Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
leparoo · 26/10/2026 18:38

murasaki · 26/10/2026 18:24

He's an unpleasant man.

There's something of the night about him.

SirChenjins · 26/10/2026 18:49

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 26/10/2026 16:21

I do have sympathy for his wife, given that she has also been thrust into the limelight to an extent by his behaviour. I doubt if it's easy to have a notorious husband who is regularly, and rightly, criticised for his behaviour. However she sees him, her choices are limited. Leaving a marriage, should she see that as an option, is rarely an easy choice, and it would be hard for her to do so quietly.

No it's not always an easy choice - but she's young, presumably capable of earning her own living and they don't have children. If she wanted to leave him she could. I strongly suspect she doesn't see anything wrong with his (odious, creepy, misogynistic) behaviour.

BezMark · 26/10/2026 19:00

Puggled minds me of paggered, which means tired out (from pagger which means a fight or to fight)

Totallygripped · 26/10/2026 21:40

I am still flummoxed by eg the BMA saying with a straight face apparently that sex is a nebulous nonsense. Are A and E call outs for adult male or adult female trauma otiose then? I also read an assertion that a penis and a vagina are exactly the same tissue wise. I've never personally had a penis but is that really so? Not that I've experienced a whole load of shafts but seems dodgy to me.

Totallygripped · 26/10/2026 22:20

Also, what does "non binary and queer" mean? Posted by someone looking at teacher's assistant role.

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 00:02

cryupmykingdom · 26/10/2026 11:30

Another facet of this scenario is that Upton is permitted to work at the Kempsey Hospital. Don't know how many of you know Kempsey but it's a rather different place to Port.

Former (maybe still a bit of a) timber town, quite rough. Lot of street crime.

Kempsey has a high indigenous population too.

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 00:11

pearpudding · 26/10/2026 11:39

Making progress - earlier today you described Port Macquarie hospital was 'tiny', now just 'small'.

I don't think you've considered that servicing a large geographic area is not the same as servicing a large population - otherwise remote hospitals would be disproportionally large with very few (or no) patients. It brings to mind a particular 'Yes Minister' episode about a brand new hospital with no waiting times and and abundant beds... 😁

@pearpudding

Making progress - earlier today you described Port Macquarie hospital was 'tiny', now just 'small'.
I don't think you've considered that servicing a large geographic area is not the same as servicing a large population - otherwise remote hospitals would be disproportionally large with very few (or no) patients. It brings to mind a particular 'Yes Minister' episode about a brand new hospital with no waiting times and and abundant beds... 😁

What on earth are you talking about? I have been describing the hospital as it is. It is small and serves a large area with what it can do - more complex medical issues go 31/2 hours down the road. Towns in the area are scattered. Everything here is a good drive from everything else.

pearpudding · 27/10/2026 05:24

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 00:11

@pearpudding

Making progress - earlier today you described Port Macquarie hospital was 'tiny', now just 'small'.
I don't think you've considered that servicing a large geographic area is not the same as servicing a large population - otherwise remote hospitals would be disproportionally large with very few (or no) patients. It brings to mind a particular 'Yes Minister' episode about a brand new hospital with no waiting times and and abundant beds... 😁

What on earth are you talking about? I have been describing the hospital as it is. It is small and serves a large area with what it can do - more complex medical issues go 31/2 hours down the road. Towns in the area are scattered. Everything here is a good drive from everything else.

So now 'small', earlier 'tiny'. Yes it services a large geographical area with a population of approx 120K. My local hospital is also a level 5 hospital like PMBH, covers a much, much smaller geographical area than PMBH, but services a population almost 4 time larger than PMBH with only a little over double the bed capacity. Of course patients will be transferred to level 6 hospital when necessary, sometimes because services may be stretched at my local hospital or because the hospital does not provide the particular medical services required.

Hospitals service the size of the populations within geographical areas, not the size of the geographical area.

We're planning on moving next year, the hospital there services a quite small population (6K-ish) within a large geographical area. Do I expect the hospital to be as large as my current local one because it has a bigger geographical area to service than my local? Of course not. It services the number of people who will likely present to it through A&E or be referred to it for the health care specialties it's able to provide.

By the way, future town hospital has approx 50 bed capacity. The hospital I was born in has 8 beds capacity - not A&E beds, the whole 'hospital'. The next town along, 1hr 20 minutes highway driving away has, drumroll please....19 beds! So huge geographical areas, very small populations so tiny hospitals. When required patients travel to or are transferred to Melbourne (from these NSW hospitals) because Melbourne is much closer than Sydney.

