Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smoking in our own property.

514 replies

Teenagerantruns · 12/11/2026 22:09

Ok l know im probably going to be slaughtered for this but here goes.
We moved a week ago into a new flat, purpose built block. We both smoke, yes l know its disgusting but whatever.
So today upstairs neighbours came down and said smoke was bothering them, im not sure how as they are not directly above us, but above on other side. I guess none of our frount doors are that good , so smoke is going out of ours upstairs and to the left to thiers? Seems unlikely but obviously they can smell it, they accused us of smoking in communal area hall which obviously l would never do. Other upstairs neighbours directly above say that they can't smell anything.
Im not really sure what to do now, l did say sorry and normally we would smoke outside just been hectic week moving and so wet but if we smoked inside we would do it furthest room away from frount door and close all the doors in between so 3 doors.
Apprently that's not good enough , they also dont want us smoking in the communal garden?
Aibu to think actually we can do what we like in our flat, and to just ignore them.

OP posts:
Thecatspantaloons · Yesterday 06:08

Lumpyteats · Yesterday 03:19

It's become less tolerated as we become more aware of how harmful passive smoking is, though. Not because people are becoming less tolerant in general.

I don't know though - people have become way more arseholery in the last few years, especially since lockdown, but passive smoking has been known for a long long time . I don't think your sums are adding up.

I'm not defending smoking or smokers btw , I just don't agree with your findings - since it's mostly the older generation that are still doing this but they are also seen as the most respectful - it's a bit of a contradiction .

Pepperlee · Yesterday 07:00

Lillytheplant · 15/11/2026 09:14

My cousin is asthmatic and has been unable to live in her flat for 6 years due to the woman below her being a smoker. Cousin has had various people round to see if there's anything that can be done to block holes or voids that might be allowing the smoke into her home. But apparently it seeps through the the walls. She's still had to pay her mortgage in that time. I've been round and can smell it. In fact, it can been seen in air in her flat. So yes, your upstairs neighbours most likely can smell it and with both of you smoking, it's probably worse than what my cousin has to tolerate.

Well unless she sells it the mortgage will have to be paid. Strange comment. And I'm sorry bit I'm finding it hard to believe that you can see cigarette smoke in a flat from another flat. I can appreciate smells travelling from flat to flat via vents etc. If the smoke is seeping through a solid wall then these walls must be flimsy.
I lived for over 30 years next door to a heavy smoker. Not once did I smell anything from her house through a dividing wall.

Shouldbedoingotherstuff · Yesterday 08:03

Bobibbsleigh · Yesterday 02:08

ewww smoking inside is truly rank - especially when you are in a flat so close to other flats - its grim and truly disgusting! Smokers have no idea how truly disgusting they and their homes smell

Be that as it may, it's OP's own home and if she wants to walk around naked, wearing nothing but a purple wig, with a cigarette in every orafice, she is entirely within her rights to do so, in her own home.

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 08:10

RogueFemale · 13/11/2026 00:56

It's quite likely nobody noticed anything.

😂 only if they have lost their sense of smell 🤷
You can smell a smoker instantly and it is gross, especially in a confined space like a bus. The only people not bothered by it will be fellow smokers.

Dutch1e · Yesterday 10:41

ChocolateCinderToffee · 15/11/2026 17:37

@Dutch1e Maybe they don't have a choice? I used to live in a flat in a big city because that was all I could afford.

And yet people choose to drive and wear perfume. It's just how life goes, people's habits will be annoying to us and we need to find a way to manage that annoyance. Because what they do within the bounds of legality is their business.

AllRighterrrr · Yesterday 15:53

Lumpyteats · Yesterday 02:47

I hate this attitude.

So much of what keeps society ticking along nicely so that communities are safe and pleasant places to live in has nothing to do with what's legal and what isn't. It's about people being aware, considerate, and sometimes putting the needs of others - especially those who are vulnerable - ahead of their own.

