Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
anyolddinosaur · 27/10/2026 08:30

Honestly who really cares about the size of the hospital apart from knowing that Upton was not the only doctor there. As he still needs supervision he clearly was not.

I dont need to see a woman for intimate care but if it wouldnt delay my treatment I'd prefer it. I wouldnt go for breast cancer screening if there was a man present. I dont need to give a reason. If I am seeing a male doctor I dont wish to see one with a poor understanding of biology and a willingness to ignore womens feelings. So I understand this woman not wishing to be treated by Upton.

Again who cares whether Upton went to treat her or she just saw him and feared he would be. That fear was real and is founded on what he said he would do. If he has changed and now recognises women can have boundaries she'd have no way of knowing that. He's still dressing as a woman, so still pretending he is, has not expressed any public regret for his behaviour.

Screamingabdabz · 27/10/2026 08:35

At this point, the danger is not even so much that he’s male, it’s that he shows utter contempt for women and sounds like he’s on a power trip to prove it.

legalalien · 27/10/2026 08:39

Ironically for female stuff I’ve always preferred a male doctor as it feels very impersonal/ clinical and I don’t want to have an empathetic/ feelings type conversation in that context. So I’d probably prefer to rule out the Dr Uptons / biological males with stereotypically feminine traits. Not sure how requesting that would go down.

Screamingabdabz · 27/10/2026 08:50

legalalien · 27/10/2026 08:39

Ironically for female stuff I’ve always preferred a male doctor as it feels very impersonal/ clinical and I don’t want to have an empathetic/ feelings type conversation in that context. So I’d probably prefer to rule out the Dr Uptons / biological males with stereotypically feminine traits. Not sure how requesting that would go down.

Me too. Not bothered at all to be seen by male doctors, but I’d rather have a hairy arsed barn door of a bloke than one who clearly has a mental health issue around females and his perception of womanhood.

TWETMIRF · 27/10/2026 08:56

We're told often enough that transwomen are so upset by their bodies that they wouldn't want to put themselves in situations that remind them they are not female. The traditional type of transwoman that TRAs want us to imagine.

Surely that just proves the likes of DrU who actively puts himself in a position to be alone with vulnerable women who are hurt/ill in potential state of undress, are fetishists.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 09:05

anyolddinosaur · 27/10/2026 08:30

Honestly who really cares about the size of the hospital apart from knowing that Upton was not the only doctor there. As he still needs supervision he clearly was not.

I dont need to see a woman for intimate care but if it wouldnt delay my treatment I'd prefer it. I wouldnt go for breast cancer screening if there was a man present. I dont need to give a reason. If I am seeing a male doctor I dont wish to see one with a poor understanding of biology and a willingness to ignore womens feelings. So I understand this woman not wishing to be treated by Upton.

Again who cares whether Upton went to treat her or she just saw him and feared he would be. That fear was real and is founded on what he said he would do. If he has changed and now recognises women can have boundaries she'd have no way of knowing that. He's still dressing as a woman, so still pretending he is, has not expressed any public regret for his behaviour.

"Honestly who really cares about the size of the hospital apart from knowing that Upton was not the only doctor there."

yep.

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 09:35

NotBadConsidering · 27/10/2026 08:23

Because you have repeatedly claimed, despite the experience of others, the size of the hospital dictates it’s very likely Upton was part of an all-male medical team at the time of the patient’s presentation.

When you have attended the hospital, for example when your grandmother was dying, how often did you not see a single female doctor?

Upton is a JHO. He will have other junior staff on the roster with him at any given time and more senior staff on shift at every possible time. Even the worst odds are 50:50 that the registrar on shift with him at the time was a woman.

@NotBadConsidering

Because you have repeatedly claimed, despite the experience of others, the size of the hospital dictates it’s very likely Upton was part of an all-male medical team at the time of the patient’s presentation.
When you have attended the hospital, for example when your grandmother was dying, how often did you not see a single female doctor?
Upton is a JHO. He will have other junior staff on the roster with him at any given time and more senior staff on shift at every possible time. Even the worst odds are 50:50 that the registrar on shift with him at the time was a woman.

My experience of Australian hospitals EDs, of which I have plenty unfortunately, is that you can ask for a female doctor in preference to a male one, but you will have to wait longer if you do.

I’m nit quite sure what you mean with the “single female doctor” question. Yes, it’s possible female doctors were on shift that day, but whether it was possible for them to see the patient is another question.

cryupmykingdom · 27/10/2026 09:39

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 07:03

There is an additional power dynamic that is very clear once you see it and it is the demand to use the demanded language.