PMBH with 220 beds is not tiny, not small, but likely well suited to cater to the number of people requiring care there. There will be services not provided that people need to travel for, because it would be absurd to fund and staff provide all specialist areas at all hospitals when there is low demand for it at a particular facility.

Do you understand what I'm on about now? Hospitals serve people now how much land those people live in.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 06:09

pearpudding · 27/10/2026 05:24

So now 'small', earlier 'tiny'. Yes it services a large geographical area with a population of approx 120K. My local hospital is also a level 5 hospital like PMBH, covers a much, much smaller geographical area than PMBH, but services a population almost 4 time larger than PMBH with only a little over double the bed capacity. Of course patients will be transferred to level 6 hospital when necessary, sometimes because services may be stretched at my local hospital or because the hospital does not provide the particular medical services required.

Hospitals service the size of the populations within geographical areas, not the size of the geographical area.

We're planning on moving next year, the hospital there services a quite small population (6K-ish) within a large geographical area. Do I expect the hospital to be as large as my current local one because it has a bigger geographical area to service than my local? Of course not. It services the number of people who will likely present to it through A&E or be referred to it for the health care specialties it's able to provide.

By the way, future town hospital has approx 50 bed capacity. The hospital I was born in has 8 beds capacity - not A&E beds, the whole 'hospital'. The next town along, 1hr 20 minutes highway driving away has, drumroll please....19 beds! So huge geographical areas, very small populations so tiny hospitals. When required patients travel to or are transferred to Melbourne (from these NSW hospitals) because Melbourne is much closer than Sydney.

PMBH with 220 beds is not tiny, not small, but likely well suited to cater to the number of people requiring care there. There will be services not provided that people need to travel for, because it would be absurd to fund and staff provide all specialist areas at all hospitals when there is low demand for it at a particular facility.

Do you understand what I'm on about now? Hospitals serve people now how much land those people live in.

Edited

Thanks Pear, I tried earlier but instead the implication was that I was a toddler a long time ago, as if that mattered a fuck. The point I was making was that a large % of my family had had occasion to be in the hospital. It was the only option before being transported 7 hours drive by ambo or a care flight of at least 90 mins out. (And as I said, that didn’t include the time it took to get to that hospital to be assessed in the first place). And we lived much closer to a regional hospital than a large portion of the state where I grew up. Some of my family only have a 30 bed within hours. Patients have to be airlifted to even get to a 200+ bed hospital.

These are the realities of living in rural Australia away from the eastern coastal areas.

It provides a sense of proportion.

I think now the issue here might be the difference of someone living in the coastal regions of a state with a large population vs other parts and lack of exposure. Some people obviously think the facility is small when the reality is, it is a medium sized hospital and if it doesn’t have a female doctor available for a patient making such a request, and that happens more than in one exceptional instance, then there is a significant issue to be addressed.

The other issue is that if there was no female doctors, the patient should be told this so that the patient can then give consent with full knowledge.

Attempting to minimise the responsibility NSW Health has to ensure a sex category mix of doctors each shift by declaring the size of a 225+ bed hospital should mean that they have special consideration, fails when you consider the actual size of the hospital and how it compares to others.

It also then opens up the discussion to ‘What size hospital should be exempt from providing female doctors to female patients requesting a female doctor?’

I argue that a 225+ hospital should be expected to be able to provide a female doctor.

legalalien · 27/10/2026 06:16

If the Royal Women's in Melbourne can't guarantee a female doctor I doubt anywhere can (yes, I realise this dates back to 2018 but still seems to be live on their website). When you want to see a female doctor. Agree with all the PP that the presentation of Dr Upton as a woman in response for a request for a female doctor is the issue, rather than whether a female doctor is or is not available.

https://www.thewomens.org.au/images/uploads/fact-sheets/Female-doctor-0818.pdf

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 06:54

In another thread we were told yesterday that Upton should not have to disclose his ‘medical information’ and that conversely he should also not have to assume a patient is using the established English language definition of the reference term ‘female’.

According to some who support him, it is also up to the female patient to decide and to announce their decision to him. It shouldn’t be up to him to self regulate and make the decision that he should not respond to a request for a female doctor as if he was not female.

Instead, according to some posters, he should continue to act as if he is female. Because his personalised definition of female includes him as a male, and that it is his right to live his philosophical belief.

Of course, there is no answer from those posters to the question of whether a female patient’s consent has been negated or coerced by him presenting himself as a female doctor to a female patient.

