Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

JKR response to Stonewall CEO comments

398 replies

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 17:03

Just posted on X by JKR in response to Stonewall CEO comments re wanting to take the ‘heat’ out of the debate around trans …..even though their slogan was ‘ no debate’.

A lot of us were very willing to have a debate without heat, @stonewalluk, and the reason that never happened wasn't because gender critical feminists didn't want one.
While we were trying to get you to listen to our concerns, your former CEO was telling a BBC boss that gay people not wanting to include the opposite sex in their dating pool was 'sexual racism'. While we were pointing out the homophobia inherent in gender ideology, Stonewall ambassador Alex Drummond (a bearded, heterosexual man who'd had no surgery and taken no cross-sex hormones but liked wearing skirts), was going into schools to talk to students about his 'lesbian' identity. @BluskyeAllison, who actually is a lesbian, was subject to unlawful discrimination at her place of work for tweeting: ‘Stonewall recently hired Morgan Page, a male bodied person who ran workshops with the sole aim of coaching heterosexual men who identify as lesbians on how they can coerce young lesbians into having sex with them. Page called [it] “overcoming the cotton ceiling”.’
When the UK Supreme Court upheld women's right to single sex spaces, you issued a statement expressing your unhappiness about the ruling. In her report on your unhappy influence at the University of Essex, you were found by barrister @akuareindorf to have misrepresented the law as it related to women's rights: '[Stonewall have] stated the law as Stonewall would prefer it to be, rather than the law as it is’.
In 2018, you publicly advised schools to shred a research pack saying there were risks to puberty blockers, in spite of the fact that you aren't a medical charity and that there was already credible evidence that puberty blockers are neither irreversible nor harm-free. Meanwhile you produced your own educational packs, recommending a children's book, for ages 5-9, in which the parent 'is neither a man, nor a woman – they’re non-binary.' In July 2022, Stonewall sent out a tweet that read ‘Research suggests that children as young as two recognise their trans identity'.
^@thetimes has reported how you've sought to control the language used by NHS trusts and government on their social-media accounts. Organisations would get points from you for replacing commonly understood words with ideologically approved terms, eg, 'birthing parent' instead of 'mother'. thetimes.com/uk/society/art…^
In short, you took a maximalist position on gender identity ideology, which you attempted to enforce by diktat. You refused to acknowledge that you'd hitched your wagon to a cause that, unlike civil rights, gay rights or women's rights, sought to strip rights from others. You sought to curtail everyone's right to freedom of speech and belief by controlling what it was permissible to think and say, through the management and political class. You have argued against women's and girl's rights to their own spaces, their sports and to assemble without men. Your CEO tried to shame gay women/men into dating the opposite sex if the latter claimed to be female/male.
Your mantra was 'no debate' because, like all totalitarians, you preferred slogans, bullying and infiltration of powerful institutions to talking to opponents. You appear to have had no concern for the lowly people your ideology was harming: gender confused kids, female rape victims, female prisoners, regular people hounded and investigated at their places of work for refusing to accept the new mandates on sex and gender issued from on high.
Your 'activism' has been a disaster for those trans-identified people who really do just want to get on with their lives in peace. You have besmirched the name of an organisation many of us were once proud to donate to, the charity that was partly responsible for securing the legal right of gay people to marry, which a lot of us thought would never happen in our lifetimes. The milquetoast words quoted below do not erase a decade of gender activism that has been disastrous not only for individuals but for society as a whole.
There was once a debate to be had, but until you acknowledge the direct harm you've caused, it is no more possible to debate you than to persuade a person in the throes of a drug-induced psychosis that they are not, in fact, the reincarnated Christ.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Prekoc2 · 02/11/2026 00:17

totino · 01/11/2026 17:35

It's funny that people are still trying to play "When was she ever transphobic" about this lady and then she bangs out another screed about "bearded men in skirts" and "male-bodied people"

"You sought to curtail everyone's right to freedom of speech and belief by controlling what it was permissible to think and say..."

They are bearded men in skirts and male-bodied people.