By demanding that female patients use language such as ‘cis gender female doctor’ when either requesting a female doctor or rejecting a male doctor. This puts female people in the position of having again to use the demanded language of a group’s philosophical belief to get respect. It means that the power dynamic is again with those male doctors who claim to be female.

The dynamic is ‘use my language (as per my philosophical belief) or you will have me, a male health care professional, present myself to you as a female HCP because you didn’t use the language that a minority of people understand. (And by the way, even those claiming to know what ‘cis’ means have confusion). This is not consent. This is not respect and it is not acceptable as a level of care.

Because it puts female people in a position where they have to know to use the specific language that may have a greater chance of avoiding having to deal with the situation where a male doctor comes.

All because a group has acquired the use of common language which then renders the established reference terms meaningless that the majority understand to have clear definitional boundaries (and the group deny that they have done so) because they have their own philosophical belief in what those words should mean.

It again forces compliance to a group’s philosophical belief and is evidence that communication is negatively impacted by that belief.

Only use "cisgender" when attributed. The term may be unfamiliar to many, and is offensive to some. [BBC Style Guide, 2026]

My little campaign against the c_s slur appears to have borne fruit.

C-s is part of what Robert J Lifton calls cults 'milieu control', framing things according to the cult's view as tho it's normal. It's best to avoid their jargon.

theilltemperedmonster · 27/10/2026 09:42

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 07:36

I think illtempered was indeed pointing out that the staff member may have meant :

A hospital staff member said: ‘It should now be very clear why Dr Upton wanted to come to work in Australia. Our laws, as they stand, mean he is regarded as a woman here.

‘But it was always only a matter of time before an allegation like this was made.’

was referring to women being outed as bigots (from the staff member quoted’s point of view )

Ironically, given the number of PPs who misunderstood this post of mine, it turned out that I had actually misunderstood the "staff member", because I didn't register that she used a male pronoun for Upton. This would have sounded the "transphobia" klaxon to any attentive trans ally.

The effects of this ideology on simple communication does my head in sometimes.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 09:49

theilltemperedmonster · 27/10/2026 09:42

Ironically, given the number of PPs who misunderstood this post of mine, it turned out that I had actually misunderstood the "staff member", because I didn't register that she used a male pronoun for Upton. This would have sounded the "transphobia" klaxon to any attentive trans ally.

The effects of this ideology on simple communication does my head in sometimes.

I hear you. The use of two letters makes a difference.

SirChenjins · 27/10/2026 09:51

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 09:35

@NotBadConsidering

Because you have repeatedly claimed, despite the experience of others, the size of the hospital dictates it’s very likely Upton was part of an all-male medical team at the time of the patient’s presentation.
When you have attended the hospital, for example when your grandmother was dying, how often did you not see a single female doctor?
Upton is a JHO. He will have other junior staff on the roster with him at any given time and more senior staff on shift at every possible time. Even the worst odds are 50:50 that the registrar on shift with him at the time was a woman.

My experience of Australian hospitals EDs, of which I have plenty unfortunately, is that you can ask for a female doctor in preference to a male one, but you will have to wait longer if you do.

I’m nit quite sure what you mean with the “single female doctor” question. Yes, it’s possible female doctors were on shift that day, but whether it was possible for them to see the patient is another question.

My experience of Australian hospitals EDs, of which I have plenty unfortunately, is that you can ask for a female doctor in preference to a male one, but you will have to wait longer if you do

At the risk of repeating myself, you were very clear earlier in this thread that women could not make the request. You've made a number of claims on this thread which then double back on themselves, so it's hard to keep up with you.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 27/10/2026 09:53

cryupmykingdom · 27/10/2026 09:39

Only use "cisgender" when attributed. The term may be unfamiliar to many, and is offensive to some. [BBC Style Guide, 2026]

My little campaign against the c_s slur appears to have borne fruit.

C-s is part of what Robert J Lifton calls cults 'milieu control', framing things according to the cult's view as tho it's normal. It's best to avoid their jargon.

Edited

Excellent work💚🤍💜

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 09:59

@SirChenjins

At the risk of repeating myself, you were very clear earlier in this thread that women could not make the request. You've made a number of claims on this thread which then double back on themselves, so it's hard to keep up with you.

I rephrased it for your benefit. It’s possible to ask. No-one’s going to stop you from making a request, even it is largely a pointless one. So ask away all you want.

Do you see the difference?

NotBadConsidering · 27/10/2026 10:01

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 09:35

@NotBadConsidering

Because you have repeatedly claimed, despite the experience of others, the size of the hospital dictates it’s very likely Upton was part of an all-male medical team at the time of the patient’s presentation.
When you have attended the hospital, for example when your grandmother was dying, how often did you not see a single female doctor?
Upton is a JHO. He will have other junior staff on the roster with him at any given time and more senior staff on shift at every possible time. Even the worst odds are 50:50 that the registrar on shift with him at the time was a woman.

My experience of Australian hospitals EDs, of which I have plenty unfortunately, is that you can ask for a female doctor in preference to a male one, but you will have to wait longer if you do.

I’m nit quite sure what you mean with the “single female doctor” question. Yes, it’s possible female doctors were on shift that day, but whether it was possible for them to see the patient is another question.

you can ask for a female doctor in preference to a male one, but you will have to wait longer if you do.

And everyone agrees with this. But your assertion, which you made on page 7 of this thread, and which you kept repeating and refused to move on from, is that it is likely there wasn’t a female doctor available at all because PMBH is small/tiny/too busy (delete depending on mood).

Now you are finally acknowledging:

Yes, it’s possible female doctors were on shift that day, but whether it was possible for them to see the patient is another question.

So you’re finally at the point everyone was telling you back on page 7. It only took you 13 pages of repetition to get here. Well done 🙄

Now that it’s settled that it’s possible/likely there was a female doctor in the teeny tiny hospital we can ask for an investigation as to why that person wasn’t offered to the patient.

Maybe there were genuine logistical difficulties. Maybe the female registrar was stuck with a resuscitation. Or maybe Upton put himself forward as a woman. Maybe the staff backed him up. But at last we can finally move on from “junior overseas doctor man was probably the only warm body in tiny hospital in the sticks” hand-waving explanation.

cryupmykingdom · 27/10/2026 10:14

legalalien · 27/10/2026 08:39

Ironically for female stuff I’ve always preferred a male doctor as it feels very impersonal/ clinical and I don’t want to have an empathetic/ feelings type conversation in that context. So I’d probably prefer to rule out the Dr Uptons / biological males with stereotypically feminine traits. Not sure how requesting that would go down.

You should request a beardy doctor holding a pint of Worthingtons, in a masonic apron.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 10:15

“ask for an investigation as to why that person wasn’t offered to the patient.”

And a clarification as to state policy, any local policy, and then how it all works with federal policy.

There ARE women in Australia requesting female care and having male people present themselves and the woman then feels she has no choice because of risk of negative outcome so say nothing.

This is a consent and safeguarding issue. If the heath care provider is up front that there are no female staff, then a patient can make an informed choice.

A woman has now said something and friends have reported it to either media or media have picked it up. I have seen her and her husband denigrated on this thread, image the bravery it takes to be that woman who said anything.

An investigate would be a fucking great start. Of course, no female patient should have been in this situation to start with. I suspect it will need some legal action to resolve the issue (I am not saying this woman should do this) because it comes down to how laws and policies are being interpreted and whether the laws and policies are doing their job protecting female patients.

BezMark · 27/10/2026 10:18

cryupmykingdom · 27/10/2026 09:39

Only use "cisgender" when attributed. The term may be unfamiliar to many, and is offensive to some. [BBC Style Guide, 2026]

My little campaign against the c_s slur appears to have borne fruit.

C-s is part of what Robert J Lifton calls cults 'milieu control', framing things according to the cult's view as tho it's normal. It's best to avoid their jargon.

Edited

Great work!

I have repeatedly pointed out that assuming assigning or allocating cis gender to a person who has not declared they identify as such, is misgendering which as we all know is basically tantamount to genoci(s)de

Not a one of our cis-assigning gender allocators has ever seen fit to reply - probably too ashamed and busy self-reporting to the gender politburo for re-education

cryupmykingdom · 27/10/2026 10:25

BezMark · 27/10/2026 10:18

Great work!

I have repeatedly pointed out that assuming assigning or allocating cis gender to a person who has not declared they identify as such, is misgendering which as we all know is basically tantamount to genoci(s)de

Not a one of our cis-assigning gender allocators has ever seen fit to reply - probably too ashamed and busy self-reporting to the gender politburo for re-education

Apparently if you make light of their genocide by pointing out that it only involved four people, deported due to administrative error, some of whom were released, that amounts to 'holocaust denial'.

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 10:33

NotBadConsidering · 27/10/2026 10:01

you can ask for a female doctor in preference to a male one, but you will have to wait longer if you do.

And everyone agrees with this. But your assertion, which you made on page 7 of this thread, and which you kept repeating and refused to move on from, is that it is likely there wasn’t a female doctor available at all because PMBH is small/tiny/too busy (delete depending on mood).

Now you are finally acknowledging:

Yes, it’s possible female doctors were on shift that day, but whether it was possible for them to see the patient is another question.

So you’re finally at the point everyone was telling you back on page 7. It only took you 13 pages of repetition to get here. Well done 🙄

Now that it’s settled that it’s possible/likely there was a female doctor in the teeny tiny hospital we can ask for an investigation as to why that person wasn’t offered to the patient.

Maybe there were genuine logistical difficulties. Maybe the female registrar was stuck with a resuscitation. Or maybe Upton put himself forward as a woman. Maybe the staff backed him up. But at last we can finally move on from “junior overseas doctor man was probably the only warm body in tiny hospital in the sticks” hand-waving explanation.

Weird. I don’t recall writing that, certainly not on Page 7, not or any page. Here’s my post from page 7:

As I said earlier, it’s entirely possible to ask for a female doctor, but one may not be available. It’s also possible to ask for a chaperone.
In an ED environment, especially a small one, getting seen and moved onto a ward (if required) is the priority. In the ED, any doctor contact is fleeting really.

That’s entirely different, isn’t it? Please do not twist my words. Other people can read them.

NotBadConsidering · 27/10/2026 10:52

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 10:33

Weird. I don’t recall writing that, certainly not on Page 7, not or any page. Here’s my post from page 7:

As I said earlier, it’s entirely possible to ask for a female doctor, but one may not be available. It’s also possible to ask for a chaperone.
In an ED environment, especially a small one, getting seen and moved onto a ward (if required) is the priority. In the ED, any doctor contact is fleeting really.

That’s entirely different, isn’t it? Please do not twist my words. Other people can read them.

You wrote:

The woman was in Emergency. It’s not possible to request the sex of a treating doctor in Emergency.

Which you then denied despite people quoting it back to you.

I wrote:

The likelihood of there being no actual women doctors in the department is also practically zero. It’s incredibly unlikely it was all men on shift at the time of the patient needing treatment.

To which you replied:

And you know this how? I live nearby. The hospital is tiny and so is the ED. My grandmother died there.

Which by any reading means you are calling into doubt my belief that there is a low probability of being all male staff on shift because “the hospital is tiny.”

Yes, other people can read your posts. Shall we have another 13 pages of posts arguing about what you said? Or can you just accept that

a) it’s possible, even in a hospital the size of PMBH, to request a female doctor
b) it’s possible, and likely, that in the hospital, and probably within the department there was a female doctor present
c) the patient may have had to wait longer if that was an option
d) a male doctor was offered, and we don’t know why.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 27/10/2026 11:12

cryupmykingdom · 27/10/2026 10:25

Apparently if you make light of their genocide by pointing out that it only involved four people, deported due to administrative error, some of whom were released, that amounts to 'holocaust denial'.

That & the fact that transexuals weren't really invented until pervy men got access to oestrogen, boob jobs & genital surgery in the 1970s.

SirChenjins · 27/10/2026 13:25

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 09:59

@SirChenjins

At the risk of repeating myself, you were very clear earlier in this thread that women could not make the request. You've made a number of claims on this thread which then double back on themselves, so it's hard to keep up with you.

I rephrased it for your benefit. It’s possible to ask. No-one’s going to stop you from making a request, even it is largely a pointless one. So ask away all you want.

Do you see the difference?

It wasn't 'rephrased for my benefit' - your inaccurate claim was corrected.

@NotBadConsidering is responding to you on this and the other points you've been corrected on, so I'll leave it there.

legalalien · 27/10/2026 15:50

cryupmykingdom · 27/10/2026 10:14

You should request a beardy doctor holding a pint of Worthingtons, in a masonic apron.

Edited

Well I could, but given NSW health rostering policy apparently doesn’t require having a female on shift I suspect it doesn’t cover this. I did ask Claude which suggested I might have more luck mentioning Coopers Sparkling Ale which is more readily available locally.

I nearly typed “c*s gender” in my previous post but checked myself in time. Phew.

Totallygripped · 27/10/2026 19:24

I am not sure why so much has been devoted to the size/staffing of hospitals in Aus. The issue is surely what the general population would expect if they thought they had an opportunity(but not a guarantee) to ask for a same sex doctor. Which would be er.."same sex" as that term has been understood since forever. But maybe we should just get used to being moaning Minnie's. Can you imagine Dr Kate Searle being told her Beth was being rejected? I would not expect sisterhood or empathy.
What's happening legal proceedings-wise there BTW?

Swipe left for the next trending thread