Particularly since a doctor holds the power in that specific relationship in many ways not limited to being the person expected to have knowledge of what a female human is, the person who the patient trusts to act ethically and respectfully in the first instance and also the person who holds the power of approving or giving treatment too.

A male doctor appearing before a female patient who has requested a female doctor has the power in that relationship.

Any male person who is in a position of power such as a doctor is, who presents himself as a female doctor when the request for a female doctor is made, then demands that a female patient reject his treatment with him right there in front of her or him treating her without that rejection, ie assuming consent, is acting in a way that directly contradicts consent being freely given. He is acting in a way that intimidates a patient into consent.

Consider the interaction from the female patient’s perspective. The female patient can react in many ways. One is trust that this male person is the female person she requested = her consent is negated because he has used his personal philosophical belief to decide he fulfilled that request and has not gained full consent through disclosure. The patient trusted him to do the right thing in respecting her request.

The patient who understands this is a male then must decide if she wishes to risk a negative outcome by rejecting him and may feel they have no choice. Again, that is not consent that is coerced compliance.

The only time a female patient in that situation can give full consent is to have full information in the first place.

In that case, patients do indeed require full disclosure that this male person is a male person and this would by that description meet the ‘knowing medical information’ requirement. In the same way that any patient requesting a same sex doctor needs to know that doctor’s ’medical information’ when it pertains to sex category of human.

This is the impact of having any policy that supports a male health care professional presenting themselves when a female HCP has been requested. Consent is not able to be freely given unless full knowledge is provided.

pearpudding · 27/10/2026 07:03

Ye gods, @Helleofabore - I'm older than Methusela!. Once upon a time (in the dark ages when I was born) the hospital in my home town with it's abundance of 8 beds had 1 doctor - whose day job was also the only GP in town - general medical, surgical, ob/gynae, x-rays and orthopaedics (I know you'll understand) - they don't train 'em like that any more.

The town luckily still has a GP (when the position can be filled by immigrant doctors) who also treats patients at the hospital and the newly attached nursing home facility. I'm sure he'd love to have the staff and equipment of a 220 bed hospital in town just so he could get some rest, poor bugger.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 07:03

There is an additional power dynamic that is very clear once you see it and it is the demand to use the demanded language.

By demanding that female patients use language such as ‘cis gender female doctor’ when either requesting a female doctor or rejecting a male doctor. This puts female people in the position of having again to use the demanded language of a group’s philosophical belief to get respect. It means that the power dynamic is again with those male doctors who claim to be female.

The dynamic is ‘use my language (as per my philosophical belief) or you will have me, a male health care professional, present myself to you as a female HCP because you didn’t use the language that a minority of people understand. (And by the way, even those claiming to know what ‘cis’ means have confusion). This is not consent. This is not respect and it is not acceptable as a level of care.

Because it puts female people in a position where they have to know to use the specific language that may have a greater chance of avoiding having to deal with the situation where a male doctor comes.

All because a group has acquired the use of common language which then renders the established reference terms meaningless that the majority understand to have clear definitional boundaries (and the group deny that they have done so) because they have their own philosophical belief in what those words should mean.

It again forces compliance to a group’s philosophical belief and is evidence that communication is negatively impacted by that belief.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 07:16

pearpudding · 27/10/2026 07:03

Ye gods, @Helleofabore - I'm older than Methusela!. Once upon a time (in the dark ages when I was born) the hospital in my home town with it's abundance of 8 beds had 1 doctor - whose day job was also the only GP in town - general medical, surgical, ob/gynae, x-rays and orthopaedics (I know you'll understand) - they don't train 'em like that any more.

The town luckily still has a GP (when the position can be filled by immigrant doctors) who also treats patients at the hospital and the newly attached nursing home facility. I'm sure he'd love to have the staff and equipment of a 220 bed hospital in town just so he could get some rest, poor bugger.

I do know what you mean. I have lived in major cities though where I often came across people who have no fucking idea when it comes to life in woop woop.

I had family who used to have to rely on the RFDS (and those medicos are fucking legends!) Even there I would expect accurate information given if no female doctor was on shift.

Medical professionals should be given all respect due, but they still should not be presenting themselves as female to patients requesting same sex care when they are male people. If there are no female doctors, the patient has the right to know that so they can decide what option they will agree to.

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 07:18

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 06:09

Thanks Pear, I tried earlier but instead the implication was that I was a toddler a long time ago, as if that mattered a fuck. The point I was making was that a large % of my family had had occasion to be in the hospital. It was the only option before being transported 7 hours drive by ambo or a care flight of at least 90 mins out. (And as I said, that didn’t include the time it took to get to that hospital to be assessed in the first place). And we lived much closer to a regional hospital than a large portion of the state where I grew up. Some of my family only have a 30 bed within hours. Patients have to be airlifted to even get to a 200+ bed hospital.

