Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smoking in our own property.

514 replies

Teenagerantruns · 12/11/2026 22:09

Ok l know im probably going to be slaughtered for this but here goes.
We moved a week ago into a new flat, purpose built block. We both smoke, yes l know its disgusting but whatever.
So today upstairs neighbours came down and said smoke was bothering them, im not sure how as they are not directly above us, but above on other side. I guess none of our frount doors are that good , so smoke is going out of ours upstairs and to the left to thiers? Seems unlikely but obviously they can smell it, they accused us of smoking in communal area hall which obviously l would never do. Other upstairs neighbours directly above say that they can't smell anything.
Im not really sure what to do now, l did say sorry and normally we would smoke outside just been hectic week moving and so wet but if we smoked inside we would do it furthest room away from frount door and close all the doors in between so 3 doors.
Apprently that's not good enough , they also dont want us smoking in the communal garden?
Aibu to think actually we can do what we like in our flat, and to just ignore them.

OP posts:
Askandyforcompo · 13/11/2026 10:30

I stayed in a flat on holiday once and it stank of cigarette smoke in the hallway and bedroom nearest the door because someone in a flat down the hall smoked. It was very strong.

ClaireEclair · 13/11/2026 10:31

Anecdotal but my sister lived next door to two heavy smokers (house) and we could smell it strongly in the kitchen/dining area. She had to stop storing things in the cupboard against the wall of the two houses because everything in it would stink of stale cigarettes. Thankfully they moved and a young non-smoker moved in. They gutted the place. It must have had smoke ingrained into the walls but thankfully my sister’s home no longer stinks.

BatchCookBabe · 13/11/2026 10:32

CarbootJunction · 13/11/2026 10:10

My parents were smokers, and after they died, and the house had been cleared (council), I went back to check everything before handing the keys back, and oh my god - the noxious stench. The place had been almost completely gutted, but the smell was in the walls, the fittings and the cupboards. It was putrid.
I felt so sorry for the family who bid for, and won, that place.
YABU, because your flat will smell like that, too.

Yes, the house we were in before this one had had 4 smokers in it before we moved in! Both middle aged adults and their 2 adult children. Took us DAYS to clean everything down. All the horrible brown nicotine stains were over everything!

We didn't buy it, it was a private let (we were between houses at the time) and it was SO stinky! We had the house because it was laughably cheap rent - £480 a month 10 years ago, and in an area on a bus route, 20 minutes walk from a big shopping centre, and the train station, so it was hugely convenient.

Was nice when we got it cleaned, and even though the area was classed as 'a bit rough' we did like it there. The neighbours were lovely. We were there 18 months. We had to move to another area due to work though, or we may have put an offer in to the landlord to buy it! (Sorry tl;dr!)

BatchCookBabe · 13/11/2026 10:33

@Cyclingmummy1 · Today 10:09

I can't believe the comments! Of course you're not being unresaonable to smoke in your own home. They need to contact the management company if it's that offensive to them.

I can't believe YOUR comment. Of COURSE they can't just do what they want in their own home - if it's affecting other people. That is a really narrow minded and selfish attitude. Sadly, too many people have this same awful attitude, and that is the problem with society today. Me me me me me, and to hell with everyone else!

NineteenSeventyThree · 13/11/2026 10:36

MacNCheesie · 13/11/2026 09:52

Oh dear not this idea again.

There are always outliers.
There will always be smokers who live to 150.

But across the population, smokers die early OR live with ill health for years.

Well, it depends what you mean by 'dying early'. It also depends on what health you experience in old age as a non-smoker. My non-smoking parents are living out their 80s with dementia. I know not everyone has that misfortune and some people are fit and active into their 90s and beyond, but personally I would rather die of a smoking related illness in my 70s than spend my 80s living with dementia, which is what I can expect genetically if I don't manage to succumb to something else sooner.

Put another way, I personally am taking no steps whatsoever to prolong my own life. A long life is wholly overrated unless you can be more or less certain (via your genetic inheritance) that your old age will be healthy.

stichguru · 13/11/2026 10:46

Smoke is essentially an airborne particle. If air can go through a gap, smoke can can too. If your door to your flat is not an airlock door, then smoke can creep out the door just like the air can, If your neighbours' door is not an airlock then the air can go from the hall into her apartment. That means that the air with smoke in can go from your apartment to hers. Don't smoke indoors unless you are in a building that vents outside. No one should be forced to breath second hand smoke.

Cyclingmummy1 · 13/11/2026 10:50

BatchCookBabe · 13/11/2026 10:33

@Cyclingmummy1 · Today 10:09

I can't believe the comments! Of course you're not being unresaonable to smoke in your own home. They need to contact the management company if it's that offensive to them.

I can't believe YOUR comment. Of COURSE they can't just do what they want in their own home - if it's affecting other people. That is a really narrow minded and selfish attitude. Sadly, too many people have this same awful attitude, and that is the problem with society today. Me me me me me, and to hell with everyone else!

You're quite right - me, me, me. In this case, the neighbours trying to dictate how the OP lives her life. How selfish and narrow minded.

There's a thread asking the opposite here https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5538744-aibu-to-ask-my-next-door-neighbours-not-to-smoke-indoors?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

Aren't MNers fickle?

AIBU to ask my next door neighbours not to smoke indoors? | Mumsnet

Genuinely not sure what my own opinion is on this so intrigued to see what the consensus is. My house is an end-of-terrace and the next door neighbour...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5538744-aibu-to-ask-my-next-door-neighbours-not-to-smoke-indoors

TunnocksOrDeath · 13/11/2026 10:56

Fit a draught excluder on your doors so it doesn't vent through the gaps round the doorframe.
Please don't smoke outside as an alternative! Our old neighbours used to do this, and it blew straight in to our (ground floor) flat via our trickle-vents and made our toddler's bedroom smell of weed. Just awful.

DiligentDandelion · 13/11/2026 11:06

So people don’t want you to smoke in your own property, but they also don’t want you to smoke outside pubs, or, let’s be honest, anywhere. Why don’t people just say what they think which is that they want smoking banned and have done with it. It’s your flat Op, you can smoke in it if you want to as it isn’t illegal. An air purifier with a carbon filter is a good idea, smart air do a really good one called Sqair Air. It wouldn’t be so bad if people weren’t utterly vile on here about people who take up vaping (often on the advice of the NHS) to give up smoking tobacco, but then couldn’t be nicer to people who struggle with ‘food noise’ and need weight loss drugs. The hypocrisy is extraordinary.

Isobel201 · 13/11/2026 11:06

I would suggest taking up vaping instead, I used to vape inside for CBD and that didn't affect the neighbours.

IzzyLeng · 13/11/2026 11:10

Would you pay for a fire door to be fitted? Maybe that would help prevent smoke leaving your flat.

BillieWiper · 13/11/2026 11:14

That is really annoying. For both you and the neighbours.
As obviously you want to just get on with doing your day to day things quietly in your house, which aren't illegal, without pissing people off.

I guess do try and do it out of the windows furthest from theirs? I don't know really but I hope you can find a compromise. If it's not breaching the tenancy or lease to smoke then there may be little they can do to stop you. I'd just not want to annoy them.

Honestly it might be a good time to call the local smoking cessation service?
They'll send you loads of free NRT and if you end up smoking less while you're in the house, you can use the NRT and reduce your costs and increase your health.

I did this in July and no regrets whatsoever. I now only smoke one a day!

It would also be showing willing to the neighbours. If you told them you're using NRT to try and quit they surely have to see that as the best you can really do?

Needlesnah · 13/11/2026 11:14

Lightmare · 13/11/2026 05:33

Someone somewhere should write a thesis on exactly what it is in the UK that bothers people about smoking. Its fascinating that something that is generally accepted without much furor in other countries, something that was completely commonplace in this country even 10 years ago, gets this much vitriol. It gets much more vitriol than other arguably more antisocial "quirks" you see every day in the UK

Everything @Metalmotha says plus you are wrong. Australia has moved into the same direction as the UK (I think NZ has as well) and during my time in Singapore I noticed the beginnings of changes there. I’ve noticed a change in attitude to many European counties as well - I don’t see that smoking is quite as well tolerated as it was.

I’m a former smoker - it is a truly disgusting habit.

Letstalkaboutitxx · 13/11/2026 11:20

IzzyLeng · 13/11/2026 11:10

Would you pay for a fire door to be fitted? Maybe that would help prevent smoke leaving your flat.

Or if drivers,smoke in the car with doors and windows closed. At least it would keep the smoke contained.😂

YouHaveAnArse · 13/11/2026 11:22

We used to live opposite a flat where someone smoked weed a lot, and it got to the point that we were worried our own landlady would think we were smoking indoors if she came to visit as the smell was so strong in our flat. The leaseholder would send round letters warning everyone but it still happened.

Are your neighbours renters who are worried they might be accused of smoking in their own properties if the smell travels?

BatchCookBabe · 13/11/2026 11:30

Cyclingmummy1 · 13/11/2026 10:50

You're quite right - me, me, me. In this case, the neighbours trying to dictate how the OP lives her life. How selfish and narrow minded.

There's a thread asking the opposite here https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5538744-aibu-to-ask-my-next-door-neighbours-not-to-smoke-indoors?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

Aren't MNers fickle?

Is that supposed to be some kind of defence or 'gotcha?'

Epic fail. Pretty much all smokers are selfish and all me me me me me by the very fact that they allow the stench of their cigarette smoke to affect others.

We get it, you're a smoker. Smokers are selfish. Own it.

Cyclingmummy1 · 13/11/2026 11:39

BatchCookBabe · 13/11/2026 11:30

Is that supposed to be some kind of defence or 'gotcha?'

Epic fail. Pretty much all smokers are selfish and all me me me me me by the very fact that they allow the stench of their cigarette smoke to affect others.

We get it, you're a smoker. Smokers are selfish. Own it.

No, not at all. Merely pointing out that the same question elicited a different response.

As it happens, I've never been a smoker, it's never appealed to me. Not much of a 'gotcha', more an 'epic fail' on your part.

However, I'm happy to live and let live. The sanctimonious attitude on this thread is quite shocking; the OP wants to smoke in her own home, yet she's the selfish one. Bizarre.

boredandgrand · 13/11/2026 11:41

You can do what you want in your own flat but you live with the consequences of upsetting your neighbours.

MacNCheesie · 13/11/2026 11:43

NineteenSeventyThree · 13/11/2026 10:36

Well, it depends what you mean by 'dying early'. It also depends on what health you experience in old age as a non-smoker. My non-smoking parents are living out their 80s with dementia. I know not everyone has that misfortune and some people are fit and active into their 90s and beyond, but personally I would rather die of a smoking related illness in my 70s than spend my 80s living with dementia, which is what I can expect genetically if I don't manage to succumb to something else sooner.

Put another way, I personally am taking no steps whatsoever to prolong my own life. A long life is wholly overrated unless you can be more or less certain (via your genetic inheritance) that your old age will be healthy.

Kindly, you're talking nonsense if you are trying to defend smoking and health.

Are you a smoker?

Dying early means before approx 85 for a woman.

But it's more about healthy years, not age of death. In some areas of the UK women do not have healthy years much after 55. It's lifestyle related not just genes.

It's not a choice between smoking and dying in your 70s, and not smoking and dying in your 80s.

And I doubt very much if you would like to die in your 70s from anything.
I am in my 70s and hope to live for many more years.

If you want to live your life without adopting a healthy lifestyle that is your choice. But don't assume you will pop your clogs in your 70s. You may live a longer and unpleasant life, with numerous chronic illnesses.

SpicyRedSoilder · 13/11/2026 11:44

Are you sure you’re actually allowed to smoke in there? Is it freehold or leasehold? Owning it doesn’t automatically mean you can smoke there.

We used to own a flat and nobody was allowed to smoke in the communal gardens, nor inside their flats. There were actually a lot of clauses that meant people weren’t allowed to do a lot of things, for the greater good imo.

FullLondonEye · 13/11/2026 11:47

Lightmare · 13/11/2026 05:33

Someone somewhere should write a thesis on exactly what it is in the UK that bothers people about smoking. Its fascinating that something that is generally accepted without much furor in other countries, something that was completely commonplace in this country even 10 years ago, gets this much vitriol. It gets much more vitriol than other arguably more antisocial "quirks" you see every day in the UK

I don't think there are any complicated social reasons. It smells and I don't want to smell it. That's it.

I don't like the smell and I don't think smokers realise how much they stink. My father used to go outside and smoke 'in secret'. Genuinely without a clue that when he came back in he absolutely reeked and none of us were in any doubt about what he'd been doing. My brother occasionally borrows my mother's car - he doesn't smoke in it but it always comes back STINKING because it transfers from his clothes. If you don't smoke, you can smell it very clearly on the hair, skin, breath, clothes of anyone who has been around it. My daughter stood next to a man at a bus stop the other day who was smoking and she STUNK. It was horrible.

I appreciate those who want to smoke should be able to do so in peace, but those of us who hate the smell (never mind the smoke itself) should be able to breathe in peace without having to deal with that, and it's SO pervasive. When someone stinks of BO or if they've stepped in dog shit we all complain about the smell. Why do smokers consider their smell more socially acceptable? To me it's far worse than those.

FullLondonEye · 13/11/2026 11:48

Cyclingmummy1 · 13/11/2026 11:39

No, not at all. Merely pointing out that the same question elicited a different response.

As it happens, I've never been a smoker, it's never appealed to me. Not much of a 'gotcha', more an 'epic fail' on your part.

However, I'm happy to live and let live. The sanctimonious attitude on this thread is quite shocking; the OP wants to smoke in her own home, yet she's the selfish one. Bizarre.

The problem is that it's not JUST "in her own home" if others outside her home are smelling it, no?

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 13/11/2026 11:48

This thread is wild. I don't smoke, so no skin in the game, but it is legal and you are smoking in your home that you own - if the neighbours don't like it then that's a shame, but you're totally within your rights. I suspect if you smoked outside in a shared garden that would be worse, as it's a communal space and they would have rights to complain about that.

MN hates smokers as much as it hates dogs. People saying to quit, OP presumably knows it's not one of her five a day or supporting heart health, and is making a choice as an adult with free will.

PilotingAWail · 13/11/2026 11:49

As much as you want to get on with new neighbours, if you aquiesce to this request, who knows what may come next?
They might not like the smell of bacon, or curry, or perfume etc.
You might talk too loud in communal areas, or start your car too early.
Visitors parking etc.
Honestly, I've read it all on here, and experienced my own crazy neighbours.
If there is a problem you can fix within your original budget then go for it.
But don't be pushed.
Enjoy your new home

Swipe left for the next trending thread