Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Antipodean fruit growers 3 - Is the Kiwi a Dodo or a Phoenix?

841 replies

Bosky · 26/05/2023 03:34

Continuation thread from Antipodean fruit growers 2 - Canary in the internet coal mine
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4632616-antipodean-fruit-growers-2-canary-in-the-internet-coal-mine

Front row seat on the seemingly eternal battle between Jersh (aka Suzi Quatro's Fat Nan) and his Merry Band of Farmers against the Transpowered Forces of Internet Censorship.

1st Thread - Antipodean fruit grower statement
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4620584-antipodean-fruit-grower-statement

OP posts:
Thread gallery
62
anyolddinosaur · 16/03/2026 10:56

@Fruityful No - when you go to donate it asks for the amount in US dollars. Some people have cards that dont charge a fee for dollar transactions but some do. Also means you need to think about exchange rates when deciding what to give. I've donated to fundraisers in other currencies before and one resulted in questions from the fraud team! It wasnt a massive donation but I guess they suspected that the next such payment would be bigger.

Bosky · 16/03/2026 16:43

anyolddinosaur · 16/03/2026 10:56

@Fruityful No - when you go to donate it asks for the amount in US dollars. Some people have cards that dont charge a fee for dollar transactions but some do. Also means you need to think about exchange rates when deciding what to give. I've donated to fundraisers in other currencies before and one resulted in questions from the fraud team! It wasnt a massive donation but I guess they suspected that the next such payment would be bigger.

Correct. When setting up a campaign the currency is based on the country in which the campaign is located.

Donating to a Campaign in a Different Currency

GiveSendGo hosts campaigns from around the world, and generosity knows no borders. You can donate to any campaign regardless of where you're located.

How Currency Works on GiveSendGo

The donation form displays amounts in the campaign's local currency, the currency of the country where the recipient is based. For example, if you're donating from the UK to a campaign based in Kenya, the amount will appear in Kenyan Shillings (KES).

GiveSendGo does not display a conversion to your local currency during checkout. You'll be charged the equivalent of the amount you enter in your own currency, based on the exchange rate applied by your card or bank at the time of the transaction.

Check the Conversion Rate Before You Donate

To confirm how much you'll be paying in your own currency before completing your donation, use a free online currency converter, such as:
Google Currency Converter
XE

Enter the campaign's displayed amount and select your local currency to see the equivalent.

Conversion Fees

GiveSendGo does not charge currency conversion fees. However, your bank or card provider may apply a foreign transaction fee when processing a payment in a different currency. Check with them directly if you have questions about applicable fees or exchange rates.

When you complete your donation, your card or bank will handle the currency conversion. The amount on your statement will reflect your local currency equivalent at the rate applied at the time of processing.

Thank you for giving across borders. Every donation is a tangible expression of hope reaching someone who needs it. For a full walkthrough of the donation process, see Making a Donation on GiveSendGo.

help.givesendgo.com/portal/en/kb/articles/donating-to-a-campaign-in-a-different-currency

OP posts:
Fruityful · 17/03/2026 09:14

Kallikrates · 16/03/2026 10:26

They won't tolerate child or animal abuse either.

They have helped to identify some awful animal abusers, including people who have tortured monkeys and dogs. This has led to convictions.

Good point. My mind didn't go to such dark places and I was thinking mostly in terms of political views which is wider than you'll find in most places online these days which are almost always echo chambers of one kind of another. But yes, child abuse, animal abuse, I don't know if you'd actually be banned for talking about them, but you wouldn't have a happy time there.

On that note, one of the most reprehensible tactics some have used to try and shut down the Farms is the posting of child porn some people have tried to do. Null has actually developed his own software to pre-emptively identify this stuff and report it and made that and some of the other software he has developed available to other site owners. He's also come up with a quite innovative way to do site registrations that preserves anonymity whilst preventing mass sign-ups for purposes of abuse. He had a very interesting thread on it a while back.

Kallikrates · 17/03/2026 10:04

He would have been bored with the site (and probably stepped away from it) years ago without all the attacks to shut it down. Thankfully, he's a stubborn bugger. It's interesting what he has developed simply because he won't back down to bullies.

BezMills · 17/03/2026 11:13

Kallikrates · 17/03/2026 10:04

He would have been bored with the site (and probably stepped away from it) years ago without all the attacks to shut it down. Thankfully, he's a stubborn bugger. It's interesting what he has developed simply because he won't back down to bullies.

Definite parallels here. All kinds of dirty tricks being played to try and shut down discussion on FWR, up to and including posting CSA images in an attempt to discredit/shut down MN.

Kallikrates · 17/03/2026 11:58

Yes. I luckily missed all that (thankfully, I wasn't online when it happened on MN), but it is the same technique to shut down discussion that they don't like. Of course, images now need to be 'approved' before showing to combat these horrific men and their vile posts.

And they want us to believe that they are 'the right side of history'!

Bosky · 22/03/2026 02:53

VICTORY FOR AFROMAN AND FREE SPEECH IN THE USA 🇺🇸

Afroman Testifies In Defamation Lawsuit Trial From Sheriff's Deputies Who Raided Home

Deputy Nicknamed 'Lemon Pound Cake' By Afroman Testifies In Defamation Trial
Shawn Cooley is a retired deputy with the Adams County Sheriff's Office in Ohio who is suing rapper Afroman for defamation.

Sheriff Deputy's Ex-Wife Testifies In Defense Of Afroman In Defamation Trial
The ex-wife of retired Adams County, Ohio, sheriff's deputy Shawn Grooms testified as a defense witness for rapper Afroman in his defamation trial today (Wednesday, March 18). The recording picks up with Afroman's lawyer David Osborne asking Rhonda Grooms about Megan Thee Stallion's and Cardi B's song "Wet Ass Pussy."

Jury Sides With Afroman In Sheriff Deputies' Defamation Lawsuit — FULL DEFENSE VERDICT
Victory for Afroman over the sheriff's deputies in Adams County, Ohio, who sued him for defamation and invasion of privacy through false light.

Hear from Afroman after the verdict in his civil trial
We spoke to Afroman just minutes after a judge delivered the news that jurors sided with the rapper in his civil trial in Adams County.

Afroman: THIS was my way of walking away from the situation…
Rapper Afroman discusses his court victory after being sued for defamation over songs he wrote following a police raid on his home on ‘Jesse Watters Primetime.

Prosecutor Reacts to Afroman Trial
The Cops raided his home, then sued him for defamation

Jury sides with Afroman in police defamation lawsuit: Inside the trial that gripped America
A flash-in-the-pan trial in a rural Ohio county pitted the "Because I Got High" rapper against seven sheriff's officials who sued him for defamation after they raided his home.
www.legalaffairsandtrials.com/p/jury-sides-with-afroman-in-police

OP posts:
Kallikrates · 22/03/2026 15:15

Congratulations to Afroman.

Bosky · 26/10/2026 14:22

Ofcom Concedes Defeat in the 4chan Case

October 20, 2026

(Preston Byrne is the lawyer who is also representing Kiwi Farms against Ofcom)

Insofar as a political organization like Ofcom is even capable of admitting defeat, it did so in the 4chan enforcement today.

In testimony before the Commons Digital, Culture, Media, and Sport Committee, Ofcom admitted it knows its jurisdiction ends where a foreign court’s jurisdiction begins.

“We won’t be able to recover every single fine on online safety. If foreign courts decide to try and get in our way, there will be a point at which we have to accept that we won’t be able to recover that money.”

