Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Judge lets ‘bright lad’ who stabbed girl 10 times avoid jail

152 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/10/2026 19:09

The young offender – who cannot be named because he is under 18 – had become obsessed with the girl at his school. He began using fake social media accounts to send her messages after she rejected his advances in December last year.

One morning in March, he waited for the girl near the shop and asked her out on a date. When she said no, he followed her, with a knife in his pocket and stabbed her at least 10 times, inflicting cuts to her neck, hands and face.

Footage released by the police shows the boy chasing the girl through the store with the knife in his hand.

...

Transcripts of court hearings in the case, seen by The Telegraph, reveal that Judge Ian Lawrie KC’s principal consideration was the offender’s rehabilitation.

“You’re a bright lad – I’m going to impose a curfew,” the judge said.
“You’re not to contact directly or indirectly by any means, social media or otherwise, [the victim] and her mother, and also keep out of mischief.

“My own view is custody is the last place you should be... What I’m trying to do is find a sentence that’s best constructed to help you and give you support.”

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/10/27/teenager-stabbed-girl-judge-ian-lawrie/

And also https://archive.is/RGbaZ

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Awkwardisfunny · 29/10/2026 14:58

IwantToRetire · 28/10/2026 19:09

The young offender – who cannot be named because he is under 18 – had become obsessed with the girl at his school. He began using fake social media accounts to send her messages after she rejected his advances in December last year.

One morning in March, he waited for the girl near the shop and asked her out on a date. When she said no, he followed her, with a knife in his pocket and stabbed her at least 10 times, inflicting cuts to her neck, hands and face.

Footage released by the police shows the boy chasing the girl through the store with the knife in his hand.

...

Transcripts of court hearings in the case, seen by The Telegraph, reveal that Judge Ian Lawrie KC’s principal consideration was the offender’s rehabilitation.

“You’re a bright lad – I’m going to impose a curfew,” the judge said.
“You’re not to contact directly or indirectly by any means, social media or otherwise, [the victim] and her mother, and also keep out of mischief.

“My own view is custody is the last place you should be... What I’m trying to do is find a sentence that’s best constructed to help you and give you support.”

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/10/27/teenager-stabbed-girl-judge-ian-lawrie/

And also https://archive.is/RGbaZ

Whaaaaaaaaaaat

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 29/10/2026 15:27

MrMurphysComeuppance · 29/10/2026 12:45

Wow. I don't know what to say.

This judge needs to be struck off. He's clearly not competent.

I don't think striking him off goes nearly far enough; he should be in the dock himself and charged to try to defend his harmful personal beliefs that caused him to abuse his position to deny justice to a female victim.

How are his clearly-demonstrated views about women and girls any different in how dangerous they are than those of a would-be terrorist who is caught by Prevent? Is it purely based on the number of their potential victims, assuming the criminal who leaves with a slapped wrist doesn't go to attack 'too many'?

In fact, the latter isn't officially sanctioned, permitted and handsomely paid to promulgate the outworkings of their views; so in that respect, the judges are clearly far more harmful.

TheFlirtationsNothingButAHeartacheNsoul · 29/10/2026 16:04

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/10/2026 14:06

Muy thai here. But also telling DD that women often freeze so whatever happens if there is an incident, she is not to feel guilt or shame.

There was a boy with a knife at her school and parents were emailed to say, "#BeKind, don't talk about it, don't be mean to the boy". I went full psycho-mum on the male headmaster. Imagine telling girls to be understanding to the boy that tried to stab a female teacher.

Bloody hell talk about brushing it under the carpet probably to avoid adverse publicity for the school.
Just so wrong.

EasternStandard · 29/10/2026 16:12

I’m not sure it’s just the judge. I feel really upset it happened. Even if the boy gets more time or something the poor girl is suffering from this.

Womanofcustard · 29/10/2026 16:29

Could the girl’s parents take out a private prosecution?

Newname26 · 29/10/2026 16:37

I actually can't get my head round this he stabbed her 10 times.
He was 14 he could so easily have killed her. Probably luck rather than anything else that he didn't.

Here's whats messing with my head right now and the very light sentences for young boys.
There was nothing light about the sentences that were given to Jamie Bulgers killers. They were 10, primary school age children and given indefinite sentences. What would they have got if it happened now? 30 years later.

DrBlackbird · 29/10/2026 17:29

Koalacanth · 29/10/2026 03:16

Maybe he was inspired by that show 'Adolescence' - this attack seems eerily similar to it.

When I watched and all those accolades were being showered on it, my thought was no, this isn’t a great film opening up important conversations about the manosphere influence on teen boys (what’s happened since then? Nothing). Instead the greater likelihood is it’s going to inspire other adolescent boys to do the same.

IwantToRetire · 29/10/2026 18:24

DrBlackbird · 29/10/2026 17:29

When I watched and all those accolades were being showered on it, my thought was no, this isn’t a great film opening up important conversations about the manosphere influence on teen boys (what’s happened since then? Nothing). Instead the greater likelihood is it’s going to inspire other adolescent boys to do the same.

I think sadly this is true.

OP posts:
IwantToRetire · 29/10/2026 18:27

I think it was earlier on on this thread that surely this is something that MNers cant do (as it had before?).

So not quite a petition but if someone has time to set up an AIBU and try and let other related threads ie not just FWR to get a response.

Supposedly, even though it is losing users, MN still has some clout in the media.

Any offers, or suggestions for wording?

OP posts:
solerolover · 29/10/2026 18:30

This is an absolutely horrendous decision from the judge, I'm at a loss for words.