Datun · 02/11/2026 00:39

CoolforKats · 01/11/2026 21:13

i'm pretty certain that Venice Allan said she asked 24 different trans people or organisations (or maybe the same one 24 times, who knows), to come to one of her talks.

Like the link says, if the framing of the debate is 'you don't exist' in the first place there's no where to go from there regardless of how many other relevant topics follow. Its one thing to discuss competing rights & quite another to pretend the other side are delusional while doing so.

And the non legitimacy of trans people is JKR's underlying premise when she implicates them as either being a danger & motivated by predation or in a 'tom boy' phase.

Edited

Like the link says, if the framing of the debate is 'you don't exist' in the first place there's no where to go from there

Well that would be news to Miranda Yardley, the transwoman who got up and talked at the actual event.

Stonewall? Not so much.

My conscience genuinely wouldn't let me defend an organisation who employed a man whose business was training other men to coerce lesbians into sex.

And that would be my next favourite projection.

'Hey Stonewall, what's the cotton ceiling?'

Emblazoned right across the front of their office.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 00:51

Datun · 02/11/2026 00:39

Like the link says, if the framing of the debate is 'you don't exist' in the first place there's no where to go from there

Well that would be news to Miranda Yardley, the transwoman who got up and talked at the actual event.

Stonewall? Not so much.

My conscience genuinely wouldn't let me defend an organisation who employed a man whose business was training other men to coerce lesbians into sex.

And that would be my next favourite projection.

'Hey Stonewall, what's the cotton ceiling?'

Emblazoned right across the front of their office.

If you think pointing to individual instances of illiberal 'wrong speak' is a defence then it works both ways. The big picture here is what is really at the crux of two groups being unable able to talk to one another & how its being facilitated by the weaponisation of a minority of extremists.

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 02:08

totino’s post highlights how important it is to bring the receipts, because it seems like it’s been forgotten exactly what Stonewall did with people like Alex Drummond.

cryupmykingdom · 02/11/2026 02:40

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 02:08

totino’s post highlights how important it is to bring the receipts, because it seems like it’s been forgotten exactly what Stonewall did with people like Alex Drummond.

Bring the receipts, in order to maintain the numbers on the majority side, and then sit and wait.

Since the groups can't talk, the comparitive size of groupings, plus external factors, probably mainly economic, will determine who actually remains. Whether there's a need for talk after ? Unsure.

OldCrone · 02/11/2026 05:22

CoolforKats · 01/11/2026 23:44

Please enough with the denial, the goal posts have always been the same: Gender. And gender as a valid identity. Let's be honest here, its a concept that the gender critical movement can't or won't reckon with which is at the heart of this dispute that they will use all manner of other perverse motivations for the existence of trans people to avoid.

Now before anyone starts up, I get it. I get that for gender critical feminists gender identity is understood as a perpetuation of gender stereotypes but the thing is, that in itself doesn't invalidate the identity or the motivation for it existing. And if you can't accept trans people's own conception of their identity then there is no moving forward with a civilised discussion about competing rights.

I see only one way forward here & that's a recognition of gender identity (which isn't the same as justifying it) without attributing other nefarious motivations from gender critical feminists & trans people accepting that rights need to be balanced. And until gender critical feminists make a good faith charitable move in acknowledging gender as a legitimate identity they can't be realistically be considered to ever have been serious about wanting to debate.

Edited

I don't think anyone has suggested that people shouldn't be free to choose to have a gender identity.

But having a gender identity doesn't change your sex.

fromorbit · 02/11/2026 05:27

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 21:03

Thank you for all the responses.

I anticipated a lot of hate.

I do think it is hard to counter what JK has said. Sadly many of us women, with ordinary lives, do not have the uncancelabilty - (made up I am aware ) that JKR has. Massive respect JKR.

Important and useful post OP
Follow up comment. From JKR

⚢ Nyssa ANGRYffindyke ⚢
The things said in the screenshot are the superlative of disingenuous. Makes my blood boil. WE have been excluded from the conversation, WE have suffered the consequences of blatant misogynistic and homophobic legislation, WE have suffered the consequences of Self-ID.

