By the same logic atheists reasonably believe the same thing about theists but that doesn't give them the right to deny the validity of their identity or deny their right to advocate for their rights.

We can all reasonably disagree on other people's conception of identity….& we do because its individually subjective. But to say 'because I disagree & therefore my more valid identity extinguishes any claims you might have' is not living by egalitarian liberal principles that underpin western civilisation.

My DH is an atheist, I'm a Catholic. We both recognize the other's "religious identity", and that's that. He doesn't claim that because he likes to visit churches that makes him a trans Catholic and allows him to define the Church's teaching or to come sing "God doesn't exist" in the middle of Mass. And saying it would be beyond the pale for him to do that doesn't make me atheophobic.

(If the comparison is not clear enough for you, I'm happy to explain it step by step cause you seem a bit hard of understanding).

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 08:28

EmmyFr · 02/11/2026 08:22

My DH is an atheist, I'm a Catholic. We both recognize the other's "religious identity", and that's that. He doesn't claim that because he likes to visit churches that makes him a trans Catholic and allows him to define the Church's teaching or to come sing "God doesn't exist" in the middle of Mass. And saying it would be beyond the pale for him to do that doesn't make me atheophobic.

(If the comparison is not clear enough for you, I'm happy to explain it step by step cause you seem a bit hard of understanding).

For a self declared catholic you don't seem to really understand the qualifying criteria. Clue: Its not church attendance.

If that is not clear enough for you, I'm happy to explain it step by step cause you seem a bit hard of understanding).

Imdunfer · 02/11/2026 08:30

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:46

"As I say I started this thread in good faith to hear reactions to the actual post by JKR not particularly to stimulate another circular discussion about gender ideology which just repeat the same old list of word salads including nonsense never quite getting the gotcha moment they hope for."

Translation: I started this thread to confirm my own biases.

Translation: I started this thread to confirm my own biases

You joined this thread to make yet another attempt to bully women into believing your own.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 08:31

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 02/11/2026 06:25

Thanks for sharing OP, she's a class act, she sliced him and diced him with the truth of his organisations perfidy.
Thanks JKR 💐

She did, and most of the comments on social media are supporting her.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 08:31

Imdunfer · 02/11/2026 08:30

Translation: I started this thread to confirm my own biases

You joined this thread to make yet another attempt to bully women into believing your own.

"bully" = explain gender

🤪

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 08:35

Barbie222 · 02/11/2026 06:50

if recognising identity is irrelevant to the justified protection of spaces, it follows that trans women need to be housed in the male estate and male hospital wards despite their identification as female gender. Their inner gender is irrelevant when justifying the need for a single sex space.

This is the GC position so why are we arguing? There is no issue with people having personal beliefs about who they are, or with people having the right to explain their beliefs to others (on both sides). It becomes an issue when real world spaces are taken away from women - that’s the top and bottom of JKR’s position?

Exactly. These people can have their “identities” and their friends and family can make the choice to play along or not. But no one else has to, and as genderists are always saying, “gender” isn’t the same as sex. And as everyone else is perfectly aware, sex matters.

Imdunfer · 02/11/2026 08:35

The question of GC women stereotying is laughable.

The challenge the trans lobby never respond to is to describe "feeling like a woman" and "living as a woman" without using female stereotyping.

That says everything anyone needs to know about who is using stereotypes.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 08:36

Imdunfer · 02/11/2026 08:35

The question of GC women stereotying is laughable.

The challenge the trans lobby never respond to is to describe "feeling like a woman" and "living as a woman" without using female stereotyping.

That says everything anyone needs to know about who is using stereotypes.

It’s a deliberate DARVO.

Imdunfer · 02/11/2026 08:39

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 08:31

"bully" = explain gender

🤪

You aren't "explaining gender". You are attempting to bully women, by repeating the same tautologous word salad over and over and over and over again, to believe that men can feel like women and live like women.

Now will you please describe "feeling like a woman" and "living as a woman" without using female stereotyping.

Until you can do that "women" have X chromosomes and no Y.

BackToLurk · 02/11/2026 08:39

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 08:28

For a self declared catholic you don't seem to really understand the qualifying criteria. Clue: Its not church attendance.

If that is not clear enough for you, I'm happy to explain it step by step cause you seem a bit hard of understanding).

Edited

I’m sure she understands the qualifying criteria both for being a catholic and being a woman.

Tallisker · 02/11/2026 08:43

Ah Magdalen Berns - “oh fuck off you wanker”. Best line ever. I showed that video to DH and instantly peaked him.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 08:43

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 08:31

She did, and most of the comments on social media are supporting her.

Many comments not supporting her post a men in pup fetish gear. Which kind of sums up people not getting that sex is real. Deciding to dress up in your fetish gear to denounce a well written piece about Stonewall is a special kind of special.

Anyhow, hopefully the post by JKR may spark sensible discussions in workplaces etc

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 02/11/2026 08:43

Mmmnotsure · 01/11/2026 21:21

Here we go again. This time, retrofitting - or trying to - the arguments.

No, that's not what we meant. When we said 'no debate', we didn't actually, er, mean, no debate.

Do the TRAs not know we have the receipts? Do they take us for fools?

#NoDebate coincided with TERF [sic] blockers all over Twitter, the closure of feminist sub-Reddits, the cancellation of feminist speakers from public platforms, the sacking of prominent feminists from their posts, doxing, public intimidation and the disruption of women who grouped in conferences or online (this site was targeted).

From this content, it’s extremely difficult to uphold the position that #NoDebate was restricted to discussions of a refusal to validate trans identity. In any case, ‘trans people don’t exist’ is a straw man. I have not seen JKR or any other women’s rights advocate make such a claim.

So forgive me if I don’t give a furry rat’s arse about now discussing the rights of the lying, aggressive, abusive, gaslighting activist body who attempted to commandeer women’s rights and deny even our language and autonomy whilst telling us to ‘enjoy your erasure’.

Sort out your own problems. Women have always had to. We are not your nursemaids.

Datun · 02/11/2026 08:47

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 00:51

If you think pointing to individual instances of illiberal 'wrong speak' is a defence then it works both ways. The big picture here is what is really at the crux of two groups being unable able to talk to one another & how its being facilitated by the weaponisation of a minority of extremists.

Stonewall are the extremists. They are still being sued by a black lesbian.

They call lesbians sexual racists, and employed a man who tried to force them into heterosexual sex.

Stonewall! A gay rights charity.

They couldn't have gone more extreme.

EmmyFr · 02/11/2026 08:48

@CoolforKats so you DO need some help...
The criteria to be a participating Catholic (a woman) in the eyes of the church (nature) are to be baptized and adhere in the beliefs of the Symbol of the Apostles (have a body organized around the production of large gamètes and be an adult).

Appreciating churches (appreciating to wear stereotypical female clothing / feeling you want to be female) does not replace these criteria. Hence, my DH (a transwoman) is not Catholic (not a woman). He's still a lovely person, though. Saying this is not hateful towards him (towards the transwoman)

(Of course the comparison has its limits, the most salient one being that adherence to Catholic belief cannot be factualized by a third party. Bein female and adult can).

KittyWilkinson · 02/11/2026 08:49

Another day, other whining plopper talking crap.
The letters JKR on a thread are like catnip.

nauticant · 02/11/2026 08:55

#nodebate from the archives with special bonus of the power Stonewall could wield at the BBC:

x.com/helenlewis/status/1988217674518913341

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 08:57

I have not seen JKR or any other women’s rights advocate make such a claim.

There is a remarkable amount of energy expended on pretending what JKR has claimed rather than what she has actually said.