“Our reading of the Act is that we do not have any capacity to require a website, for example, to block themselves in the United States… I am not quite sure how you can carry that out. The Americans are pretty clear about that as well, it should be said. That means that, in essence, the furthest a UK court could go even if we had applied for a business disruption measure is to secure a geo-block, and to do so with the telecoms companies, with search and so on to make sure it is comprehensive, but it is as far as you can go.”
– Dame Melanie Dawes, Chief Executive, Ofcom

Noting that Ofcom has, previously, asserted that the First Amendment offers Americans no protection of any type from any part of the Online Safety Act, Guido Fawkes characterizes this admission thus: “Ofcom Admits Defeat.”
Guido is right. Speaking of foreign courts, American courts have, by now, provided their preliminary view on the likelihood of Ofcom’s enforcement powers being successful in U.S. proceedings – specifically in the obiter dicta in 4chan v. Ofcom, the opinion in the case 4chan filed against Ofcom in the federal District Court for the District of Columbia a little over a year ago.

Those dicta made it awfully clear that Ofcom can expect a very chilly reception in an American courtroom if it ever tries to enforce its fines in the United States. By way of reminder, the Court in 4chan said:

Because Plaintiffs represent that they have “no presence, infrastructure, or operations abroad”[,]… that likely means enforcing any judgment in the United States. At that point, Plaintiffs could avail themselves of the protection of American courts.

Unless Ofcom is prepared to sail a British invasion fleet here and land ground troops, enforcement would indeed have to proceed through American courts. Which presents the following problem for Ofcom:

American courts generally decline to enforce foreign judgments that violate the United States Constitution, if indeed Plaintiffs are correct in their constitutional claims. See, e.g., Matusevitch v. Telnikoff, 877 F. Supp. 1, 4 (D.D.C. 1995) (refusing to enforce a British judgment because it contravened the First Amendment and was therefore “repugnant to the public policies of the State of Maryland and the United States”)[.]

Suffice it to say, 4chan’s constitutional arguments are correct.

The Court then added, gratuitously and sua sponte as this was not an issue which was actually briefed by either party in the case, but is relevant on account of Ofcom’s hard-won sovereign status:

Finally, at the risk of gilding the lily, to the extent any foreign judgment against Plaintiffs were penal in nature, Plaintiffs may find a receptive audience before American courts regardless of the judgment’s compatibility with the United States Constitution. That is because American courts are not necessarily required to enforce foreign penal judgments[.]

Put another way, even though the Court ruled against 4chan on the sovereign immunity motion, the Court nonetheless went out of its way to communicate a message to Ofcom in this decision.

That message was: your writ doesn’t run here.

U.S. courts don’t enforce penalties on behalf of foreign sovereigns, especially when those penalties violate the Constitution.

Losing the sovereign immunity motion was a price well worth paying for those dicta on enforceability and their associated deterrent value, especially considering that the only remedy 4chan sought from the D.D.C. – the one the Court couldn’t give due to sovereign immunity – was a declaration of the rights of the parties. What we got instead was the Court’s opinion as to the state of the law, inviting the parties to read between the lines; this is the substance of what 4chan had asked for, albeit delivered in a different form.

Thus ended this dispute, for all practical purposes. Ofcom can’t enforce the Online Safety Act in America. Ofcom knows it, Ofcom has known it for a long time, and now, Ofcom has, finally, admitted it.

It would be a gift – to 4chan – if Ofcom decided to show up in an American court after all this, waiving sovereign immunity and thus facing the prospect of an adverse merits ruling in the process. Filing that lawsuit would be suicidal, leading to virtually certain defeat and total loss of enforcement credibility in the United States. It will almost certainly never happen, not for 4chan, and likely not for any other American target, either.

Defeat, for all practical purposes, in one matter, however, will not stop Ofcom and British parliamentarians in their continuing mission to censor the British people, and the world. Ofcom has targeted 200-ish American platforms with censorship orders; only four of those sites, all of which are my clients, refused, and only one is 4chan. The First Amendment remains very much under direct, sustained assault from foreign censorship agencies, who rely on their orders to cow U.S. companies who don’t have the stomach for a prolonged and public regulatory fight.

We have a long way to go until our fight with the foreign censors is done. We need permanent U.S. law reform to turn the tide.

The GRANITE Act, a foreign censorship shield now before both the House and Senate (H.R. 10174 / S. 5478), is one proposed legal response America could adopt. The HOMEFRONT Act, H.R. 10309, is another. Either of GRANITE or HOMEFRONT would strip sovereign immunity from foreign censors and let Americans targeted by their orders drag those agencies into federal court, where they could be held accountable for their actions. As we learn from Ofcom’s admissions today, foreign censors won’t start litigation fights they know they will lose.

What will happen next is that Ofcom is going to go back to Parliament to ask for the authority to obtain “interim business disruption measures” – i.e., more or less unilateral censorship powers to block foreign websites in the UK before starting an enforcement process, rather than after. These powers were explicitly rejected by Parliament the last time around and have even now been repudiated by Nadine Dorries, the former MP who introduced the Bill, having seen what a mess Ofcom has made of it. These powers will also be easily defeated through the use of a VPN.

They may also seek to block 4chan. My client has already priced that in and it is a price worth paying, as this will constitute the UK censoring its own people and ISPs, rather than censoring my client. The UK has the sovereign right to do that. My client has the constitutional right to decline to assist the UK in that terrible work.

The UK thus continues its authoritarian backsliding. Sorting out their own country is, ultimately, a matter for the British, and opposing the grant of new powers for Ofcom – an agency which was held off by a pair of American solos, myself and Ron Coleman, working for free – on domestic policy grounds is a task for the growing UK free speech movement to take up, with urgency.
I wish them luck in that important work. In the meantime, we Americans have plenty more work to do on this side of the pond to protect our border and prevent the British, Australian, Russian, and other foreign censorship regimes from crossing it.

https://prestonbyrne.com/2026/10/20/ofcom-concedes-defeat/

Linked from X: https://x.com/prestonjbyrne/status/2112543648873111821

In Slow News, Josh is President of the United States Internet Preservation
Society 🇺🇸 🛜 🧑‍💻

usips.org/us/board/

X: https://x.com/USIPSorg

The blog includes articles on access to banking:
https://usips.org/blog/

Which reminded me that Josh wrote about problems with Payment Networks in 2021.

Section 230 isn't the problem, Payment Networks are
madattheinternet.substack.com/p/section-230-isnt-the-problem-payment

Ofcom Bypassed US Treaty to Send 197 Censorship Orders

A British regulator bypassed every formal legal treaty and just emailed American companies into compliance, and 98% of them apparently obliged.

https://reclaimthenet.org/ofcom-bypassed-us-treaty-to-send-197-censorship-orders

OP posts:
UtopiaPlanitia · 26/10/2026 15:58

UK legislators keep passing badly-drafted legislation 🙄

Ereshkigalangcleg · 26/10/2026 16:49

Bosky · 26/10/2026 14:22

Ofcom Concedes Defeat in the 4chan Case

October 20, 2026

(Preston Byrne is the lawyer who is also representing Kiwi Farms against Ofcom)

Insofar as a political organization like Ofcom is even capable of admitting defeat, it did so in the 4chan enforcement today.

In testimony before the Commons Digital, Culture, Media, and Sport Committee, Ofcom admitted it knows its jurisdiction ends where a foreign court’s jurisdiction begins.

“We won’t be able to recover every single fine on online safety. If foreign courts decide to try and get in our way, there will be a point at which we have to accept that we won’t be able to recover that money.”

“Our reading of the Act is that we do not have any capacity to require a website, for example, to block themselves in the United States… I am not quite sure how you can carry that out. The Americans are pretty clear about that as well, it should be said. That means that, in essence, the furthest a UK court could go even if we had applied for a business disruption measure is to secure a geo-block, and to do so with the telecoms companies, with search and so on to make sure it is comprehensive, but it is as far as you can go.”
– Dame Melanie Dawes, Chief Executive, Ofcom

Noting that Ofcom has, previously, asserted that the First Amendment offers Americans no protection of any type from any part of the Online Safety Act, Guido Fawkes characterizes this admission thus: “Ofcom Admits Defeat.”
Guido is right. Speaking of foreign courts, American courts have, by now, provided their preliminary view on the likelihood of Ofcom’s enforcement powers being successful in U.S. proceedings – specifically in the obiter dicta in 4chan v. Ofcom, the opinion in the case 4chan filed against Ofcom in the federal District Court for the District of Columbia a little over a year ago.

Those dicta made it awfully clear that Ofcom can expect a very chilly reception in an American courtroom if it ever tries to enforce its fines in the United States. By way of reminder, the Court in 4chan said:

Because Plaintiffs represent that they have “no presence, infrastructure, or operations abroad”[,]… that likely means enforcing any judgment in the United States. At that point, Plaintiffs could avail themselves of the protection of American courts.

Unless Ofcom is prepared to sail a British invasion fleet here and land ground troops, enforcement would indeed have to proceed through American courts. Which presents the following problem for Ofcom:

American courts generally decline to enforce foreign judgments that violate the United States Constitution, if indeed Plaintiffs are correct in their constitutional claims. See, e.g., Matusevitch v. Telnikoff, 877 F. Supp. 1, 4 (D.D.C. 1995) (refusing to enforce a British judgment because it contravened the First Amendment and was therefore “repugnant to the public policies of the State of Maryland and the United States”)[.]

Suffice it to say, 4chan’s constitutional arguments are correct.

The Court then added, gratuitously and sua sponte as this was not an issue which was actually briefed by either party in the case, but is relevant on account of Ofcom’s hard-won sovereign status:

Finally, at the risk of gilding the lily, to the extent any foreign judgment against Plaintiffs were penal in nature, Plaintiffs may find a receptive audience before American courts regardless of the judgment’s compatibility with the United States Constitution. That is because American courts are not necessarily required to enforce foreign penal judgments[.]

Put another way, even though the Court ruled against 4chan on the sovereign immunity motion, the Court nonetheless went out of its way to communicate a message to Ofcom in this decision.

That message was: your writ doesn’t run here.

U.S. courts don’t enforce penalties on behalf of foreign sovereigns, especially when those penalties violate the Constitution.

Losing the sovereign immunity motion was a price well worth paying for those dicta on enforceability and their associated deterrent value, especially considering that the only remedy 4chan sought from the D.D.C. – the one the Court couldn’t give due to sovereign immunity – was a declaration of the rights of the parties. What we got instead was the Court’s opinion as to the state of the law, inviting the parties to read between the lines; this is the substance of what 4chan had asked for, albeit delivered in a different form.

Thus ended this dispute, for all practical purposes. Ofcom can’t enforce the Online Safety Act in America. Ofcom knows it, Ofcom has known it for a long time, and now, Ofcom has, finally, admitted it.

It would be a gift – to 4chan – if Ofcom decided to show up in an American court after all this, waiving sovereign immunity and thus facing the prospect of an adverse merits ruling in the process. Filing that lawsuit would be suicidal, leading to virtually certain defeat and total loss of enforcement credibility in the United States. It will almost certainly never happen, not for 4chan, and likely not for any other American target, either.

Defeat, for all practical purposes, in one matter, however, will not stop Ofcom and British parliamentarians in their continuing mission to censor the British people, and the world. Ofcom has targeted 200-ish American platforms with censorship orders; only four of those sites, all of which are my clients, refused, and only one is 4chan. The First Amendment remains very much under direct, sustained assault from foreign censorship agencies, who rely on their orders to cow U.S. companies who don’t have the stomach for a prolonged and public regulatory fight.