This is not a recent thing at all - in the past the vast majority of people were raised to be good citizens. Most still are, but unfortunately a recent development is that many aren't anymore, and that's when the inevitable clash in values happens.

I don't disagree with how people should behave. But people cannot dictate to other people what they can and can't do. Well they can, but they can't expect people to listen. We've lost the art of persuasion. Community cohesion. Negotiation and compromise. That's what I'm calling for. Rather than your interpretation of my post. It's so divided. Black and white. When actually what people would really benefit from is a healthy dose of perspective.

Is it reasonable to ask people not to smoke in their own house? Not really. Is it reasonable to ask them to buy an air purifier? Possibly. Is it reasonable to offer to buy one for them and ask them to use it? Probably. The possibly one depends on their financial circumstances and that's where the art of persuasion and negotiation comes in.

BlueSherbet · Yesterday 16:24

Teenagerantruns · 12/11/2026 22:09

Ok l know im probably going to be slaughtered for this but here goes.
We moved a week ago into a new flat, purpose built block. We both smoke, yes l know its disgusting but whatever.
So today upstairs neighbours came down and said smoke was bothering them, im not sure how as they are not directly above us, but above on other side. I guess none of our frount doors are that good , so smoke is going out of ours upstairs and to the left to thiers? Seems unlikely but obviously they can smell it, they accused us of smoking in communal area hall which obviously l would never do. Other upstairs neighbours directly above say that they can't smell anything.
Im not really sure what to do now, l did say sorry and normally we would smoke outside just been hectic week moving and so wet but if we smoked inside we would do it furthest room away from frount door and close all the doors in between so 3 doors.
Apprently that's not good enough , they also dont want us smoking in the communal garden?
Aibu to think actually we can do what we like in our flat, and to just ignore them.

There is no way anyone outside your own property can smell smoke.

It sounds to me like they have noticed you smoking and gotten a bee in their bonnet over it.

No doubt they will be convincing themselves they can smell the smoke, so furious they will be at the very thought of you enjoying a cigarette at home.

There is nothing worse than some zealot on any issue.

But you can do what you like in your own home.

If they complain again, raise a counter complaint: say you can smell when they go to the toilet and they will need to do something, because they are absolutely stinking. See how they like that.

I used to smoke tobacco, but gave it up many years ago. I liked it at the time, but don't miss it at all now. But I am tolerant of responsible smokers and wouldn't dream of trying to dictate what people did in their own home.

BatchCookBabe · Yesterday 16:27

@BlueSherbet

There is no way anyone outside your own property can smell smoke.

Nonsense. This is a myth heavily perpetuated by smokers.

You are deluded if you think NO-ONE else (outside your property) can smell smoke if you smoke in your own property.

The smell travels, and it's foul.

BlueSherbet · Yesterday 16:32

BatchCookBabe · Yesterday 16:27

@BlueSherbet

There is no way anyone outside your own property can smell smoke.

Nonsense. This is a myth heavily perpetuated by smokers.

You are deluded if you think NO-ONE else (outside your property) can smell smoke if you smoke in your own property.

The smell travels, and it's foul.

I think there are probably circumstances where it might travel - eg an open window or the smoker being somehow careless or inconsiderate.

But its just a smell like any other, it doesnt have superpowers to travel through walls or whatever.

You never hear of people complaining that the smell of farts, burnt cooking or a wet dog is coming through the wall. Those smells are foul too.

I would NEVER want anyone to be subject to tobacco smoke if they didn't want to be, but there is (or was) certainly a constituency of zealous anti-smokers who can be very intolerant / unreasonable and would go out of their way to take offence at someone enjoying a cigarette.

(I am not saying you are like that BatchCookBabe and I respect your opinion, even if I dont agree).

evilharpy · Yesterday 17:06

BlueSherbet · Yesterday 16:32

I think there are probably circumstances where it might travel - eg an open window or the smoker being somehow careless or inconsiderate.

But its just a smell like any other, it doesnt have superpowers to travel through walls or whatever.

You never hear of people complaining that the smell of farts, burnt cooking or a wet dog is coming through the wall. Those smells are foul too.

I would NEVER want anyone to be subject to tobacco smoke if they didn't want to be, but there is (or was) certainly a constituency of zealous anti-smokers who can be very intolerant / unreasonable and would go out of their way to take offence at someone enjoying a cigarette.

(I am not saying you are like that BatchCookBabe and I respect your opinion, even if I dont agree).

It genuinely does travel. My mum's flat smells of it, she gets into my car and I can smell it on her coat. She has never smoked in her life. I don't know if there's a tiny gap somewhere (we can't find one) or if it permeates the walls. We can't smell cooking, but we are not hallucinating the smell of cigarette smoke.

In some areas of her block (not ones she walks through) the corridors absolutely stink from people smoking in their own flats.

Teenagerantruns · Yesterday 18:00

Franjipanl8r · 14/11/2026 21:17

Why are your smoke alarms not going off?

Smoking is the leading cause of fatal fires.

This one of the most ridiculous comments on this thread of course smoke alarms dont go off from cigarette smoke...

OP posts:
fashionqueen0123 · Yesterday 19:21

BlueSherbet · Yesterday 16:32

I think there are probably circumstances where it might travel - eg an open window or the smoker being somehow careless or inconsiderate.

But its just a smell like any other, it doesnt have superpowers to travel through walls or whatever.

You never hear of people complaining that the smell of farts, burnt cooking or a wet dog is coming through the wall. Those smells are foul too.

I would NEVER want anyone to be subject to tobacco smoke if they didn't want to be, but there is (or was) certainly a constituency of zealous anti-smokers who can be very intolerant / unreasonable and would go out of their way to take offence at someone enjoying a cigarette.

(I am not saying you are like that BatchCookBabe and I respect your opinion, even if I dont agree).

It goes under doors and in and out of windows. In some places it can go through various vents, badly insulated walls etc. Its pretty common as you can see from this thread. Suggesting a fart does that is hilarious! Someone is farting for minutes or hours on end are they?

I've lived in a corridor where the person opposite me smoked and I had to tape my door to stop it coming into my flat. In the airbnb we stayed in the entire corridor stank. It happens!

Dimdam · Yesterday 20:35

Who are you to dictate to anyone? I bet you're a barrel of laughs at a party, what's it like to be the epitome of perfecttion, and what has age got to do with it?

A relation of mine was a clean living personal trainer, fastidious about he's diet and always advising people what they should or shouldn't be eating at the dinner table, he does at age 30 on the treadmill in the gym, heart attack. Over the last weekend an distant aunt of mine died, heavy smoker she was 86 years old

I don't drink, smoke or take narcotics, but I don't dictate to others what they should or shouldn't do, each to their own. I despise drunks, but I couldn't give a damn what they do with their lives as long as it does no interfere with mine!

I advise kids about life I don't dictate to them, I advice, I let them make their own mistakes and to live their lives not exist in them.

FireEngine25 · Yesterday 20:39

Dimdam · Yesterday 20:35

Who are you to dictate to anyone? I bet you're a barrel of laughs at a party, what's it like to be the epitome of perfecttion, and what has age got to do with it?

A relation of mine was a clean living personal trainer, fastidious about he's diet and always advising people what they should or shouldn't be eating at the dinner table, he does at age 30 on the treadmill in the gym, heart attack. Over the last weekend an distant aunt of mine died, heavy smoker she was 86 years old

I don't drink, smoke or take narcotics, but I don't dictate to others what they should or shouldn't do, each to their own. I despise drunks, but I couldn't give a damn what they do with their lives as long as it does no interfere with mine!

I advise kids about life I don't dictate to them, I advice, I let them make their own mistakes and to live their lives not exist in them.

It DOES interfere with other people though. Duh.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread