Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to cancel going out for Xmas dinner in these circumstances?

828 replies

NothingDefinite · 09/11/2026 18:41

My family (mum and her partner, my sister and half sister and their families) are due to visit and stay with us for a few days over Xmas. We live about 150 miles from them so we alternate spending Christmas in the two places, although we always go out for Christmas dinner. My half sister doesn’t always join us but does sometimes and is this year.

We all agreed on the restaurant for Christmas Day a few months ago and I booked it. My half sister is now saying she can’t afford it and wants us to host Xmas dinner at home. We really don’t want to do that as we look forward to going out for it, not cooking and just relaxing.

I’ve suggested that she comes before or after Xmas for a day or two instead but she thinks that’s unfair and doesn’t see why we can’t just cook dinner at home. My mum is siding with her and it’s causing friction. Are we being unreasonable to not want to change our plans and not want to have to cook dinner ourselves when we were looking forward to going out?

OP posts:
Roosnoodles · 12/11/2026 00:40

Notonthestairs · 11/11/2026 23:18

The Op has already said they have breakfast and dinner in their hotel when they go there for Christmas. Their hosts cook one meal, Christmas lunch.

When the family go to the OP’s they go out for one meal (Christmas lunch) and she and her husband cover the remaining days.

The half sister’s family includes her husband and 3 children so you’re expecting her to pay for 5, not 1, and cater the rest of Christmas.

If that’s the case then the mum should pay. She’s the one that thought that she should be paid for and they are all being served on all day except one meal.

scoobysnaxx · 12/11/2026 01:03

Gosh how entitled are they? Hold firm OP!
things could’ve been negotiated more if they’d never had agreed!
on what planet would a husband wife feel comfortable and not embarrassed having their family pay for their entire family on Xmas! They can stay home and cook their own dinner then! That’s the sensible idea.
we can’t afford if so we’ll bow out and spend Xmas together just us.
ridiculous!

Emma6cat · 12/11/2026 01:55

She has had 364 days to save up for the meal. Tell her to do one..

BeWittyRobin · 12/11/2026 06:05

So it’s not just her it’s her hubby/partner and their children?! If it were just her I’d be inclined to say to everyone else you can all chip in. The fact your mum has suggested you contribute but sounds like she isn’t offering to contribute I do fine very rude. I would be saying that you’d have considered hosting and cooking Xmas dinner as a family meaning everyone helps and contributes with their time cooking it and financially. Or you are off for a meal as planned she and her family can come or not that’s up to them. I mean I’m not being funny I’m guessing this hasn’t just been organised so she will have known about the cost for quite sometime

Notonthestairs · 12/11/2026 06:34

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 11/11/2026 23:39

No they still go for Christmas lunch at a restaurant

when OP is in the hotel she gets a lunch each at mum, hs and sis plus Xmas lunch out

whereas when it’s her year she lays on everything except the Xmas lunch

Ah, thank you. I got lost in the mix!

EmmaB1309 · 12/11/2026 07:36

Yanbu. The implication in asking you to do it at home is that you’ll be paying for it all, which would also annoy me. I agree with others that if she’s particularly young or has a particular circumstance that means she genuinely can’t afford it such as recent job loss or large unplanned expenditure then I’d consider everyone chipping in for her, but I wouldn’t be changing plans.

Newname26 · 12/11/2026 08:20

EmmaB1309 · 12/11/2026 07:36

Yanbu. The implication in asking you to do it at home is that you’ll be paying for it all, which would also annoy me. I agree with others that if she’s particularly young or has a particular circumstance that means she genuinely can’t afford it such as recent job loss or large unplanned expenditure then I’d consider everyone chipping in for her, but I wouldn’t be changing plans.

Its a family of 5, so not cheap to chip in for.

SALaw · 12/11/2026 08:32

tinyspiny · 11/11/2026 21:05

I actually don’t know how you’d cater a full course Christmas dinner for 15 for £140 without using very cheap ingredients however that aside the OP doesn’t want to do it , she wants to have the previously agreed meal out .

Exactly! A large turkey alone will cost a large portion of that unless it is of very poor quality.

ThreadGuardDog · 12/11/2026 08:41

thisismeithinkorisit · 11/11/2026 19:45

then she needs to pay for half sister, or at least suggest a 3 way split in leui of presents to her

It’s not just half sister though. It’s also her DH and three kids. So at £140 per head that comes out at £700. That’s insane. If she couldn’t afford it why didn’t she say that at the time it was booked instead of paying the deposit and then pleading poverty at the eleventh hour ?

SpainToday · 12/11/2026 09:12

I’ve been told by my mum that as half sister has 3 younger children, things are more difficult financially for her so it would be a nice gesture for us to pay for them.

Maybe tell your Mum it would be a nice gesture if SHE paid for them! Your half-sis is just being cheeky, but you're Mum's stance is in a whole different league!!

Woodfiresareamazing2 · 12/11/2026 09:25

BirmaBright · 11/11/2026 20:48

£140 for one adult does sound expensive , I could cater easily for the whole meal for that, two types of meat, all the trimmings, starters and puddings, cheese board, chuck in a bit extra and I could give you enough alcohol too.
Granted it would be me doing the hard graft , but I would feel really strange spending the type of money you are on eating out when I could offer you an absolute banquet for a fraction of the price at home.

Obviously it would be much cheaper to buy food and cook ar home (although I would question the quality of what youd6provide for 15 people for only £140).

But that's not the point.

The point is that everyone agreed to eat Christmas lunch at this particular venue knowing the cost.

Everyone paid their deposit.

Now a family of 5 is saying they can't afford it. Fair enough, things can change, unexpected expenses etc.

But they and another member of the group is demanding that OP either pays for that family of 5. No. Just no.

OR hosts/pays/cooks at their home for 15 people. Which they don't want to do.

@NothingDefinite I think you've chosen the right course of action, and they can have their own Christmas celebrations wherever they choose.

AlwaysExtraHot · 12/11/2026 09:39

BirmaBright · 11/11/2026 20:48

£140 for one adult does sound expensive , I could cater easily for the whole meal for that, two types of meat, all the trimmings, starters and puddings, cheese board, chuck in a bit extra and I could give you enough alcohol too.
Granted it would be me doing the hard graft , but I would feel really strange spending the type of money you are on eating out when I could offer you an absolute banquet for a fraction of the price at home.

Oh, give it a rest. It's irrelevant how you could cater and how you would feel. The OP has said multiple times that this is how SHE and HER family do Christmas.

sueelleker · 12/11/2026 09:59

SALaw · 12/11/2026 08:32

Exactly! A large turkey alone will cost a large portion of that unless it is of very poor quality.

Unless it's related to the Mumsnet chicken, that feeds a family for a week!

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 12/11/2026 10:01

sueelleker · 12/11/2026 09:59

Unless it's related to the Mumsnet chicken, that feeds a family for a week!

Pair the week long chicken with the MN famous massive salad and OP could feed the entire neighbourhood.

SandyCastles · 12/11/2026 10:08

NothingDefinite · 11/11/2026 20:57

I don’t mind you being nosy. 😂 I have ignored their calls because I’ve been busy at work but they’ve sent me messages saying I’m ruining the family Xmas, that we need to think of her children missing out and I’ve been told by my mum that as half sister has 3 younger children, things are more difficult financially for her so it would be a nice gesture for us to pay for them. I don’t actually think that is true because my mum looks after her children so no paid childcare is needed whereas we are supporting our kids at uni. I don’t care anyway, it’s not a competition and it’s not our responsibility to pay for others. She agreed to come and paid the deposit knowing the price. I think my half sister pleads poverty even though her and her partner have good careers and seem to have money for other things.

We want to go out for dinner so that is we’ll be doing. They’ve gone quiet now so I think they’re sulking.

I honestly don't get it, aren't you all spending Christmas together anyway, this is just the Christmas dinner part of it? Why would them not going to the dinner ruin anything?

But even if that was the case why on earth have you not thrown the question straight back to your mum? Why can't she pay for them?

SweetnsourNZ · 12/11/2026 10:32

AutumnOakTree · 09/11/2026 18:50

Just seen this. So not even one meal, but several!

Yes, I was imagining a young girl with a low income being left out on Christmas day and I think others were too especially as its half sister which can often point to a wider age gap.
As she has her own little family (and maybe in laws as well) it changes my perspective.

BirmaBright · 12/11/2026 10:36

We don't eat turkey , nobody likes it , so for 15 I would do a couple of chickens and a porchetta for the meat. I tend to pre part cook my roasties a few weeks before and freeze them, same with the stuffing. Potatoes dauphinoise I do the day before and heat through. Carrot and swede mash I also freeze and add creme fraiche on the day. I make my own pigs in blankets. Nobody likes red cabbage so I don't bother with it. Sprouts with streaky bacon and chestnuts. Peas, carrots and broccoli, personally I would be a bit more exotic with the veg but my fussy lot wouldn't eat it ! Yorkshire puddings if there is time or anyone has a strong preference.
Ive already bought the Christmas pudding and cake. Always buy the pudding reduced after Christmas in Waitrose as they have such a long date and get the Christmas cake when they have the offer on like they do now.
Starter is either home made soup or pate, with nice bread or crackers.
Home made black forest trifle or tiramisu for the non christmas pudding eaters, or there is always a tub of really nice ice cream for anyone who doesn't want a heavy pud.
Cheese board is a fairly simple affair of 6 cheeses and I have been given some homemade chutney and quince jelly.
I would say the most expensive thing is the meat, so about £60, I make up the porchetta myself. Then cheese and cream, then veg and herbs, then sundries.

I appreciate that it is very standard fare, possibly a bit too school dinners for some on here, but nobody ever leaves hungry Smile

I also don't think there is anything wrong with people like OP going out to eat if that is what they prefer to do. I am just too tight to spend £600 on Christmas dinner out and I personally like the cooking and feeding everyone part, but understand to others that would be a nightmare.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 12/11/2026 10:38

@BirmaBright your bargain basement Christmas meal planning is completely irrelevant to the thread

you clearly put a lot of work into it - work OP doesn’t want to do

SweetnsourNZ · 12/11/2026 10:44

I would carry on with your plan to go out for dinner. Give everyone a week or so to say if they are coming or not and book. If there is a deposit everyone coming pays before you book.
Those not attending can make their own arrangements.
Christmas traditons are nice but sometimes they do have to change as family dynamics change and this sounds like one that has had its day for your family.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 12/11/2026 10:44

SweetnsourNZ · 12/11/2026 10:44

I would carry on with your plan to go out for dinner. Give everyone a week or so to say if they are coming or not and book. If there is a deposit everyone coming pays before you book.
Those not attending can make their own arrangements.
Christmas traditons are nice but sometimes they do have to change as family dynamics change and this sounds like one that has had its day for your family.

They’ve already booked and paid the deposit

Choccyp1g · 12/11/2026 10:45

BirmaBright · 12/11/2026 10:36

We don't eat turkey , nobody likes it , so for 15 I would do a couple of chickens and a porchetta for the meat. I tend to pre part cook my roasties a few weeks before and freeze them, same with the stuffing. Potatoes dauphinoise I do the day before and heat through. Carrot and swede mash I also freeze and add creme fraiche on the day. I make my own pigs in blankets. Nobody likes red cabbage so I don't bother with it. Sprouts with streaky bacon and chestnuts. Peas, carrots and broccoli, personally I would be a bit more exotic with the veg but my fussy lot wouldn't eat it ! Yorkshire puddings if there is time or anyone has a strong preference.
Ive already bought the Christmas pudding and cake. Always buy the pudding reduced after Christmas in Waitrose as they have such a long date and get the Christmas cake when they have the offer on like they do now.
Starter is either home made soup or pate, with nice bread or crackers.
Home made black forest trifle or tiramisu for the non christmas pudding eaters, or there is always a tub of really nice ice cream for anyone who doesn't want a heavy pud.
Cheese board is a fairly simple affair of 6 cheeses and I have been given some homemade chutney and quince jelly.
I would say the most expensive thing is the meat, so about £60, I make up the porchetta myself. Then cheese and cream, then veg and herbs, then sundries.

I appreciate that it is very standard fare, possibly a bit too school dinners for some on here, but nobody ever leaves hungry Smile

I also don't think there is anything wrong with people like OP going out to eat if that is what they prefer to do. I am just too tight to spend £600 on Christmas dinner out and I personally like the cooking and feeding everyone part, but understand to others that would be a nightmare.

But the things you buy in advance still cost money.

SweetnsourNZ · 12/11/2026 11:13

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 12/11/2026 10:44

They’ve already booked and paid the deposit

Oh okay. I see that now. Then I would carry on especially if it is a non refundable deposit (not sure of rules on deposits in UK).
If your half sister doesn't come and loses her deposit that would be a shame for her but you all shouldn't have to lose for one person.

BirmaBright · 12/11/2026 11:16

you clearly put a lot of work into it - work OP doesn’t want to do

@BeardySchnauzer I did say I understand that OP would think what I do is a nightmare. I definitely don't think she should be forking out for anyone else given that she is already hosting them for the rest of Christmas. She can always send them my way if they don't mind slumming it Xmas Wink

MyMilchick · 12/11/2026 11:43

ThreadGuardDog · 12/11/2026 08:41

It’s not just half sister though. It’s also her DH and three kids. So at £140 per head that comes out at £700. That’s insane. If she couldn’t afford it why didn’t she say that at the time it was booked instead of paying the deposit and then pleading poverty at the eleventh hour ?

Edited

I would imagine it's £140 for an adult, probably not as much for a kids portion (that's besides the point though I wouldn't be paying either if I were OP)

CrazyMidget · 12/11/2026 11:47

NothingDefinite · 11/11/2026 20:57

I don’t mind you being nosy. 😂 I have ignored their calls because I’ve been busy at work but they’ve sent me messages saying I’m ruining the family Xmas, that we need to think of her children missing out and I’ve been told by my mum that as half sister has 3 younger children, things are more difficult financially for her so it would be a nice gesture for us to pay for them. I don’t actually think that is true because my mum looks after her children so no paid childcare is needed whereas we are supporting our kids at uni. I don’t care anyway, it’s not a competition and it’s not our responsibility to pay for others. She agreed to come and paid the deposit knowing the price. I think my half sister pleads poverty even though her and her partner have good careers and seem to have money for other things.

We want to go out for dinner so that is we’ll be doing. They’ve gone quiet now so I think they’re sulking.

Good for you, OP. You are simply sticking to the plan that was discussed and agreed to ages ago. If they have good careers and no childcare costs, then they are just being CFs. More likely, they just decided that they wanted to spend the money on something else and decided to plead poverty - using your mum as a wing-woman!

Anyway, you REALLY didn't want dinner at home and you rightly objected to spending hundreds and hundreds subsidising your five (five!) relatives, so good for you. Half-sis will learn a valuable lesson from this: That you are not to be manipulated and that she needs to put money aside to cover her expenses, if she agrees to do something.

Did they really want you to cover all five meals? That's 700 pounds plus tip!!!! And drinks.

Swipe left for the next trending thread