PaterPower · 30/10/2026 16:58

I also think the judge could have formulated a better sentence than this.

But isn’t this the direction of travel we (society) have been following for offenders younger than 18? That locking them up is inappropriate and doesn’t have an impact on them reoffending later?

ScrollingLeaves · 30/10/2026 17:26

PaterPower · 30/10/2026 16:58

I also think the judge could have formulated a better sentence than this.

But isn’t this the direction of travel we (society) have been following for offenders younger than 18? That locking them up is inappropriate and doesn’t have an impact on them reoffending later?

That locking them up is inappropriate and doesn’t have an impact on them reoffending later?
It is probably true.

They do need to be locked up imo, but in appropriate places where they can be helped properly.

YourAmplePlumPoster · 31/10/2026 00:13

The current mentality of the judiciary is that they don't want to incarcerate young offenders as it sets them onto a path of lifelong crime.

YourAmplePlumPoster · 31/10/2026 00:15

He should be in a secure unit where there is rehabilitation and treatment available.

TracyBeakerSoYeah · 31/10/2026 00:35

So if this 'bright' young lad only causing mischief?
If I was the mother of the victim & decided to stab the scroat with a knife a couple of times then I assume that would be ok too, as I am a very bright but older thing & have led an exemplary life so far?
And I pay my taxes too, so I'm far more deserving of a little slap on the hand & a pat on the head.
Or would that only apply to my husband? 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♂️

hotmumshit · 31/10/2026 00:44

Is there a petition yet please? X

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 00:54

Whilst I am not supporting this sentencing or the comments made by the judge, the context may be more nuanced than is immediately obviously.

This podcast gave an insight into youth offender sentencing in the Fordingbridge rape case. It doesn't seem that punishment really comes into the considerations and that young offender institutions are not conducive to rehabilitation.

https://open.spotify.com/episode/3sM5fya66iHYi44RylIAG2?si=K7p2NlehQj-VZnxrcd7WYQ&utm_source=copy-link

The Fordingbridge Rape Sentences: The Dilemma of Sentencing Children for Serious Crime.

Double Jeopardy - UK Law and Politics · Episode

https://open.spotify.com/episode/3sM5fya66iHYi44RylIAG2?si=K7p2NlehQj-VZnxrcd7WYQ&utm_source=copy-link

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 31/10/2026 08:21

The question for me is do girls have equal human rights to boys or not. This sentence, and others like it, suggest not.

There seems no concern about risks and potential future victims. No effort to make this victim feel safer, to feel she has the basic human right to life, to safety, to liberty. Why are her rights not discussed or balanced. It's all about the boy. There's a vast body of evidence about escalation of male violence - when males get away with violence, they usually escalate.

Why are judges getting away with treating girls as less deserving of full human rights as boys? The bias and discrimination in the approach seems clear. Sex is a PC under EA 2010. Why are judges allowed to get away with anti-female bias?

EasternStandard · 31/10/2026 08:32

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 31/10/2026 08:21

The question for me is do girls have equal human rights to boys or not. This sentence, and others like it, suggest not.

There seems no concern about risks and potential future victims. No effort to make this victim feel safer, to feel she has the basic human right to life, to safety, to liberty. Why are her rights not discussed or balanced. It's all about the boy. There's a vast body of evidence about escalation of male violence - when males get away with violence, they usually escalate.

Why are judges getting away with treating girls as less deserving of full human rights as boys? The bias and discrimination in the approach seems clear. Sex is a PC under EA 2010. Why are judges allowed to get away with anti-female bias?

Yes and the language is upsetting. The boys are generally mollified and with that the girl is forgotten and de-prioritised, it must feel so exclusionary.

The injustice is enraging and frustratingly sad.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 08:35

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 31/10/2026 08:21

The question for me is do girls have equal human rights to boys or not. This sentence, and others like it, suggest not.

There seems no concern about risks and potential future victims. No effort to make this victim feel safer, to feel she has the basic human right to life, to safety, to liberty. Why are her rights not discussed or balanced. It's all about the boy. There's a vast body of evidence about escalation of male violence - when males get away with violence, they usually escalate.

Why are judges getting away with treating girls as less deserving of full human rights as boys? The bias and discrimination in the approach seems clear. Sex is a PC under EA 2010. Why are judges allowed to get away with anti-female bias?

Exactly.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 08:37

EasternStandard · 31/10/2026 08:32

Yes and the language is upsetting. The boys are generally mollified and with that the girl is forgotten and de-prioritised, it must feel so exclusionary.

The injustice is enraging and frustratingly sad.

It’s actually one of the main problems I had with the “Adolescence” drama that Starmer was such a fan of and thought should be shown in schools. The female murder victim is not the focus, she’s largely irrelevant. There’s more than a whiff of victim blaming.

Notonmyland · 31/10/2026 09:19

YourAmplePlumPoster · 31/10/2026 00:13

The current mentality of the judiciary is that they don't want to incarcerate young offenders as it sets them onto a path of lifelong crime.

That's political.

The government has to change policy before the police and courts can do anything.

This is what the police told people after the murder of Ibrahim in New Moston.

BatFeminist · 31/10/2026 09:38

Have emailed my mp quoting the governments VAWG strategy. See what good if any that will do

EasternStandard · 31/10/2026 09:55

Notonmyland · 31/10/2026 09:19

That's political.

The government has to change policy before the police and courts can do anything.

This is what the police told people after the murder of Ibrahim in New Moston.

True it’s political. The judiciary and police follow the laws.