Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Judge lets ‘bright lad’ who stabbed girl 10 times avoid jail

152 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/10/2026 19:09

The young offender – who cannot be named because he is under 18 – had become obsessed with the girl at his school. He began using fake social media accounts to send her messages after she rejected his advances in December last year.

One morning in March, he waited for the girl near the shop and asked her out on a date. When she said no, he followed her, with a knife in his pocket and stabbed her at least 10 times, inflicting cuts to her neck, hands and face.

Footage released by the police shows the boy chasing the girl through the store with the knife in his hand.

...

Transcripts of court hearings in the case, seen by The Telegraph, reveal that Judge Ian Lawrie KC’s principal consideration was the offender’s rehabilitation.

“You’re a bright lad – I’m going to impose a curfew,” the judge said.
“You’re not to contact directly or indirectly by any means, social media or otherwise, [the victim] and her mother, and also keep out of mischief.

“My own view is custody is the last place you should be... What I’m trying to do is find a sentence that’s best constructed to help you and give you support.”

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/10/27/teenager-stabbed-girl-judge-ian-lawrie/

And also https://archive.is/RGbaZ

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 01/11/2026 18:43

I was poking about the history of a particular prison yesterday and came across a case from 1887 that struck me in relation to this one. A 28 year old man stabbed an 18 year old woman 40 times because she refused his advances, she died.

It caught me in a bloody hell, there's nothing new under the sun kind of way. It wasn't the only case I found of a woman murdered due to rejecting a mans advances, and although one can look at and make arguments about the social attitudes at that time men are still attacking and sometimesl killing women who reject them, and women still have no way of knowing which men are going to do it.

Interestingly the first trial saw the jury unable to make a decision due to the questioning of the murderers sanity. The second jury rejected the insanity argument and he was convicted, and hanged. Murder is usually a singular catastrophic event, people I know who have worked with men convicted of murder mention that the thing that strikes most is how very ordinary they are, not insane, just people like the rest of us. But that's scary so we tend to attribute things to murderers, and other violent people, to make the distinction between us and them. I think it is a cop out to not face up to what humans are capable of.

Note, I am not advoctaing for the return of capital punishment, I thought I'd better mention that as false inferences abound in this particular form of communication.

MarieDeGournay · 02/11/2026 10:30

It's interesting that a woman refusing advances is used as a defence for murder, and a man making advances is also used as a defence,
i.e. the 'homosexual panic defence' - murder caused by the understandable loss of control brought about by the obviously intolerable horror of a man making sexual advances to another man. 😒

New posts on this thread. Refresh page