LabourWomen’sDeclaration reposted
J.K. Rowling
As you might have guessed, my blood, too, boils. I've seen up close the harm they've done, through my Women's Fund and through Beira's Place. They're stupid as well as shameless if they think a slight shift in rhetoric will make us all forget the last decade.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 06:12

CoolforKats · 01/11/2026 23:44

Please enough with the denial, the goal posts have always been the same: Gender. And gender as a valid identity. Let's be honest here, its a concept that the gender critical movement can't or won't reckon with which is at the heart of this dispute that they will use all manner of other perverse motivations for the existence of trans people to avoid.

Now before anyone starts up, I get it. I get that for gender critical feminists gender identity is understood as a perpetuation of gender stereotypes but the thing is, that in itself doesn't invalidate the identity or the motivation for it existing. And if you can't accept trans people's own conception of their identity then there is no moving forward with a civilised discussion about competing rights.

I see only one way forward here & that's a recognition of gender identity (which isn't the same as justifying it) without attributing other nefarious motivations from gender critical feminists & trans people accepting that rights need to be balanced. And until gender critical feminists make a good faith charitable move in acknowledging gender as a legitimate identity they can't be realistically be considered to ever have been serious about wanting to debate.

Edited

You used the term gender critical several times in your post. I do not consider myself gender critical just a realist about sex.

OP posts:
fromorbit · 02/11/2026 06:15

CoolforKats · 01/11/2026 23:44

Please enough with the denial, the goal posts have always been the same: Gender. And gender as a valid identity. Let's be honest here, its a concept that the gender critical movement can't or won't reckon with which is at the heart of this dispute that they will use all manner of other perverse motivations for the existence of trans people to avoid.

Now before anyone starts up, I get it. I get that for gender critical feminists gender identity is understood as a perpetuation of gender stereotypes but the thing is, that in itself doesn't invalidate the identity or the motivation for it existing. And if you can't accept trans people's own conception of their identity then there is no moving forward with a civilised discussion about competing rights.

I see only one way forward here & that's a recognition of gender identity (which isn't the same as justifying it) without attributing other nefarious motivations from gender critical feminists & trans people accepting that rights need to be balanced. And until gender critical feminists make a good faith charitable move in acknowledging gender as a legitimate identity they can't be realistically be considered to ever have been serious about wanting to debate.

Edited

Gender identity concepts are a theory about how humans behave socially and sexually.

There are LOTS of theories, lots of cultures/religions with different gender patterns. Hundreds if not thousands of them worldwide. You think your particular theory is the bedrock which everyone has to accept. Yet every culture or religion thinks that. Humans are great at convincing themselves that their concept of gender patterns are the ideal. Yet a glance at human existence shows that reality is way more complicated.

A whole bunch of gender identities were invented on tumblr in the last ten years. Are ALL of them valid? Who decides ? What are the criteria? We have listened to trans people and you guys can't agree on anything and hate each other. Why should we listen to you when half of you think that genderfluid people don't exist and the other half do?

When you dig into it the whole thing collapses with semi circular definitions.

It also has huge conflict with other theories about humans like forms of sexuality.

It seems pretty clear that a bunch of straight males are into crossdressing for sexual reasons. Where do they fit? Are they all a different gender? 15 years ago most didn't think they were. Now gender theory is fashionable they tend to think of themselves differently and go crazy if you say they are guys.

If straight crossdressers are real then there are HUGE implications for gender theory. Most trans people seem to accept that crossdressers are a thing and they are different, but when you start asking questions about the dividing line they get anxious and defensive. Why?

The evidence is clear some men in dresses like raping and murdering women/kids. Are those guys actual men or trans? Who decides? If you want us to think all the male criminals in makeup/dresses are trans then there are huge safeguarding implications to that. When we start asking that question as happened in Scotland the whole thing starts to look absurd.

