Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Secondary schools - are any of these red flags for gender madness?

150 replies

GCburneraccount · 09/10/2026 11:46

I've recently visited 8 state secondary schools in my city. Can anyone advise me if any of these things are red flags for gender madness having taken hold, or is this just normal in secondary these days?

My baseline is that none of these would have been allowed at the school I went to - but I'm very out of date! Things were certainly not great for gay kids back then and I hope this has changed for the better.

  • Every school had an LGBTQ club
  • A prominently displayed Stonewall poster 'trans people exist, get over it' (not in context of studying activism/advertising)
  • Specific toilets for 'all genders'
  • Activist/political flags like progress pride used in an activist context (rather than studying activism)
  • Wall displays encouraging activism - e.g. on climate/green issues, LGBT issues, race issues
  • Displays on teachers doors alluding to that teachers political beliefs and activism
  • School posters talking about 'decolonising the curriculum'
  • Shelves of trashy teen romance books in the school library (Heartstopper and similar) - I'd expect to see books with sex as a theme in a secondary library, but 1984/Brave New World/Dorian Grey type stuff rather than Forever(!)
  • So many wall displays including people who haven't made significant contributions to their field but were there purely on identity. The most bizarre one I saw was in Physics and had Dr Rachel Padman (an MtoF chap who taught me at Cambridge in the 90's!)

I guess I want a school to deal quickly with any type of bullying, and help kids who are struggling, but I don't love how this now seems to be tied to identity groups and bleed into activism now.

OP posts:
MrsOvertonsWindow · 12/10/2026 20:15

Shortshriftandlethal · 12/10/2026 19:53

I'm not sure what is nonsensical about anything i've posted. I've experience in schools because I used to teach - and I can tell you with total certainty that just 15 years ago there was no such thing as a 'trans child', or children 'questioning their gender'. It wasn't a thing. Nobody had heard of it.

I know what is going on behind the scenes in some schools - and that is that there are some teachers who see themselves as righteous activists - and they push and promote the concept of 'gender identity', and they don't like pupils questioning the notion. They put out false information and peddle untruths. Most often they are gay or lesbian, some of them identify as 'trans' or 'non binary' themselves; but not always. There are plenty of 'allies'.

Teachers are not supposed to push political agendas in school. 'Gender Theory' is highly contested, and with potential negative consequences and potential harms for the children that get caught up in it.

Agreed.
The guidance that states schools must not promote political views is clear that political issues must be presented as part of a balanced curriculum offer.
It's why the teaching SRE / Health Ed guidance states that gender identity is a contested belief and must not be taught as factual to children
It's why the new KCSIE guidance is clear that recorded sex must be birth sex, that there must be no mixed sex undressing, toileting and sleeping.
It's why all the national anti bullying guidance covers a range of protected characteristics and has no hierarchy. It's expected that schools will identify the key issues that affect their school (using data, pupil voice etc) and tackle them.

While the political impartiality and anti bullying guidance is long standing, it's very telling that it's a labour government that has initiated the changes to KCSIE / SRE guidance. It's evident - even to them - how much damage has been done to children by pushing GI at them in schools.

The OP is quite right to raise red flags about some of what she's seen.

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 20:46

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 12/10/2026 19:27

But unfortunately routine here on this particular forum. The irrational ranty overreactions kind of have a Barbara Covett Notes From A Scandal feel to them. They also remind me of those teachers from back in the day who long lost the plot from taking on a job that was completely unsuited to them & were regularly manipulated by the class delinquent into full blwn meltdowns for their sadstic pleasure. I used to wonder where they all ended up & I think I know now…

Actually, on re-reading some of the posts on this thread, I'm persuaded of the evil of anything remotely connected with trans. I think we should reject it entirely.

It's not the logic or persuasive efforts of posters that has won me over; it's the unreconstructed sneering venom with which they're expressed. It's great for deterring any kind or constructive debate and ensures the board creates plenty of heat, even if there is no light. I'm glad so many posters spend their time in this vein; it achieves so much.

JanesLittleGirl · 12/10/2026 21:02

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 20:46

Actually, on re-reading some of the posts on this thread, I'm persuaded of the evil of anything remotely connected with trans. I think we should reject it entirely.

It's not the logic or persuasive efforts of posters that has won me over; it's the unreconstructed sneering venom with which they're expressed. It's great for deterring any kind or constructive debate and ensures the board creates plenty of heat, even if there is no light. I'm glad so many posters spend their time in this vein; it achieves so much.

I'm getting 9.96 on my sneer-o-meter.

lavendarwillow · 12/10/2026 21:05

Rareusername · 09/10/2026 11:48

Thank goodness both of my teens are private. Honestly, none of this virtue signalling

Don’t be so sure on that! They can be worse!

ScrollingLeaves · 12/10/2026 21:08

GCburneraccount · 09/10/2026 11:46

I've recently visited 8 state secondary schools in my city. Can anyone advise me if any of these things are red flags for gender madness having taken hold, or is this just normal in secondary these days?

My baseline is that none of these would have been allowed at the school I went to - but I'm very out of date! Things were certainly not great for gay kids back then and I hope this has changed for the better.

  • Every school had an LGBTQ club
  • A prominently displayed Stonewall poster 'trans people exist, get over it' (not in context of studying activism/advertising)
  • Specific toilets for 'all genders'
  • Activist/political flags like progress pride used in an activist context (rather than studying activism)
  • Wall displays encouraging activism - e.g. on climate/green issues, LGBT issues, race issues
  • Displays on teachers doors alluding to that teachers political beliefs and activism
  • School posters talking about 'decolonising the curriculum'
  • Shelves of trashy teen romance books in the school library (Heartstopper and similar) - I'd expect to see books with sex as a theme in a secondary library, but 1984/Brave New World/Dorian Grey type stuff rather than Forever(!)
  • So many wall displays including people who haven't made significant contributions to their field but were there purely on identity. The most bizarre one I saw was in Physics and had Dr Rachel Padman (an MtoF chap who taught me at Cambridge in the 90's!)

I guess I want a school to deal quickly with any type of bullying, and help kids who are struggling, but I don't love how this now seems to be tied to identity groups and bleed into activism now.

Piles of red flags. Probably way too little learning.

alcovecupboards · 12/10/2026 21:14

Shortshriftandlethal · 12/10/2026 19:53

I'm not sure what is nonsensical about anything i've posted. I've experience in schools because I used to teach - and I can tell you with total certainty that just 15 years ago there was no such thing as a 'trans child', or children 'questioning their gender'. It wasn't a thing. Nobody had heard of it.

I know what is going on behind the scenes in some schools - and that is that there are some teachers who see themselves as righteous activists - and they push and promote the concept of 'gender identity', and they don't like pupils questioning the notion. They put out false information and peddle untruths. Most often they are gay or lesbian, some of them identify as 'trans' or 'non binary' themselves; but not always. There are plenty of 'allies'.

Teachers are not supposed to push political agendas in school. 'Gender Theory' is highly contested, and with potential negative consequences and potential harms for the children that get caught up in it.

"I can tell you with total certainty that just 15 years ago there was no such thing as a 'trans child', or children 'questioning their gender'. It wasn't a thing. Nobody had heard of it."

You're talking utter nonsense. 2011 was 15 years ago and what you've said is demonstrably incorrect. What do you gain from lying about this in such an obvious way?

Leafstamp · 13/10/2026 07:44

alcovecupboards · 12/10/2026 21:14

"I can tell you with total certainty that just 15 years ago there was no such thing as a 'trans child', or children 'questioning their gender'. It wasn't a thing. Nobody had heard of it."

You're talking utter nonsense. 2011 was 15 years ago and what you've said is demonstrably incorrect. What do you gain from lying about this in such an obvious way?

I think the point @Shortshriftandlethal was making that is that 15 years ago the vast majority of people had not heard of or did not entertain the idea of a trans child.

Certainly the numbers exploded after 2011. Funny that that coincides with 2015 when Mermaids become a charity and when Stonewall added the T to LGB. What a coincidence!

Example of news report, from the Guardian of all places! www.theguardian.com/world/2025/jan/24/children-england-gender-dysphoria-diagnosis-rise

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:08

alcovecupboards · 12/10/2026 21:14

"I can tell you with total certainty that just 15 years ago there was no such thing as a 'trans child', or children 'questioning their gender'. It wasn't a thing. Nobody had heard of it."

You're talking utter nonsense. 2011 was 15 years ago and what you've said is demonstrably incorrect. What do you gain from lying about this in such an obvious way?

I was teaching in schools 15 years ago, and I can say with certainty nobody had ever heard of it. It wasn't a thing in schools. The 'trans child' had not really taken off. LGB was still just LGB. There was no TQ+. This came in after a concerted campaign by Stonewall and others to push it after gay marriage equality had been achieved.

Children who wanted to express their uniquenerss or differentness were stil largely doing this via the residual music youth sub-cultures that still existed, or by being into gothic horror or ghosts stories, as but one example. Of course there have always been nascently gay boys and lesbian girls and 'coming out' was common.

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:19

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 12/10/2026 20:03

So you were a teacher & think flags are the only bullying prevention strategy? There are no other protocols? That you accuse others of not knowing anything about the education system is rich.

And that some teachers over reach their job description is not exclusive to LGBTQ issues but part of the human condition. Welcome to planet earth.

You are distorting and twisted what i said to suit your point.

I wouldn't even class flags as being an anti bullying strategy. I didn't once mention flags. What I said was that 'diversity' is promoted and learned by being diverse and that teachers should not be pushing political agendas.

Gender Iidentity theory/ideology is most definitely a political ideology and a whole theory of Self which is highly contested and controversial - in a way that simply accepting that some people are gay or lesbian is not.

Accepting that some people are same sex attracted doesn't impact directly on anyone else; doesn't make any demands on them to comply; and doesn't infringe upon sex based provisions or categories. It doesn't require special or enforced language to validate it.

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:30

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:08

I was teaching in schools 15 years ago, and I can say with certainty nobody had ever heard of it. It wasn't a thing in schools. The 'trans child' had not really taken off. LGB was still just LGB. There was no TQ+. This came in after a concerted campaign by Stonewall and others to push it after gay marriage equality had been achieved.

Children who wanted to express their uniquenerss or differentness were stil largely doing this via the residual music youth sub-cultures that still existed, or by being into gothic horror or ghosts stories, as but one example. Of course there have always been nascently gay boys and lesbian girls and 'coming out' was common.

Edited

https://www.stonewall.org.uk/resources/lgbtq-hubs/trans-hub/stonewalls-journey-to-trans-inclusion

"
While there had been significant legal and social progress in the UK throughout the 2000s for trans people, including the lifting of the military ban in 2000, the passing of the Gender Recognition Act in 2004 and the introduction of the Equality Act in 2010, by 2014 Stonewall had not yet adopted a trans-inclusive stance.
During this period, activists like Christine Burns, Angela Clayton and Claire McNab (all awarded MBEs) worked through 'Press For Change' to help shape these landmark pieces of legislation for transgender rights. Stonewall, meanwhile, continued to focus on lesbian, gay, and bi rights. This reflected the organisation’s original remit rather than an explicit opposition to trans inclusion. It was not until 16 February 2015 that Stonewall formally expanded, announcing a shift in policy and became trans inclusive"

An arrow and text reading 'Stonewall'

Stonewall’s journey to trans inclusion

Stonewall is part of a vibrant, growing and global movement advocating for LGBTQ+ rights. Over the last 35+ years, we have helped create transformative…

https://www.stonewall.org.uk/resources/lgbtq-hubs/trans-hub/stonewalls-journey-to-trans-inclusion

AStonedRose · 13/10/2026 09:33

There were no trans people until 10 years ago when Stonewall invented them? What absolute fucking arrant bullshit. Unbelievable.

I bet Stonewall invented gay people in the 80s as well.

You're a bunch of extremists at this point.

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:34

"That same year ( 2015), the newly formed Women and Equalities Select Committee opened an inquiry into transgender equality, putting trans equality firmly on the political agenda. Stonewall submitted the evidence it had compiled during its consultation process that contributed to its landmark report.

CassOle · 13/10/2026 09:36

AStonedRose · 13/10/2026 09:33

There were no trans people until 10 years ago when Stonewall invented them? What absolute fucking arrant bullshit. Unbelievable.

I bet Stonewall invented gay people in the 80s as well.

You're a bunch of extremists at this point.

No-one is saying that transexualism was invented in 2015.
No-one is saying that homosexuality was invented in the 1980s.

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:37

AStonedRose · 13/10/2026 09:33

There were no trans people until 10 years ago when Stonewall invented them? What absolute fucking arrant bullshit. Unbelievable.

I bet Stonewall invented gay people in the 80s as well.

You're a bunch of extremists at this point.

That is not what i said. I said that the concept of a 'trans child' was not a thing in schools. Nobody had heard of it.

I'm not saying that children have never explored their feelings or their identity. Of course they have - but 'gender identity' was not being pushed via social media ( which also exploded in around 2014) and Stonewall had not yet got their campaign into schools. 'Queer' was still not commonly used as an identity marker in the gay and lesbian community, either. 'Non -binary' had definitely not been invented.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 13/10/2026 09:38

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:30

https://www.stonewall.org.uk/resources/lgbtq-hubs/trans-hub/stonewalls-journey-to-trans-inclusion

"
While there had been significant legal and social progress in the UK throughout the 2000s for trans people, including the lifting of the military ban in 2000, the passing of the Gender Recognition Act in 2004 and the introduction of the Equality Act in 2010, by 2014 Stonewall had not yet adopted a trans-inclusive stance.
During this period, activists like Christine Burns, Angela Clayton and Claire McNab (all awarded MBEs) worked through 'Press For Change' to help shape these landmark pieces of legislation for transgender rights. Stonewall, meanwhile, continued to focus on lesbian, gay, and bi rights. This reflected the organisation’s original remit rather than an explicit opposition to trans inclusion. It was not until 16 February 2015 that Stonewall formally expanded, announcing a shift in policy and became trans inclusive"

Edited

Trans issues were initially "trojan horsed' into schools on the back of some excellent work from Stonewall on homophobic bullying. Stonewall started working with the DfE / Government Equalities Office from about 20 years ago with the govt ending up funding all sorts of male dominated trans lobby groups who frankly should have been nowhere near schools. Their influence escalated to trying to remove single sex sports, changing rooms, dormitories, toilets etc and weighing in on the curriculum. All part of the "queering the curriculum" movement that caused such chaos in certain Birmingham primary schools (the No Outsiders grift)
I came across my first unhappy boy who'd decided he must be a girl in a school about 10 years ago - when Mermaids were in ascendancy and recommending whole school assemblies and cakes for these children - trying to ensure they became permanently glued into their new identity. His profile matched what we now know is typical for many of these children - abusive criminal family, death of a sibling, suicidal ideation. He was a very unhappy teenager.

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:41

AStonedRose · 13/10/2026 09:33

There were no trans people until 10 years ago when Stonewall invented them? What absolute fucking arrant bullshit. Unbelievable.

I bet Stonewall invented gay people in the 80s as well.

You're a bunch of extremists at this point.

Distorted hyperbole is not a great replacement for logical engagement.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 13/10/2026 09:43

AStonedRose · 13/10/2026 09:33

There were no trans people until 10 years ago when Stonewall invented them? What absolute fucking arrant bullshit. Unbelievable.

I bet Stonewall invented gay people in the 80s as well.

You're a bunch of extremists at this point.

We're talking about children. And sharing the evidence about how Stonewall was the initial vehicle for the promotion of gender identity in education.

As for gays - if you ask some of us we could reassure you that we existed before 1989 when Stonewall was formed.

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:43

AStonedRose · 13/10/2026 09:33

There were no trans people until 10 years ago when Stonewall invented them? What absolute fucking arrant bullshit. Unbelievable.

I bet Stonewall invented gay people in the 80s as well.

You're a bunch of extremists at this point.

When you have stopped ranting, maybe you could read through the posts and also become cognisant of the fact we are talking about 'gender ideology' in schools.

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 10:09

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:43

When you have stopped ranting, maybe you could read through the posts and also become cognisant of the fact we are talking about 'gender ideology' in schools.

Edited

The imagination has a tendency to run wild. Whilst some here clearly imagine they are talking with goodness knows who, the reality isn that many of us have been politically engaged our entire adult lives; have been in and around and involved with women's rights and gay rights all of that time. Have experience in all manner of profession and occupation; many involved with mental health, education and so on, and that we also have children and/or family members who are gay and some of us with some ( including husbands and partners) who are now trans identified.

FrippEnos · 13/10/2026 10:37

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 10:09

The imagination has a tendency to run wild. Whilst some here clearly imagine they are talking with goodness knows who, the reality isn that many of us have been politically engaged our entire adult lives; have been in and around and involved with women's rights and gay rights all of that time. Have experience in all manner of profession and occupation; many involved with mental health, education and so on, and that we also have children and/or family members who are gay and some of us with some ( including husbands and partners) who are now trans identified.

Edited

For someone that supports a group that promotes the 'lived experience' of trans people.
You are very quick to dismiss the 'lived experience' of people in schools.
Its similar to the 'don't mis gender me, cos its literal violence' whilst being quick to push unwanted labels on people that don't want them.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 13/10/2026 11:50

FrippEnos · 13/10/2026 10:37

For someone that supports a group that promotes the 'lived experience' of trans people.
You are very quick to dismiss the 'lived experience' of people in schools.
Its similar to the 'don't mis gender me, cos its literal violence' whilst being quick to push unwanted labels on people that don't want them.

Presumably that was meant for the stoned one? 😀

There's been seething tantrums upthread when those of us who actually know this stuff - education legislation, teaching in schools, being a parent and even (buttergasp) are gay / lesbian teachers, dare to challenge the guff spouted by those determined that men are women when they say they are.

Twas ever thus of course. Those trying to force a lie on society (and in particular children) are desperate in the face of society's push back & will say anything - no matter how mad it is.

GCburneraccount · 13/10/2026 12:14

Wow - after a busy weekend I check the thread again and there is a lot here!

Thanks for your views - you've helped me think through what I think.

Its reminded me how catholic/protestant sectarianism was managed in my school/area. It could be a problem so we had rules that if you didn't know what they were there for you'd think were quite odd (no football colours etc), but if it was something you knew about you could spot the places that were trying to avoid trouble a mile off. Teachers had to be careful to avoid it getting out what team they supported or church they went to. As a result teachers very much did not bring their whole selves to school! I suppose teachers showing their interests and personality (outside their subject) will always feel odd to me.

I guess with that as my baseline I probably notice anything vaguely political more and think 'thats odd' more often - even today when I see primary kids wearing football kit on non uniform days I do a double take!

OP posts:
MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 13/10/2026 15:59

Shortshriftandlethal · 13/10/2026 09:37

That is not what i said. I said that the concept of a 'trans child' was not a thing in schools. Nobody had heard of it.

I'm not saying that children have never explored their feelings or their identity. Of course they have - but 'gender identity' was not being pushed via social media ( which also exploded in around 2014) and Stonewall had not yet got their campaign into schools. 'Queer' was still not commonly used as an identity marker in the gay and lesbian community, either. 'Non -binary' had definitely not been invented.

Edited

'Non -binary' had definitely not been invented.

According to Wikipedia the term 'non-binary' wasn't coined until 2014.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-binary#History

Non-binary - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-binary#History

Babayagahaha · 13/10/2026 16:42

I'd say more like 20 years when a trans child wasn't a thing. However it literally wasn't a thing. Then it peaked, and now you barely hear of one now.

NB was another fad, lingering a bit longer but it'll geg boring soon enough.

FrippEnos · 13/10/2026 16:59

MrsOvertonsWindow · 13/10/2026 11:50

Presumably that was meant for the stoned one? 😀

There's been seething tantrums upthread when those of us who actually know this stuff - education legislation, teaching in schools, being a parent and even (buttergasp) are gay / lesbian teachers, dare to challenge the guff spouted by those determined that men are women when they say they are.

Twas ever thus of course. Those trying to force a lie on society (and in particular children) are desperate in the face of society's push back & will say anything - no matter how mad it is.

Yes, it was meant for the stoned one :)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page