Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 01:39

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 01:27

You are missing the point (unsurprisingly). They can publish what is known and in the public domain.

But Australians commenting on Riley Dennis (Kirralie Smith), and overseas people commenting on Teddy Cook (Billboard Chris) have found themselves being pursued by the Australian government over their remarks about them.

So they know they have to be careful with how much information they share and attribute to people like Rachael Wong because there’s a risk it will become another Kirralee Smith case or generate a censorship request from the esafety commissioner.

So the point stands: the Daily Mail, regardless of where they published the article, would have had to be mindful of the potential actions of the Australian government before it published the piece. The fact this particular piece originated in Scotland doesn’t matter at all. The esafety commissioner successfully got Meta to remove posts by Kirralie Smith. She tried with X for Billboard Chris but Musk refused. Maybe the Daily Mail would be equally belligerent to such a request. Maybe they don’t want the hassle, which is why they kowtow to wrong sex pronouns in their articles.

Your point doesn't make sense. If they can 'publish what is known and in the public domain' then how did the story - which is an exclusive to them - get published? Is it all manner of this weird behaviour you keep insisting is happening behind the scenes - or is it just simply that there is no extra information and the story that was published is the entire story they had? I know what's far more likely.

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 01:57

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 01:39

Your point doesn't make sense. If they can 'publish what is known and in the public domain' then how did the story - which is an exclusive to them - get published? Is it all manner of this weird behaviour you keep insisting is happening behind the scenes - or is it just simply that there is no extra information and the story that was published is the entire story they had? I know what's far more likely.

Is it all manner of this weird behaviour you keep insisting is happening behind the scenes - or is it just simply that there is no extra information and the story that was published is the entire story they had? I know what's far more likely.

It doesn’t matter which is more likely. The point is both options are possible. You are dismissing the possibility of there being caution around their reporting because of zealous actions completely. You can’t be sure it didn’t happen anymore than anyone can be sure it did. But it’s possible.

LadyCapybara · 02/11/2026 03:59

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 01:28

Yet it was all over Australian social media. Funny that.

But the original point was it published in the Australian version of the Daily Mail, not was it splashed over social media. If it was, that means there were links to the SCOTTISH ARTICLE.

Needmoresleep · 02/11/2026 04:57

LadyCapybara · 02/11/2026 01:10

Australian readers - or even any readers outside Scotland - would need to know it’s there in order to read it. I only knew about it because of the link here.

There are no links to the article on the Australian version of the Daily Mail.

My impression was that MoL articles are boosted by clicks. So this article may have written by staff for the Scottish print edition but was quite prominent in the English online feed.

Assuming interest in Australia, and
the number of Australian posters on this thread suggests Dr U is of interest to Australians, the article would start appearing on the Australian feed. Unless the Mail are de-boosting it.

The Mail deciding to de-boost a story in the Australian feed which is about a Doctor working in Australia, would be interesting. Why? Australian laws?

FWIW health and fitness stories showing attractive Australian influencers keep popping up in the English edition. Again I assume clicks.

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 05:57

LadyCapybara · 02/11/2026 03:59

But the original point was it published in the Australian version of the Daily Mail, not was it splashed over social media. If it was, that means there were links to the SCOTTISH ARTICLE.

No the original point was Australia is censorious and punishing of people who make claims trans activists don’t like. Which is true.

It is also true that international media organisations that publish articles about Australian people are not considered out of reach by the Australian government, particularly those that have an Australian publishing arm. The Guardian has a UK version, a US version, and an Australian version. If it published an article that was potentially discriminatory (as seen through the eyes of the esafety commissioner) to an Australian in its UK version, it seems the esafety commissioner would not see that as beyond her scope to try to get them to remove it. This has been shown to be true by the actions demonstrated.

