From TT
DS in report framed as allowing people to access ponds in lived gender, I would accept that there is a distinction between the way the policy has been formulated and the practical application of it, what is clear is that the aim as set out in the report is that people should be
able to access according to lived gender rather than bio sex. True to say that the formulation is broader than that in practice, NB can access the ponds of their bio sex even if they don't live in one gender or the other, one of the reasons option 3 was confusing was because
no provision of NB people. The aim was to have 2 ponds, one for female gender, the other for lived gender is male, albeit the way it is formulated is somewhat more inclusive than that.
J are we talking about the same rule, requiring the pc of GRA is quite narrow,
DS I'm not
sure that's right, Option 2 permits NB people to use the pond of their bio sex, and in theory it permits a trans person,
J what do you mean
DS I mean someone with the pc of GRA, they could use the pool of their bio sex. So 2 is broader that 3. It is about lived gender.
J are you saying in reality its option 3,
DS it's option 3 plus, includes NB, TP who could use the pond for their bio sex,
J right
DS it's formulated in that way for the pragmatic reason that people found Option 3 confusing, left NB in an anomalous situation, and couldn't be
distinguished from Option 2.
J yes, so it's lived gender, all right
DS if that analysis is right, then that's the end of the direct discrim case, if its not right then we are into arguments about less favourable treatment, I will go to Coll (sp) to see if segregation
is sufficient. The C relies on that in support of the proposition that not all men would be allowed into LP for direct discrim to be established. So this one is about someone who might be sent to approved accommodation far from their home, much more likely to happen to women