Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My eldest daughter thinks she can tell me how to raise MY own children??

266 replies

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 14:16

my eldest daughter has really annoyed me today 🙄

she has been having a go at me about how i raise the younger ones, apparently they need more routine and apparently im too soft with them??

she has got children herself so now she thinks shes some sort of parenting expert lol

i have raised my children and i know what im doing. im not saying im perfect because nobody is but they are fed, clothed, loved and looked after so what exactly is the problem??

what annoys me most is she seems to forget who was there when she had her first child. who was up with her, who helped her, who dropped everything when she needed somebody and who was there when she didnt know what she was doing 🤷‍♀️

i certainly wasnt standing over her criticising every little thing she did.

now shes got a few years of being a mum under her belt she thinks she can lecture me about my own household. she was happy enough to come running to me when she needed help but apparently everything i do is wrong now 🙄

ive told her if she doesnt like how i do things then she can stay at her own house. i dont go round telling her how to raise hers so why does she think she can tell me how to raise mine??

at the end of the day im still their mum and i know my own children better than anybody else does.

AIBU to think your grown children shouldnt constantly criticise your parenting??

or am i just expected to sit there and take it because shes my daughter??

OP posts:
Leopardspota · 09/11/2026 19:26

thebrowncatisback · 09/11/2026 16:24

Isnt it totally normal to think we’re better parents than our own were? I know I do

Yes and this daughter is in quite an unusual situation. Most of us have these reflections/insights once our parents are no longer raising children, so there’s little point in discussing.

I think we’d all find it hard to have our parenting critiqued… but if the OP can find the strength to not take it personally and see it as a unique insight it could really help her younger kids.

SeenYourArse · 09/11/2026 19:29

Sounds like you were a crappy mum to her and she’s now trying to guide you in a better direction for her younger siblings. All the things you listed ARE big important things the fact you don’t think they are raises red flags

AllDownhillToChristmas · 09/11/2026 19:39

So it was 2020 when your daughter got pregnant… did you not have “the talk” about contraception, STIs, etc. Absolutely no need for an accidental pregnancy nowadays, there is far more choice of contraception than when I was 16. Likewise going on to have a second just 2 years later!
Somethings not quite right here, OP.
Do you think your daughter feels that you let her do whatever she wanted, and now she’s a mum, she is seeing you repeat the same mistakes?

FunAtParties · 09/11/2026 19:43

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:59

HAHAHA chavvy because im not middle class is it?? 😂😂

honestly some of these comments are ridiculous. apparently because i dont write like im submitting an essay and dont live some picture perfect middle class lifestyle that makes me a bad mum??

my daughter made her own decisions. ive never claimed she made every decision right but shes an adult now and im not going to spend my life taking responsibility for everything she does.

and whats wrong with my daughter coming round?? shes my daughter, those are my grandchildren. sorry for actually having a relationship with my family and helping each other out.

youve decided my whole family are badly brought up because of our ages and the way we speak.

you dont know us so perhaps stop pretending you do.

Honestly some of the comments on your post are shocking. There are some really snobby judgemental people on here who need smelling salts if they hear about folk who don’t live in a snooty middle class bubble. Please don’t pay it any mind. It’s classist nonsense. They seem to think they are above everyone else.

OpheliaNightingale · 09/11/2026 19:50

Being looked after, fed, and clothed is the absolute bare minimum parenting though.

Jimmyjumpy · 09/11/2026 19:50

Kids always think they know best. Stick some headphones in.

CJsGoldfish · 09/11/2026 19:52

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 19:17

yes she was 16, i am not disputing that she was young. but it was still her body and her decision. what exactly was i supposed to do, force her to live the life you think she should have had??

i guided her as best i could at the time. hindsight is a wonderful thing isnt it. she is 22 now and has her own children, and i have always been there to help her.

you seem to think every decision my daughter has made is proof that ive failed as a parent. i dont agree.

