In another thread we were told yesterday that Upton should not have to disclose his ‘medical information’ and that conversely he should also not have to assume a patient is using the established English language definition of the reference term ‘female’.
According to some who support him, it is also up to the female patient to decide and to announce their decision to him. It shouldn’t be up to him to self regulate and make the decision that he should not respond to a request for a female doctor as if he was not female.
Instead, according to some posters, he should continue to act as if he is female. Because his personalised definition of female includes him as a male, and that it is his right to live his philosophical belief.
Of course, there is no answer from those posters to the question of whether a female patient’s consent has been negated or coerced by him presenting himself as a female doctor to a female patient.
Particularly since a doctor holds the power in that specific relationship in many ways not limited to being the person expected to have knowledge of what a female human is, the person who the patient trusts to act ethically and respectfully in the first instance and also the person who holds the power of approving or giving treatment too.
A male doctor appearing before a female patient who has requested a female doctor has the power in that relationship.
Any male person who is in a position of power such as a doctor is, who presents himself as a female doctor when the request for a female doctor is made, then demands that a female patient reject his treatment with him right there in front of her or him treating her without that rejection, ie assuming consent, is acting in a way that directly contradicts consent being freely given. He is acting in a way that intimidates a patient into consent.
Consider the interaction from the female patient’s perspective. The female patient can react in many ways. One is trust that this male person is the female person she requested = her consent is negated because he has used his personal philosophical belief to decide he fulfilled that request and has not gained full consent through disclosure. The patient trusted him to do the right thing in respecting her request.
The patient who understands this is a male then must decide if she wishes to risk a negative outcome by rejecting him and may feel they have no choice. Again, that is not consent that is coerced compliance.
The only time a female patient in that situation can give full consent is to have full information in the first place.
In that case, patients do indeed require full disclosure that this male person is a male person and this would by that description meet the ‘knowing medical information’ requirement. In the same way that any patient requesting a same sex doctor needs to know that doctor’s ’medical information’ when it pertains to sex category of human.
This is the impact of having any policy that supports a male health care professional presenting themselves when a female HCP has been requested. Consent is not able to be freely given unless full knowledge is provided.