Then there are gay men who like crossdressing are they the real trans? What about drag queens? Gender identity is academic theory which makes NO sense in the real world. It is designed to quash other forms of identity which focus on letting people coming to terms with their actual body and sexuality.

Loads of women and men have seen through all this. JKR is merely the most famous.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 02/11/2026 06:25

Thanks for sharing OP, she's a class act, she sliced him and diced him with the truth of his organisations perfidy.
Thanks JKR 💐

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 06:34

fromorbit · 02/11/2026 06:15

Gender identity concepts are a theory about how humans behave socially and sexually.

There are LOTS of theories, lots of cultures/religions with different gender patterns. Hundreds if not thousands of them worldwide. You think your particular theory is the bedrock which everyone has to accept. Yet every culture or religion thinks that. Humans are great at convincing themselves that their concept of gender patterns are the ideal. Yet a glance at human existence shows that reality is way more complicated.

A whole bunch of gender identities were invented on tumblr in the last ten years. Are ALL of them valid? Who decides ? What are the criteria? We have listened to trans people and you guys can't agree on anything and hate each other. Why should we listen to you when half of you think that genderfluid people don't exist and the other half do?

When you dig into it the whole thing collapses with semi circular definitions.

It also has huge conflict with other theories about humans like forms of sexuality.

It seems pretty clear that a bunch of straight males are into crossdressing for sexual reasons. Where do they fit? Are they all a different gender? 15 years ago most didn't think they were. Now gender theory is fashionable they tend to think of themselves differently and go crazy if you say they are guys.

If straight crossdressers are real then there are HUGE implications for gender theory. Most trans people seem to accept that crossdressers are a thing and they are different, but when you start asking questions about the dividing line they get anxious and defensive. Why?

The evidence is clear some men in dresses like raping and murdering women/kids. Are those guys actual men or trans? Who decides? If you want us to think all the male criminals in makeup/dresses are trans then there are huge safeguarding implications to that. When we start asking that question as happened in Scotland the whole thing starts to look absurd.

Then there are gay men who like crossdressing are they the real trans? What about drag queens? Gender identity is academic theory which makes NO sense in the real world. It is designed to quash other forms of identity which focus on letting people coming to terms with their actual body and sexuality.

Loads of women and men have seen through all this. JKR is merely the most famous.

There are LOTS of theories, lots of cultures/religions with different gender patterns

You could say the same thing about the multitude of religious beliefs.

By the same logic atheists reasonably believe the same thing about theists but that doesn't give them the right to deny the validity of their identity or deny their right to advocate for their rights.

We can all reasonably disagree on other people's conception of identity….& we do because its individually subjective. But to say 'because I disagree & therefore my more valid identity extinguishes any claims you might have' is not living by egalitarian liberal principles that underpin western civilisation.

Barbie222 · 02/11/2026 06:42

That last paragraph is pretty close to the position trans activists took, @CoolforKats, and Stonewall’s influence here resulted in women’s safe spaces being taken away and given to bad actor men - which prompted the position we are in today and the general backlash we are seeing against trans women identifying into sport, prisons etc.

there still isn’t a satisfactory answer about how to safeguard women here.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 06:45

Barbie222 · 02/11/2026 06:42

That last paragraph is pretty close to the position trans activists took, @CoolforKats, and Stonewall’s influence here resulted in women’s safe spaces being taken away and given to bad actor men - which prompted the position we are in today and the general backlash we are seeing against trans women identifying into sport, prisons etc.

there still isn’t a satisfactory answer about how to safeguard women here.

You act as if exemptions from anti discrimination law for cis/natal women don't exist & they do so recognising identity is irrelevant to the justified protection of spaces.

Barbie222 · 02/11/2026 06:50

if recognising identity is irrelevant to the justified protection of spaces, it follows that trans women need to be housed in the male estate and male hospital wards despite their identification as female gender. Their inner gender is irrelevant when justifying the need for a single sex space.

This is the GC position so why are we arguing? There is no issue with people having personal beliefs about who they are, or with people having the right to explain their beliefs to others (on both sides). It becomes an issue when real world spaces are taken away from women - that’s the top and bottom of JKR’s position?