You don't think that a teenager who goes down the path of 2 kids before leaving their teens with a 3rd by 21 has lacked something in her life to make her think that's the best she could do?
Maybe there is a cycle that she desperately wants to break. FOR her siblings. Maybe she is reacting to the circumstances of her own upbringing. Maybe she just wants to feel like she has something to offer because, other than having babies, what else can she do, really?
You need to move past this defensiveness and listen to her and listen to what she is really telling you.

Franpie · 09/11/2026 19:54

I don’t know, my mum doesn’t have young children but I’ve got pretty strong views on her lack of parenting skills having experienced them first hand!

She would be like you though and wouldn’t listen so I keep my views to myself.

Bababear987 · 09/11/2026 19:54

Maybe shes just seeing where you went wrong with her and making some suggestions for her siblings.
Being fed, clothed and loved isnt anything to boast about, its the bare minimum.
I do wonder about how she was raised if she had so many children so young and your excuse was "well what could I do?"
It sounds so passive.
Then the fact you went on to have more children seems so irresponsible. Maybe listen to some of her suggestions.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 09/11/2026 19:55

It's an unusual dynamic with the big age gap. The only thing I would say is it's a tale as old as time but usually the opposite way. Grandmothers telling mums that they do everything wrong. Just tell her it's not her place to intervene but it's no harm for you to reflect a bit as she might have some good points to raise too.

StreetFighter16 · 09/11/2026 20:09

I feel you OP, they think they know it all. Yet, they come to us for everything whilst we ask them for nothing. So frustrating!

20centurySteph · 09/11/2026 20:11

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 14:32

where have i said my children dont go to school?? 😂

nobody has said anything about them not attending school so not sure where youve got that from.

they go to school and are looked after, fed and clothed. my daughter is having a go about little things like what they watch on tv and what they eat, not because im neglecting them.

It’s an example. None of us know what she objects to and so she’s saying some things are minor, and some things are not. Nobody is saying you said your kids don’t go to school, but we don’t really know what of your parenting she is criticizing.

I’m gonna ask a slightly different question…. Are you a different parent now with your younger children than you were with her? Could that be impacting? Some of her hot takes?

trikonasanallama · 09/11/2026 20:23

zingally · 09/11/2026 19:19

Next time she does it, I'd just give her a faintly quizzical look and just say, "This is the way I've always done it... I did it like this with you, and you turned out okay."
And from that point on, ignore.
It's not worth falling out over, and likely will stop the next time she enters one of the trickier stages of parenting, like the teen years. It sounds like her kids are in the primary years, when it is actually pretty easy, compared to the baby and teen eras.

Maybe she doesn't think she turned out ok, and is trying to protect her younger siblings?

Redpaisely · 09/11/2026 20:25

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 15:01

my daughter is 22

she was going on about them watching too many cartoons, what they eat, how much screen time they have, what time they go to bed and just generally picking at everything

they arent even well at the minute so yes theyve probably had more tv on than usual. what does she expect me to do, have them doing activities all day when they feel rubbish??

she actually came round this morning when they were getting ready for school and one of the boys couldnt find his school jumper. i was helping him look for it and she called me SOFT because apparently i shouldve left him to face the consequences and gone to school without it.
hes in secondary school now so apparently he should know better according to her.

but why would i deliberately let him go without his uniform when i can help him find it?? thats what parents do isnt it??

honestly its little comments like that constantly. she seems to think shes got it all figured out now shes 22 and has children herself. i dont criticise every little thing she does with hers.

Did you have your dd very young? Assuming from your username that you are 38. If that's true, perhaps she has some resentment over the difference in parenting she experienced and how her younger siblings are being raised.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 09/11/2026 20:26

Errr, you raised this gobby little know it all...?

SapphireSeptember · 09/11/2026 20:32

AllDownhillToChristmas · 09/11/2026 19:39

So it was 2020 when your daughter got pregnant… did you not have “the talk” about contraception, STIs, etc. Absolutely no need for an accidental pregnancy nowadays, there is far more choice of contraception than when I was 16. Likewise going on to have a second just 2 years later!
Somethings not quite right here, OP.
Do you think your daughter feels that you let her do whatever she wanted, and now she’s a mum, she is seeing you repeat the same mistakes?

