Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Secondary schools - are any of these red flags for gender madness?

150 replies

GCburneraccount · 09/10/2026 11:46

I've recently visited 8 state secondary schools in my city. Can anyone advise me if any of these things are red flags for gender madness having taken hold, or is this just normal in secondary these days?

My baseline is that none of these would have been allowed at the school I went to - but I'm very out of date! Things were certainly not great for gay kids back then and I hope this has changed for the better.

  • Every school had an LGBTQ club
  • A prominently displayed Stonewall poster 'trans people exist, get over it' (not in context of studying activism/advertising)
  • Specific toilets for 'all genders'
  • Activist/political flags like progress pride used in an activist context (rather than studying activism)
  • Wall displays encouraging activism - e.g. on climate/green issues, LGBT issues, race issues
  • Displays on teachers doors alluding to that teachers political beliefs and activism
  • School posters talking about 'decolonising the curriculum'
  • Shelves of trashy teen romance books in the school library (Heartstopper and similar) - I'd expect to see books with sex as a theme in a secondary library, but 1984/Brave New World/Dorian Grey type stuff rather than Forever(!)
  • So many wall displays including people who haven't made significant contributions to their field but were there purely on identity. The most bizarre one I saw was in Physics and had Dr Rachel Padman (an MtoF chap who taught me at Cambridge in the 90's!)

I guess I want a school to deal quickly with any type of bullying, and help kids who are struggling, but I don't love how this now seems to be tied to identity groups and bleed into activism now.

OP posts:
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:28

HeadAboveHeadBelow · 11/10/2026 08:21

I think that is exactly what most educators are trying to do when they use the pride flag, i think their intentions are genuinely to support the kids and create an inclusive and empathic culture.
The trouble is that now part of that whole movement as signalled by the flag includes these very complicated and controversial ideas, such as 'born in the wrong body' ... or 'if you don't feel quite right as a girl whilst you're figuring it all out, maybe you're a boy, and your body is the wrong body for you' etc a rejection of periods and breasts, etc- this happens: This is a reality, and it's not healthy. It's not a healthy way to approach gender non-conformity. So with this getting all wrapped up in the whole movement, it makes it Problematic to support fully.

You could say the same for gay people who many still think are 'groomed' into being & as such educators have no business supporting.

'Problematic' interpretations aren't a green light for censoring existence or enabling bullying.

Educators have a responsibility to be proactive to prevent bullying these days or they can be considered culpable & that doesn't mean pushing problematic groups back into the closet.

HeadAboveHeadBelow · 11/10/2026 08:28

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:22

Whilst the EA classifies trans people as a protected group from discrimination it remains a civil standard that no 'guidance' has authority over.

Discrimination is a totally different matter.
The EA also protects beliefs, including a gender critical belief. If part of the trans rights movement is a belief that for example "trans women are women" (amongst many other contested beliefs) then the gender , critical belief would be that no , in fact , they are not... and would a child or a teacher be able to openly say that at school , would they feel able to say that , in a classroom adoned with pride flags for example? , I think not , and therefore this inclusive supportive environment is one sided it isn't... the respect only needs to go one way.

VashtaNerada · 11/10/2026 08:29

I don’t think all these concerns are equal. I cannot imagine anyone having a problem with schools trying to decolonise the curriculum. The terminology is new but trying to teach more widely than what white men think is fairly standard nowadays.
And I do think teachers’ views and political activism can be appropriate depending on what it is. Teachers still have the public sector equality duty and “British values” to teach (terrible name) so saying that you are anti-racist or feminist is entirely in keeping with that IMO. I also think it’s fine for teachers to promote recycling and saving energy. Of course, if someone has a ‘Vote Labour’ sticker on their door or similar, that’s different.

HeadAboveHeadBelow · 11/10/2026 08:31

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:28

You could say the same for gay people who many still think are 'groomed' into being & as such educators have no business supporting.

'Problematic' interpretations aren't a green light for censoring existence or enabling bullying.

Educators have a responsibility to be proactive to prevent bullying these days or they can be considered culpable & that doesn't mean pushing problematic groups back into the closet.

Who mentioned censoring existence or enabling bullying?You're making quite a few leaps there.
Of course , I think that bullying should be addressed in every way at every level in schools , as i'm sure everybody on this thread also does.
As for censoring existence, that's just hyperbole. Nobody is suggesting that existence of anything or anyone is 'censored'.Anybody should be able to act, be, and call themselves what they want.

AStonedRose · 11/10/2026 08:32

I agree OP. This is why I home school my kids! It's much better and you can choose exactly what to teach them.

This is what an average day looks like

Lesson 1: Maths
Lesson 2: The dangers of trans people
Lesson 3: Science (climate change denial)
Lesson 4: English
Lesson 5: More anti-trans

My kids are turning out really tolerant, well-rounded individuals! I have all kinds of lesson plans etc. Let me know if you'd like me to share any.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:34

HeadAboveHeadBelow · 11/10/2026 08:28

Discrimination is a totally different matter.
The EA also protects beliefs, including a gender critical belief. If part of the trans rights movement is a belief that for example "trans women are women" (amongst many other contested beliefs) then the gender , critical belief would be that no , in fact , they are not... and would a child or a teacher be able to openly say that at school , would they feel able to say that , in a classroom adoned with pride flags for example? , I think not , and therefore this inclusive supportive environment is one sided it isn't... the respect only needs to go one way.

The difference between a teacher promoting LGBTQ & GC ideology is that only one of those is a student bullying risk …& after all its in their job description to prevent bullying/harm not to promote their personal beliefs.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:38

HeadAboveHeadBelow · 11/10/2026 08:31

Who mentioned censoring existence or enabling bullying?You're making quite a few leaps there.
Of course , I think that bullying should be addressed in every way at every level in schools , as i'm sure everybody on this thread also does.
As for censoring existence, that's just hyperbole. Nobody is suggesting that existence of anything or anyone is 'censored'.Anybody should be able to act, be, and call themselves what they want.

Edited

Of course , I think that bullying should be addressed in every way at every level in schools , as i'm sure everybody on this thread also does.

And how exactly would you achieve that if you aren't allowed to

A. Talk about the existence of the group being bullied or
B. Support them?

FrippEnos · 11/10/2026 08:51

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:22

Whilst the EA classifies trans people as a protected group from discrimination it remains a civil standard that no 'guidance' has authority over.

Just FYI the EA doesn't list trans as a protected group. The characteristic is gender reassignment.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:58

FrippEnos · 11/10/2026 08:51

Just FYI the EA doesn't list trans as a protected group. The characteristic is gender reassignment.

Same thing.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 11/10/2026 09:11

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 10:57

Careful, your complicated stories about imaginary kids are catching you out. I’ve recommended before that you use a spreadsheet to keep track of your lies then you wouldn’t make faux pas like forgetting how many children you have.

@TransParentlyAnnoyed has always said she has two older boys plus a younger child who is trans and who she refers to as her son. They are as real or imaginary as anyone else's kids on here.

Move on.

Phineyj · 11/10/2026 09:14

Hmm, OK, I have taught in a number of London schools and yes, LGBTQA+ clubs yes and trashy novels in the library. The rest: no. It is very clear in teaching codes of conduct that your own political views should stay out of the classroom.

Igmum · 11/10/2026 09:25

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:34

The difference between a teacher promoting LGBTQ & GC ideology is that only one of those is a student bullying risk …& after all its in their job description to prevent bullying/harm not to promote their personal beliefs.

There’s a recent Finnish study showing that kids identifying as trans are more likely to bully than be bullied. I’ve certainly seen kids identifying as trans going apeshit if they feel they are losing control over a group on issues of pronouns/new name/acceptable views and expression. For some I suspect power over others is a major factor in ‘transition’. It’s always such a relief to see them detransition/desist - often years later - but so much better for their mental health.

Leafstamp · 11/10/2026 09:40

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:22

Whilst the EA classifies trans people as a protected group from discrimination it remains a civil standard that no 'guidance' has authority over.

I don’t think you fully understand the application of the EA in schools versus the application of KCSIE guidance, which is statutory. The RSHE guidance is also statutory.

Leafstamp · 11/10/2026 09:43

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:34

The difference between a teacher promoting LGBTQ & GC ideology is that only one of those is a student bullying risk …& after all its in their job description to prevent bullying/harm not to promote their personal beliefs.

Being a sex realist (or “GC”) is not an ideology. It’s evidenced based and grounded in science and the law. You do know that the what the EA2010 says means trans woman are not women?

Funnily enough, that’s what the biology textbooks say too.

ImBeeZee · 11/10/2026 09:44

I’m not an expert. But I look for a secondary school that primarily advertises its focus as academic rather than pastoral.

I’ve noticed the secondary schools in my area that talk a lot about focusing on the pupils’ “holistic wellbeing” as the starting point for getting them engaged in learning, tend also to be the ones that are employing the kind of teachers who hope to help children with issues that have no place being addressed or explored in a school.

Case in point: local comp has very active lgbtqia+ club. It’s very trendy to be in it. All the cool kids want a label. A surprisingly high % of these kids have ended up with severe mental health problems and I currently know two who aren’t attending school in my parents WhatsApp group.

I’d be looking for a school that talked about resilience, gcse results, having an insanely high number of lunchtime activity clubs like KPop, crochet or handball or model United Nations and ideally no lgbtqia+ group.

Why do lgtbqia+ kids NEED a group? It creates a subculture and highlights difference. If kids need counselling for complex issues arising during adolescence the place for that is NOT a casual club at lunchtime. If they want to discuss books, or debate politics, they should join a general club.

DialSquare · 11/10/2026 09:47

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 15:41

Understanding about difference isn't a red flag. It's progress.

It's a reflection of how aware teachers are of the extreme bullying in schools, especially secondaries, of people who are different.

One of my sons had a best friend in school.whose Dad was Brazilian. Poor kid moved between schools until he settled at ours, which had a strong emphasis on anti-racism. He was relentlessly called racial slurs in the others. This was only twelve or so years ago. Teaching acceptance to kids (ours was a very white area) mattered. It still does.

Two of my sons are autistic, one also has adhd and the other is deaf. Their younger brother is trans. My aunt is gay, I'm non-binary and have a neurological disability, my brother has learning disability. And we aren't in any way unusual in that. I'm actually very cheered to hear your report, because I know how ignorance has affected my family.

Difference is normal, everyday and should be explained to kids, preferably early.

Being trans is no more imposed on children than being gay, and there are very few trans kids in schools. Existence is not violence. Celebrating difference is a wonderful thing.

There is no 'gender madness,' just a few kids getting the help and support they need. Given the massive upsurge in anti-trans violence in schools, early education is an absolute priority.

You’re sounding more and more like Dame Katy everyday!

Notellinganyone · 11/10/2026 09:48

Rareusername · 09/10/2026 11:48

Thank goodness both of my teens are private. Honestly, none of this virtue signalling

I teach in a big independent private school and we have all of the above. Not sure what your problem is. It’s the 21st century.

Babayagahaha · 11/10/2026 09:58

LGBT club and library books are the only not red flags. The rest is concerning.

FrippEnos · 11/10/2026 10:22

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 08:58

Same thing.

Its not, and your showing why language matters.

Lhori · 11/10/2026 10:24

All schools I have ever worked in have single sex toilets, single sex changing rooms and are very strict about having teachers of the appropriate sex on residential trips. They have to be for safeguarding reasons Some schools have a mixed sex toilet as well. There always has to be single sex facilities available though.

All the rest of the stuff depends a bit on the pupils. There are a lot of issues with secondary schools. You are probably prioritising the wrong thing. When your child is crying because they didn't make their uni offer you won't stressing about the number of single sex loos vs mixed, you'll be stressing about the number of qualified physics teachers the school was able to provide.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 10:32

Igmum · 11/10/2026 09:25

There’s a recent Finnish study showing that kids identifying as trans are more likely to bully than be bullied. I’ve certainly seen kids identifying as trans going apeshit if they feel they are losing control over a group on issues of pronouns/new name/acceptable views and expression. For some I suspect power over others is a major factor in ‘transition’. It’s always such a relief to see them detransition/desist - often years later - but so much better for their mental health.

The study does NOT say that all transgender teens are more likely to bully than to be bullied. It says non binary students are more likely than cisgender teens to self-report being both victims and perpetrators of bullying. Further research would be needed to ascertain whether this is reactive bullying (that is, kids who get bullied more have increased likelihood of themselves bullying others), or whether transgender teens are simply more sensitized to bullying and more likely to identify their own and others’ behavior in those terms, and whether the self-reported incidence of bullying and being bullied can be corroborated by objective observation.

The study does not specify how many trans students were involved in the study (only the total of students) so its difficult to know whether it was a statistically relevant number & as such any meaningful conclusions be made.

Its also the only study reflecting these results so lacks replication.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 10:33

Leafstamp · 11/10/2026 09:40

I don’t think you fully understand the application of the EA in schools versus the application of KCSIE guidance, which is statutory. The RSHE guidance is also statutory.

Do point to where it says bullying trans people isn't in breach of discrimination law.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 10:37

Leafstamp · 11/10/2026 09:43

Being a sex realist (or “GC”) is not an ideology. It’s evidenced based and grounded in science and the law. You do know that the what the EA2010 says means trans woman are not women?

Funnily enough, that’s what the biology textbooks say too.

the EA2010 says means trans woman are not women?

Are you suggesting this special exemption that's only under certain contexts permits the bullying of trans students?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/10/2026 10:45

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 10:37

the EA2010 says means trans woman are not women?

Are you suggesting this special exemption that's only under certain contexts permits the bullying of trans students?

That's some reach - even for you Chopping. 😂

There's lots of links upthread with some of the statutory guidelines for UK schools that might be useful if you're unfamiliar with children, parenting and UK schools.

Ensuring that this exceptionally mentally vulnerable group feel safe and are able to access education is a priority. There are far too many young people caught up in this who are failing to thrive as adults because they've been caught up with a narcissistic obsession about identity. This has limited their journey through adolescence and rather than learning and achieving, maturing and building successful relationships and being able to navigate communities and the work place, they're stuck in a perpetual, emotional self involved state..

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 11/10/2026 10:47

ImBeeZee · 11/10/2026 09:44

I’m not an expert. But I look for a secondary school that primarily advertises its focus as academic rather than pastoral.

I’ve noticed the secondary schools in my area that talk a lot about focusing on the pupils’ “holistic wellbeing” as the starting point for getting them engaged in learning, tend also to be the ones that are employing the kind of teachers who hope to help children with issues that have no place being addressed or explored in a school.

Case in point: local comp has very active lgbtqia+ club. It’s very trendy to be in it. All the cool kids want a label. A surprisingly high % of these kids have ended up with severe mental health problems and I currently know two who aren’t attending school in my parents WhatsApp group.

I’d be looking for a school that talked about resilience, gcse results, having an insanely high number of lunchtime activity clubs like KPop, crochet or handball or model United Nations and ideally no lgbtqia+ group.

Why do lgtbqia+ kids NEED a group? It creates a subculture and highlights difference. If kids need counselling for complex issues arising during adolescence the place for that is NOT a casual club at lunchtime. If they want to discuss books, or debate politics, they should join a general club.

Edited

A surprisingly high % of these kids have ended up with severe mental health problems and I currently know two who aren’t attending school in my parents WhatsApp group.

What's your point here?

Its not exactly news that children who are "different" including those with neuro developmental, genetic or socio-demographic differences like LGBTQ face a significantly higher risk of developing mental health conditions. Large-scale research shows that children experiencing these differences face complex internal and social pathways that frequently lead to elevated rates of anxiety, depression, and psychological distress so its hardly the fault of a supportive network in fact its jus t the opposite.