Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Opinion of Non-Resident Mothers?

143 replies

CheeseSandwich1 · 12/11/2026 20:39

If you were to find out a mother at school/nursery/club was a non resident mother what would be your opinion?

Would you think negatively of her or would it not bother you?

OP posts:
HauntedBungalow · 12/11/2026 23:35

OP I wrote my previous post before seeing all of yours, apologies. It sounds like you feel you are carrying a heavy burden around your illness and how it has impacted your circumstances now.

Which is understandable - there is huge stigma attached to serious mental ill health.

But, deep breath. Anyone seeing you at pickup isn't going to know whether you live with your child or not. They aren't going to be counting how many times you are there. They are vanishingly unlikely to extrapolate from that - from something they haven't noticed - anything about your health status.

I get that these are difficult circumstances for you, and that you are acutely aware of them. But that doesn't mean they are evident to anyone else.

If it would put your mind at rest, maybe try thinking about a neutral response you could make to any direct questions. Something factual but bland.

But really I think what is upsetting you is the circumstance itself. Are you getting support around it? How is your network? Do you have someone on your side?

AFigureWalks · 12/11/2026 23:36

I’d “judge” that the NR mum must have had a really tough time and my heart would go out to her.

FunPartyIdeas · 13/11/2026 00:13

Well I ended up becoming a NRP due to a coercively controlling ex-husband who fully manipulated the court system and also used his extensive wealth.
I remain an exceptional mother and if anybody wants to judge me without knowing the strength and resilience I have had to find to survive then go ahead.

Gealach · 13/11/2026 00:18

I wouldn’t judge but I would think that extreme circumstances have led to this. I would also be fully aware that I don’t think the same about dad’s like this.

But most people don’t notice how often you pick up or why.

BeSharpHelper · 13/11/2026 00:23

I know / have know a couple , one was because she worked long hours and the dad didn’t, she said he would have had to be in breakfast club and afternoon clubs and she would barely see him during the week so it made sense to them all. She saw him a lot though . Another one the kids chose and they stay with her a lot but more at dads. Another one because she was a chaotic loose cannon . I probably would wonder which camp you came under tbh , however I don’t think I’d wonder that much, I know lots of people with 50/50 and shared care where it would be an educated guess which one was the ‘ main ‘ parent so I wouldn’t give it a great deal of thought, i would assume you both look after him but he’s with his dad more days iyswim. It’s becoming more commonplace.

quequerido · 13/11/2026 00:29

I would judge because I’ve been the child in that position and it has had life long negative impacts on my sibling and I. I’m afraid that’s the honest truth

AnneLovesGilbert · 13/11/2026 00:30

It’s unusual so you must know people will have opinions. Why haven’t you tried to get 50/50?

Cuttertheduck · 13/11/2026 00:41

I mean if the father had been the main carer for the children in day to day activities ( because of job flexibility for example) then it follows he would be the resident parent.
OP is obviously very involved in their life's.

I find the assumptions that mothers are NRP because of mental health problems quite presumptuous and honestly quite sexist.

Mama2many73 · 13/11/2026 00:50

CheeseSandwich1 · 12/11/2026 20:56

What would be your opinion? As a NRP I’m interested to know what other parents, specifically mums may think!

I tjink the pp was judging uou because uou were being nosy about a mum who was NRP.

I used to teach in a very deprived area and families were very mixed. I think generally it usually the dad that is NRP but I do know a few families where it is mum. Some through work and some personally. They were all lovely people some had their 'demons' and others struggled to be the RP, on their own.
As pp have said the parent who just ups and leaves and doesn't think about their kids is going to be judged and it wouldnt matter if it was mum and dad.

I think that issues could arise from the gossips at the gate who might manufacture a story to match their thoughts.
Personally i wouldnt jump to conclusions because we have no idea of reasons why. I trust and treat people as I find them and how they are with me. You obviously see and are involved with your children which means no safeguarding issues.

ShouldBeSeenNotHeard · 13/11/2026 00:55

I’ve known three NRP Mums.
Two of them ended up as NRP because they had vastly different styles of parenting. Both mums tried to enforce rules and boundaries while the Dads were quite relaxed and let the kids do what they wanted. The kids chose the relaxed Dad home situation. The third NRP chose to let her kids remain.with their dad in the local area while she moved to pursue a new relationship.
i feel very sad for the first two. Not so much for the third. Lots of reasons this can happen.

OneNewEagle · 13/11/2026 00:57

If I heard other parents gossiping I’d hate it, I was the person they gossiped about at the school gates when my DC was young. So I know it’s awful.

me personally I don’t gossip or judge and I’d also keep my opinions to myself. I’d just hope the mum was OK obviously as she’s probably had a hard time.

OneNewEagle · 13/11/2026 01:00

Pearlstillsinging · 12/11/2026 21:25

I'd think she is doing better than those mothers who walked out on their children, leaving them with their father never to be seen again.

I have taught 2 families where this was the case and the same thing happened to my late OH, except that she took one son with her and left one. I have seen the effect that a completely absent parent has on children.

That’s not really a nice comment. I was a lone parent I did everything in my power for my DC to be happy. I couldn’t just make the absent one reappear (in my horrific case the courts revoked his parental responsibility).

BeSharpHelper · 13/11/2026 01:21

OneNewEagle · 13/11/2026 01:00

That’s not really a nice comment. I was a lone parent I did everything in my power for my DC to be happy. I couldn’t just make the absent one reappear (in my horrific case the courts revoked his parental responsibility).

That’s a bit of a stretch isn’t it , thats clearly not what they meant, thats quite unfair. You’ve taken one sentence out of that and applied it incorrectly to your situation . Also, Im sure youre doing a great job. Your kids will be fine with you in their corner Im sure .

SkyBlueTopper · 13/11/2026 01:32

My starting point unless know otherwise would assume that the mother was ill, abused by the dad or dead.
If it was the otherwise round I would assume he was useless, ill, dead or abused. I wouldn't judge as I wouldn't know.
Men are 10 times likely to leave but the ones that stay tend to be the best.

oscarthethird · 13/11/2026 01:57

It’s very damaging for the children. I’d think it was odd, honestly. Also not my problem so I’d carry on with my life and not give it any more thought.

wandawaves · 13/11/2026 02:17

I'd be very curious, i admit. Just because it isn't that common.
I would assume either work related (travel/shifts), mental health, or addiction.
I wouldn't judge any of them negatively (as long as the mum wasn't turning up drug affected!).

ChewbaccasMrs · 13/11/2026 02:54

I wouldn't judge them,I would feel worried,sad for them and I'd just try to be as supportive as they'd like me to be.

MulberryFresser · 13/11/2026 03:52

Changingforthisone66 · 12/11/2026 20:59

Everyone is being very proper on here!! I'll be honest....I'd be interested. I'd consider mental health issues, possible substance abuse or possible DV (unless it was clear this arrangement was due to mum's working pattern for example)
I wouldn't judge, particularly if mental health issues seemed probable but I would definitely be curious. I do judge weekend fathers who don't do any meaningful childcare but if we're all honest it's very unusual for a child to be full time with father.

My sister is an NRP at the moment due to working pattern and a choice for her partner to live near his workplace + her to live in a hotel 60 miles away three days a week - she sees her daughter some weekends and stays in the partner’s home during those weekends. She is a very good mum when she is present. Both she and her partner seem to be away a lot without their child at weekends - her daughter is spending a lot of time with grandparents. I try not to judge them but it it really hard - my niece is 16 months but the adults have to see their friends too.

Thecatspantaloons · 13/11/2026 03:59

Just fyi
📣We do judge men, we judge them ALL THE FCKING TIME.
Next question.

Sorry for the harsh rant, but I have several very solid reasons to judge people who don't see their own children without really good reasons , mums or dads.

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 13/11/2026 04:00

NET145 · 12/11/2026 20:57

I’m some cases it is because of an exceptionally manipulative and abusive other parent that the other parent is effectively forced into being an NRP. You should judge her on how she is with you and your children and her children from your direct experience, not judge her for any assumptions or prejudices

I have a friend in this exact position. Shuttered severe emotional abuse and stayed to protect the children, eventually so depressed she has to leave or she would have hurt herself. She now has the children full time, but the ex is still abusive and almost wrecked her relationship with her children permanently. He told everyone she'd abused him and he made her leave. It was a complete fabrication, I took her to a refuge!

Thankfully, the judge was very understanding and wisely stated that the most abusive men never leave; they're out for everything they can get.

I wouldn't judge. She may well be feeling terrible as it is and be unable to discuss it because it's too painful.

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 13/11/2026 04:14

Cuttertheduck · 13/11/2026 00:41

I mean if the father had been the main carer for the children in day to day activities ( because of job flexibility for example) then it follows he would be the resident parent.
OP is obviously very involved in their life's.

I find the assumptions that mothers are NRP because of mental health problems quite presumptuous and honestly quite sexist.

This is very true and quite honestly, a lot of mental distress is caused by the abuse that the woman faces, both at home and out in the wider world through judgemental attitudes.

Twatterati · 13/11/2026 04:24

OneRedFinch · 12/11/2026 22:28

Of course I'd think less of her. Who wouldn't, truly? Nothing like finding out someone doesn't love their children to make you think differently.

What??? WTF.

@CheeseSandwich1 - I’m assuming this is what you’re worried people will think. Please know that this view is the minority view.

fuckeditupbadly · 13/11/2026 05:29

OneRedFinch · 12/11/2026 22:28

Of course I'd think less of her. Who wouldn't, truly? Nothing like finding out someone doesn't love their children to make you think differently.

What weird take. It is possible to end up as the NRP and love your children like most parents do. It is also possible to be an entirely present, abusive and harmful parent.

Bournetilly · 13/11/2026 05:44

No one would know unless you told them.

My DH works 6am-2pm so he does 4 pick ups, I do 1 pick up on my day off. I’d never even considered people would think I’m the NRP.

Missey85 · 13/11/2026 05:49

No worse than a dropkick dad 🤷 oh that's right it's a woman so people will be along with all the excuses in the world

Swipe left for the next trending thread