Contraception still has a failure rate, even long acting ones like the coil. I wanted to be sterilised and was told that has a higher failure rate than the mirena or copper coil, so I went with the copper coil instead.

CelticTok · 09/11/2026 20:59

OP, you are coming across as quite defensive on here, and from what you've said you're also being defensive towards what your daughter is saying to you.

I hope you can listen to your DD, and try to take on board what she's trying to say about her experience of her childhood, even if you find it annoying/ rude / hurtful. It will probably bring you and her closer, if you can show her that you're open to listening and learning.

All the best.

FashionVixen · 09/11/2026 21:01

MarcellaGrace · 09/11/2026 18:40

That’s what strikes me here. I would say that having a child, not once but twice, in your teens was a terrible idea.

Agree. I wouldn’t be taking parenting tips from someone with that track record in decision-making.

SylvanMoon · 09/11/2026 21:02

@JustAskingReally88 ignore the nasty comments on here. It sounds like you're a lovely mother and grandmother caring for your DC and GC in a generous way. But your daughter is 22. I don't know if you remember how you were then, but I can certainly remember that when I was in my 20s I knew EVERYTHING about EVERYTHING and anyone older than 35 was hopelessly out of touch. Your daughter is raising her own children and doing parenting based on how she was raised and what she's learning about how to do it from her friends and social media (probably). And because she's 22, of course she knows better than you, who are in her eyes a fossil and doesn't understand child development or anything. If I were you, her criticisms would certainly annoy me, but I think I'd get into a habit of saying something like, "oh, that's interesting." or "I'll consider that" or even (and this would be difficult to do without being sarcastic) "I've not thought of that before. Thanks." And then just carry on as you are (unless of course she does come up with something reasonable that you perhaps haven't considered before). Good luck!

nolongersurprised · 09/11/2026 21:35

I don’t know why this bothers you? My second daughter, who is 18, tells me this exactly about how I treat my 13 year old son. Shes away at uni but scolds me on her return during breaks. He’s the youngest.

Apparently I “baby him”, he should be doing more for himself and he watches too much tv on Sundays.

It doesn’t bother me at all. I don’t baby him, as the youngest of 4 he’s pretty independent. When she says this, I give her more attention, as I interpret as her wanting to be a bit “looked after”.

She’s 100% correct that I wouldn’t have let her or her older sister watch tv for a whole morning and she’s just looking out for him, really. She wants him to do well. I am more relaxed about it because he is doing well academically and plays a lot of sport, with busy Saturdays and week days.

I think it’s a good thing, she loves him and she’s making sure I’m looking after him well.

TheGander · 09/11/2026 21:40

I get that it must be annoying OP but try not to fall out over it, because if you do everyone will lose out- you, your daughter, your younger kids and your daughter’s kid. If you can, allow a conversation about it. Just listen in the first instance without saying anything. Then take your time to think it over and then come back with your comments. I remember I wrote a letter to my father once writing down all the things I’d found difficult with his parenting ( in my case in included scenes, shouting and beatings). He just wrote back denying everything and saying I needed to move on. There was a weakness in our relationship from that point on because I did not feel listened to, believed or that he had any insight into how his behaviour had affected me.

waitinginwonderland · 09/11/2026 22:00

Assuming your username is your birth year, you’ve had her at 16? And she’s had her first at 16? And three by 22? Perhaps she is advising you to do things differently so that your younger children can break the cycle?

Popstarrrrr · 09/11/2026 22:16

No one likes their parenting critiqued. But your older daughter does have a unique position as she's lived through being raised by you. It could be well worth the feedback and quite insightful for you.

MissingMeadow · 09/11/2026 22:21

Are you the poster who lives in a very messy house and is often posting about tidying up?

If you are then she has a point. If not apologies.

PenelopeFlipFlop · 09/11/2026 22:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.