We have a long way to go until our fight with the foreign censors is done. We need permanent U.S. law reform to turn the tide.

The GRANITE Act, a foreign censorship shield now before both the House and Senate (H.R. 10174 / S. 5478), is one proposed legal response America could adopt. The HOMEFRONT Act, H.R. 10309, is another. Either of GRANITE or HOMEFRONT would strip sovereign immunity from foreign censors and let Americans targeted by their orders drag those agencies into federal court, where they could be held accountable for their actions. As we learn from Ofcom’s admissions today, foreign censors won’t start litigation fights they know they will lose.

What will happen next is that Ofcom is going to go back to Parliament to ask for the authority to obtain “interim business disruption measures” – i.e., more or less unilateral censorship powers to block foreign websites in the UK before starting an enforcement process, rather than after. These powers were explicitly rejected by Parliament the last time around and have even now been repudiated by Nadine Dorries, the former MP who introduced the Bill, having seen what a mess Ofcom has made of it. These powers will also be easily defeated through the use of a VPN.

They may also seek to block 4chan. My client has already priced that in and it is a price worth paying, as this will constitute the UK censoring its own people and ISPs, rather than censoring my client. The UK has the sovereign right to do that. My client has the constitutional right to decline to assist the UK in that terrible work.

The UK thus continues its authoritarian backsliding. Sorting out their own country is, ultimately, a matter for the British, and opposing the grant of new powers for Ofcom – an agency which was held off by a pair of American solos, myself and Ron Coleman, working for free – on domestic policy grounds is a task for the growing UK free speech movement to take up, with urgency.
I wish them luck in that important work. In the meantime, we Americans have plenty more work to do on this side of the pond to protect our border and prevent the British, Australian, Russian, and other foreign censorship regimes from crossing it.

https://prestonbyrne.com/2026/10/20/ofcom-concedes-defeat/

Linked from X: https://x.com/prestonjbyrne/status/2112543648873111821

In Slow News, Josh is President of the United States Internet Preservation
Society 🇺🇸 🛜 🧑‍💻

usips.org/us/board/

X: https://x.com/USIPSorg

The blog includes articles on access to banking:
https://usips.org/blog/

Which reminded me that Josh wrote about problems with Payment Networks in 2021.

Section 230 isn't the problem, Payment Networks are
madattheinternet.substack.com/p/section-230-isnt-the-problem-payment

Thank you for this update. Lolsuit of the century on Ofcom’s part.

ChequerToRed · 26/10/2026 17:24

Ereshkigalangcleg · 26/10/2026 16:49

Thank you for this update. Lolsuit of the century on Ofcom’s part.

Indeed, what the hell were they thinking, and how much has this ridiculous case cost?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 26/10/2026 17:31

ChequerToRed · 26/10/2026 17:24

Indeed, what the hell were they thinking, and how much has this ridiculous case cost?

As you’ll no doubt find totally astounding, they’ve refused multiple FOI requests asking how much public money they’ve pissed up the wall on these cases.

Bosky · 26/10/2026 18:24

Ereshkigalangcleg · 26/10/2026 17:31

As you’ll no doubt find totally astounding, they’ve refused multiple FOI requests asking how much public money they’ve pissed up the wall on these cases.

There is a new FOIR registered on What Do They Know on 24 Oct - no reply as yet:

Freedom of Information Request – Total Costs of Ofcom Enforcement Action Against 4chan
https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/freedom_of_information_request_t_1472

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 27/10/2026 00:00

Thanks for the update @Bosky !

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/10/2026 10:09

Bosky · 26/10/2026 18:24

There is a new FOIR registered on What Do They Know on 24 Oct - no reply as yet:

Freedom of Information Request – Total Costs of Ofcom Enforcement Action Against 4chan
https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/freedom_of_information_request_t_1472

Thank you, I hope he escalates it if they refuse.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread