Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to cancel going out for Xmas dinner in these circumstances?

828 replies

NothingDefinite · 09/11/2026 18:41

My family (mum and her partner, my sister and half sister and their families) are due to visit and stay with us for a few days over Xmas. We live about 150 miles from them so we alternate spending Christmas in the two places, although we always go out for Christmas dinner. My half sister doesn’t always join us but does sometimes and is this year.

We all agreed on the restaurant for Christmas Day a few months ago and I booked it. My half sister is now saying she can’t afford it and wants us to host Xmas dinner at home. We really don’t want to do that as we look forward to going out for it, not cooking and just relaxing.

I’ve suggested that she comes before or after Xmas for a day or two instead but she thinks that’s unfair and doesn’t see why we can’t just cook dinner at home. My mum is siding with her and it’s causing friction. Are we being unreasonable to not want to change our plans and not want to have to cook dinner ourselves when we were looking forward to going out?

OP posts:
gamerchick · 14/11/2026 20:37

AncientHill · 14/11/2026 19:18

Oh Lord, just have a whip-round and pay for her meal out, why don't you? It's Christmas and you are family. Problem solved!

Why dont you send OP the money instead? It's easy to spend other peoples money.

Lunde · 14/11/2026 20:37

AncientHill · 14/11/2026 19:18

Oh Lord, just have a whip-round and pay for her meal out, why don't you? It's Christmas and you are family. Problem solved!

It's 5 people - not 1! (step sister, husband and 3 kids)

Busylizzy87 · 14/11/2026 20:46

Life is expensive for a lot of people right now.

If she can't afford the restaurant and you want to be able to spend the time with her and her family, either change the restaurant to a cheaper one, cook, or suggest going to hers again.

If you're not that fussed about seeing her and her family, stick to the restaurant you've picked.

It's awful to feel left out due to finances which, let's face it, are not always completely in our control with stagnant salaries, rising bills, and family costs. But, at least if you don't change your plans, she will know where she stands on future and will be able to prioritise herself and her immediate family.

Chickadee26 · 14/11/2026 20:55

If she cared very much she would have budgeted for Christmas and the resturant while planning their recent trip abroad. She can have a Christmas she can afford at her home. I wouldn't be surprised if she does manage to find money to join you all.
Either way she should have learned a lesson in the importance of budgeting for upcoming events in the future.

Newname26 · 14/11/2026 23:27

@Chickadee26
Maybe she does budget tightly but has been caught of guard you just don't know and Op hasn't said.

It could be any number of things a drop in imcome, less bonus money than expected an unexpected but necessary expense broken boiler, a car accident with a hefty excess.

Or as I said earlier kids are looking for much more expensive Christmas presents than they normally ask for, consoles or bikes or something. It amazes me on MN how little people often budget for kids. But then they claim kids still have consoles and bikes - how if the budget is £100 max.

Whatever has happened the Step-sis is reallocating money and budgets.

VTown · 14/11/2026 23:39

BirmaBright · 11/11/2026 20:48

£140 for one adult does sound expensive , I could cater easily for the whole meal for that, two types of meat, all the trimmings, starters and puddings, cheese board, chuck in a bit extra and I could give you enough alcohol too.
Granted it would be me doing the hard graft , but I would feel really strange spending the type of money you are on eating out when I could offer you an absolute banquet for a fraction of the price at home.

She said she didn’t want to cook on Christmas; she wants to relax and enjoy her family. Why would you even suggest this? A lot of people don’t like cooking or don’t like cooking for a crowd during the holidays. I certainly don’t. It’s very stressful. How do you not get this?

Newname26 · 15/11/2026 00:01

But just because Sis is reallocating money and budgets doesn't mean other people need to plug the gap - esp not to the tune of £600.

Lots of people just couldn't justify that sort of money on a dinner.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 15/11/2026 00:07

Newname26 · 13/11/2026 19:53

I didn't say the family should change their plans.
I'm only agreeing that its a huge amount of money, for one meal on one day.

I do wonder what has happened that step-sis who must have known the price and known what it would cost when she paid the deposit.
I can't help wonder if its the kids are no longer content with hoodie, a lego set, book and a jigsaw but are after Xboxs or bikes or something that has completely raided the family budget.

You are being ridiculous. The sister and her husband know way in advance what they have committed to for eating out on Christmas Day. If THEY then choose to spend far more on their THREE children's presents than they can afford. Their choice. That should not impact anyone else.

Newname26 · 15/11/2026 00:08

That poster has hands up admitted she couldn't do it for £140. Fair Play.

She was missing bits out of her budget, forgetting the items she buys in advance and she was thinking Christmas Dinner for 8-10 people not 15.

Fair Play Award to @BirmaBright to actually admit she couldn't do it.

But £140 a head is still a lot of money, especially when you multiply it out and add drinks to it.

ItsCloudyToday · 15/11/2026 00:11

Busylizzy87 · 14/11/2026 20:46

Life is expensive for a lot of people right now.

If she can't afford the restaurant and you want to be able to spend the time with her and her family, either change the restaurant to a cheaper one, cook, or suggest going to hers again.

If you're not that fussed about seeing her and her family, stick to the restaurant you've picked.

It's awful to feel left out due to finances which, let's face it, are not always completely in our control with stagnant salaries, rising bills, and family costs. But, at least if you don't change your plans, she will know where she stands on future and will be able to prioritise herself and her immediate family.

So life is expensive for everyone, yet OP and other family members need to lose their deposits that they’ve already paid or fully fund an Christmas dinner for 15 people on top of all the other costs of hosting for a few days? 🤔

Maybe the sister and her family can have a meal at home within their budget and then join their rest of the family as has been suggested to her? Expecting 10 other people to change their plans/fund your family is beyond entitled behaviour.

Newname26 · 15/11/2026 00:17

socialdilemmawhattodo · 15/11/2026 00:07

You are being ridiculous. The sister and her husband know way in advance what they have committed to for eating out on Christmas Day. If THEY then choose to spend far more on their THREE children's presents than they can afford. Their choice. That should not impact anyone else.

Thats the point we have no idea what has caused them to decide they can no longer afford it.

Could be absolutely anything that has broken and needs replacing or something they think has more value than a few hours sitting in a restaurant.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 15/11/2026 00:26

Newname26 · 15/11/2026 00:17

Thats the point we have no idea what has caused them to decide they can no longer afford it.

Could be absolutely anything that has broken and needs replacing or something they think has more value than a few hours sitting in a restaurant.

An adult needs to own this. If an unexpected large bill has come in then DS and her husband need to say clearly, sorry we can no longer join you. We understand our deposit is forfeit. Have a great day, we will make our own plans, love you. But they haven't: they are demanding that their meal cost for effectively 5 adults is paid for by others. That is NOT them deciding to pay for one bill rather than another, that is them deciding unilaterally that others shall pay for a bill. The reply to that is NO.

ItsCloudyToday · 15/11/2026 00:28

Newname26 · 15/11/2026 00:17

Thats the point we have no idea what has caused them to decide they can no longer afford it.

Could be absolutely anything that has broken and needs replacing or something they think has more value than a few hours sitting in a restaurant.

That’s true. Then you would say to your family “we’re really sorry, something has come up and we can not longer afford to come for Christmas lunch. We will sort ourselves out at home and see you all at a later time”. Yes?

Newname26 · 15/11/2026 06:06

I think thats it maybe its the way it has been said was it a demand or a suggestion to eat at home?

Sorry Sis, we can no longer afford to go out on Christmas Day, due to unexpected bills, how do you feel about us eating at home?

Its the mother who's asked the Op to pay half obviously realising the other sister who saves all year for it. Wouldn't have the money to do it.

Given Op has kids at uni its probably not that often the 3 sisters and families get together ever. They'll always be someone who can't make it at any point in the year.
Depending on whats changed the mum probably realises she might never get her 3 kids & families together for Christmas ever.

As always on MN you get one side of a story and people jump up and down.

ItsCloudyToday · 15/11/2026 07:52

Newname26 · 15/11/2026 06:06

I think thats it maybe its the way it has been said was it a demand or a suggestion to eat at home?

Sorry Sis, we can no longer afford to go out on Christmas Day, due to unexpected bills, how do you feel about us eating at home?

Its the mother who's asked the Op to pay half obviously realising the other sister who saves all year for it. Wouldn't have the money to do it.

Given Op has kids at uni its probably not that often the 3 sisters and families get together ever. They'll always be someone who can't make it at any point in the year.
Depending on whats changed the mum probably realises she might never get her 3 kids & families together for Christmas ever.

As always on MN you get one side of a story and people jump up and down.

Edited

Did you miss the emotional blackmail of “you’re ruining everyone’s Christmas”, “think of the children”, even though some years OP doesn’t see this half sister at all as she spends it with other family?
The OP’s mom doesn’t want her to pay half, she wants her to cover the whole bill for the half sister and her family. She herself hasn’t offered to contribute at all. The half sister “can’t see why OP can’t just cook at home”, as well as providing her with all other meals over the festive period.

Nobody should be suggesting how others spend their time and money.

Busylizzy87 · 15/11/2026 07:53

ItsCloudyToday · 15/11/2026 00:11

So life is expensive for everyone, yet OP and other family members need to lose their deposits that they’ve already paid or fully fund an Christmas dinner for 15 people on top of all the other costs of hosting for a few days? 🤔

Maybe the sister and her family can have a meal at home within their budget and then join their rest of the family as has been suggested to her? Expecting 10 other people to change their plans/fund your family is beyond entitled behaviour.

We don't know their circumstances, is what I'm saying.

Assuming their family is two parents and two small children (because we don't know) perhaps they only have one income, and perhaps that income is not high.

If you invite someone to spend Christmas with you, you have to take into account their situation.

I'm super lucky. My job pays amazing. I out earn everyone I know by a tens of thousands. If I want to do something with a friend or family member, I have to make choices that fit their budget not mine, or I offer to treat them.

If you want to spend Christmas with someone, you make a choice that caters to them too.

OP doesn't have to change plans or lose their deposit. BUT if the other family is important to them, and they want to spend Christmas with them, they will need to change their plans or offer to chip in.

It all comes down to how much they want to include them, and whether or not they are happy to potentially hurt them by excluding them.

Does it suck? Yes. But sometimes you have do things that suck when you love someone.

MyMiniMetro · 15/11/2026 08:06

Why do so many people who now can’t do ‘the planned thing’ think it’s okay to expect everyone to do a different thing to suit them instead of politely dropping out of ‘the planned thing’?

NothingDefinite · 15/11/2026 08:07

Busylizzy87 · 15/11/2026 07:53

We don't know their circumstances, is what I'm saying.

Assuming their family is two parents and two small children (because we don't know) perhaps they only have one income, and perhaps that income is not high.

If you invite someone to spend Christmas with you, you have to take into account their situation.

I'm super lucky. My job pays amazing. I out earn everyone I know by a tens of thousands. If I want to do something with a friend or family member, I have to make choices that fit their budget not mine, or I offer to treat them.

If you want to spend Christmas with someone, you make a choice that caters to them too.

OP doesn't have to change plans or lose their deposit. BUT if the other family is important to them, and they want to spend Christmas with them, they will need to change their plans or offer to chip in.

It all comes down to how much they want to include them, and whether or not they are happy to potentially hurt them by excluding them.

Does it suck? Yes. But sometimes you have do things that suck when you love someone.

Have you read my posts. 😬

I have said they are 2 parents and 3 children and they both work. I’ve also said I know what jobs they do, they earn well and on paper they shouldn’t be struggling. (Her partner has a similar role as me and the role has an excellent salary).

I have said they agreed on the restaurant. That is, we all discussed it and decided on it together. Everyone was taken into account and had a say.

We thereore won’t be changing our plans or paying for them because as well as all of the info above, we want to eat out. ‘Chipping in’ wouldn’t be good enough, we were expected to either cook at home at our expense or pay for them in full, because it’s ’our year’.

OP posts:
ItsCloudyToday · 15/11/2026 08:18

MyMiniMetro · 15/11/2026 08:06

Why do so many people who now can’t do ‘the planned thing’ think it’s okay to expect everyone to do a different thing to suit them instead of politely dropping out of ‘the planned thing’?

Honestly. Just this. You can’t go now so that’s it, you can’t go now 🤷🏻‍♀️ It’s not up to anyone else to accommodate that. Bow out of the thing you can’t do now and work with things you can do, like meeting up later as the OP has suggested.

ItsCloudyToday · 15/11/2026 08:20

NothingDefinite · 15/11/2026 08:07

Have you read my posts. 😬

I have said they are 2 parents and 3 children and they both work. I’ve also said I know what jobs they do, they earn well and on paper they shouldn’t be struggling. (Her partner has a similar role as me and the role has an excellent salary).

I have said they agreed on the restaurant. That is, we all discussed it and decided on it together. Everyone was taken into account and had a say.

We thereore won’t be changing our plans or paying for them because as well as all of the info above, we want to eat out. ‘Chipping in’ wouldn’t be good enough, we were expected to either cook at home at our expense or pay for them in full, because it’s ’our year’.

Oh thank God, you’re back OP. There’s now another of your posts for some people to not read properly 🙈🙄

Fortuity · 15/11/2026 08:57

It sounds like your family Christmas has become too big and unwieldy anyway. It would probably make more sense for each family to do their own Christmas and aim to visit each other for a short time over the Christmas period.

Busylizzy87 · 15/11/2026 09:48

NothingDefinite · 15/11/2026 08:07

Have you read my posts. 😬

I have said they are 2 parents and 3 children and they both work. I’ve also said I know what jobs they do, they earn well and on paper they shouldn’t be struggling. (Her partner has a similar role as me and the role has an excellent salary).

I have said they agreed on the restaurant. That is, we all discussed it and decided on it together. Everyone was taken into account and had a say.

We thereore won’t be changing our plans or paying for them because as well as all of the info above, we want to eat out. ‘Chipping in’ wouldn’t be good enough, we were expected to either cook at home at our expense or pay for them in full, because it’s ’our year’.

And that's your prerogative. I'm not saying you're wrong either.

I'm saying you change your plans if the people are more important to you than the plans are. If they aren't, you keep your plans.

That's neither right nor wrong. It is entirely personal. There are people I wouldn't dream of cancelling for because I simply don't care that much about them. And there are people I would cancel in a heartbeat for because it wouldn't be Christmas without them.

If they can't afford it, they can't afford it. What you do with that information is up to you.

No judgement.

DanceMumTaxi · 15/11/2026 09:55

So many people not reading the OP posts. It’s not hard you can read them all in one go to get the gist of what’s been said. I’m pleased you’re sticking to your guns. Your sister is the one who’s changed the previously agreed plans so it’s up to her to make alternative arrangements.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 15/11/2026 10:11

DanceMumTaxi · 15/11/2026 09:55

So many people not reading the OP posts. It’s not hard you can read them all in one go to get the gist of what’s been said. I’m pleased you’re sticking to your guns. Your sister is the one who’s changed the previously agreed plans so it’s up to her to make alternative arrangements.

Yes it’s frustrating!

the half sister clearly isn’t on the breadline and I suspect there’s a lot of back story given OPs response

Gengha · 15/11/2026 10:19

Busylizzy87 · 15/11/2026 07:53

We don't know their circumstances, is what I'm saying.

Assuming their family is two parents and two small children (because we don't know) perhaps they only have one income, and perhaps that income is not high.

If you invite someone to spend Christmas with you, you have to take into account their situation.

I'm super lucky. My job pays amazing. I out earn everyone I know by a tens of thousands. If I want to do something with a friend or family member, I have to make choices that fit their budget not mine, or I offer to treat them.

If you want to spend Christmas with someone, you make a choice that caters to them too.

OP doesn't have to change plans or lose their deposit. BUT if the other family is important to them, and they want to spend Christmas with them, they will need to change their plans or offer to chip in.

It all comes down to how much they want to include them, and whether or not they are happy to potentially hurt them by excluding them.

Does it suck? Yes. But sometimes you have do things that suck when you love someone.

Such a stellar role with an amazing salary, and yet, unable to read. Nice one.