Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Judge lets ‘bright lad’ who stabbed girl 10 times avoid jail

152 replies

IwantToRetire · 28/10/2026 19:09

The young offender – who cannot be named because he is under 18 – had become obsessed with the girl at his school. He began using fake social media accounts to send her messages after she rejected his advances in December last year.

One morning in March, he waited for the girl near the shop and asked her out on a date. When she said no, he followed her, with a knife in his pocket and stabbed her at least 10 times, inflicting cuts to her neck, hands and face.

Footage released by the police shows the boy chasing the girl through the store with the knife in his hand.

...

Transcripts of court hearings in the case, seen by The Telegraph, reveal that Judge Ian Lawrie KC’s principal consideration was the offender’s rehabilitation.

“You’re a bright lad – I’m going to impose a curfew,” the judge said.
“You’re not to contact directly or indirectly by any means, social media or otherwise, [the victim] and her mother, and also keep out of mischief.

“My own view is custody is the last place you should be... What I’m trying to do is find a sentence that’s best constructed to help you and give you support.”

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/10/27/teenager-stabbed-girl-judge-ian-lawrie/

And also https://archive.is/RGbaZ

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SwirlyGates · 31/10/2026 10:12

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 00:54

Whilst I am not supporting this sentencing or the comments made by the judge, the context may be more nuanced than is immediately obviously.

This podcast gave an insight into youth offender sentencing in the Fordingbridge rape case. It doesn't seem that punishment really comes into the considerations and that young offender institutions are not conducive to rehabilitation.

https://open.spotify.com/episode/3sM5fya66iHYi44RylIAG2?si=K7p2NlehQj-VZnxrcd7WYQ&utm_source=copy-link

Then we need some other kind of incarceration.

We need somewhere to lock up these monsters - yes, to rehabilitate them of course, but also to protect the public in the meantime and to give some kind of justice to the victims.

Oh, and the Fordingbridge rapists were apparently too dim to know that rape was wrong. This boy is "bright", so perhaps the judge thinks prison is beneath him. Which level of intellectual averageness then is suitable for locking them away?

SwirlyGates · 31/10/2026 10:14

hotmumshit · 31/10/2026 00:44

Is there a petition yet please? X

There's one above, linked by theserockingchicks. Small numbers so far.

I'm also going to write to my MP.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 10:25

SwirlyGates · 31/10/2026 10:12

Then we need some other kind of incarceration.

We need somewhere to lock up these monsters - yes, to rehabilitate them of course, but also to protect the public in the meantime and to give some kind of justice to the victims.

Oh, and the Fordingbridge rapists were apparently too dim to know that rape was wrong. This boy is "bright", so perhaps the judge thinks prison is beneath him. Which level of intellectual averageness then is suitable for locking them away?

Agree, it shows so much contempt for women and girls. It sends a really shitty message.

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 10:59

SwirlyGates · 31/10/2026 10:12

Then we need some other kind of incarceration.

We need somewhere to lock up these monsters - yes, to rehabilitate them of course, but also to protect the public in the meantime and to give some kind of justice to the victims.

Oh, and the Fordingbridge rapists were apparently too dim to know that rape was wrong. This boy is "bright", so perhaps the judge thinks prison is beneath him. Which level of intellectual averageness then is suitable for locking them away?

Effective incarceration for rehabilitation would be expensive and there doesn't seem to be the political will from any party to spend more on prisons or young offenders institutions.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 11:25

FizzyPopLove · 31/10/2026 11:03

You can ask for a lenient sentence to be reviewed. https://www.gov.uk/ask-crown-court-sentence-review

People have tried and been fobbed off dismissively, apparently youth court sentences aren’t included in the “scheme”.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 11:26

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 10:59

Effective incarceration for rehabilitation would be expensive and there doesn't seem to be the political will from any party to spend more on prisons or young offenders institutions.

Most people think rehabilitation needs to be balanced with victim rights, justice and punishment. The parties might like to think about that.

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 11:34

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 11:26

Most people think rehabilitation needs to be balanced with victim rights, justice and punishment. The parties might like to think about that.

What are you actually suggesting as the solution?

I think it needs to be something that, as a minimum, doesn't produce people who are a higher risk to the public than when they were sentenced.

Allseeingallknowing · 31/10/2026 12:51

hotmumshit · 31/10/2026 10:17

Got it, thanks @SwirlyGates

Signed xx

I signed it but they keep asking for donations.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 13:23

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 11:34

What are you actually suggesting as the solution?

I think it needs to be something that, as a minimum, doesn't produce people who are a higher risk to the public than when they were sentenced.

Im suggesting that people go to prison for violent crime. I don’t think it’s a particularly unreasonable expectation.

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 14:25

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 13:23

Im suggesting that people go to prison for violent crime. I don’t think it’s a particularly unreasonable expectation.

Are you willing to pay more tax to make that happen?

At the moment, young people are much more likely to commit further crimes if they get a custodial sentence, compared to rehabilitation in the community. So we are creating more victims if we demand more prison sentences for youth offenders, purely for our desire for punishment and to see justice being done.

If we want young offender institutions to be used, but also be effective places of rehabilitation and not pass the problem on to future victims, they need to change and will need more resources.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 15:30

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 14:25

Are you willing to pay more tax to make that happen?