These are the realities of living in rural Australia away from the eastern coastal areas.

It provides a sense of proportion.

I think now the issue here might be the difference of someone living in the coastal regions of a state with a large population vs other parts and lack of exposure. Some people obviously think the facility is small when the reality is, it is a medium sized hospital and if it doesn’t have a female doctor available for a patient making such a request, and that happens more than in one exceptional instance, then there is a significant issue to be addressed.

The other issue is that if there was no female doctors, the patient should be told this so that the patient can then give consent with full knowledge.

Attempting to minimise the responsibility NSW Health has to ensure a sex category mix of doctors each shift by declaring the size of a 225+ bed hospital should mean that they have special consideration, fails when you consider the actual size of the hospital and how it compares to others.

It also then opens up the discussion to ‘What size hospital should be exempt from providing female doctors to female patients requesting a female doctor?’

I argue that a 225+ hospital should be expected to be able to provide a female doctor.

Edited

Indeed it does matter a fuck how long ago you were a toddler, as the situation with hospitals is generally somewhat different than, say, 40 years ago. Even if the local hospital in the town you were born in hasn’t changed a great deal in size, it would be much more modern.

You write not only as if you are the only person with experience of many Australian hospitals, but only your experience matters. It doesn’t.

i have lived in many areas of Australia. I grew up in Victoria, quite rural, and moved around frequently. I am now in NSW and also rural, not coastal. I lived nearer Port Mac when my Grandmother was still alive.

Attempting to minimise the responsibility NSW Health has to ensure a sex category mix of doctors each shift by declaring the size of a 225+ bed hospital should mean that they have special consideration, fails when you consider the actual size of the hospital and how it compares to others.
This misrepresentation annoys me. I did minimise anything and I resent that implication, particularly when you know how my thoughts about NSW Health and its treatment of women.

Katkins17 · 27/10/2026 07:31

theilltemperedmonster · 24/10/2026 19:37

I don't read it that way. They may just mean that, despite Australia having lovely inclusive laws, there's always going to be some horrible bigot trying to spoil things.

And there we have it … I was wondering how long it would take for the lovely bigot slur to be used for a woman wanting her own boundaries.

it seems only entitled men are allowed rights … women and girls… nah

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 07:33

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 07:18

Indeed it does matter a fuck how long ago you were a toddler, as the situation with hospitals is generally somewhat different than, say, 40 years ago. Even if the local hospital in the town you were born in hasn’t changed a great deal in size, it would be much more modern.

You write not only as if you are the only person with experience of many Australian hospitals, but only your experience matters. It doesn’t.

i have lived in many areas of Australia. I grew up in Victoria, quite rural, and moved around frequently. I am now in NSW and also rural, not coastal. I lived nearer Port Mac when my Grandmother was still alive.

Attempting to minimise the responsibility NSW Health has to ensure a sex category mix of doctors each shift by declaring the size of a 225+ bed hospital should mean that they have special consideration, fails when you consider the actual size of the hospital and how it compares to others.
This misrepresentation annoys me. I did minimise anything and I resent that implication, particularly when you know how my thoughts about NSW Health and its treatment of women.

My point in saying I was a toddler in the hospital was in addition to the rest of the paragraph which pointed out that other family members have also had to be in that same hospital. That includes currently. Ie. I still have family using that same hospital and it does have many of the same issues it had back then. I don’t believe it has been extended from last I saw it.

I made a point about your statement on size. I also pointed out that the size of hospital for a regional hospital of that size, should indeed have a female doctor available otherwise NSW Health is failing its duty.

You made a statement about size being a reason for no female doctor being available. And you misrepresented the size of the hospital calling it ‘small’ and ‘tiny’. You might not have intended that to be a dismissal but the outcome is that it is an argument to defend no female doctors being present. Others interpreted it as so as well.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 07:36

Katkins17 · 27/10/2026 07:31

And there we have it … I was wondering how long it would take for the lovely bigot slur to be used for a woman wanting her own boundaries.

it seems only entitled men are allowed rights … women and girls… nah

I think illtempered was indeed pointing out that the staff member may have meant :

A hospital staff member said: ‘It should now be very clear why Dr Upton wanted to come to work in Australia. Our laws, as they stand, mean he is regarded as a woman here.

