Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smoking in our own property.

514 replies

Teenagerantruns · 12/11/2026 22:09

Ok l know im probably going to be slaughtered for this but here goes.
We moved a week ago into a new flat, purpose built block. We both smoke, yes l know its disgusting but whatever.
So today upstairs neighbours came down and said smoke was bothering them, im not sure how as they are not directly above us, but above on other side. I guess none of our frount doors are that good , so smoke is going out of ours upstairs and to the left to thiers? Seems unlikely but obviously they can smell it, they accused us of smoking in communal area hall which obviously l would never do. Other upstairs neighbours directly above say that they can't smell anything.
Im not really sure what to do now, l did say sorry and normally we would smoke outside just been hectic week moving and so wet but if we smoked inside we would do it furthest room away from frount door and close all the doors in between so 3 doors.
Apprently that's not good enough , they also dont want us smoking in the communal garden?
Aibu to think actually we can do what we like in our flat, and to just ignore them.

OP posts:
Stancherd · 13/11/2026 12:55

NineteenSeventyThree · 13/11/2026 10:36

Well, it depends what you mean by 'dying early'. It also depends on what health you experience in old age as a non-smoker. My non-smoking parents are living out their 80s with dementia. I know not everyone has that misfortune and some people are fit and active into their 90s and beyond, but personally I would rather die of a smoking related illness in my 70s than spend my 80s living with dementia, which is what I can expect genetically if I don't manage to succumb to something else sooner.

Put another way, I personally am taking no steps whatsoever to prolong my own life. A long life is wholly overrated unless you can be more or less certain (via your genetic inheritance) that your old age will be healthy.

I would rather die of a smoking related illness in my 70s

This kind of comment is trite and ignorant. Have you seen anyone die of lung cancer or COPD? Attached to oxygen all day. Slowly choking to death and bed bound. Never mind all the other related cancers. These illnesses can cause slow and painful deaths and suffering. What nonsense you spout.

Switcher · 13/11/2026 12:57

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 13/11/2026 11:48

This thread is wild. I don't smoke, so no skin in the game, but it is legal and you are smoking in your home that you own - if the neighbours don't like it then that's a shame, but you're totally within your rights. I suspect if you smoked outside in a shared garden that would be worse, as it's a communal space and they would have rights to complain about that.

MN hates smokers as much as it hates dogs. People saying to quit, OP presumably knows it's not one of her five a day or supporting heart health, and is making a choice as an adult with free will.

I sometimes get the impression that 80% of the population would be quite happy with an autocracy. They want to micromanage every aspect of individual lives, justified of course by health, or safety, or being nice. With no real imagination on what handing unfettered power to government means - if you want them to fix everything, they own you.

blackpooolrock · 13/11/2026 12:58

RaspberryCoffeePot · 13/11/2026 12:37

Yrs but it isnt in her own house and garden only, is it, it"'s in their house which is another matter.

They are smoking in their house - other neighbours say they cannot smell it? Anyway OP can't help where their fumes go so doesn't really matter what the neighbours say to them. They are controlling. If this was OP's DH telling her not to smoke people would be up in arms because it's controlling - but all of a sudden it's ok for neighbours to tell her not to do it? erm... just no.

Applepiewithcream · 13/11/2026 13:00

@JustaSongAboutPingPong I was in the supermarket this morning and there were a couple of women together and at least one of them was a smoker. The stench was just awful. I had to get my husband onside for us to either speed up or walk slower as they were directly in front of us and I couldn’t escape the overpowering smell.

RaspberryCoffeePot · 13/11/2026 13:04

blackpooolrock · 13/11/2026 12:58

They are smoking in their house - other neighbours say they cannot smell it? Anyway OP can't help where their fumes go so doesn't really matter what the neighbours say to them. They are controlling. If this was OP's DH telling her not to smoke people would be up in arms because it's controlling - but all of a sudden it's ok for neighbours to tell her not to do it? erm... just no.

Oh dont be so bloody stupid..They are violating someone else's private space. Simple as. They might as well go round the person's flat and walk in over their threshold and hit them.round the face, because it's the same kind of trespass, same kind of physical violation, only with smoke. They could literally make the other people ill.

Verv · 13/11/2026 13:08

I am a smoker. Started really young and quit regularly, but nonetheless, I can speak from experience here.

It stinks. It's pervasive. And because we are so inured to it, we genuinely have no clue just how bad it smells, except I do. Because I've quit so many times, and have been around smoke as someone who's not indulging, and dear god - it reeks.

As a result of this, I smoke either at the end of my garden or on the balcony projection of a top floor flat with nobody above or around me, which is far away from the rest of humanity, because I dont want to inflict my habit and its surrounding stink on other people or animals - i think its unfair.

Yes, you have every "right" to smoke inside your flat. But rights and responsibility aren't the same, and while you have the right, you also have a responsibility as a functioning member of society not to inflict your toxic and genuinely grim habit on those who have to live in spaces that are affected by it.
It's not decent. And while smoking is absolutely legal, as is smoking in outdoor spaces, and in your own property - the respectful thing to do is to go indulge your addiction far enough away from other people that they are not affected by your choice to smoke.

It drifts,, it carries on the air, and it gets into every nook and cranny, its an absolute b*tch to get rid of once its absorbed in soft furnishings - and your neighbours are right when they tell its negatively affecting them.

We pay a stupid amount of money to smoke, we risk our health, we go to shops in order to purchase cigarettes and we do it in pursuit of an addiction thats incredibly difficult to quit, its an effort, so making an additional effort to ensure that you're not making those around you miserable is a drop in the ocean.

Balloonhearts · 13/11/2026 13:11

So because its your home, she has to smell it in her home too? If it didnt stink, she would be none the wiser that you smoke.

You don't think you're being unreasonable by making the place smell and causing her and any children to inhale carcinogenic second hand smoke?

Tortephant · 13/11/2026 13:24

Verv · 13/11/2026 13:08

I am a smoker. Started really young and quit regularly, but nonetheless, I can speak from experience here.

It stinks. It's pervasive. And because we are so inured to it, we genuinely have no clue just how bad it smells, except I do. Because I've quit so many times, and have been around smoke as someone who's not indulging, and dear god - it reeks.

As a result of this, I smoke either at the end of my garden or on the balcony projection of a top floor flat with nobody above or around me, which is far away from the rest of humanity, because I dont want to inflict my habit and its surrounding stink on other people or animals - i think its unfair.

Yes, you have every "right" to smoke inside your flat. But rights and responsibility aren't the same, and while you have the right, you also have a responsibility as a functioning member of society not to inflict your toxic and genuinely grim habit on those who have to live in spaces that are affected by it.
It's not decent. And while smoking is absolutely legal, as is smoking in outdoor spaces, and in your own property - the respectful thing to do is to go indulge your addiction far enough away from other people that they are not affected by your choice to smoke.

It drifts,, it carries on the air, and it gets into every nook and cranny, its an absolute b*tch to get rid of once its absorbed in soft furnishings - and your neighbours are right when they tell its negatively affecting them.

We pay a stupid amount of money to smoke, we risk our health, we go to shops in order to purchase cigarettes and we do it in pursuit of an addiction thats incredibly difficult to quit, its an effort, so making an additional effort to ensure that you're not making those around you miserable is a drop in the ocean.

<THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST RESPONSE ON THE WHOLE THREAD>

Alwayswonderedwhy · 13/11/2026 13:26

Stop smoking inside where other people live!

withlotsoflove · 13/11/2026 13:27

RogueFemale · 13/11/2026 00:13

Ex-smoker. My experience is that people feel very high and mighty about 'the smell', while probably being smelly or very annoying in other ways themselves - bad body odour, BBQs, fireworks frightening wildlife, loud music - but smokers are such an easy way to feel morally superior.

Can’t really catch much from a fireworks display tho can you?😡

CelticSilver · 13/11/2026 13:28

SpicyRedSoilder · 13/11/2026 11:44

Are you sure you’re actually allowed to smoke in there? Is it freehold or leasehold? Owning it doesn’t automatically mean you can smoke there.

We used to own a flat and nobody was allowed to smoke in the communal gardens, nor inside their flats. There were actually a lot of clauses that meant people weren’t allowed to do a lot of things, for the greater good imo.

Intones: the greater good.

(Hot Fuzz reference)

Dixie81 · 13/11/2026 13:32

Getting an air purifier is a good idea. It’ll help keep your own flat smelling fresh as well as keeping the neighbours happy.

I’m in a council house so I have to put up with their workmen smoking in my home whenever they come to fix anything. The smell is unpleasant and does tend to linger but it’s not horrendous. What really bothers me is my neighbour who has an open fire. The smoke is so bad even when I keep all the windows closed. It gives me a sore throat and it feels like I’m choking. I’d take cigarette smoke over that any day!

TheAmberKoala · 13/11/2026 13:39

LouisFuton · 13/11/2026 10:00

What if you were cooking curry everyday?What if you were burning incense every day? What if what if what if what if

smelling my neighbours curry doesnt kill me.

BatchCookBabe · 13/11/2026 13:41

FullLondonEye · 13/11/2026 11:48

The problem is that it's not JUST "in her own home" if others outside her home are smelling it, no?

That poster just isn't able to grasp this very simple concept. Bizarre isn't it???

I literally can't even fathom it. (How it's so hard to grasp something so simple.)

I can only surmise that poster is a smoker, and is just stubborn, and has very narrow minded views. 'I will smoke if I wanna, I will I will I will! 😖And I don't care if you don't like it, just hold your nose if you don't like the smell. Me me me me meeeeeeeee.'

.

WhyIsThereGlitterEverywhere · 13/11/2026 13:41

YABU, the smell of smoke carries and is very unpleasant for people who don’t do it. I don’t know if there’s anything legally they can do to stop you but even if not it’s very unkind to inflict a horrible smell and ruin the air quality of your neighbours.

shuffleofftobuffalo · 13/11/2026 13:41

Three of my neighbours smoke (block of flats) I could smell it occasionally before I had my front door sealed for fire regs. It’s disgusting to have smoke coming into your property. Luckily one gave up, one cut down and the other started going outside.

I don't think they can tell you what to do in your own home but they can’t tell you not to smoke in the garden. What do they propose you do?!

Evidently there is a vent or a loose seal or something letting the smoke in. My brother had that problem with a neighbour and a chimney once - the smell came right down to him. Much better once they sealed the chimney.

Letstalkaboutitxx · 13/11/2026 13:42

ScholesPanda · 13/11/2026 12:45

I don't smoke. I am, however, capable of understanding that I shouldn't seek to control others and what they do, and to see that trying to do that is irrational and anti-social.

If it was a direct neighbour who was complaining of smoke smell infecting their flat it would be a different matter, but it isn't a direct neighbour in this case. I can guarantee you that the neighbour in this case will be a bored individual with a control complex.

Just because people are minorities, or they do something that you dislike, doesn't mean you get to control them.

Its not about non smokers trying to inflict control on anyone.Its about smokers inflicting their habit on to them by causing an obnoxious stench in their property.They have every right to object to that.

BatchCookBabe · 13/11/2026 13:45

Basically this......... ^

BatchCookBabe · 13/11/2026 13:46

I mean @Letstalkaboutitxx said ^

OrganicDecafEarlGrey · 13/11/2026 13:47

I'm kind of in the middle. I wouldn't want the smell in my flat because I think it just makes buildings smell a bit dirty and dingy. However, I don't imagine it's much of a health hazard as it's not proper smoke. I would probably prefer it to air freshener and fabric conditioner.

The neighbours telling you that you're not allowed to smoke in the garden, is very controlling. I'd just smoke next to an open window to keep them quiet.

MaggieBsBoat · 13/11/2026 13:48

Our neighbours downstairs and upstairs both smoke and it’s an absolute pain. The kids have started to complain that they are worried about being smelly at school when they use the stairwell. It’s just a blight.
Good luck to your kids selling the place after you’re dead.

CurlewKate · 13/11/2026 13:51

In My Glorious Reign, smoking will only be allowed in a fume cabinet. Or possibly on your own private island.

RafaFan · 13/11/2026 13:55

Specialneedsnightmare · 13/11/2026 03:05

Just be aware that if you want to sell your flat in the future you will be seriously limiting potential buyers because not many people these days will want to buy a property that reeks of cigarette smoke. The smell is all pervasive and you simply can't get rid no matter how unaware of it you will be as a smoker.

If you rent it will probably be against your contract to smoke indoors.

It's not actually true that you can't get the smell out. I just moved into a new office where the previous tenants had smoked for years (despite the ban on smoking in workplaces). The whole place was yellow. Anyway, good wash down, painted throughout, and replace the carpet. Good as new, and no smell. I say this as a non-smoker with a really good sense of smell.

QuietArtisan · 13/11/2026 13:55

I’m in a council house so I have to put up with their workmen smoking in my home whenever they come to fix anything.

Who on earth led you to believe that is true? @Dixie81

Swipe left for the next trending thread