Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sex Matters - Hampstead Heath Ponds -

1000 replies

SexRealismBeliefs · 15/12/2025 18:42

Sex Matters, a charity that campaigns for single-sex rights, will argue that the City of London Corporation is breaching equality law by allowing trans women to use Kenwood Ladies’ Pond on Hampstead Heath.

Hearing this Wednesday.

https://www.thetimes.com/article/cceca8ca-4167-4b04-875a-40ddacfea782?shareToken=e9fe25a546d20835f1a5a66564cbf27b

Hampstead women’s pond sued over transgender access

Sex Matters claims that the City of London Corporation is defending a policy that defies the Supreme Court ruling on single-sex services

https://www.thetimes.com/article/cceca8ca-4167-4b04-875a-40ddacfea782?shareToken=e9fe25a546d20835f1a5a66564cbf27b

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
42
Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:11

Need coffee!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:11

From TT

DS I'll come back to that if I may.
End of afternoon session part 1.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:09

From TT

Sec 158 is all about small minorities and under-represented groups. It would be extremely common for positive action to discriminate against the majority for the benefit of the minority.
J yes, I get that
DS we don't accept the factual premise of MLF on this. If one looks at

the evidence of women, far more in favour than against.
[DS talking to junior] 10% of people said they had an uncomfortable experience, in many cases it is that they disagree with the policy.
[DS looking for reference].

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:08

From TT

they have gone to to make the decision.
DS conts, [reading out excerpts from decision], speaks to the context of a JR, how much scope does the authority have to second guess the authority of those running the ponds. There are five factors here:

1st decision, decision was made by D in exercise of its statutory authority to run leisure facilities, 2nd expertise of stewards and management used in decision, 3rd decision took place after consultation, user association and focus group, that is enough

and overwhelming support for current arrangements. 4th the feelings aroused by the issue are strong,
J strong feelings on both sides
DS yes, lots of people for strong feelings on both sides, all the more reason for the D to rely on the expertise of its officials and 5th

there was no individual claimant, that's a further reason to take a deferential approach.
We rely upon proportionality as set out in our skeleton,
J you want me to have that in front of me
DS struggling to find it, but the factors are there, in summary the privacy of the

changing arrangements are mitigations of the additional arrangements. Been in place for a long time and have worked well, the fact that bio sex option would cause TP to use other facilities where they do not feel comfortable or safe, not using facilities of lived gender

TP are a small minority, but the disadvantage they would suffer would be high. Strong support in user groups, strong support in consultation from women many of whom see the policy as an advantage and also the ease of enforceability. ML asked me about Option 5 and why a

balance would have been struck.
J yes, why not
DS it was seen as an option that combined the worst aspects and indeed, C did not suggest. 90% of those surveyed opposed this. Why did they oppose? Active discrimination and segregation. Regarded by those consulted as more

intrusive then any other option (the timed options)
J I can see the statistics but the reasoning doesn't make sense
DS well you might say they got it wrong,
J it doesn't make sense
DS it would be very different from say a women's swimming evening where men aren't allowed, one

is protecting a vulnerable minority, giving them their own time, not stigmatising men, what's proposed here by having non-trans people
J well that's just women
DS its a period of time when the vulnerable minority is excluded
J along with all other men
DS TP are a uniquely

vulnerable group
J they are vulnerable in a particular way, as women are vulnerable in a different way
DS it's not the same thing at all to exclude TP, as it is to exclude men
J It doesn't make sense to me to be in favour of segregated swimming and then say not having

segregated evening.
DS TP just want to live their lives and forcing them to use the facility at specific times, forces them to confront their exclusion from the facility
J I've got your point but why does exclusion at some points seem worse than complete exclusion.
DS just

trying to find passage I was relying on.
J could we move on,
DS the point I was on is this, strong belief that scheduled ss times, singled out tp, and created windows of exclusion and stigmatised tp. By highlighting them
J I see it's not complicated but still doesn't explain

why segregation every day of the week isn't worse.
DS let's say you have a cafe that excludes Jewish people but allows them to come for an hour a day, how much more humiliating is that policy, it simple serves to reinforce the exclusion and draw attention to them, would attract

anti-semitic people. That's the point. There's nothing illogical about that, reflects the humiliation of being there temporarily rather than not at all.
DS moving on, MLF says proportionality is a numbers game, more women who want SS spaces than TW who want inclusion.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:04

From TT

Struggle because of all the issues highlighted in the evidence. In particular I would ref in the supplemental bundle, particularly make these points, also came up in the focus groups. Come up in the evidence of SR of TL. Let's very quickly look at those paras, TL bundle, p48

[bundle shuffling]
J got it now
DS SR referring to hate crimes against tp, death threats, other threats, general observation about hostility to TP, TW like other women are anxious in front of men, need to TP to get more exercise tend to be less active than others,

excluding trans people from ponds creates stigma against TP. Profoundly important to be treated as who we are. This also came out in the consultation. Let's turn to proportionality, you asked some questions about the approach to proportionality,
J I would welcome your thoughts

on what weight I give to these issues as considered by Ds, and what weight should I give to the consultation.
DS I will address those issues. First to MLs on Michaela Schools, where you addressed
J I hadn't realised I had addressed those questions
DS page 30 in authorities,

we refer to passages from 159, under the heading weight to be given by decision maker, we say that those who manage the ponds and are responsible for them, should be given weight.
Ultimately is the measure proportionate, and attention must be give to the breadth of the decision

maker. You do say that some criticisms can be made about the quality of the decision. In our case, the time, care and expense that has been taken for the decision about the admission requirements are impressive, and weight should be given to the very great care and trouble

LadyinPainting · 04/11/2026 15:00

'The disadvantages of TP have been well recognised according the Strasbourg, the nature of the disadvantage is important. TP have to struggle to be recognised in their identity, stigma, crime, mental health, exclusion struggle to be recognised as who they are.'

But they can be who they are in a mixed pond, surely? Where I swim doesn't change who I am.

PrettyDamnCosmic · 04/11/2026 14:59

moto748e · 04/11/2026 14:25

DS seems to be doing a lot of arguing with the judge?

It's interesting. I haven't followed a Judicial Review before but it seems very collegiate. The barristers are having a dialogue with the judge teasing out points of law to allow him to reach his decision. It's refreshing even if Daniel is coming out with total bobbins.😀

PrettyDamnCosmic · 04/11/2026 14:54

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:15

From TT

DS cont LP has total area of 5300 sqm, MP has a smaller swimming area of 8000 sqm. (What I heard but seems wrong)
J is your argument that women don't know what the circumstances are
DS this is evidence only rec'd in reply and it appears to be problematic.

Google AI tells me swimming area of the Ladies' Pond is 6,845 m² while the Men's Pond is 18,290 m². I think Daniel needs to look at a map as the Men's Pond is clearly much bigger than the Ladies' Pond.

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 14:45

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 14:41

TP have to struggle to be recognised in their identity, stigma, crime, mental health, exclusion struggle to be recognised as who they are.

And that is why that diving board in the men's pond is finally within my sights!!!!!

Or do you have to be more selective to make a positive discrimination argument?

Sorry - 'positive action', not positive discrimination.

I understand that positive action has to be time limited?

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 14:41

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:26

From TT

who doesn't have the pc of GRA, what is the comparator
DS I'm not sure its for us to formulate the comparator, its for the C
J but they have, you say they haven't put forward right comparators under law
DS if they put forward a cis man as a comparator

TP have to struggle to be recognised in their identity, stigma, crime, mental health, exclusion struggle to be recognised as who they are.

And that is why that diving board in the men's pond is finally within my sights!!!!!

Or do you have to be more selective to make a positive discrimination argument?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:39

From TT

If a charity sets up a scholarship to remedy lack of young black men in a profession, then it discriminates on the basis of sex, age and race. None of that is prohibited, if the scholarship is set up for young black men.
J you say that the action here is the whole of the

arrangements set up for admissions to the ponds. It speaks to proportionality.
DS I accept that the nature and seriousness of the discrim nature of the arrangements may come in at the proportionality arrangements,
J any action is the whole of the arrangements governing

admission. The disadvantages of TP have been well recognised according the Strasbourg, the nature of the disadvantage is important. TP have to struggle to be recognised in their identity, stigma, crime, mental health, exclusion struggle to be recognised as who they are.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:37

From TT

provided proportionate action. I understood the discussion with MLF and ML yesterday, is there a connection between disadvantage and remedy.
J I was going to ask you about this as well, if the remedy is allowing TP to swim in pond associated with lived gender.

DS the positive action here is the admission requirements, which may have a number of discrim results. If the gateway is met and the positive action is proportionate, none of the discriminatory results are unlawful. 158 does result in discrimination against other groups.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:37

From TT

disadvantage connected to the pc.
J it's an established class in law,
DS in the law, in the results of the consultation, no one would deny that they have different needs and suffer a disadvantage, positive action not prohibited from taking any action to remedy

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:36

From TT

J we're looking for a comparator who is a woman seeking to access the MP
DS the material difference is the C lives as a woman where as the comparator lives as a man and then if it's suggested that the comparator is a TW so, a cis woman who compares self to TW who is bio man,

that's the comparator being adopted, not an appropriate comparator, there is a material difference between those the comparator has the pc of GRA and the C does not. So that's what we say on comparators.
J right
DS now section 158.

DS we submit that the Ds are entitled to rely on the provisions of 158 if there is direct discrim. First with the gateway, it merely requires that the person reasonably thinks and it's not an unreasonable belief that people with the pc of GRA have different needs or suffer a

rebax · 04/11/2026 14:28

moto748e · 04/11/2026 14:25

DS seems to be doing a lot of arguing with the judge?

More typical of these cases than Employment Tribunals - judge is testing the strength of the argument being made.

CriticalCondition · 04/11/2026 14:27

moto748e · 04/11/2026 14:25

DS seems to be doing a lot of arguing with the judge?

The judge is doing a lot of arguing with DS!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:26

From TT

who doesn't have the pc of GRA, what is the comparator
DS I'm not sure its for us to formulate the comparator, its for the C
J but they have, you say they haven't put forward right comparators under law
DS if they put forward a cis man as a comparator

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:25

From TT

DS even taking it to that theoretical level, the TW has the pc of GRA and the woman doesn't. That's another material difference.
J right
DS that's what we say about comparators, now onto positive action under 158.
J I'm not clear what you do say about comparators, a bio woman

moto748e · 04/11/2026 14:25

DS seems to be doing a lot of arguing with the judge?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:24

“Desperate” - you’re not wrong

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:24

From TT

DS not on a strict reading of the rule
J in practice
DS in practice a TW would not want to use the MP,
J any particular reason you say that
DS it's all about lived gender and the evidence is that those who are trans are desperate to use to pond of their lived gender

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:23

From TT

both live as their sex.
J can I just check that, I thought there was a 4th category, a bio male who had a pc of GRA, they live as a woman but could go to the MP, is that correct
DS we wouldn't accept that's an appropriate comparator
J but is it correct

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:22

From TT

DS like detriment, doesn't it have to have some substance
J if so, then I don't think it helps your case
DS other than saying there are some differences, or just preferences, there need to be genuine reasons
J and your submission is that these are not genuine or not

correct
DS there are real question marks, we haven't had a chance to test this evidence
J you're saying that the MP isn't materially bigger than the LP,
DS parts of it are roped off, and its about the size of swimming laps
J so you say no LFT

DS yes. On to comparator, no material diff in circumstances relating to each case. We say that the position of a woman and the man she compares herself to
J which pond
DS the position of the woman is materially different
J without the pc of a GRA
DS neither has in this case

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 14:21

I just want to know whether I can use the diving board and the hot showers if I identify as gender fluid.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:19

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 14:16

😮😲🤯😱😳

I missed that! Can’t believe they said that out loud in court 😆

I know right! On tenterhooks to know if there will be enough time for Translucent…

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread