Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Opinion of Non-Resident Mothers?

143 replies

CheeseSandwich1 · 12/11/2026 20:39

If you were to find out a mother at school/nursery/club was a non resident mother what would be your opinion?

Would you think negatively of her or would it not bother you?

OP posts:
GoodGirlFaith · 13/11/2026 10:34

I have a friend who was a NRP. She had a breakdown when her child was very young and did something that she couldn't forgive herself for (and that placed her child at risk). She signed a legal paper that meant her child lived with her ex boyfriend and his new girlfriend.

She saw her child at weekends. She did think about consulting a solicitor to try to get back permission for her child to live with her but decided that she didn't want to destabalise the child's life (they had a younger half sister by then).

The child must be in their mid-20's now, they're really close and spend loads of time together.

I always thought that my friend probably signed the legal agreement when she was quite vulnerable, and it sounded like she was persuaded to do it by her parents.

I never judged her, if that's what you are asking. I have an ex boyfriend whose mother left him when he was days old, moved away, saw him about one a year and was just an awful person. I have always judged her negatively. I tried for a long time to understand but she showed many times that she is a terrible woman.

topoftheplops · 13/11/2026 10:39

I’d have probably judged many years ago, not openly though. I keep my opinions to myself.

then some years ago my lovely sister had her husband very suddenly tell her he was no longer in love with her and wanted to end their marriage. They had three boys, two with significant needs. She’d become their full time carer so he could work. She had little real support. He was off having lads breaks, hobbies and furthering his career.

so he drops the bombshell to her. She got up and went to pack a bag. Came down, handed him her keys and said “I’ll see the boys on Friday”. And she left with him yelling all sorts at her. And she stayed with me. Got herself a job. Saw her sons at the marital home but refused to be the resident parent. He had been having an affair. His new woman didn’t last long.

They are now parenting 50/50 after the divorce.

men think they can just walk away. Women are shamed for it. I’d never judge now and I certainly have never judged my sister for forcing this idiot man to actually step up and be a father

lalaloopyhead · 13/11/2026 10:41

Honestly I would be curious, and I would probably assume your situation to be as you say and I wouldn't be judgemental of that in the slightest.

The only person I know in the situation was in an abusive relationship and her ex went all out to take the kids from her when she left - I only felt sympathy for her because she obviously did the right thing by splitting, but in her eyes it was a mistake because she lost her kids.

I think if someone was NRP by choice I would probably think differently but then again we don't always know what is going on in peoples lives and I can't imagine there are many people at all in a situation like this that don't think they are doing things for the best.

FunPartyIdeas · 13/11/2026 10:52

lalaloopyhead · 13/11/2026 10:41

Honestly I would be curious, and I would probably assume your situation to be as you say and I wouldn't be judgemental of that in the slightest.

The only person I know in the situation was in an abusive relationship and her ex went all out to take the kids from her when she left - I only felt sympathy for her because she obviously did the right thing by splitting, but in her eyes it was a mistake because she lost her kids.

I think if someone was NRP by choice I would probably think differently but then again we don't always know what is going on in peoples lives and I can't imagine there are many people at all in a situation like this that don't think they are doing things for the best.

This lady's story sounds very similar to my own. I fought with everything I had to remain the RP but when you have been married to a very wealthy narc it is impossible.
Was it worth leaving? Yes. But I lost everything as I was told I would. The threat of "If you dare leave me, b (swear), you will lose everything" was pretty much achieved. I remember those words to this day. Somehow I kept my career, despite attempts to even take that away.
I remember when I first got my first rented place and sobbing because the landlord said I could paint my bedroom wall in whatever colour I wanted; I'd never been allowed to make such choices for so long!
My children are young adults now and perhaps beginning to understand the sacrifice I had to make; there is a reason why I'm still in privately rented a decade on whilst ex has a million pound property with swimming pool and hot tub.
My biggest hope is that my sons are as proud of me as I am of them.

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 10:54

BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 10:20

Hi OP, I don’t think many women choose to become a NRP. It’s brave to share your MH struggles, because you didn’t have to.

You’d have to give more detail before anyone could judge your circumstances, if that’s what you’re after?

How significant was the PND? Were you a danger to yourself or the children? Was your behaviour affecting others? How and why did you split with your ex? Were psychologists involved in the court decisions? Do you think the court decision was fair upon reflection or can you at least understand the decision at the time?

My situation is very unique, so much so I don’t think many people would believe it.

Around 1 PP I developed psychosis (I’d never had an episode before). Ex rang police/social services and said I was an ‘unfit mother’ - I take issue with this as I don’t believe a first time mum of 1 week can be classed as unfit.

Perinatal mental health team admitted me to hospital, Ex would not consent to baby going so I couldn’t go to a MBU.

Baby remained with him and court awarded him a CAO when DC was 14 months old, as he’d effectively made himself RP early on.

There’s no social services involvement (there was during court), no safeguarding issues etc. I see DC 2-3 times a week but Ex makes it very difficult. I wouldn’t go back to court as I was torn apart.

OP posts:
FunPartyIdeas · 13/11/2026 10:57

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 10:54

My situation is very unique, so much so I don’t think many people would believe it.

Around 1 PP I developed psychosis (I’d never had an episode before). Ex rang police/social services and said I was an ‘unfit mother’ - I take issue with this as I don’t believe a first time mum of 1 week can be classed as unfit.

Perinatal mental health team admitted me to hospital, Ex would not consent to baby going so I couldn’t go to a MBU.

Baby remained with him and court awarded him a CAO when DC was 14 months old, as he’d effectively made himself RP early on.

There’s no social services involvement (there was during court), no safeguarding issues etc. I see DC 2-3 times a week but Ex makes it very difficult. I wouldn’t go back to court as I was torn apart.

I feel your pain. Some men will go to any lengths to destroy the mother of their children (see some of my story as above). I thought the family courts would help me and my children against an abuser, not enable him. How naive I was.
Have you heard of MATCHMothers? They are incredible group of mothers apart x

PassOnThat · 13/11/2026 11:00

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 10:54

My situation is very unique, so much so I don’t think many people would believe it.

Around 1 PP I developed psychosis (I’d never had an episode before). Ex rang police/social services and said I was an ‘unfit mother’ - I take issue with this as I don’t believe a first time mum of 1 week can be classed as unfit.

Perinatal mental health team admitted me to hospital, Ex would not consent to baby going so I couldn’t go to a MBU.

Baby remained with him and court awarded him a CAO when DC was 14 months old, as he’d effectively made himself RP early on.

There’s no social services involvement (there was during court), no safeguarding issues etc. I see DC 2-3 times a week but Ex makes it very difficult. I wouldn’t go back to court as I was torn apart.

I'm so sorry, that must have been so hard. I would count that as abusive behaviour on his part.

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 11:02

FunPartyIdeas · 13/11/2026 10:57

I feel your pain. Some men will go to any lengths to destroy the mother of their children (see some of my story as above). I thought the family courts would help me and my children against an abuser, not enable him. How naive I was.
Have you heard of MATCHMothers? They are incredible group of mothers apart x

I’m so sorry you had to go through that.

The family courts are pretty much useless if you’re up against a well-dressed, well-spoken man with buckets of money to fund a never ending process. Ex literally had every ‘professional’ hanging on his every word.

He dated a mother at DC’s school for a while and I assume he told her what an awful Mum I was so it worries me what others may think and how it could affect DC.

OP posts:
FunPartyIdeas · 13/11/2026 11:03

oscarthethird · 13/11/2026 01:57

It’s very damaging for the children. I’d think it was odd, honestly. Also not my problem so I’d carry on with my life and not give it any more thought.

Some NRP mothers have had no choice. In my case my ex-husband was a incredibly wealthy narc who vowed that I would lose everything. He was pretty much right. I lost thousands fighting for my children 50/50 and then reduced marginally from there due to vastly different lifestyles. What teenage kid doesn't want a swimming pool.and hot tub?
But my love is unconditional - the only parent that can hand on heart say that.

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 11:04

PassOnThat · 13/11/2026 11:00

I'm so sorry, that must have been so hard. I would count that as abusive behaviour on his part.

My current MH team have been incredible and acknowledged he was and continues to be abusive.

I’m currently on the waiting list for specialist therapy as I have significant PTSD.

OP posts:
FunPartyIdeas · 13/11/2026 11:07

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 11:02

I’m so sorry you had to go through that.

The family courts are pretty much useless if you’re up against a well-dressed, well-spoken man with buckets of money to fund a never ending process. Ex literally had every ‘professional’ hanging on his every word.

He dated a mother at DC’s school for a while and I assume he told her what an awful Mum I was so it worries me what others may think and how it could affect DC.

I learnt to stop worrying about the lies that he told "friends" about why we split; it was simply a reflection on him as he wasn't going to tell the truth about the control etc.
The people that distanced themselves meant nothing as my real friends were never going to. Yes I had hidden what was going on, but when it came out they knew what was going on. They never doubted me as a mother for one second.
I hope you are happy now?
I'm now remarried (after vowing never to again!) and all is well x

FunPartyIdeas · 13/11/2026 11:11

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 11:04

My current MH team have been incredible and acknowledged he was and continues to be abusive.

I’m currently on the waiting list for specialist therapy as I have significant PTSD.

I've PMd you x

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 13/11/2026 11:12

Bananacrepewithnuts · 12/11/2026 21:51

Then you should have put it like this in the first place and you would have got more helpful replies.

Well I don’t think the way she put it from the start didn’t explicitly say it was her but did also suggest it might be. She didn’t lie to us at all or post a reverse

Livelovebehappy · 13/11/2026 11:16

I know one, but i know the reasons why so i do judge her unfavourably as she put a new partner before her dcs. Its all about context though, and depends on why the mum is nrp.

Periperi2025 · 13/11/2026 11:36

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 10:54

My situation is very unique, so much so I don’t think many people would believe it.

Around 1 PP I developed psychosis (I’d never had an episode before). Ex rang police/social services and said I was an ‘unfit mother’ - I take issue with this as I don’t believe a first time mum of 1 week can be classed as unfit.

Perinatal mental health team admitted me to hospital, Ex would not consent to baby going so I couldn’t go to a MBU.

Baby remained with him and court awarded him a CAO when DC was 14 months old, as he’d effectively made himself RP early on.

There’s no social services involvement (there was during court), no safeguarding issues etc. I see DC 2-3 times a week but Ex makes it very difficult. I wouldn’t go back to court as I was torn apart.

That's an awful thing for anyone to do to another person, shame on him.

But try to reframe things, many people have a LOT of family support and/or pay for a lot of childcare. They don't have more than 2-3 lots of quality time with their child a week. If you focus on making your time with your kid really count, and leave your nasty ex to the grind of parenting - running around to extracurriculars, facilitating playdates and attempting to get them to to their homework. You can be the BEST disney mum ever and justifiably so.

SJM1988 · 13/11/2026 11:39

I wouldn't judge her. My best friend is a non resident mother.
You had no idea of the situation and why they have made that decision.

BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 11:53

Periperi2025 · 13/11/2026 10:23

I think judging women from the point of anything less than 50/50 as "bad", or as a sign that kids "shouldn't live there" implying she is an unfit parent is regressive sexism.

Women have careers too, what if they have 70/30 (EOW weekend and one night a week) based around their job and commute, when the Dad works from home/ close to the home and has flexibility. How is that "bad" plenty of men do it and would not be judged as abandoning their kids, assuming they always pay adequate child maintenance.

I can't believe there are so many women (other than those escaping obvious abuse - not simply angry words in the dying days of a marriage) who would want more than 50/50 beyond the baby/toddler years. Do you not have hobbies or career goals?!

50/50 is amazing, I can work, progress my career with an MSc, do a little bit of socialising and exercise and still be an active, engaging and unstressed mum during the time with my DD, and her DF can do the same.

Some women really don't help other women with their attitudes and judgement.

@CheeseSandwich1 I think you are being harsh on yourself, you have a serious health problem, no different to living with any other disability and so long as you are actively involved in your kids lives up to the amount your health allows and they are well cared for the rest of the time then you are doing a good job, don't judge yourself by sexist standards.

Edited

If you’re a woman with a busy career who is happy to go less than 50/50 (like many men do) you won’t be judged anywhere near as harshly.

I think the relevant point is how the custody arrangements have come to be. An amicable agreement without court involvement would suggest both parents and children are happy with the arrangements. When a court order determines that one parent should get more custody than the other there are reasons for that, usually that the children prefer to live with one parent over the other or that one parent isn’t as “fit” as the other, often both. This applies to men too, it’s just more unusual to see a NRP mother. Judges don’t spin a wheel and hope for the best when making these decisions.

Of the women I know, they struggle to look at the behaviours that drove their children away or take any accountability because it’s easier to blame the ex than it is to self reflect. Again, men do this too, almost certainly more than women.

Nobody loves their kids as much as a
dead beat dad who “isn’t allowed to see his kids” whilst slagging the ex off on Facebook and not paying a penny in CM. I judge these types even more.

Periperi2025 · 13/11/2026 12:05

BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 11:53

If you’re a woman with a busy career who is happy to go less than 50/50 (like many men do) you won’t be judged anywhere near as harshly.

I think the relevant point is how the custody arrangements have come to be. An amicable agreement without court involvement would suggest both parents and children are happy with the arrangements. When a court order determines that one parent should get more custody than the other there are reasons for that, usually that the children prefer to live with one parent over the other or that one parent isn’t as “fit” as the other, often both. This applies to men too, it’s just more unusual to see a NRP mother. Judges don’t spin a wheel and hope for the best when making these decisions.

Of the women I know, they struggle to look at the behaviours that drove their children away or take any accountability because it’s easier to blame the ex than it is to self reflect. Again, men do this too, almost certainly more than women.

Nobody loves their kids as much as a
dead beat dad who “isn’t allowed to see his kids” whilst slagging the ex off on Facebook and not paying a penny in CM. I judge these types even more.

Courts are confidential, unless women are routinely sharing very sensitive information about themselves then all the judgement cast on them is based purely on assumptions.

I have many many coparenting friends, but only know the legal status of the set-up of a handful, one because i was asked for a character reference, one where they sorted 50/50 via a couple of formal mediations session and nothing from then on, and one colleague who has fought hard throught the courts for 50/50 not helped by our employer who is notoriously family unfriendly and has a rant now and then to get it off his chest!! Beyond that I'd have no idea, and also wouldn't know in many cases if they were 50/50, 60/40 or 70/30. Because i don't make a habit of monitoring the school pickups, between afterschool club kids, grand parents, playdates, or my set up where exH picks up on my evenings and I then pick up from his a bit later.

Assumptions and judgement, and sexism is what most of this is based on.

PassOnThat · 13/11/2026 12:06

@CheeseSandwich1 . Mothers who 'fail' are judged harshly, in part because society (and men) are so dependent on the unpaid labour that they provide. If women on a societal level refused or were unable to provide this care, children would not be cared for and society would go under, because men as a group would not pick up the slack.

I believe this is one of the reasons why we as a society judge NRP mothers so harshly. Because we need them to keep providing labour, otherwise everything would stop functioning.

If there is no father able or willing to step in to take up the slack (and you were unlucky in one sense that your ex was willing to exploit your postpartum MH issues to become primary parent), then children will often be left with obviously ill and struggling mothers rather than fathers, family or social services stepping in to care for them. The case of Deveca Rose is one that has haunted me for a long time.

Iwasyoungoncebutnotnow · 13/11/2026 12:08

I'm a non resident mother.

It breaks my heart.

I married into a controlling, wealthy family having been persuaded into a quick marriage because I was led to believe it was God's will. I was naive to say the least.

Ten years into the marriage, I was told that I had never been loved and would be happier without the expectation of it. By that time I was convinced I was crazy and knew I didn't have the stability to care for the children alone.

Another five years in, I was deeply suicidal and my children had seen and heard things they shouldn't have.

I was admitted to a psychiatric institution and my children were given permission to move with their father to an area that I could never afford to live. The divorce is proving to be a nightmare as it turns out my signature was forged on the sale of shares belonging to the family business.

My son was devastated when I had to go into hospital and didn't want to leave the area. He now won't go to school or to social events. He has blocked me on his phone although I don't think it is because he's angry with me. He was once an incredibly outgoing, switched on kid who made friends effortlessly. That child is gone. I see my daughter as often as she will allow, usually once a week if I can make myself useful with her ponies.

I fought in the courts with everything I had. Every professional I spoke to said they had no concerns about my parenting, it was in the interests of the children to spend more time with me and there was nothing more I could be doing. I was the one who did the words and pictures books about what was happening, researched how to support children emotionally and took a parenting course on how to support children through divorce.

The court appointed an independent psychiatrist and social worker who disagreed with everything my own doctors and children's services had said. They reached a consensus that I was unable to appreciate the impact of my behaviour on others and capable of meeting only the basic needs of our children. This was the opposite of what my own NHS psychiatrist and nurse believed. They asked if they could submit a report but were refused. In the independent report, it was advised that I take the parenting course I had described already taking and given evidence of actioning. My daughter was described saying things she says she never said. My son's wishes were ignored. He had been nervous about being observed for the report so we had planned that time together quite carefully. We made Angel Delight. In the course of it, we spilt milk and laughed about it. It was noted that the way it was cleaned up felt "deliberate and forced'. Then we had a chocolate spread taste test because my son wanted this. He enjoyed it. The psychiatrist wrote that I had a tendency to plan over elaborate activities, which should be discouraged. My strong support system of local friends was described as a tendency to form intense attachments.

When I was first sworn into court, I had concerns because I knew that many judges were clients in the family business I had married into. The hearing could not go ahead because this proved to be the case. I wondered what my chances were, a person living in a women's refuge without the children, discharged from a psychiatric unit, against a man who many judges were happy to trust with their money. I don't live in a large place.

My solicitor has had to take action after being repeatedly harassed and told she won't work again because she's representing me fearlessly. I think she'll win with the money - I don't receive a penny and inherited quite a lot while I was married which was always spent on the children. But it's too late for the only people I care about.

My children are now 15 and 11. I wish I had done many things differently. I have not cared for them since they were 8 and 12. I look back at some of my behaviours when I was very unwell and am horrified. I was very ill for many years. I have a diagnosis of cPTSD and didn't understand why I was behaving the way they I was. I thought I deserved to die. But when it came to the children, I did anything and everything. I know I should have left before I got so ill and shouldn't have been so naive as to believe the children's father in everything he said. He said he was a narcissist which was not his fault and it was God's will I should stay and support his recovery. He later said he was trying to switch the part of my brain off that would want to be loved. Everything I did was done in a blur of agitation. I felt like an animal and believed the strangest things as I sank deeper into suicidal ideation. I would feel triggered and become physically violent towards my husband, then not be able to remember anything about the previous days the following day.

I'm not excusing anything at all. As I've said, I believed I deserved to die and almost did. I have lost everything I have and have tried constantly to support our children from a distance now I'm whatever way is best. I worked so hard to get better and I was better. I'm successfully training to be a BACP accredited psychotherapist and the time I'm describing feels like another lifetime.

What I would give to be back just for five minutes, to be able to take my daughter a snack and ask my son if he'd like to meet friends at the park.

I don't know if I'm judged. I would understand if I was. I would understand if I wasn't. In my darkest moments, I judge myself as much as anyone could. I'm also incredibly grateful for supportive friends and family who have encouraged me to believe that I still have something to offer my children and the world generally. But only yesterday, when I commented that I didn't know how to face a fourth Christmas without the children, my closest friend said "I see how much pain you're in and I would help you to go myself if it didn't mean I'd go to prison". I was shocked but I know it came from a place of love and despair at the situation.

I don't think anyone who took my situation at face value and judged it would be in a strong position to evaluate what has happened. I feel sorry for everyone in this story, including my ex husband but particularly our children.

BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 12:09

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 10:54

My situation is very unique, so much so I don’t think many people would believe it.

Around 1 PP I developed psychosis (I’d never had an episode before). Ex rang police/social services and said I was an ‘unfit mother’ - I take issue with this as I don’t believe a first time mum of 1 week can be classed as unfit.

Perinatal mental health team admitted me to hospital, Ex would not consent to baby going so I couldn’t go to a MBU.

Baby remained with him and court awarded him a CAO when DC was 14 months old, as he’d effectively made himself RP early on.

There’s no social services involvement (there was during court), no safeguarding issues etc. I see DC 2-3 times a week but Ex makes it very difficult. I wouldn’t go back to court as I was torn apart.

I’m sorry to hear this happened to you. I do think it’s harsh that a decision could be made so quickly in terms of handing over ongoing majority residency before you had a chance to recover.

How was your relationship before the post natal psychosis? It seems really odd for someone to bail on their partner like this unless he was truly frightened for the safety of the baby?

There is no judgement from me in your circumstances, though I’d be right in assuming there were significant issues that lead to a judge making such a decision, which is what I assume when any parent is given less than 50/50 in court.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 13/11/2026 12:18

CheeseSandwich1 · 12/11/2026 21:29

I’ve experienced severe mental health problems that developed during pregnancy and got worst immediately post birth.

Ex DP wasn’t supportive and used everything in his power to get a CAO in his name.

I really try to be as involved as possible and that also involves school and clubs but it does worry me that other women will judge when they find out!

You didn't owe anyone an explanation but I think Id have preferred knowing you were talking about yourself not some random mother you spotted in front of the school gate- your post was set up as a reverse, and I personally hate these.
The women I know that are NRP were in similar situation (MH) although a few decided to leave their families of their own accord despite the family encouraging/wanting them to stay. I learned not to judge and not so assume the worst about a non residential parent as long as they are involved with the child, unless they disclose something that would have changed my mind.
Long story short, even if people do judge you, don't give a flying f* about them. You know you and it should not matter what others think.

Overwhelmedandtired · 13/11/2026 12:21

Honestly, I would probably think it was unusual but would like to think I wouldn't be judgemental as there are obviously (as your circumstances show) many reasons why a mum might be a NRP through no fault or choice of their own. And even if they did choose it, it was very possibly for the best interests of the child.

I had a period of work away from home when my DD was young. It wasn't specifically by choice, but not uncommon in my profession at the time so I had accepted it might happen when I went back to work. There are many dads who do the same thing, but I did get a number of judgemental comments and lots of surprised people that I 'could' leave my DD, whilst nothing was said to the Dads. And my DH was perfectly competent to look after her. It was definitely upsetting at times being away, the same as it will be for many dads (who incidentally probably don't have enough compassion towards them while working away from family).

When its not the norm, too many people have uninformed opinions, and too readily express them. Even if the situation regularly happens with genders reversed, or when they know so little of the story behind it. I hope you feel better soon.

BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 12:22

Periperi2025 · 13/11/2026 12:05

Courts are confidential, unless women are routinely sharing very sensitive information about themselves then all the judgement cast on them is based purely on assumptions.

I have many many coparenting friends, but only know the legal status of the set-up of a handful, one because i was asked for a character reference, one where they sorted 50/50 via a couple of formal mediations session and nothing from then on, and one colleague who has fought hard throught the courts for 50/50 not helped by our employer who is notoriously family unfriendly and has a rant now and then to get it off his chest!! Beyond that I'd have no idea, and also wouldn't know in many cases if they were 50/50, 60/40 or 70/30. Because i don't make a habit of monitoring the school pickups, between afterschool club kids, grand parents, playdates, or my set up where exH picks up on my evenings and I then pick up from his a bit later.

Assumptions and judgement, and sexism is what most of this is based on.

I don’t disagree completely. In the cases I know of, the women do make excuses and blame their exes when they are the problem. I’ve seen the evidence of it myself including manipulative text messages to the kids. If only they knew the things their kids have said about them to me in passing and I do my best to brush it off but teenagers are not stupid.

OneandFiveOnly · 13/11/2026 12:29

PigeonsAmongstTheCats · 12/11/2026 21:15

I wouldn't really think anything beyond it being quite rare. I think generally it's commendable to put the child above your own wants.

That’s quite an assumption.