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 06:52

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 06:45

You act as if exemptions from anti discrimination law for cis/natal women don't exist & they do so recognising identity is irrelevant to the justified protection of spaces.

@CoolforKats this thread was started to discuss the post put out by JKR in response to Stonewall’s CEO comments about wanting to take the ‘heat’ out of the debate - ironic considering their stance was ‘no debate’.

If you have strong views about the trans community why not start a thread yourself? It would be good to be allowed one thread that is not distracted from the original post and descends into word salads including words such as cis and natal. In is acceptable to be a sex realist and also not have a fear (phobia) of people who do not conform to stereotypes.

OP posts:
CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:10

Barbie222 · 02/11/2026 06:50

if recognising identity is irrelevant to the justified protection of spaces, it follows that trans women need to be housed in the male estate and male hospital wards despite their identification as female gender. Their inner gender is irrelevant when justifying the need for a single sex space.

This is the GC position so why are we arguing? There is no issue with people having personal beliefs about who they are, or with people having the right to explain their beliefs to others (on both sides). It becomes an issue when real world spaces are taken away from women - that’s the top and bottom of JKR’s position?

if recognising identity is irrelevant to the justified protection of spaces, it follows that trans women need to be housed in the male estate and male hospital wards despite their identification as female gender. Their inner gender is irrelevant when justifying the need for a single sex space.

The law explicitly allows for that regardless of gender identity so what's the problem with acknowledging identity then?

that’s the top and bottom of JKR’s position?

Not quite. The problem is her framing that implies trans people as being either a danger to women or in a 'tom boy' phase. You don't get to use tropes to justify spaces & expect 'debate'. And what's more you don't need to because the law allows for exemptions if there's a legitimate aim.

Just like its not necessary to imply 'Muslims are terrorists' or 'Mexicans are rapists' to effectively discuss the concern of unsustainable & unchecked immigration, we don't need to dehumanise & demonise groups to make a valid point.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:13

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 06:52

@CoolforKats this thread was started to discuss the post put out by JKR in response to Stonewall’s CEO comments about wanting to take the ‘heat’ out of the debate - ironic considering their stance was ‘no debate’.

If you have strong views about the trans community why not start a thread yourself? It would be good to be allowed one thread that is not distracted from the original post and descends into word salads including words such as cis and natal. In is acceptable to be a sex realist and also not have a fear (phobia) of people who do not conform to stereotypes.

Edited

JKR specifically called out Stonewall in her post for their 'no debate' stance. I'm simply explaining why there can be 'no debate'. How is that not relevant to this discussion? Unless of course you aren't actually interested in getting a debate?

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 07:14

The problem is her framing that implies

No. The problem is the constant deliberately false inferring.

2021x · 02/11/2026 07:17

No debate only works if your rights do not infringe of someone else’s.

Debate is definitely needed if you are trying to convince society that reality is an illusion.

Women owning property doesn’t effect men’s rights too.

Gay people getting married doesn’t effect straight people’s right to OR the right to believe that marriage is between a man and a woman.

A man entering a female single sex space
does effect the privacy, dignity and safety of women due the facts that women are
more likely to be attacked by males in a private space where they remove their clothes.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 07:18

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:13

JKR specifically called out Stonewall in her post for their 'no debate' stance. I'm simply explaining why there can be 'no debate'. How is that not relevant to this discussion? Unless of course you aren't actually interested in getting a debate?

I am interested in people’s reaction to JKRs post from Sunday afternoon. Her post came off the back of an interview with the Stonewall CEO who appears to be backtracking and asking for a debate. I have no interest, on this thread, debating if cis or natal are relevant terms. I began this thread to discuss JKRs post on X yesterday. Others may want to distract from her excellent and timely post. I do not. She said out loud what many people think.