At the moment, young people are much more likely to commit further crimes if they get a custodial sentence, compared to rehabilitation in the community. So we are creating more victims if we demand more prison sentences for youth offenders, purely for our desire for punishment and to see justice being done.

If we want young offender institutions to be used, but also be effective places of rehabilitation and not pass the problem on to future victims, they need to change and will need more resources.

I think we’re going to have to agree to disagree here, I’m simply saying there needs to be a balance and justice for victims is important too. Not debating the fine details but I’m not an anti-carceral feminist, shall we say, and when you grievously wound someone that isn’t in self defence, you should be punished. It’s not just about rehabilitation. It’s about the message it sends to society.

BlackBirdInFlight · 31/10/2026 15:36

Signed

fudgy · 31/10/2026 15:38

Horrific, the poor girl, her family and all the other girls who have now been sent the message that there is no punishment for this kind of crime. In addition men and boys inclined to do this kind of thing may rightly assume that its not that big of a deal in the eyes of the law to harm women or girls in this way.

I thought the current government has declared violence against women and girls a national emergency?

lcakethereforeIam · 31/10/2026 16:18

Surely a properly funded prison system that rehabilitates offenders will in the long term save money? I don't think there's the political will to make that investment. Particularly when governments are looking to save money and prisons are an easy, if shortsighted, place to make cuts. Crumbling prisons, poorly paid, trained and motivated staff, open to corruption, inmates bored and brutalised, unless you or a loved one is incarcerated most people don't see that. They see if a repeat offender targets them but it's seen as a failure of policing or in the criminal more often than not, not a failure to rehabilitate because of the shit state of the prisons.

There's the same problems in probation.

This boy was, despite his best efforts, likely millimetres from being a murderer. His nature and environment did that to him. He was a blank slate. Prison didn't corrupt him. Releasing him to the same life will not rehabilitate him. I hope the other measures put in place will.

YourAmplePlumPoster · 31/10/2026 16:23

Talking as someone who worked in YOI, the notion of rehabilitation is a Liberal fantasy. With the background checks, most employers won't touch them with a bargepole which is why the judiciary have decided prison is the last resort. They can't get jobs and will reoffend. Simple as that. They may even be let out of jail with a few quid in their pocket and nowhere to go.

lcakethereforeIam · 31/10/2026 16:28

I nearly added something about homelessness but I'd droned on for long enough.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 16:54

fudgy · 31/10/2026 15:38

Horrific, the poor girl, her family and all the other girls who have now been sent the message that there is no punishment for this kind of crime. In addition men and boys inclined to do this kind of thing may rightly assume that its not that big of a deal in the eyes of the law to harm women or girls in this way.

I thought the current government has declared violence against women and girls a national emergency?

Edited

Well quite.

YourAmplePlumPoster · 31/10/2026 17:11

Of course this boy should be in a secure unit where he would get psychiatric treatment and meds but they are few and far between. This is a mental health crisis which has been going on a long time under all Governments. I assumed he should have been sectioned and wasn't. In the toxic mix you have human rights lawyers who get state money to spring them from secure units or prisons. I have seen all of this in action.

likelysuspect · 31/10/2026 17:56

YourAmplePlumPoster · 31/10/2026 17:11

Of course this boy should be in a secure unit where he would get psychiatric treatment and meds but they are few and far between. This is a mental health crisis which has been going on a long time under all Governments. I assumed he should have been sectioned and wasn't. In the toxic mix you have human rights lawyers who get state money to spring them from secure units or prisons. I have seen all of this in action.

What diagnosed, treatable MH condition does he have?

Weirdpig · 31/10/2026 20:44

lcakethereforeIam · 31/10/2026 16:18

Surely a properly funded prison system that rehabilitates offenders will in the long term save money? I don't think there's the political will to make that investment. Particularly when governments are looking to save money and prisons are an easy, if shortsighted, place to make cuts. Crumbling prisons, poorly paid, trained and motivated staff, open to corruption, inmates bored and brutalised, unless you or a loved one is incarcerated most people don't see that. They see if a repeat offender targets them but it's seen as a failure of policing or in the criminal more often than not, not a failure to rehabilitate because of the shit state of the prisons.

There's the same problems in probation.

This boy was, despite his best efforts, likely millimetres from being a murderer. His nature and environment did that to him. He was a blank slate. Prison didn't corrupt him. Releasing him to the same life will not rehabilitate him. I hope the other measures put in place will.

Politics is full of short-termism. The criminal justice system is an example of this. The up-front cost of rehabilitation wouldn't result in lowered recidivism for years.

YourAmplePlumPoster · 01/11/2026 17:13

likelysuspect · 31/10/2026 17:56

What diagnosed, treatable MH condition does he have?

You think stabbing someone is not a sign of mental illness?

EasternStandard · 01/11/2026 17:21

YourAmplePlumPoster · 01/11/2026 17:13

You think stabbing someone is not a sign of mental illness?

It’s a fair question though, which MH condition are you thinking of?

likelysuspect · 01/11/2026 17:42

YourAmplePlumPoster · 01/11/2026 17:13

You think stabbing someone is not a sign of mental illness?

No I dont. Which one?

You could have a condition and that condition cause you to stab someone.

But stabbing someone per se, just as a standalone action is not 'a sign of MH illness'

Which one?

Swipe left for the next trending thread