Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

JKR response to Stonewall CEO comments

398 replies

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 17:03

Just posted on X by JKR in response to Stonewall CEO comments re wanting to take the ‘heat’ out of the debate around trans …..even though their slogan was ‘ no debate’.

A lot of us were very willing to have a debate without heat, @stonewalluk, and the reason that never happened wasn't because gender critical feminists didn't want one.
While we were trying to get you to listen to our concerns, your former CEO was telling a BBC boss that gay people not wanting to include the opposite sex in their dating pool was 'sexual racism'. While we were pointing out the homophobia inherent in gender ideology, Stonewall ambassador Alex Drummond (a bearded, heterosexual man who'd had no surgery and taken no cross-sex hormones but liked wearing skirts), was going into schools to talk to students about his 'lesbian' identity. @BluskyeAllison, who actually is a lesbian, was subject to unlawful discrimination at her place of work for tweeting: ‘Stonewall recently hired Morgan Page, a male bodied person who ran workshops with the sole aim of coaching heterosexual men who identify as lesbians on how they can coerce young lesbians into having sex with them. Page called [it] “overcoming the cotton ceiling”.’
When the UK Supreme Court upheld women's right to single sex spaces, you issued a statement expressing your unhappiness about the ruling. In her report on your unhappy influence at the University of Essex, you were found by barrister @akuareindorf to have misrepresented the law as it related to women's rights: '[Stonewall have] stated the law as Stonewall would prefer it to be, rather than the law as it is’.
In 2018, you publicly advised schools to shred a research pack saying there were risks to puberty blockers, in spite of the fact that you aren't a medical charity and that there was already credible evidence that puberty blockers are neither irreversible nor harm-free. Meanwhile you produced your own educational packs, recommending a children's book, for ages 5-9, in which the parent 'is neither a man, nor a woman – they’re non-binary.' In July 2022, Stonewall sent out a tweet that read ‘Research suggests that children as young as two recognise their trans identity'.
^@thetimes has reported how you've sought to control the language used by NHS trusts and government on their social-media accounts. Organisations would get points from you for replacing commonly understood words with ideologically approved terms, eg, 'birthing parent' instead of 'mother'. thetimes.com/uk/society/art…^
In short, you took a maximalist position on gender identity ideology, which you attempted to enforce by diktat. You refused to acknowledge that you'd hitched your wagon to a cause that, unlike civil rights, gay rights or women's rights, sought to strip rights from others. You sought to curtail everyone's right to freedom of speech and belief by controlling what it was permissible to think and say, through the management and political class. You have argued against women's and girl's rights to their own spaces, their sports and to assemble without men. Your CEO tried to shame gay women/men into dating the opposite sex if the latter claimed to be female/male.
Your mantra was 'no debate' because, like all totalitarians, you preferred slogans, bullying and infiltration of powerful institutions to talking to opponents. You appear to have had no concern for the lowly people your ideology was harming: gender confused kids, female rape victims, female prisoners, regular people hounded and investigated at their places of work for refusing to accept the new mandates on sex and gender issued from on high.
Your 'activism' has been a disaster for those trans-identified people who really do just want to get on with their lives in peace. You have besmirched the name of an organisation many of us were once proud to donate to, the charity that was partly responsible for securing the legal right of gay people to marry, which a lot of us thought would never happen in our lifetimes. The milquetoast words quoted below do not erase a decade of gender activism that has been disastrous not only for individuals but for society as a whole.
There was once a debate to be had, but until you acknowledge the direct harm you've caused, it is no more possible to debate you than to persuade a person in the throes of a drug-induced psychosis that they are not, in fact, the reincarnated Christ.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BlueLegume · 03/11/2026 08:50

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 21:05

Left-wing politics generally prioritises social equality, egalitarianism, and collective or government intervention to reduce economic AND social disparities.

Its also characterised by a more liberal progressive stance (social progress & equality) than a conservative one (traditionalism, caution & hierarchy).

So if you think of the left in terms of principles, sex realism sits more to the right in its traditionalist, hierarchical cautious stance than on the left & trans rights more to the left. The left's success has also been characterised as uniting force (solidarity) between all groups that seek equality. Hence Stonewall & unions being consistent in their support for trans people.

And let's not forget, in terms of political outcomes, sex realism enables right wing ascension which hardly supports feminist principles.

I will summarise this post for you. Left wing/Socialism never works. And before you quote the New Labour Tony Blair years - Blair is the biggest capitalist we have had as a PM. He stepped into the shoes of the great John Smith and grinned his evil grin all the way to the bank.

OP posts:
BlueLegume · 03/11/2026 08:56

@CoolforKats do you ever join a thread an actually comment on the title or do you just blurt your pro trans anti women stance out? Simple question.

You are all over several threads - or your compatriots are - same poor grammar, same rebuttals when we challenge.

Why not start a thread of your own?

OP posts:
BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 03/11/2026 09:04

Kalalily · 03/11/2026 08:25

Not derailing. An important observation and I’m grateful you brought it to my attention

Don't mind me. I'm a cynical, fed up, old woman most of the time 🙄

CoolforKats · 03/11/2026 09:06

No debate! No debate! No debate!

Why not start a 'no debate' thread if that's what you need?

Bit weird for a discussion forum tho. Maybe MN isn’t the right 'fit' for you?

brownbootsandhats · 03/11/2026 09:06

How is it left wing to deny science ? How is it left wing to enforce gender norms and stereotypes thus not providing equality for the female sex ?

cryupmykingdom · 03/11/2026 09:25

sorry, i'm kinda new. what is FWR ?

cryupmykingdom · 03/11/2026 09:28

But you don't discuss. You are silent on the male sex offenders you tried to say were in prison for prostitution ?

Possible topics for discussion.

1/ why prostitution offences aren't 'sexual offences' for purposes of UK law

2/ why a trans activist is trying to pretend they are

3/ why he goes quiet when hes caught out

Tallisker · 03/11/2026 09:29

This board used to called Feminism & Women’s Rights until some whingers wanted the gender stuff to be hidden in a basement, so the board was split into two.

Shortshriftandlethal · 03/11/2026 09:33

CoolforKats · 03/11/2026 05:40

By all means feel free to dispute any of these definitions that are relevant to my conclusions. Links attached.

Right-wing politics, or rightism, is the range of political ideologies that view certain social stratifications and orders as inevitable, natural, normal, or desirable,[1][2][3] typically supporting this position in favour of conservatism, natural law, economics, authority, property, religion, or tradition.[4][5][6][7] Hierarchy and inequality may be seen as natural results of traditional social differences[8][9] or competition in market economies.[10][11][12]

Left-wing politics, leftist politics, and leftism are descriptions within the left–right political spectrum for a range of political ideologies that generally support and seek to achieve social equality and egalitarianism.[1][2][3][4][5] Left-wing politics typically involve a concern for those in society whom its adherents perceive as disadvantaged relative to others as well as a belief that there are unjustified inequalities that need to be reduced or abolished.[3][5]

Conservatism is a cultural, social, and political philosophy and ideology that seeks to promote and preserve traditional institutions, customs, and values.[1][2][3] The central tenets of conservatism may vary in relation to the culture and civilization in which it appears.[4] In Western culture, depending on the particular nation and the particular time period, conservatives seek to promote and preserve a range of institutions, such as the nuclear family, organized religion, the military, the nation-state, constitution, property rights, rule of law, aristocracy, and monarchy.[5][6]

Progressivism is a political philosophy that seeks to make progress in the human condition through reforms aimed at increasing positive liberty.[1] Progressivism arose during the Age of Enlightenment out of the belief that civility in Europe was improving due to the application of new empirical knowledge.[2]
Progressivism as an umbrella term is associated with variants of social liberalism,[3][4][5] social democracy and democratic socialism.[6][7]

You are merely repeating the doctrines and dogmas of your chosen tribe. The narratives are always exactly the same.Nothing you are saying is original or self created - or even based on your own experiences and observations over time

As someone who has been politically conscious ( and active) all of their adult life; who studied Sociology at degree level, and then taught it too - these sorts of 'essays' on Left/Right politics are standard beginners stuff. Anyone who can riff with confidence through an understanding of the basic set narratives can get by in Sociology.

Simply repeating such narratives rather than a direct and spontaneous engagement with presenting arguments reveals their hollow nature, and by framing counter argments as 'right wing' you think you can absolve yourself and your positions from scrutiny.

Shortshriftandlethal · 03/11/2026 09:42

CoolforKats · 03/11/2026 06:28

So you aren't disputing anything particular because you can't?

Ok. Thanks for clarifying.

Btw the Wik has resource links attached for the galactically ignorant

Edited

If someone really understands a topic they can frame it and convey it in such a way that someone who has no prior understanding of it can then understand the basics. Because true understanding, rather than rote learning and regurgitation, involves further reflection, observation, investigation and consideration. You need to be flexible and agile and quick to respond to presenting information.

You seem to think that merely identifying as 'Progressive' and 'Left wing' means you don't need to do the donkey work involved in supporting your positions.

akkakk · 03/11/2026 09:48

CoolforKats · 03/11/2026 00:58

The right aren't exactly known for comprehending nuance for one thing. Like sex realists, their lens of the world is an oversimplified binary black & white one not to mention sex realism appeals to their notions biological essentialism. You can only imagine their delirious joy that there's finally a movement afoot where where biology is destiny has finally got another crack at relevancy…& by women of all people which makes it all the more satisfying for them. Who needs the patriarchy when women will do their dirty work for them eh? Anti trans electoral adds & political pitches being relentlessly deployed by the right aren't for no reason.

The right aren't exactly known for comprehending nuance for one thing.

their lens of the world is an oversimplified binary black & white one

  • Sex is binary - man or woman.
  • Black and white is by definition binary (two options = binary) so binary black and white is tautological
  • you can not get more simplified than binary where there is more than one possibility - so you definitely can not oversimplify binary anything...
  • If something is binary there is no nuance it is black and white / it is a or b / it is man or woman. The minute you have nuance - it is greyscale, not black or white...

So the start of the comment makes little sense - as for the rest, no idea what is meant by phrases such as sex realism appeals to their notions biological essentialism

if this is word salad it has been through a shredder and then composted before being posted!

brownbootsandhats · 03/11/2026 09:49

We are biological though?

really AI should shove off and make its own forums where none biological beings can discuss themselves

Datun · 03/11/2026 09:59

I'm not sure Kats has skin in the game of trans at all. He just likes arguing with women.

All his arguments are the same. When you get too general he tells you that trans people aren't a monolith, when you get too specific he says it's not about being individual and they're not representative.

When you talk about stereotypes he claims women are saying they don't have any agency, and why are you saying that, aren't you a feminist. blah blah blah.

He's just using bog standard argument devices to go round and round in such tedious circles, it's difficult to believe he doesn't nod off en route.

This is whyGroundhog Day is invoked all the time.

Edited to that men looking to get one over on women isn't exactly rare. And this board attracts them like bees to a honey pot. Always has. To me, the most depressing part of it is they all think they're unique. Not just the latest in a looong line.

cryupmykingdom · 03/11/2026 10:25

This Kats poster thinks he is using AI, but it sounds like the AI is confusing him and playing him like a fiddle.

That's why he's so conflicted and so obsessive about being here, perhaps.

There's things he can't deal with at all tho - he's obviously really scared at having realised he's in lock-step with serious sexual offenders in his movement - which is why the Kat runs away and never mentions them.

quantumbutterfly · 03/11/2026 10:27

akkakk · 03/11/2026 09:48

The right aren't exactly known for comprehending nuance for one thing.

their lens of the world is an oversimplified binary black & white one

  • Sex is binary - man or woman.
  • Black and white is by definition binary (two options = binary) so binary black and white is tautological
  • you can not get more simplified than binary where there is more than one possibility - so you definitely can not oversimplify binary anything...
  • If something is binary there is no nuance it is black and white / it is a or b / it is man or woman. The minute you have nuance - it is greyscale, not black or white...

So the start of the comment makes little sense - as for the rest, no idea what is meant by phrases such as sex realism appeals to their notions biological essentialism

if this is word salad it has been through a shredder and then composted before being posted!

😂👍
Not going to put it on the garden though, god knows what will grow.

nutmeg7 · 03/11/2026 10:49

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 21:43

Um, the context here is what characterises the left not trans people. You do understand the difference? Oh wait…

Yes, I was describing what characterises the left and the right.

Extreme individualism and freedom to act without consideration for others being a right wing phenomenon.

Shortshriftandlethal · 03/11/2026 11:02

nutmeg7 · 03/11/2026 10:49

Yes, I was describing what characterises the left and the right.

Extreme individualism and freedom to act without consideration for others being a right wing phenomenon.

Edited

Ironically I think that much of what has emerged out of the American cult of the individual now informs much of 'Progressive - Left' thinking - with its emphasis on the individual's right to do and be whatever they want. The emphasis on 'Gender Self Id' is the epitome of this.

That focus is on the individual's 'personal truth' and flat out ignores, or denies, that there are some things the individual cannot change or create in the shape of their desire; that other groups have rights too, and that boundaries exist, most often, for good reason.

Shortshriftandlethal · 03/11/2026 11:08

So much of what passes for Left wing thinking represents a kind of secular religiosity with its emphahsis on high ideals. The problem for idealism is reality and human nature.

solerolover · 03/11/2026 11:34

Datun · 03/11/2026 09:59

I'm not sure Kats has skin in the game of trans at all. He just likes arguing with women.

All his arguments are the same. When you get too general he tells you that trans people aren't a monolith, when you get too specific he says it's not about being individual and they're not representative.

When you talk about stereotypes he claims women are saying they don't have any agency, and why are you saying that, aren't you a feminist. blah blah blah.

He's just using bog standard argument devices to go round and round in such tedious circles, it's difficult to believe he doesn't nod off en route.

This is whyGroundhog Day is invoked all the time.

Edited to that men looking to get one over on women isn't exactly rare. And this board attracts them like bees to a honey pot. Always has. To me, the most depressing part of it is they all think they're unique. Not just the latest in a looong line.

Edited

His arguments are always the same, but I remember him going full mask off and just coming out and saying that those who believe in the importance of single sex spaces for women and girls as being "infected by phallophobia."

nicepotoftea · 03/11/2026 11:39

solerolover · 03/11/2026 11:34

His arguments are always the same, but I remember him going full mask off and just coming out and saying that those who believe in the importance of single sex spaces for women and girls as being "infected by phallophobia."

Can't think why these arguments aren't being pushed more by Stonewall...

Datun · 03/11/2026 11:44

solerolover · 03/11/2026 11:34

His arguments are always the same, but I remember him going full mask off and just coming out and saying that those who believe in the importance of single sex spaces for women and girls as being "infected by phallophobia."

Oh, I'd forgotten that.😝

'Infected'. That men's predatory behaviour towards women resulting in them wanting privacy has got nothing to do with those men, it's a disease that women just acquire through the, er, atmosphere.

Maybe bog standard men's rights activist in that case.

There are a considerable number of men who have feverishly jumped on the trans bandwagon, because they see it as such a marvellously legitimate way to stick it to women.

Inadequate doesn't even cover it.

Imdunfer · 03/11/2026 17:24

CoolforKats · 03/11/2026 08:33

Yeah you did when you assumed just because trans women are inclined towards feminine coded presentation women will dutifully follow.

OMG! If trans women wear dresses how will society ever correct their expectations that all women do!!!!

The demented hysteria is farcical at this stage.

No, I have never assumed that.

And although I do have a uterus and you don't, the hysterical one here is definitely you not me.

Helleofabore · 04/11/2026 06:08

Fucking hell. I missed that phallophobia accusation. But here it is.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womensrights/5560313-uk-radical-feminists-what-to-do?reply=153843645&utmcampaign=reply&utmmedium=share

“What's obvious to someone with a modicum of brain cells that hasn’t been infected with phallophobia is the potential for harm dictates access not what might or might not be between someone’s legs”

This was in response to AmpleSheep discussing why some female people needed female single sex provisions to exclude male people.

But phallophobia has been mentioned by a username with identical arguments in the past as well. It is remarkable behaviour for feminists to have their arguments be dismissed by someone using that as an argument. Yet then again, MRA terms such as young women ‘whoring’ about.

It is no wonder that JK Rowling is hated with such power by people who accuse women who exclude and want legislation to exclude male people as being phallophobic and young women of ‘whoring’ about. Because JK Rowling has very clearly called out that behaviour in some people in the past.

(thanks solero for posting the prompt. Very important to remember what has been said amongst the constant stream of consciousness. The hatred for women is clear and worth remembering)

Helleofabore · 04/11/2026 06:10

Mind you, there has been an important reminder that some people in the world have a humiliation fetish and all that involves.

Helleofabore · 04/11/2026 06:14

My reference to excluding male people is also only limited to excluding them from female single sex provisions, by the way.