OP posts:
CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:27

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 07:18

I am interested in people’s reaction to JKRs post from Sunday afternoon. Her post came off the back of an interview with the Stonewall CEO who appears to be backtracking and asking for a debate. I have no interest, on this thread, debating if cis or natal are relevant terms. I began this thread to discuss JKRs post on X yesterday. Others may want to distract from her excellent and timely post. I do not. She said out loud what many people think.

Edited

And I'm giving you a relevant substantive 'reaction'. If you only wanted to limit reactions to agreement you should have said so….although that would hardly be relevant to a DISCUSSION forum.

Do you even know where you are? This isn't a fan club.

Barbie222 · 02/11/2026 07:31

To clarify the position you outline here, @CoolforKats:

Trans women understand and accept the need for them to use male facilities as the Supreme Court clarified

The main issue here is how JKR allegedly frames them (although there are many times when she’s openly says she has no issue with how people identify)?

im not sure that’s where we are in reality? Have you seen Reddit recently?

OldCrone · 02/11/2026 07:36

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:10

if recognising identity is irrelevant to the justified protection of spaces, it follows that trans women need to be housed in the male estate and male hospital wards despite their identification as female gender. Their inner gender is irrelevant when justifying the need for a single sex space.

The law explicitly allows for that regardless of gender identity so what's the problem with acknowledging identity then?

that’s the top and bottom of JKR’s position?

Not quite. The problem is her framing that implies trans people as being either a danger to women or in a 'tom boy' phase. You don't get to use tropes to justify spaces & expect 'debate'. And what's more you don't need to because the law allows for exemptions if there's a legitimate aim.

Just like its not necessary to imply 'Muslims are terrorists' or 'Mexicans are rapists' to effectively discuss the concern of unsustainable & unchecked immigration, we don't need to dehumanise & demonise groups to make a valid point.

The law explicitly allows for that regardless of gender identity so what's the problem with acknowledging identity then?

Has anyone said that people can't choose a gender identity?

The problem is her framing that implies trans people as being either a danger to women or in a 'tom boy' phase. You don't get to use tropes to justify spaces & expect 'debate'.

Has she said those are the only two possibilities? There are dozens more reasons for a trans identity, and I'm sure she's aware of that

we don't need to dehumanise & demonise groups to make a valid point.

Nobody is dehumanising or demonising whole groups. Apart from the TRAs who think "woman" is a costume. That's pretty dehumanising.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 07:39

Barbie222 · 02/11/2026 07:31

To clarify the position you outline here, @CoolforKats:

Trans women understand and accept the need for them to use male facilities as the Supreme Court clarified

The main issue here is how JKR allegedly frames them (although there are many times when she’s openly says she has no issue with how people identify)?

im not sure that’s where we are in reality? Have you seen Reddit recently?

Thank you @Barbie222 better articulated than my post.

Yes @CoolforKats I know where I am. I am on the Feminism board of Mumsnet.

I have at no point suggested this is a ‘fanclub’. You did that and you did it in a tone familiar on many of the threads around this subject. The tone being you dislike any dissent about gender identity.

As I say I started this thread in good faith to hear reactions to the actual post by JKR not particularly to stimulate another circular discussion about gender ideology which just repeat the same old list of word salads including nonsense never quite getting the gotcha moment they hope for.

OP posts:
CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:44

Barbie222 · 02/11/2026 07:31

To clarify the position you outline here, @CoolforKats:

Trans women understand and accept the need for them to use male facilities as the Supreme Court clarified

The main issue here is how JKR allegedly frames them (although there are many times when she’s openly says she has no issue with how people identify)?

im not sure that’s where we are in reality? Have you seen Reddit recently?

Firstly, the supreme court has clarified no such thing other than to say special exemptions apply to cis/ natal women not trans women that a legitimate aim justification is required. As yet there's no case law to confirm whether this applies to all contested spaces like public toilets other than employment law.

Secondly, talking out of both sides of your mouth by saying you have 'no issues with trans people' but at the same time implying harmful stereotypes is hardly 'having no issues'. You can't have it both ways.

Lastly, social media isn't the real world. Have you seen X recently?

Swipe left for the next trending thread