Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Secondary schools - are any of these red flags for gender madness?

150 replies

GCburneraccount · 09/10/2026 11:46

I've recently visited 8 state secondary schools in my city. Can anyone advise me if any of these things are red flags for gender madness having taken hold, or is this just normal in secondary these days?

My baseline is that none of these would have been allowed at the school I went to - but I'm very out of date! Things were certainly not great for gay kids back then and I hope this has changed for the better.

  • Every school had an LGBTQ club
  • A prominently displayed Stonewall poster 'trans people exist, get over it' (not in context of studying activism/advertising)
  • Specific toilets for 'all genders'
  • Activist/political flags like progress pride used in an activist context (rather than studying activism)
  • Wall displays encouraging activism - e.g. on climate/green issues, LGBT issues, race issues
  • Displays on teachers doors alluding to that teachers political beliefs and activism
  • School posters talking about 'decolonising the curriculum'
  • Shelves of trashy teen romance books in the school library (Heartstopper and similar) - I'd expect to see books with sex as a theme in a secondary library, but 1984/Brave New World/Dorian Grey type stuff rather than Forever(!)
  • So many wall displays including people who haven't made significant contributions to their field but were there purely on identity. The most bizarre one I saw was in Physics and had Dr Rachel Padman (an MtoF chap who taught me at Cambridge in the 90's!)

I guess I want a school to deal quickly with any type of bullying, and help kids who are struggling, but I don't love how this now seems to be tied to identity groups and bleed into activism now.

OP posts:
musicalfrog · 09/10/2026 13:44

Biggest red flag for me was pronouns on emails.

Send them all an email that needs a reply.

Beowulfa · 09/10/2026 13:54

Poppingby · 09/10/2026 13:33

Decolonising the curriculum means making a concerted effort to learn/teach things additional to those that dead posh white men told us we should learn 100 hundred years ago. In a state school in zone 3 London the presumably very varied student body in terms of class and culture makes those conversations entirely appropriate if you're interested in engaging your students in that curriculum. Difficult to argue otherwise really.

We studied the likes of Farrukh Dhondy, Ruth Prawer Jabhvala and Derek Alcott for GCSE/A Level at my local yokel West Country state comp back in the 90s. The teacher was open to our proposing any text at A Level; she said she would ring up the exam board and make a case. I didn't realise this was unusual in any way.

Imdunfer · 09/10/2026 15:01

Poppingby · 09/10/2026 13:12

My kids' z3 London school probably has all these. I'm quite gender critical - in the true sense, i.e. I think gender is made up, not in the I hate men who wear a dress sense - and I think it is led by the kids and because of that these are the greenest of green flags. Kids feel comfortable, school doesn't make a huge drama out of using whichever pronouns people want to, separate all gender bogs as well as single sex is perfectly legal, nobody is feeling shut down or victimised so kids are more or less happy to do what they're told. With exceptions obviously.

As for the library, kids perform better where reading for pleasure is encouraged and kids like reading the stuff you mentioned.

I think you've gone in deciding to have a conniption. Hope you don't end up as a parent at my kids' school.

Kids feel comfortable

The kids will only feel comfortable if they fit in with the political viewpoints being expressed, though, won't they?

Depending on what was actually being displayed, a gay kid could be very unhappy about Pride flags, a Jewish kid terrified by the implications of a Palestinian flag, a politically right wing kid might not dare open their mouth.

There are good reasons why teachers and schools were supposed to be politically neutral.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 15:41

GCburneraccount · 09/10/2026 11:46

I've recently visited 8 state secondary schools in my city. Can anyone advise me if any of these things are red flags for gender madness having taken hold, or is this just normal in secondary these days?

My baseline is that none of these would have been allowed at the school I went to - but I'm very out of date! Things were certainly not great for gay kids back then and I hope this has changed for the better.

