Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Opinion of Non-Resident Mothers?

143 replies

CheeseSandwich1 · 12/11/2026 20:39

If you were to find out a mother at school/nursery/club was a non resident mother what would be your opinion?

Would you think negatively of her or would it not bother you?

OP posts:
Canitrustagain · 13/11/2026 06:50

I’d suspect major safeguarding issues. I’d think the same for men who barely see their children too (my ex is one of them).

PassOnThat · 13/11/2026 07:01

Anecdotal but the two NRP mothers I know are victims of abuse and in one case has a wealthy ex who has a new relationship and a full time nanny. In neither case does the father do much actual care for the kids... it's a combination of family/paid childcare/new partner and now boarding school as the kids are getting older.

One of them is a great mother imo (although it's hard to know the full story) who has tried to do the best for her kids throughout, the other loves them but is an ineffective parent who isn't capable of putting them first. This fed into her ex's narrative and has left the children in a difficult situation where they live full time with a very aggressive father and have limited contact with their mother.

None of the children involved are particularly happy and I feel very sorry for them. Most of their lives have been marked with conflict.

I'm not judging the mothers at all of course, but it does make me think twice about whether I'd leave if my own relationship was abusive. People always say 'leave, to protect the kids', but that doesn't always happen.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 13/11/2026 07:03

Missey85 · 13/11/2026 05:49

No worse than a dropkick dad 🤷 oh that's right it's a woman so people will be along with all the excuses in the world

No. Non resident mothers aren't at as as common as dad's, and the reasons ate often more complex than that of fathers.

WhatNoRaisins · 13/11/2026 07:03

I once knew a woman who became very mentally unwell after having her children and struggled to cope. She split from her partner and her partner's family stepped in to help with the children. It probably wasn't maliciously intended but the relatives "helped" in a way that pushed her further and further out of those kids lives over time.

Before that maybe I would have raised eyebrows at a NRP mother but I don't think this person had any intention of pulling away from her kids.

The other scenario where I could see myself considering it is if we were split and my ex wanted 50:50 but it became apparent that the kids weren't coping with it. I like to think I'd be willing to take the hit and let my kids spend most of their time with him if they needed the stability.

interestedandsol · 13/11/2026 07:18

This used to be so common back in the day. That women would have babies, have to work, and other family would step in and help. It’s weird how suddenly in the last 50 years or so it’s judged this harshly.
I would (rightly or wrongly) assume dv victim in your case, as it sounds like your ex didn’t support you and weaponised your difficulties to take your child

Wishitsnows · 13/11/2026 07:18

I would wonder if she had an abusive ex that used the court to limit the time with her child. Or maybe wonder if she had a mental health issue previously and when getting better she hasn’t yet been able to increase hr time with her child. I wouldn’t judge her at all but I would maybe think these things. Whereas I don’t think most people would wonder why a dad had limited time.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 13/11/2026 07:21

CheeseSandwich1 · 12/11/2026 20:56

What would be your opinion? As a NRP I’m interested to know what other parents, specifically mums may think!

If this was a reverse, then you think maybe you are very clever to gauge what people think without being upfront.
I personally met non resident mums and know there has been a reason for it, and don't really ask what is going on in people's homes as long as they themselves are OK with it and it was their choice.

VisitingInkMonitor · 13/11/2026 07:30

People do judge and trust and guess what the reason is because it is so unusual. My SIL left my DB because she had alcohol dependency issues. She used to tell people she had 50:50 custody when she didn’t because people were so judgemental. Obviously she didn’t go round telling people the real issue so my DB who was already in a horrendous situation had people judging him assuming he had forced her out or he was violent or controlling. He also had issues with some people refusing to let their kids come round for play dates with his daughters because they were suspicious of him being a single dad with full custody. I’m sorry this is hard for you OP but the truth is people will be at best curious and at worst very judgemental of both you and your ex.

ConfusedSoShutUp · 13/11/2026 07:48

To be honest, I would be curious.

I may - actually would- have an initial judgy pants moment.

Then I would check myself (and judge myself for jumping to conclusions, more than I had judged the NRP) and realise I don't know the full story.

I would then think MH, substance, DV, and, if I don't know the RP whether the NRP had some problems (or not) which have then been manipulated by the ex to get the children.

Then I would sit in the nosy but hopefully not judgemental camp.

Missey85 · 13/11/2026 07:54

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 13/11/2026 07:03

No. Non resident mothers aren't at as as common as dad's, and the reasons ate often more complex than that of fathers.

Way to prove my point 😂 it's a woman so she gets excuses meanwhile dropkick dad's get torn to shreds and no reason is allowed thief automatically the bad guy

Shardonneigghhh · 13/11/2026 08:13

My mother was an NRP. She left when I was about 10. My dad remarried pretty quickly, and was wrapped up in his new relationship. He provided but there was little time or emotional care. My sibling and I raised ourselves. It left me with no one in my corner and I have abandonment and trust issues. I stay longer in relationships than I should.

If the NRP mother is a constant in the child's life, they are already doing better than most of the NR fathers I know.

interestedandsol · 13/11/2026 08:14

Missey85 · 13/11/2026 07:54

Way to prove my point 😂 it's a woman so she gets excuses meanwhile dropkick dad's get torn to shreds and no reason is allowed thief automatically the bad guy

Isn’t that some internalised misogyny right there? Women have very few advantages, and this is a board for women, so what did you expect?

TheBlueKoala · 13/11/2026 08:18

@CheeseSandwich1 I wouldn't judge but I would wonder if there was drug abuse/dv/mh problems.

NerdyBird · 13/11/2026 08:26

People aren’t going to realise you’re a NRP based on pick ups. They will just assume work or travel or something means the other parent shares the pick ups. If they do find out, yes people will be curious, some might judge some might not.
I only know one NRP mum and that was due to safeguarding reasons.

Quitelikeit · 13/11/2026 09:48

Op there’s some nasty people on this thread - projecting their issues onto you

Dont take their comments to heart they are not reflective nor true of you as a mother

ChillingWithMySnowmies · 13/11/2026 09:57

my bff is an NRP mother, her son is the same age as mine and when she left to come to the UK, he stayed in the USA with his dad and grandparents.

She doesn't have much contact with him, but i know she still loves him deeply, loves when they do talk (he's now 20) always tells me about his achievements in college/uni like any proud mum.

TBH, i have never pressed her on why she came here and left him there, but i love her dearly, and i have no judgement in any way. I would feel the same about any NRP mom... that yes i'd be curious, but that it's none of my business.

BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 09:57

I’ll get hammered for this but yes my immediate thought would be that’s odd. Of all the separated families I know which is a lot unfortunately, 4 are doing 50/50. 5 have the kids majority with them going to their dad every other weekend and a week or so in school holidays.

The 2 cases I know of (one being my cousin) where the dad has majority custody is because the children (all boys in my examples) wanted to live with him over the mother. The reasons I’ve heard cited from the children themselves is that their mums are emotionally exhausting, insecure, manipulative, lazy and immature. In the case of my cousin there is some MH issues too.

These women love blaming the ex, citing parental alienation when the children themselves say it’s the opposite. It’s easier to blame an ex than accept your own shortcomings.

With a NR dad I’d think typical Disney dad, or deadbeat.

With a NR mum I’d think what has she done that the kids don’t want to be with her, because it’s so unusual to see and unusual for a
judge to decide without good cause.

Sartre · 13/11/2026 09:58

How would anyone know? Why are people so wrapped up in other peoples lives? I honestly do not know nor care about the ins and outs of random peoples lives.

MyKindHiker · 13/11/2026 10:01

I’ll be honest because it’s an anonymous forum.

I knew one, once. She left her husband and kids for a much younger man who was my colleague. She left them in the US and came to the UK to live with her new fella.

Yes we judged her. I think there were pretty unkind comments, we called her the lizard because lizards lay their eggs and leave the nest. Made comments that even rats look after their own babies.

Sorry. I think i’d be kinder now. But yes, that is what people think.

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 10:07

MyKindHiker · 13/11/2026 10:01

I’ll be honest because it’s an anonymous forum.

I knew one, once. She left her husband and kids for a much younger man who was my colleague. She left them in the US and came to the UK to live with her new fella.

Yes we judged her. I think there were pretty unkind comments, we called her the lizard because lizards lay their eggs and leave the nest. Made comments that even rats look after their own babies.

Sorry. I think i’d be kinder now. But yes, that is what people think.

Thank you for your honesty, I imagine most people think the same!

To make it clear I’m not NRP by choice. I had significant mh problems when pregnant/postpartum but Ex used this significantly to his advantage in court. I envisage if I’d had a more supportive husband/Ex I’d be in a very different position.

OP posts:
BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 10:11

MyKindHiker · 13/11/2026 10:01

I’ll be honest because it’s an anonymous forum.

I knew one, once. She left her husband and kids for a much younger man who was my colleague. She left them in the US and came to the UK to live with her new fella.

Yes we judged her. I think there were pretty unkind comments, we called her the lizard because lizards lay their eggs and leave the nest. Made comments that even rats look after their own babies.

Sorry. I think i’d be kinder now. But yes, that is what people think.

That’s why I’ve name changed. But, I think it’s uncommon that a mum would have her children less than half the time.

In your example it’s abandonment which is appalling. Generally, when a court order gives more custody to one parent over the other it suggests the pendulum is swaying to that the NRP just being a bad enough parent that the children don’t want to or shouldn’t live there.

Cuttertheduck · 13/11/2026 10:17

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 13/11/2026 04:14

This is very true and quite honestly, a lot of mental distress is caused by the abuse that the woman faces, both at home and out in the wider world through judgemental attitudes.

I think you misunderstood my post a little bit.
This has nothing to do with abuse or mental stress but sometimes the dad is the RP for practical reasons.
For example: my BIL does most of the day to day care because he has a more flexible job. My sister is a teacher so less flexibility.
If they were to split up my BIL would become the RP because the children are more used to him doing the day to day care and for purely practical reasons. Absolutely nothing to do with abuse or mental health reasons.

I think it's a little bit of a cultural difference, in the Nordics while not that common nobody would bat an eye. It has probably to do with the fact that fathers are more encouraged to take responsibility for childcare.

BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 10:20

CheeseSandwich1 · 13/11/2026 10:07

Thank you for your honesty, I imagine most people think the same!

To make it clear I’m not NRP by choice. I had significant mh problems when pregnant/postpartum but Ex used this significantly to his advantage in court. I envisage if I’d had a more supportive husband/Ex I’d be in a very different position.

Hi OP, I don’t think many women choose to become a NRP. It’s brave to share your MH struggles, because you didn’t have to.

You’d have to give more detail before anyone could judge your circumstances, if that’s what you’re after?

How significant was the PND? Were you a danger to yourself or the children? Was your behaviour affecting others? How and why did you split with your ex? Were psychologists involved in the court decisions? Do you think the court decision was fair upon reflection or can you at least understand the decision at the time?

Periperi2025 · 13/11/2026 10:23

BahRamEwe · 13/11/2026 10:11

That’s why I’ve name changed. But, I think it’s uncommon that a mum would have her children less than half the time.

In your example it’s abandonment which is appalling. Generally, when a court order gives more custody to one parent over the other it suggests the pendulum is swaying to that the NRP just being a bad enough parent that the children don’t want to or shouldn’t live there.

I think judging women from the point of anything less than 50/50 as "bad", or as a sign that kids "shouldn't live there" implying she is an unfit parent is regressive sexism.

Women have careers too, what if they have 70/30 (EOW weekend and one night a week) based around their job and commute, when the Dad works from home/ close to the home and has flexibility. How is that "bad" plenty of men do it and would not be judged as abandoning their kids, assuming they always pay adequate child maintenance.

I can't believe there are so many women (other than those escaping obvious abuse - not simply angry words in the dying days of a marriage) who would want more than 50/50 beyond the baby/toddler years. Do you not have hobbies or career goals?!

50/50 is amazing, I can work, progress my career with an MSc, do a little bit of socialising and exercise and still be an active, engaging and unstressed mum during the time with my DD, and her DF can do the same.

Some women really don't help other women with their attitudes and judgement.

@CheeseSandwich1 I think you are being harsh on yourself, you have a serious health problem, no different to living with any other disability and so long as you are actively involved in your kids lives up to the amount your health allows and they are well cared for the rest of the time then you are doing a good job, don't judge yourself by sexist standards.

cowxst · 13/11/2026 10:27

As someone who had their mother leave, and no contact for many of my childhood years, I would not judge a mother in your circumstances OP. There is always a reason; sometimes it’s just because the mother is a cunt (see mine) but I am fully aware that there is a vast array of reasons for a mother being the NRP and one thing I have learned is that we never know what’s going on. I’m quite open minded regarding mothers being less then present despite my own experience.