‘But it was always only a matter of time before an allegation like this was made.’

was referring to women being outed as bigots (from the staff member quoted’s point of view )

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 27/10/2026 07:37

It doesn't matter how many beds the hospital has the staffing in the ED will need to support the 55K attendances per year. That's 150 patients each day. I have worked in similar size ED in the UK. There will be plenty of doctors on shift during the day although probably only 2-3 overnight. I would be astonished if there wasn't a female doctor always available.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 07:47

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 07:36

I think illtempered was indeed pointing out that the staff member may have meant :

A hospital staff member said: ‘It should now be very clear why Dr Upton wanted to come to work in Australia. Our laws, as they stand, mean he is regarded as a woman here.

‘But it was always only a matter of time before an allegation like this was made.’

was referring to women being outed as bigots (from the staff member quoted’s point of view )

“was referring to women being outed as bigots (from the staff member quoted’s point of view )”

should be that the statement was referring to women being outed as bigots (from the staff member quoted’s point of view ).

In other words, that the staff statement could be interpreted either way.

Newname26 · 27/10/2026 07:48

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 27/10/2026 07:37

It doesn't matter how many beds the hospital has the staffing in the ED will need to support the 55K attendances per year. That's 150 patients each day. I have worked in similar size ED in the UK. There will be plenty of doctors on shift during the day although probably only 2-3 overnight. I would be astonished if there wasn't a female doctor always available.

As I said regardless of size of hospital or who is or isn't available.
If someone asks for female or some men might want a man, you give them what they want or you let that person make the decision.

Sorry we don't have a female (or male) available you can accept whos available, wait until shift change, or go to different hospital.

What is absolutely not acceptable is to say I'm female when they aren't.

legalalien · 27/10/2026 07:50

I am not sure why the question of the size of the hospital is proving such an issue and am completely conflicted as I love both hellebores (just installed one in my garden in Australia and reminds me of my old house in the UK) and capybaras (I have just checked and Samba is still at large Expert says escaped Marwell capybara Samba will prove a challenge to catch). A friend's husband worked at the hospital in Taree for a long time and retired recently - I can pop next door for a second opinion maybe? (apologies for the slightly flippant tone, I am not trying to pour petrol on the flames - quite the reverse as it sounds as if there is agreement on key principles in any case).

ETA fwiw I asked AI about NSW health rostering principles and it said there wasn't a policy about having a female doctor available except for the specific case of sexual assault victims presenting at an emergence dept - Responding to Sexual Assault (adult and child) Policy and Procedures.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/other/expert-says-escaped-marwell-capybara-samba-will-prove-a-challenge-to-catch/ar-AA2fHeip?ocid=BingNewsSerp

GreyskySexRealistsky · 27/10/2026 07:58

Katkins17 · 27/10/2026 07:31

And there we have it … I was wondering how long it would take for the lovely bigot slur to be used for a woman wanting her own boundaries.

it seems only entitled men are allowed rights … women and girls… nah

It is heavy sarcasm

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 08:12

legalalien · 27/10/2026 07:50

I am not sure why the question of the size of the hospital is proving such an issue and am completely conflicted as I love both hellebores (just installed one in my garden in Australia and reminds me of my old house in the UK) and capybaras (I have just checked and Samba is still at large Expert says escaped Marwell capybara Samba will prove a challenge to catch). A friend's husband worked at the hospital in Taree for a long time and retired recently - I can pop next door for a second opinion maybe? (apologies for the slightly flippant tone, I am not trying to pour petrol on the flames - quite the reverse as it sounds as if there is agreement on key principles in any case).

ETA fwiw I asked AI about NSW health rostering principles and it said there wasn't a policy about having a female doctor available except for the specific case of sexual assault victims presenting at an emergence dept - Responding to Sexual Assault (adult and child) Policy and Procedures.

Edited

Focusing on the size of the hospital and what I called it (“small”, “tiny”, apparently there’s a great difference between those two words) is an effort to discredit my posts for whatever reason.

NotBadConsidering · 27/10/2026 08:23

LadyCapybara · 27/10/2026 08:12

Focusing on the size of the hospital and what I called it (“small”, “tiny”, apparently there’s a great difference between those two words) is an effort to discredit my posts for whatever reason.

Because you have repeatedly claimed, despite the experience of others, the size of the hospital dictates it’s very likely Upton was part of an all-male medical team at the time of the patient’s presentation.

When you have attended the hospital, for example when your grandmother was dying, how often did you not see a single female doctor?

Upton is a JHO. He will have other junior staff on the roster with him at any given time and more senior staff on shift at every possible time. Even the worst odds are 50:50 that the registrar on shift with him at the time was a woman.