  • Every school had an LGBTQ club
  • A prominently displayed Stonewall poster 'trans people exist, get over it' (not in context of studying activism/advertising)
  • Specific toilets for 'all genders'
  • Activist/political flags like progress pride used in an activist context (rather than studying activism)
  • Wall displays encouraging activism - e.g. on climate/green issues, LGBT issues, race issues
  • Displays on teachers doors alluding to that teachers political beliefs and activism
  • School posters talking about 'decolonising the curriculum'
  • Shelves of trashy teen romance books in the school library (Heartstopper and similar) - I'd expect to see books with sex as a theme in a secondary library, but 1984/Brave New World/Dorian Grey type stuff rather than Forever(!)
  • So many wall displays including people who haven't made significant contributions to their field but were there purely on identity. The most bizarre one I saw was in Physics and had Dr Rachel Padman (an MtoF chap who taught me at Cambridge in the 90's!)

I guess I want a school to deal quickly with any type of bullying, and help kids who are struggling, but I don't love how this now seems to be tied to identity groups and bleed into activism now.

Understanding about difference isn't a red flag. It's progress.

It's a reflection of how aware teachers are of the extreme bullying in schools, especially secondaries, of people who are different.

One of my sons had a best friend in school.whose Dad was Brazilian. Poor kid moved between schools until he settled at ours, which had a strong emphasis on anti-racism. He was relentlessly called racial slurs in the others. This was only twelve or so years ago. Teaching acceptance to kids (ours was a very white area) mattered. It still does.

Two of my sons are autistic, one also has adhd and the other is deaf. Their younger brother is trans. My aunt is gay, I'm non-binary and have a neurological disability, my brother has learning disability. And we aren't in any way unusual in that. I'm actually very cheered to hear your report, because I know how ignorance has affected my family.

Difference is normal, everyday and should be explained to kids, preferably early.

Being trans is no more imposed on children than being gay, and there are very few trans kids in schools. Existence is not violence. Celebrating difference is a wonderful thing.

There is no 'gender madness,' just a few kids getting the help and support they need. Given the massive upsurge in anti-trans violence in schools, early education is an absolute priority.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 09/10/2026 15:51

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 15:41

Understanding about difference isn't a red flag. It's progress.

It's a reflection of how aware teachers are of the extreme bullying in schools, especially secondaries, of people who are different.

One of my sons had a best friend in school.whose Dad was Brazilian. Poor kid moved between schools until he settled at ours, which had a strong emphasis on anti-racism. He was relentlessly called racial slurs in the others. This was only twelve or so years ago. Teaching acceptance to kids (ours was a very white area) mattered. It still does.

Two of my sons are autistic, one also has adhd and the other is deaf. Their younger brother is trans. My aunt is gay, I'm non-binary and have a neurological disability, my brother has learning disability. And we aren't in any way unusual in that. I'm actually very cheered to hear your report, because I know how ignorance has affected my family.

Difference is normal, everyday and should be explained to kids, preferably early.

Being trans is no more imposed on children than being gay, and there are very few trans kids in schools. Existence is not violence. Celebrating difference is a wonderful thing.

There is no 'gender madness,' just a few kids getting the help and support they need. Given the massive upsurge in anti-trans violence in schools, early education is an absolute priority.

This isn't about understanding difference. This is both selling a regressive belief that sex change is a good option for teenage pubertal angst and teachers ignoring their legal requirements to be politically neutral.
It's perfectly possible (and the majority of schools manage this) to nurture an accepting anti bullying environment where children know that they will be safe and their views listened to and respected.
Political activists in schools are replicating a frantic online world where everyone's a bigot and phobe if they fail to spout the accepted mantras or fail to use compelled speech.
The young are entitled to learn, play and mature without having to navigate age inappropriate beliefs pushed at them by activists.

WearyAuldWumman · 09/10/2026 16:09

The worst, I'd say is "Displays on teachers doors alluding to that teachers political beliefs and activism." That would be it for me - I'd not want my child to attend the school.

In Scotland, teachers are told that they shouldn't be sharing their politics with children.

I worked in an LA where councillors were pressurising headteachers into displaying LGBT+ posters. There was also a push for those clubs, but that's not necessarily a red flag, provided they're just being used as a 'safe space' for gay and bi teenagers to talk.

If staff are all displaying their pronouns, then that suggests that the SLT has been captured. I was aware of some schools where Headteachers were vying for Stonewall accreditation.

I did supply in one school where there was a rainbow crossing, but it had been ordered by a previous HT and was being allowed to flake off by the time I arrived.

I covered a class where the absent teacher had a nameplate with a cartoon pic of himself (bloke with a beard) and "Mx" as his title. From what the kids said, he was off with stress because they remembered to call him "Mx" but kept using the wrong pronouns. [No, I didn't hold a conversation with them about this - it was one throwaway comment made by a boy and I went temporarily deaf.]

He's obviously no longer there - I recently saw a community FB post where a parent was complaining (in rather robust terms) about a woman in a different department who 'doesnae ken what she is' and was insisting on being "Mx" with particular pronouns. The parent voiced his concern that someone with obvious mental health issues shouldn't be in the school. I should imagine that the other teacher would have had a mention if he were still there.

My opinion is that staff are entitled to their beliefs, but they shouldn't be foisting them upon pupils.

As an example, during the Scottish independence referendum, staff were warned that they shouldn't be discussing how they were going to vote with pupils. (Two members of staff did tell the kids that they were voting "No" and weren't pulled up on it, however, probably because the HT was also a "No" voter.)

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 18:50

Re Mx - an app that the school uses uses for homework or similar appeared to have all teachers set to Mx as default.

This disappeared rather quickly after I emailed one of the less reconstructed maths teachers using it.

This stupid bullshit has been woven through so many layers of life it will take years to get rid.

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 19:02

Imdunfer · 09/10/2026 15:01

Kids feel comfortable

The kids will only feel comfortable if they fit in with the political viewpoints being expressed, though, won't they?

Depending on what was actually being displayed, a gay kid could be very unhappy about Pride flags, a Jewish kid terrified by the implications of a Palestinian flag, a politically right wing kid might not dare open their mouth.

There are good reasons why teachers and schools were supposed to be politically neutral.

Absolutely.

No teacher should be sharing their views on politics, let alone contentious politics.

Its scunnering to me that we seem to have completely abandoned the understanding and agreement that being objective and no partisan is de rigeur for all public servants.

Plurality of belief and tolerance seem to be out the window.

The bedrock of a free, democratic society has been chopped up and scattered in favour of pomo havering.

Pomo ideas were supposed to critique and question the orthodoxies and power structures - instead they've done their best to destroy all norms, and replace the old power with new power that is proud to be a vacuum of experience/knowledge/morality. Based on what? Vague, empty tribalism, a quasi religious approach, and empty platitudes.

The anti Enlightenment and the enshittification of everything continues. Ironically it relies on and feeds off the structures it claims to despise.

Leafstamp · 09/10/2026 19:45

I think every single one of your bullet points are red flags and are not normal for a school that is properly fulfilling its legal and moral duties. The only exception being the one about library books, sadly I think that’s normal, and doesn’t particularly breach any guidance, unlike the others which risk doing so.

If I was you, my next move would be looking at policies on the school website. And, if you can find the time and energy, writing them to point out any blatant breaches of new RSHE guidance and KCSIE.

JanesLittleGirl · 09/10/2026 20:00

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 19:02

Absolutely.

No teacher should be sharing their views on politics, let alone contentious politics.

Its scunnering to me that we seem to have completely abandoned the understanding and agreement that being objective and no partisan is de rigeur for all public servants.

Plurality of belief and tolerance seem to be out the window.

The bedrock of a free, democratic society has been chopped up and scattered in favour of pomo havering.

Pomo ideas were supposed to critique and question the orthodoxies and power structures - instead they've done their best to destroy all norms, and replace the old power with new power that is proud to be a vacuum of experience/knowledge/morality. Based on what? Vague, empty tribalism, a quasi religious approach, and empty platitudes.

The anti Enlightenment and the enshittification of everything continues. Ironically it relies on and feeds off the structures it claims to despise.

The Enlightenment was the product of freedom from centuries of blind faith. Now powerful agencies and individual agents are moving heaven and earth to force us back into blind faith.

HeadAboveHeadBelow · 10/10/2026 08:05

My kid goes to a secondary school and went to their l g b t q club from year 7 for a couple of years ( on the basis that she was gay or at least believed she was). I was worried because I am sceptical of many aspects of gender identity as a ideology , and I spoke to the year head about it asking what the club was for , what they did in the club, etc.I also casually asked my kid what they'd done in that club that day. It seemed to be a lot of non-gender related activities such as baking cookies and sometimes gender related, such as drawing lGBTQ, flags, etc.Doing posters about identity. The head of year said it was more about kids who felt different getting some extra support making friends with each other. Etc. I pointed out that the whole school should be helping kids that felt different in any way and not just picking out LGBTQ as an issue. And he acknowledged that I had a point I also said there were a lot of ideas that were contested and this was around the time of the cass review and he was aware of the cass review, and said that they were being very sensitive to this and aware of this. A lot of schools did have l g b t q clubs and probably still do and I think if your kid goes to that school , it's perfectly reasonable to talk to the relevant person about it and just make it known that it's being noticed and that parents are on the ball with this stuff.
The other things I don't particularly think are red flags except the posters on the teachers doors.I think that tells you that there is a culture of transactivism in the school , which isn't necessarily true of all schools to that extent.
Most secondary schools will have some of this.You won't be able to avoid it completely.You just have to keep gently pushing back or not gently as the case may be, things will change it.Just will take time.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 10:57

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 15:41

Understanding about difference isn't a red flag. It's progress.

It's a reflection of how aware teachers are of the extreme bullying in schools, especially secondaries, of people who are different.

One of my sons had a best friend in school.whose Dad was Brazilian. Poor kid moved between schools until he settled at ours, which had a strong emphasis on anti-racism. He was relentlessly called racial slurs in the others. This was only twelve or so years ago. Teaching acceptance to kids (ours was a very white area) mattered. It still does.

Two of my sons are autistic, one also has adhd and the other is deaf. Their younger brother is trans. My aunt is gay, I'm non-binary and have a neurological disability, my brother has learning disability. And we aren't in any way unusual in that. I'm actually very cheered to hear your report, because I know how ignorance has affected my family.

Difference is normal, everyday and should be explained to kids, preferably early.

Being trans is no more imposed on children than being gay, and there are very few trans kids in schools. Existence is not violence. Celebrating difference is a wonderful thing.

There is no 'gender madness,' just a few kids getting the help and support they need. Given the massive upsurge in anti-trans violence in schools, early education is an absolute priority.

Careful, your complicated stories about imaginary kids are catching you out. I’ve recommended before that you use a spreadsheet to keep track of your lies then you wouldn’t make faux pas like forgetting how many children you have.

user293948849167 · 10/10/2026 11:18

That all sounds quite extreme. My DDs are in different secondaries, one has a few LGBTQ posters but alongside anti bullying and anti racism posters so in context. Nothing on classroom doors etc. Yes teen romance type books in the library (i’m ok with that at secondary, I’m not keen on censoring books).
Other school has nothing really, just general anti bullying posters.
Not sure if they have LGBTQ clubs as my DDs wouldn’t be interested anyway.
Neither have “all gender” toilets. Single sex changing rooms.

WearyAuldWumman · 10/10/2026 12:17

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 18:50

Re Mx - an app that the school uses uses for homework or similar appeared to have all teachers set to Mx as default.

This disappeared rather quickly after I emailed one of the less reconstructed maths teachers using it.

This stupid bullshit has been woven through so many layers of life it will take years to get rid.

When I did supply last year, SEEMIS only had Mrs, Mrs, Mrs, Dr, Prof or Other. The Mx for whom I was covering was down on the system as "Other [Surname]".

MrsOvertonsWindow · 10/10/2026 12:36

All those insisting that teachers must be allowed to share their political / activist views need to remember this if their local area becomes a more "right leaning" LA . Politicians holding more right wing views will be equally enthusiastic about sharing these with children?
That's why schools and the staff in them are required to be politically neutral.

You shouldn't need a degree in politics to understand this simple fact. 🙄

WearyAuldWumman · 10/10/2026 12:38

MrsOvertonsWindow · 10/10/2026 12:36

All those insisting that teachers must be allowed to share their political / activist views need to remember this if their local area becomes a more "right leaning" LA . Politicians holding more right wing views will be equally enthusiastic about sharing these with children?
That's why schools and the staff in them are required to be politically neutral.

You shouldn't need a degree in politics to understand this simple fact. 🙄

Thank you! Precisely this.

Poppingby · 10/10/2026 12:41

I will say that although my kids' school -as discussed above - has many of the items on the list it doesn't have political activist posters up on classroom doors and I think that's right. In fact, though, I don't think teachers have their own classrooms, just departments, and have never seen a secondary school where teachers did 'own' their classroom, so any posters put up on a classroom door wouldn't necessarily reflect the opinions of the person teaching in it.

I think that letting kids express themselves with clubs, pronouns etc is perfectly reasonable and actually de-dramatises what can become a really contentious issue.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 10/10/2026 13:17

Poppingby · 10/10/2026 12:41

I will say that although my kids' school -as discussed above - has many of the items on the list it doesn't have political activist posters up on classroom doors and I think that's right. In fact, though, I don't think teachers have their own classrooms, just departments, and have never seen a secondary school where teachers did 'own' their classroom, so any posters put up on a classroom door wouldn't necessarily reflect the opinions of the person teaching in it.

I think that letting kids express themselves with clubs, pronouns etc is perfectly reasonable and actually de-dramatises what can become a really contentious issue.

The school "owns" the displays in classrooms, corridors etc. Displays reflect the ethos of a school and should reflect the attitudes the school wants to encourage.

Clubs about pronouns etc (presumably LGBT etc) must comply with the statutory requirements that dictate how schools should address gender identity & gender questioning children. Teachers and older children involved in these usually mixed age groups, discussing sexuality and gender identity are potentially being exposed to allegations of grooming children if they address issues / answer questions / unintentionally encourage relationships without having planned how to address them. Teachers of Sex, Relationships education are trained in how to manage questions appropriately in a classroom setting.

Imagine the feedback if Mr Simms runs a group for heterosexual girls in Key Stage 4 or the Science technician runs a group for younger heterosexual boys! Discussing sex, sexuality and gender identity with children in school should not be carried out in private groups like this. There's a massive naivety about all this.

Schools are about nurturing a safe learning community where children (the majority below the age of consent) can grow, mature and navigate all the challenges of adolescence safely.

Bluespottedfrog · 10/10/2026 13:26

Are gender the general mental toilets a big toilet block for every, or individual self contained toilets that anyone can use which I have seen before

Leafstamp · 10/10/2026 18:06

Poppingby · 10/10/2026 12:41

I will say that although my kids' school -as discussed above - has many of the items on the list it doesn't have political activist posters up on classroom doors and I think that's right. In fact, though, I don't think teachers have their own classrooms, just departments, and have never seen a secondary school where teachers did 'own' their classroom, so any posters put up on a classroom door wouldn't necessarily reflect the opinions of the person teaching in it.

I think that letting kids express themselves with clubs, pronouns etc is perfectly reasonable and actually de-dramatises what can become a really contentious issue.

Letting kids express themselves with pronouns is not “perfectly reasonable” when it breaches statutory guidance or when others are expected to use wrong-sex pronouns.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/10/2026 18:50

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 15:41

Understanding about difference isn't a red flag. It's progress.

It's a reflection of how aware teachers are of the extreme bullying in schools, especially secondaries, of people who are different.

One of my sons had a best friend in school.whose Dad was Brazilian. Poor kid moved between schools until he settled at ours, which had a strong emphasis on anti-racism. He was relentlessly called racial slurs in the others. This was only twelve or so years ago. Teaching acceptance to kids (ours was a very white area) mattered. It still does.

Two of my sons are autistic, one also has adhd and the other is deaf. Their younger brother is trans. My aunt is gay, I'm non-binary and have a neurological disability, my brother has learning disability. And we aren't in any way unusual in that. I'm actually very cheered to hear your report, because I know how ignorance has affected my family.

Difference is normal, everyday and should be explained to kids, preferably early.

Being trans is no more imposed on children than being gay, and there are very few trans kids in schools. Existence is not violence. Celebrating difference is a wonderful thing.

There is no 'gender madness,' just a few kids getting the help and support they need. Given the massive upsurge in anti-trans violence in schools, early education is an absolute priority.

Christ on a bike

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 10/10/2026 23:55

GCburneraccount · 09/10/2026 11:46

I've recently visited 8 state secondary schools in my city. Can anyone advise me if any of these things are red flags for gender madness having taken hold, or is this just normal in secondary these days?

My baseline is that none of these would have been allowed at the school I went to - but I'm very out of date! Things were certainly not great for gay kids back then and I hope this has changed for the better.

  • Every school had an LGBTQ club
  • A prominently displayed Stonewall poster 'trans people exist, get over it' (not in context of studying activism/advertising)
  • Specific toilets for 'all genders'
  • Activist/political flags like progress pride used in an activist context (rather than studying activism)
  • Wall displays encouraging activism - e.g. on climate/green issues, LGBT issues, race issues
  • Displays on teachers doors alluding to that teachers political beliefs and activism
  • School posters talking about 'decolonising the curriculum'
  • Shelves of trashy teen romance books in the school library (Heartstopper and similar) - I'd expect to see books with sex as a theme in a secondary library, but 1984/Brave New World/Dorian Grey type stuff rather than Forever(!)
  • So many wall displays including people who haven't made significant contributions to their field but were there purely on identity. The most bizarre one I saw was in Physics and had Dr Rachel Padman (an MtoF chap who taught me at Cambridge in the 90's!)

I guess I want a school to deal quickly with any type of bullying, and help kids who are struggling, but I don't love how this now seems to be tied to identity groups and bleed into activism now.

Part of combating bullying is promoting diversity & acceptance. Many educators treat the flag as an expression of general human empathy, equity, and diversity rather than a partisan political statement.

It's certainly a testimony of how far we have regressed that acceptance is now considered as a 'political position' rather than a general standard.

Jesus wept….

Leafstamp · 11/10/2026 08:15

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 10/10/2026 23:55

Part of combating bullying is promoting diversity & acceptance. Many educators treat the flag as an expression of general human empathy, equity, and diversity rather than a partisan political statement.

It's certainly a testimony of how far we have regressed that acceptance is now considered as a 'political position' rather than a general standard.

Jesus wept….

It doesn’t matter what “many educators” treat the flag as. The fact is that trans ideology is a contested belief and the statutory RSHE guidance says as much. The statutory safeguarding guidance is also sceptical about it.

If a school absolutely insists on flying the progress pride flag then they also need to fly the Woman = Adult Human Female one.

HeadAboveHeadBelow · 11/10/2026 08:21

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 10/10/2026 23:55

Part of combating bullying is promoting diversity & acceptance. Many educators treat the flag as an expression of general human empathy, equity, and diversity rather than a partisan political statement.

It's certainly a testimony of how far we have regressed that acceptance is now considered as a 'political position' rather than a general standard.

Jesus wept….

I think that is exactly what most educators are trying to do when they use the pride flag, i think their intentions are genuinely to support the kids and create an inclusive and empathic culture.
The trouble is that now part of that whole movement as signalled by the flag includes these very complicated and controversial ideas, such as 'born in the wrong body' ... or 'if you don't feel quite right as a girl whilst you're figuring it all out, maybe you're a boy, and your body is the wrong body for you' etc a rejection of periods and breasts, etc- this happens: This is a reality, and it's not healthy. It's not a healthy way to approach gender non-conformity. So with this getting all wrapped up in the whole movement, it makes it Problematic to support fully.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:22

Leafstamp · 11/10/2026 08:15

It doesn’t matter what “many educators” treat the flag as. The fact is that trans ideology is a contested belief and the statutory RSHE guidance says as much. The statutory safeguarding guidance is also sceptical about it.

If a school absolutely insists on flying the progress pride flag then they also need to fly the Woman = Adult Human Female one.

Whilst the EA classifies trans people as a protected group from discrimination it remains a civil standard that no 'guidance' has authority over.

Swipe left for the next trending thread