So the original criticism of the original point, that because it wasn’t published in a uniquely Australian publication the censorious nature of the Australian government is a “conspiracy theory” is false.

oviraptor21 · 02/11/2026 09:52

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 31/10/2026 13:48

I don't see an issue if the patient's request can be accommodated. It's only expressing a preference. If it's not convenient the request won't be granted. We would try & accommodate people who didn't speak English very well so a Polish patient might be seen by a Polish doctor or an Urdu speaker would see a Pakistani patient. It's a question of comfort & convenience for both patients & staff.

Did it occur to you that for many, especially the elderly or those with hearing problems, the reason for asking for a British doctor is because they are likely to have easy to understand accents. This is not inherently racist.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 02/11/2026 10:03

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 05:57

No the original point was Australia is censorious and punishing of people who make claims trans activists don’t like. Which is true.

It is also true that international media organisations that publish articles about Australian people are not considered out of reach by the Australian government, particularly those that have an Australian publishing arm. The Guardian has a UK version, a US version, and an Australian version. If it published an article that was potentially discriminatory (as seen through the eyes of the esafety commissioner) to an Australian in its UK version, it seems the esafety commissioner would not see that as beyond her scope to try to get them to remove it. This has been shown to be true by the actions demonstrated.

So the original criticism of the original point, that because it wasn’t published in a uniquely Australian publication the censorious nature of the Australian government is a “conspiracy theory” is false.

Thanks for patiently explaining this over several posts. Very interesting.

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 15:20

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 01:57

Is it all manner of this weird behaviour you keep insisting is happening behind the scenes - or is it just simply that there is no extra information and the story that was published is the entire story they had? I know what's far more likely.

It doesn’t matter which is more likely. The point is both options are possible. You are dismissing the possibility of there being caution around their reporting because of zealous actions completely. You can’t be sure it didn’t happen anymore than anyone can be sure it did. But it’s possible.

If only we could ask the people claiming they have extra information... But they've declined to answer. Weird that.

Anthophile · 02/11/2026 18:35

oviraptor21 · 02/11/2026 09:52

Did it occur to you that for many, especially the elderly or those with hearing problems, the reason for asking for a British doctor is because they are likely to have easy to understand accents. This is not inherently racist.

Not MrPrettyDamnCosmic, but this would often depend on which accent is easier to understand for whom. British patients with hearing problems may still struggle to understand other British doctors if they have very strong Glaswegian or Geordie accents, for instance, and there are non-British-born/educated doctors who have less pronounced, or "neutral", for lack of a better term, accents. Concerns about potential racism would not likely be raised in most cases if it is clearly communicated that the issue solely lies in personal difficulty understanding certain accents, irrespective of a doctor's ethnicity or nationality.

Anthophile · 02/11/2026 18:53

CohensDiamondTeeth · 25/10/2026 00:09

And while there is an argument to be had over the right and wrongs of localised areas where there is a culture of casual usage of shortened terms for Pakistani and Chinese still being used (which incidentally is still an unfortunately slow to die thing local to where I live too, and I don't like it FWIW), I don't think that is proof of racism either.

And again I'm going to weigh up your lies and misrepresentations Vs over 30 years of no complaints and exemplary service along with anecdotal evidence from prior patients. You might have a different opinion to me, again that is your right. You know what they say about opinions though, they're a bit like arseholes. Everyone's got one, not everyone needs to see it.

I'm going to have to remind myself about the "it" comment, but my vague memory is that you are "misrepresenting" lying about that as well. Remember that Sandie Peggie's daughter is a lesbian too.

I'm about done with my replies to you, I don't like you very much, and I think giving you air time makes you think I'm giving your opinions legitimacy and not just rolling my eyes so hard I think I pulled something.

But I'll ask again, leveraged the rape of any women in your quest to allow men access to women and girls in a state of undress recently? You've done it twice that I've seen.

Edit for spelling.

Edited

And while there is an argument to be had over the right and wrongs of localised areas where there is a culture of casual usage of shortened terms for Pakistani and Chinese still being used (which incidentally is still an unfortunately slow to die thing local to where I live too, and I don't like it FWIW), I don't think that is proof of racism either.

There are more than 600 replies so I'm not sure if someone else has already said this, but even if she didn't actively bear ill will towards them, using slurs is still a racist action. That doesn't negate the other aspects of her legal cases or women's concerns about being unable to access single-sex spaces where birth sex may matter, but criticism of her comments in this instance is more than fair.

KnottyAuty · 02/11/2026 21:41

FeralWoman · 24/10/2026 19:22

Correct. In fact Beth/Lis might make a complaint about the patient to the anti discrimination commission and have the patient punished. Set an example to future patients who might dare to say no to him.

This would be terrible for the patient involved, but ultimately is what needs to happen for the greater good of women generally. Some males really do have a problem when women set down boundaries don't they?

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 22:26

KnottyAuty · 02/11/2026 21:41

This would be terrible for the patient involved, but ultimately is what needs to happen for the greater good of women generally. Some males really do have a problem when women set down boundaries don't they?

Given there's no evidence that Dr Upton had any kind of problem in this situation, this is such a strange post.

murasaki · 02/11/2026 22:32

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 22:26

Given there's no evidence that Dr Upton had any kind of problem in this situation, this is such a strange post.

But that's exactly what he did in complaining about Sandie Peggie, so there's every chance he'd do it again.

He's a mendacious delusional nightmare.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 22:33

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 22:26

Given there's no evidence that Dr Upton had any kind of problem in this situation, this is such a strange post.

There is plenty of evidence. His own testimony under oath. The entire problem here, his alleged behaviour to a person with dementia, and his alleged behaviour towards a woman in Australia, hope that helps!

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 23:12

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 22:33

There is plenty of evidence. His own testimony under oath. The entire problem here, his alleged behaviour to a person with dementia, and his alleged behaviour towards a woman in Australia, hope that helps!

Given I was specific about this situation - what's the alleged behaviour? And who alleged it?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 23:31

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 23:12

Given I was specific about this situation - what's the alleged behaviour? And who alleged it?

The woman concerned was clearly uncomfortable with him, why else do you think she would think she needed her husband to protect her from Upton treating her against her wishes? Do you think she followed the case in detail from Australia and knew he’d said he didn’t respect that “female only” meant an actual woman?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 23:32

Also, KnottyAuty was speaking generally about what we already know about Upton, that he doesn’t respect boundaries.

CohensDiamondTeeth · 03/11/2026 02:41

Anthophile · 02/11/2026 18:53

And while there is an argument to be had over the right and wrongs of localised areas where there is a culture of casual usage of shortened terms for Pakistani and Chinese still being used (which incidentally is still an unfortunately slow to die thing local to where I live too, and I don't like it FWIW), I don't think that is proof of racism either.

There are more than 600 replies so I'm not sure if someone else has already said this, but even if she didn't actively bear ill will towards them, using slurs is still a racist action. That doesn't negate the other aspects of her legal cases or women's concerns about being unable to access single-sex spaces where birth sex may matter, but criticism of her comments in this instance is more than fair.

Look I get your POV and I kind of agree with you to an extent, I don't think these terms grew in a vacuum, I think they were borne from racism originally. I also agree that these terms are still used in a racist way.

I've already said that I don't like it. I would like people not to use them even if they, personally, aren't using them in a racist way. I do think people continuing to use these terms makes it harder to fight against racism.

However, I also think the fact that in certain areas of Scotland these terms have entered into common language, and are often used as non-racist, colloquial terms, should be taken into account in SP's case.

Her using them in the local manner is being held up as proof of racism. She is saying that using them for her is not her being racist, it's local colloquialism.

So around where I live, and in Fife where SP lives, a short conversation in passing between two locals might sound something like this. Switch out the words in italics for the other terms.

"Where are you off to?"
"I'm off down the town to pick up tea"
"What're you having?"
"It's a chippy for us tonight"

or

"Where are you off to?"
"I'm just away down the shops"
"You going to the big Tesco?"
"Nah, I'm just popping to the wee corner shop"

I think in SP's case everything needs to be looked at as a complete picture.

Did she use those local colloquial terms? Yes, I think probably as often as most of the locals do.

Did she send really horrible dark humour jokes to her work friends? Yes, one time.

Is she racist to her patients or colleagues? No. The other comments Alcove alluded to were not said by SP, and in one of those the colleague who was apparently subject to racism by SP denied that SP was racist towards her. By all accounts she gets on well with her colleagues and has never been accused of racism by them, and ditto her patients who have never made complaints, and some who have since the tribunal posted online in support of SP (obvious caveat here that anyone could say they are anyone online).

Is SP racist? On balance I think probably not. Others may come to different conclusions.

CohensDiamondTeeth · 03/11/2026 03:19

I should have made use of the word "pejorative" instead of the word "racist" in some places in that last post.

For example I should have said

"I would like people not to use them even if they, personally, aren't using them in a pejorative way"

and

"in certain areas of Scotland these terms have entered into common language, and are often used as non-pejorative, colloquial terms"

cryupmykingdom · 03/11/2026 12:10

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 22:26

Given there's no evidence that Dr Upton had any kind of problem in this situation, this is such a strange post.

Not really. He has complained previously against a nurse called Peggie in a somewhat similar situation.

Stupidity is often a serial affliction, eg your posting history?

anyolddinosaur · 04/11/2026 08:14

There is a difference between using descriptive language you have always used and regarding a particular race or ethnic group as inferior or treating people badly because you see them as different. The second of these is definitely racist and I dont believe Sandie has ever behaved in that way. The only "evidence" is sharing some bad jokes and I have no doubt she will have shared much black humour with her colleagues, it's a coping mechanism for dealing with what you see in a&e. The first is debatable but labelling that as racist does nothing to stop the second and actually promotes it. edit for bad typing.

oviraptor21 · 04/11/2026 08:27

Anthophile · 02/11/2026 18:35

Not MrPrettyDamnCosmic, but this would often depend on which accent is easier to understand for whom. British patients with hearing problems may still struggle to understand other British doctors if they have very strong Glaswegian or Geordie accents, for instance, and there are non-British-born/educated doctors who have less pronounced, or "neutral", for lack of a better term, accents. Concerns about potential racism would not likely be raised in most cases if it is clearly communicated that the issue solely lies in personal difficulty understanding certain accents, irrespective of a doctor's ethnicity or nationality.

Yes - absolutely agree. British regional accents can also be a problem.

anyolddinosaur · 04/11/2026 08:55

As you get older you lose the higher hearing tones and that means speech loses it's clarity. It can make understanding accents more difficult - whether that is a white Glaswegian or Polish dentist or an Indian nurse. A British born nurse of Indian heritage can be easier to understand. Asking for "British" can just be a hope of speech they can understand. It would be better to phrase it as someone with less of an accent but even this would be seen by the woke as racist.

Needmoresleep · 05/11/2026 20:37

https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/world-news/dr-beth-upton-cant-treat-37844035

"Female patients in Australia have been told they can object to being seen by a transgender doctor and that treatment without "informed consent" amounts to assault."

Legally can anyone stop Upton from treating a patient who asks to see a woman doctor, since in Australia Upton is registered as female?

Dr Beth Upton CAN'T treat female patients without consent, says Australian group

The Scottish doctor has moved to New South Wales with wife Zoe and caused a new gender stooshie after a woman objected to being treated by a male medic

https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/world-news/dr-beth-upton-cant-treat-37844035

Wishesandhorses · 05/11/2026 21:18

I think that confirms exactly what happened.

And again that line - 'Lis is lovely'.

I'm sure he is. Up until you're a woman saying no to him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread