Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sex Matters - Hampstead Heath Ponds -

1000 replies

SexRealismBeliefs · 15/12/2025 18:42

Sex Matters, a charity that campaigns for single-sex rights, will argue that the City of London Corporation is breaching equality law by allowing trans women to use Kenwood Ladies’ Pond on Hampstead Heath.

Hearing this Wednesday.

https://www.thetimes.com/article/cceca8ca-4167-4b04-875a-40ddacfea782?shareToken=e9fe25a546d20835f1a5a66564cbf27b

Hampstead women’s pond sued over transgender access

Sex Matters claims that the City of London Corporation is defending a policy that defies the Supreme Court ruling on single-sex services

https://www.thetimes.com/article/cceca8ca-4167-4b04-875a-40ddacfea782?shareToken=e9fe25a546d20835f1a5a66564cbf27b

OP posts:
Thread gallery
42
Keeptoiletssafe · 03/11/2026 20:56

Thankyou for replying @CriticalCondition. The reason I was interested if they had changed was that I had saved the information previously. It’s still up here so you can see the designs they were thinking. For a cool million I could be persuaded to project manage if they want!! I believe the designs must be still most like Option 3:

https://www.klpa.uk/revised-plans-from-the-city-new-survey/

The comments are interesting to the survey. Very practical comments.

https://mcusercontent.com/0e871ffde380e120f7dffe46c/files/f1859c93-4276-e4ee-5ae2-4282d3360c93/Survey_April_2022_chart_results.pdf

According to building regs and standards and legislation you cannot have facilities that are designed as single sex, as these are, for mixed sex use.

Moving on from the designs above, the management know this which is why the options are now:

  1. to keep the single sex ponds single sex
  2. to completely change the facilities so they fulfil the criteria for universal toilet accommodation.

They have opted for 2. This will be a problem. From 2024 there are very publicised rules for toilets in England. Approved Document T (2024) says that you have to satisfy single sex toilets first. So they can possibly satisfy this by creating all universal toilets but with female pictograms, male pictograms and unisex pictograms. Which is a bit farcical. Or they can take the government on to get building regulations changed.

Universal toilets and private changing cubicles are not suitable in this location, not least because of the extra safety issues and less ability to clean, but also because of the damp and drainage. The humidity (rotting, smell) is always going to be a problem as can be seen if you click on the survey results. You need as much ventilation as possible in a place where people are changing. And the ability to use a mop to clean under the partitions and doors (universal design is floor to ceiling). If the cubicle occupant can’t see who’s about and someone enters the building that causes voyeurism problems. Open sightlines have advantages for safety and health.

The current problems include there are not enough toilets at busy times and there are damp issues.

If they try and convert the existing building, there will be bigger queues (universal toilets have to have the sink in there so you need 25% extra for the same turnover). You will need better ventilation as universal toilets will be enclosed so some sort of dehumidifying mechanical ventilation as extraction is more difficult when the facilities are literally next to water.

The other concern is an environmental one. In 2016, there were lots of concerns about getting the facilities in place because of the environment. That a lot of machinery that’s going to be needed again to change the facilities. That’s not an easy task considering the location.

https://hampsteadheathpondsproject.wordpress.com/2016/04/08/ladies-pond-building/comment-page-1/

https://mcusercontent.com/0e871ffde380e120f7dffe46c/files/f1859c93-4276-e4ee-5ae2-4282d3360c93/Survey_April_2022_chart_results.pdf

Slothtoes · 03/11/2026 22:20

my friend usually changes in and out of her swimming stuff in the open air out on the grass, due to the indoor facilities usually being busy.
If there had been a man there, her and I imagine a lot of the other women changing outside (and communally inside) would have to have not wanted to get changed at all- ie missed having their swim completely or had to leave putting clothes on top of wet swimmers to go home or something, which when you have to cross the whole Heath to get to transport links to wherever you need to go, is totally miserable.

The men at CoL might have not understood but there’s different expectations to women changing in a mixed public beach or pond where you have different options for changing cover than in a women-only environment with habitual expectations of safe, temporary, nudity. and we all know the kind of bloke who puts himself in a woman’s area is not a safe man for women to be around. Not the same as a man going along to mixed beach or mixed ponds. No issue there. We can all freely risk assess accordingly in a mixed environment.

The CoL have a very simple, cheap, effective legal solution to this, they can just leave the women’s pond as a women’s pond. Everybody knows that safe, decent men would never want to encroach into women’s spaces like this.

Keeptoiletssafe · 03/11/2026 22:36

Agree

moto748e · 03/11/2026 22:59

The CoL have a very simple, cheap, effective legal solution to this, they can just leave the women’s pond as a women’s pond. Everybody knows that safe, decent men would never want to encroach into women’s spaces like this.

Of course. But still I don't feel optimistic it will happen.

anyolddinosaur · 04/11/2026 07:28

A reminder that Judicial Review is an expensive process and that Sex Matters would still like another 13k. On their website if you click on take action you'll find a useful option. All donations can be gift aided.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 08:26

I’m happy to copy and paste live from TT all or part of today if wanted, don’t expect fancy formatting as I only have x on my old phone and it’s not great. But I can c&p.

Slothtoes · 04/11/2026 09:25

yes please- thank you

Slothtoes · 04/11/2026 09:33

anyolddinosaur · 04/11/2026 07:28

A reminder that Judicial Review is an expensive process and that Sex Matters would still like another 13k. On their website if you click on take action you'll find a useful option. All donations can be gift aided.

Thank you for sharing- very important case to support and thank you to every single women pushing this forward. but also, it’s infuriating that women are still having to contribute individually financially to bring cases.

This seems like a failure of parliament to give regulatory powers. Why isn’t this case against the CoL being brought by EHRC? Do their enforcement powers not extend to stopping organisations from ignoring equality law? CoL are subject to PSED so surely EHRC could investigate?

I just don’t understand the background to why this case because as I understand it, there isn’t any doubt in the law.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 09:34

Slothtoes · 04/11/2026 09:25

yes please- thank you

Cool, better get ready and get the coffee on! Is it 10am start?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:07

From TT

C/SM - Sex Matters, claimant
TC - Tom Cross, KC, barrister for the claimant
SS - Sarah Steinhardt, junior barrister for the claimant
D/CL - Mayor & Commonalty & Citizens of the City of London, defendant
J/ML - the Honourable Mr Justice Linden, My Lord

MLF - my learned friend, barristers referring to opposing counsel
SR - Sasha Rozansky, solicitor for the claimant
MF - Maya Forstater of Sex Matters
DS - Daniel Stilitz, barrister for Ds

KE - Katherine Eddy , junior barrister for Ds
LP - ladies pond
MP - men’s pond
MSP - mixed sex pond
TW - trans women, men claiming a female gender identity,
TM - trans men, women claiming a male gender identity

EA - Equality Act 2010
PC - protected characteristic
FWS - Supreme Court decision in For Women Scotland, April 2025
PCP - provision, criteria or practice
GC - gender critical belief, biological sex is immutable

GI - gender identity, a person’s internal sense of being male, female, some combination of male and female, or neither male nor female
TI - trans inclusive, allowing TW to use women’s facilities or services and likewise for TMs

GIP - gender identity policy of R: Since at least 2017 biological women and trans women have been permitted to swim at the Kenwood Ladies Pond (“the Ladies Pond”) and biological men and trans men have been permitted to swim at the Highgate Men’s Pond (“the Men’s Pond”).

We will return at 10 am.

Unusual for the London Administrative Court, we expect to begin at 10 am, rather than the usual 10:30 am. Expecting to hear from counsel for the Ds. Observers and press have been admitted to Court 1.

We will also hear from Translucent who have been granted leave to intervene.
HS - Hannah Slarks, senior
CK - Crash Krylova (Wigley)

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:09

From TT

We begin.
DS in the real world of the people who use the ponds, and run the ponds. They are very popular, 4000 swims alone last year, a rare opportunity to open air swim, a surprise for those of us who are fair weather swimmers. The ponds have a long history of inclusivity

for the LGBTQ community, and especially the trans community. The ponds have worked well for many years with trans inclusive policies. Inclusive atmosphere valued by many users including women. Current arrangements are pragmatic and sensitively managed.

Current arrangements are very popular and neither segregation by biological sex or fully mixed is popular with users. The trans inclusive nature of the ponds is a feature not a bug.
J excuse me
DS its the tech term, ML. The trans arrangement is valued, and if these arrangements

must change it is likely that the Ponds will become fully mixed, and the LP will cease to exist. The Cs have said they don't have a preference but not true, look at letter before action. It says 'confirm the policy withdrawn', 'statement on line, will comply with FWS and operate

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:09

thats up to date now

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:10

From TT

the LP as a single sex service' and 'change the signage'. That is entirely consistent with the tenor of MF's evidence. It may be that the Cs have retreated from that. The thrust of Ground 1 is that both ponds should be fully mixed.
J I thought G1 was sex segregated

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:13

From TT

DS Ground 3 (G3) is sex segregated. So the leaps needed from FWS are 3; first sex means biological sex, second TW are excluded, third, any service that includes TW is unlawful.
J well, we'll see if that is there case, I'm not sure it is.
DS yes, well I propose to go over the

facts briefly. Outlining the structure of his submissions. Seven main headings, in his structure.
J you need to leave time for HS to make her subs.
DS may I be impertinent and ask how late you're prepared to sit.
J hard stop at 5 pm.
DS a good guide.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:18

From TT

DS will bear it in mind. Now to WS of BL (Bill Losasso). Ponds have a history of inclusion,
J well that depends on what inclusion means
DS MF describes as an idyll, and has been trans inclusive since the 90s, probably and certainly since the 200s. It is part of what makes

the ponds idyllic. The Cs seek to destroy that idyll. Statement from JW, chair of the men's pond is that the TM have been admitted to the MP at least since 2009 when he started swimming there. So inclusive means trans inclusive for more than a decade. BL WS says the provision

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:20

From TT

prior to FWS was aligned with the EHRC code. Announcement of trans inclusive policy was a non-event, everyone knew what the arrangements were. It was hot topic locally, and you would have known what the access arrangements were.
J so recently but what about before then

DS at least since 2017, there were press inquiries then so for at least a decade. And the LP association is supportive of the (trans inclusive) TP policy. Para 109 of BL WS; [reading out very rapidly] support for trans inclusive policy following survey. No specific harms.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:27

From TT

DS conts BL WS on complaints, very few complaints, [now reading so rapidly as to be in comprehensible] Only one recording complaint in 2017; unsafe behaviour from TW, investigated but not upheld. Staff approach is very active management, no such incidents that have required

the police. Para 121, since FWS things have become more difficult for stewards. Raised public tensions, protest, many stewards have been subjected to verbal harassment, felt pressure, distracted from other tasks such as health and safety. Practical difficulties in enforcing a

single sex policy. Staff could not practically do physical inspections, inspect documents etc. Even the most intimate physical inspection could not tell
J I saw that and questioned that, its very difficult to establish the pc of GRA than to tell the difference between the sexes

DS I disagree, reading out from WS from TM, I pass as male.
J I saw this was part of the reasoning from the Ds, appearances can be misleading, but in the generality enforcing the bio sex criteria would be much easier than enforcing the pc of GRA.
DS I respectfully disagree

Keeptoiletssafe · 04/11/2026 10:28

Here’s the most accurate changing rooms and toilets plan (I believe) so you can envisage the toilet facilities, and the changing rooms for the people who want to use them.

This 2022 plan was for slight alterations to help women with disabilities more, which was to leave the WC block much as it is now but with one WC cubicle having grab rails and having a combined accessible WC/shower room created, which is enlarged by removing the panelling in the existing accessible WC .

For information, the upper right section in front of the cubicles has no roof, nor does the outside shower bottom right. The changing room cubicle doors have gaps.

To make the toilet facilities universal, you would lose at least one toilet due to reconfigurations and plumbing in the individual sinks and dryers. The toilet doors would need to lead straight outside or the door taken off from the outside. The four toilets are of single sex design.

The open plan changing room is unlikely to survive when officially it is mixed sex. This is why the management have discussed increasing individual privacy. Even they realise these are not fit for purpose if mixed sex.

For a million pounds (!), I am presuming they are going to scrap the whole building as it was purpose built in 2016 for single sex use, cost a lot of money, and raised environmental concerns getting the whole thing in place.

Sex Matters - Hampstead Heath Ponds -
Datun · 04/11/2026 10:30

They are very popular, 4000 swims alone last year

So who are the tens of thousands of people who filled in the survey??

Columbidae · 04/11/2026 10:30

"J I saw that and questioned that, its very difficult to establish the pc of GRA than to tell the difference between the sexes
DS I disagree, reading out from WS from TM, I pass as male.
J I saw this was part of the reasoning from the Ds, appearances can be misleading, but in the generality enforcing the bio sex criteria would be much easier than enforcing the pc of GRA."

Judge seems sensible but I fear having false hope. And thanks @Ereshkigalangcleg!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:31

From TT

DS we handed up this morning a small bundle of authorities, including sections of the EHRC CoP. Do you have that?
[J given a hard copy]
DS extracts from code, status of the code, page 9, [again reading so quickly incomprehensible], 'in many cases the main way to provide

SS services,.....service providers must keep in mind that it is not always possible to determine the sex of persons by physical appearance. Look at the WS of Stephanie Richards (SR), trans exclusion policy, forces service providers to guess, many TP live their lives with no

ArabellaScott · 04/11/2026 10:33

enforcing the bio sex criteria would be much easier than enforcing the pc of GRA."

No shit!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:33

From TT

questions about their sex. We do not accept that it is easier to police bio sex than PC of GRA. That is what BL says, born out by para 28 of BL WS.

CriticalCondition · 04/11/2026 10:33

I think the judge has done some rather illuminating reading overnight. He's making some good points today.

Datun · 04/11/2026 10:34

Irrelevance. The proposal isn't whether or not they pass, the proposal is if they have a GRA. Which requires no surgery, no hormones, and zero change to your appearance

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.