Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My eldest daughter thinks she can tell me how to raise MY own children??

266 replies

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 14:16

my eldest daughter has really annoyed me today 🙄

she has been having a go at me about how i raise the younger ones, apparently they need more routine and apparently im too soft with them??

she has got children herself so now she thinks shes some sort of parenting expert lol

i have raised my children and i know what im doing. im not saying im perfect because nobody is but they are fed, clothed, loved and looked after so what exactly is the problem??

what annoys me most is she seems to forget who was there when she had her first child. who was up with her, who helped her, who dropped everything when she needed somebody and who was there when she didnt know what she was doing 🤷‍♀️

i certainly wasnt standing over her criticising every little thing she did.

now shes got a few years of being a mum under her belt she thinks she can lecture me about my own household. she was happy enough to come running to me when she needed help but apparently everything i do is wrong now 🙄

ive told her if she doesnt like how i do things then she can stay at her own house. i dont go round telling her how to raise hers so why does she think she can tell me how to raise mine??

at the end of the day im still their mum and i know my own children better than anybody else does.

AIBU to think your grown children shouldnt constantly criticise your parenting??

or am i just expected to sit there and take it because shes my daughter??

OP posts:
DressOrSkirt · 10/11/2026 13:15

PenelopeFlipFlop · 10/11/2026 11:12

Lots of people get on with it. Plenty of people from all sorts of difficult backgrounds, with kids, caring responsibilities, etc all manage to figure it out.

That's great for them. It doesn't mean that everyone has the opportunity to go to uni.

What if they are from a background or religion that doesn't allow women to go to university?
What if they are disabled, or have bad mental health, that prevents them from attending?
What if they have full time caring responsibilities (with no help)?
What if they need to work full time to help their family?
What if they didn't get a good education and don't get accepted anywhere?

PenelopeFlipFlop · 10/11/2026 13:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DressOrSkirt · 10/11/2026 13:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You are just proving how privileged you are if you genuinely think that.

Metromayhem · 10/11/2026 14:06

DressOrSkirt · 10/11/2026 13:44

You are just proving how privileged you are if you genuinely think that.

She doesn’t genuinely think that. She’s definitely rage baiting at this point, I’m just reporting her posts now.

Amegaphone · 10/11/2026 14:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Wonkybaby · 10/11/2026 16:24

If your user name reflects your year of birth, then you were also 16 when you had your oldest. Tbh your daughter is probably hoping there isn’t a third generation of teen parents in the family.

Girlsjustwannahavefunno1 · 10/11/2026 17:51

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 14:16

my eldest daughter has really annoyed me today 🙄

she has been having a go at me about how i raise the younger ones, apparently they need more routine and apparently im too soft with them??

she has got children herself so now she thinks shes some sort of parenting expert lol

i have raised my children and i know what im doing. im not saying im perfect because nobody is but they are fed, clothed, loved and looked after so what exactly is the problem??

what annoys me most is she seems to forget who was there when she had her first child. who was up with her, who helped her, who dropped everything when she needed somebody and who was there when she didnt know what she was doing 🤷‍♀️

i certainly wasnt standing over her criticising every little thing she did.

now shes got a few years of being a mum under her belt she thinks she can lecture me about my own household. she was happy enough to come running to me when she needed help but apparently everything i do is wrong now 🙄

ive told her if she doesnt like how i do things then she can stay at her own house. i dont go round telling her how to raise hers so why does she think she can tell me how to raise mine??

at the end of the day im still their mum and i know my own children better than anybody else does.

AIBU to think your grown children shouldnt constantly criticise your parenting??

or am i just expected to sit there and take it because shes my daughter??

Tell her , "when I want your opinion I will ask for it..."

Bushmillsbabe · 10/11/2026 18:24

PenelopeFlipFlop · 10/11/2026 11:12

Lots of people get on with it. Plenty of people from all sorts of difficult backgrounds, with kids, caring responsibilities, etc all manage to figure it out.

It isn't always that easy. Some health courses are really hard to get into. I applied for physio degree in 2000. There were over 20 thousand applicants for under a thousand places. So 19 thousand didn't get a place. I got straight A's at GCSE and A level, Gold DoE, volunteering experience during my school holidays, glowing school reference, you name it, I had it. I only got 1 offer, friends with similar 'CV's' didn't get any offers. The course was 40 hours a week, 44 weeks a year, moving house every 6 weeks on placements so unable to have a part time job to support living costs. I only managed it with my parents support, as did most of my very 'middle class' cohort.

Bluedenimdoglover · 10/11/2026 18:48

Are the children you have now from a different father and form part of a new relationship? Is your daughter comparing you as a parent now to the time she was at home? Has her own experience of being a very young mother brought her to the belief that a more established routine would benefit her siblings? You need to remember times have changed since you raised your daughter and you have changed, too. It's no judgement on you, but there is no point in posting on here if you expect everyone to agree with your view.

JJWT · 10/11/2026 18:48

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 14:32

where have i said my children dont go to school?? 😂

nobody has said anything about them not attending school so not sure where youve got that from.

they go to school and are looked after, fed and clothed. my daughter is having a go about little things like what they watch on tv and what they eat, not because im neglecting them.

She isn't saying you did. Can you see the word "if"? You are over reacting like mad. I'm hoping we see a post called Should I comment on the way my mum is raising my younger siblings...Then well be able to see both sides!

VeneziaJ · 10/11/2026 18:48

Nobody is a perfect parent! every child will have something they will criticise as adults looking back on their upbringing; and furthermore it is not reasonable to judge previous parenting by todays rules as things change constantly.
When I brought my family up the internet was fairly new and not well established, so a great deal of the information and research available to today’s parents via Google and AI was not available to us

RareJoker · 10/11/2026 19:18

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 19:17

yes she was 16, i am not disputing that she was young. but it was still her body and her decision. what exactly was i supposed to do, force her to live the life you think she should have had??

i guided her as best i could at the time. hindsight is a wonderful thing isnt it. she is 22 now and has her own children, and i have always been there to help her.

you seem to think every decision my daughter has made is proof that ive failed as a parent. i dont agree.

I wonder if your daughter still wants to feel like your daughter from time to time, not just a parent? Maybe she’s projecting. I know you’re both very busy, but would it be worth taking her out for a coffee/cinema date/shopping and reminding her how much you love her equally to the younger ones?
She might just be wanting to still feel loved & protected by you. Talk to her and find out x

Ketzele · 10/11/2026 19:19

devonsevon11 · 09/11/2026 15:44

Your daughter is 22.

Based on your username, are you 38?

which means you had your daughter at 16 and are now already a gran, and also have younger kids as well?

It all sounds pretty chaotic to me to be honest, and I get the impression maybe you should take on board what your daughter is saying.

Some very judgey posts on this thread. OP, my mum and gran were pregnant at the same time twice, and when I broke the family history of young mums by waiting till I was 40 they both turned round and criticised me! Still, there are lots of benefits to doing it their way - not least that I am now in my 60s and my gran is still alive and kicking, and my kids have grown up knowing their gran and great-gran.

Look, none of us can know whether your dd is rightfully pointing out your truly shit parenting, or whether she is using her 'equal' parenting status to have a pop. Mother-daughter dynamics are often fraught, aren't they? My eldest, who is at a good university, has often criticised how I raised her younger sister, who dropped out of school at 14 and has zero GCSEs. I do listen to her, but I am older and wiser and also know that cookie cutter parenting is eaten for breakfast by the range of personalities and needs that different children bring to the table.

In the end, I think your options are to smile every time and say thanks for the advice, or sit her down for a talk about how unhelpful is for her to keep judging you, and remind her how much she'd hate it if you did the same to her. Only you can know which approach will work with her.

Bearbookagainandagain · 10/11/2026 19:27

I think you're right OP.

But that's what older teens and young 20s do, they know better and criticise everything, starting with their parents.

If it wasn't your parenting, it would be how you're cooking, driving, or your hobbies.

I would calmly tell her to mind her own business. It will pass.

YourPlumTree · 10/11/2026 20:42

KittyCattyWoman · 09/11/2026 15:29

Ime, parents that mention their children being ‘fed and clothed’ are usually not great parents. I find it weird that anyone would mention the absolute bare minimum in this way when talking about parenting. There is something ‘off’ about your posts.

Exactly this. She sounds very defensive and her dd probably just wants better for her siblings... Parenting when you're older, but also when you have been doing it for a long time and are stuck in your ways, when standards were probably lower/we knew less, but also now with less energy... not a recipe for strong parenting. Before I read any of the responses I guessed this would be in relation to bad screen time, poor diet and lack of boundaries. Seems I was correct. If you still care, listen to your daughter. She is just starting out and is striving for better.

Nettie1964 · 10/11/2026 20:58

This is the worse platform to ask on.

Airyfairy77 · 10/11/2026 21:48

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:26

granddaughters are 5 and 17m and grandson just turned 4

Yeah sorry, the fact your daughter has 3 kids by 22, 2 of them whilst still a teenager, I’d say you where/are a shit Mum!

GabriellaFaith · 11/11/2026 01:33

My brother is 12 years younger than me. He is now 29. Lives with my parents still or at girlfriends. They are awful parents to him. Way too soft. He has zero responsibility. They bail him out of every stupid decision with no consequences. They make decisions for an easy life. I tell my mum she is doing wrong. She, like you, takes great offense at it and doesn't want to listen and says she must be a great mum because she raised me. One thing that is different though, is that I left home at 16 as I simply couldn't stand being there any more. I had no help unlike your daughter. I put myself through uni and post grad. Took on 2 jobs to clear my debt after and now that I'm doing well in life, through my own hard work, she seems to think it's to her credit.

Anyway, I have gone slightly off topic.

You are being unreasonable in thinking that others cannot speak to you if they think something could be done different for the benefit of the kids. It is only a fool whose pride would stop this. Listening to her does not mean necessarily doing as she suggests, but it certainly warrants conversation as to why she thinks it. Indeed routine is well evidenced to be good for kids, so maybe she has a well reasoned point...

askmenow · 11/11/2026 10:21

Mumsntfan1 · 09/11/2026 14:35

I think that eating, sleeping and what they watch on TV are quite important. If they're staying up late eating sweets while watching rubbish on TV that's not great!

It’s not for the eldest daughter to criticise tho. Her siblings aren’t her children!

She needs to mind her own business. When her own kids are grown then she might be experienced enough to voice an opinion. Until then…..shut it!

Is she saying her mum didn’t do a good enough job on raising her? Thus making her deficient in some way?

God, the brats we raise these days, so damned entitled.

TheDevilWears · 11/11/2026 10:26

I’ve always said that the only people who can judge me as a parent are my DDs. And any criticisms that they want to level at me I will listen to … they’re sixteen and eighteen and often question me on my parenting choices. Maybe stop being so defensive and hear what she has to say. Maybe she’s saying that she wishes you’d provided HER with more routine and guidance … but doesn’t want to hurt your feelings or suspects you will become defensive and re-route back to ‘you were fed, clothed’ etc

OneJollySloth · 11/11/2026 10:37

This is cheeky but are you a bit more lax with the younger 1s than you were with her? I just say that because I remember arguing with my mum cos she let my youngest sister away with murder and she was a lot stricter with me and my big sister. She let my little sister away with walking up and hitting me infront if her, never said a word, then told me she wasn't telling her off because she thought me and my big sister lacked confidence from how she'd raised us so she was trying out something different 🙄🙄 i was probably 12 or 13 and telling her that was ridiculous parenting and still think that now. Not saying that you're doing anything like that but could she be salty cos she felt she had stricter rules? Maybe just the arrogance of youth though.

mondaytosunday · 11/11/2026 10:54

Ha my stepson (who I met when he was 13 and is a dad now) actually texted me about my (then teenage son) who had a pocket knife. He was saying things like how knife crime was bad etc etc, and then said something about him smoking weed… I was like hold on buddy! Who was kicked out of school at 17? Who had a nickname in sixth form because he drank so much? You may be a responsible person at 33 but you sure as hell gave us grief as a teenager!
My son was given the jackknife ( a multi tool kind) from my sister and he uses it mainly as a box cutter at work. He’s certainly had his fair share of trouble but nothing out of the ordinary. I very much resented this man telling me ‘the facts of raising kids’ when I had helped raise him (he lived with us full time), his younger brother plus my own two. I actually didn’t throw those home truths back at him but I was very annoyed (and for all his talk he could have stepped up himself if he thought my son was a bit wayward - their father died when he was very young - but even after I asked for some ‘older brother guidance’ none was forthcoming).
Ooo you’ve hit a nerve with me!

hooverthefloor · 11/11/2026 11:29

Well you raised her, so if she thinks she is so competent at parenting, where did she get those skills from, if not you? Therefore you don't need her advice.

Or if you apparently did such a bad job with her that she has to do everything differently (and thinks you should too), then you must be a lost cause, so there's no point her advising you.

Either way, she should not tell you how to parent if there are no major safeguarding issues.

Is there any chance she feels controlled/criticised by her partner, so is passing that on to you?

SerenaCat93 · 11/11/2026 13:14

hooverthefloor · 11/11/2026 11:29

Well you raised her, so if she thinks she is so competent at parenting, where did she get those skills from, if not you? Therefore you don't need her advice.

Or if you apparently did such a bad job with her that she has to do everything differently (and thinks you should too), then you must be a lost cause, so there's no point her advising you.

Either way, she should not tell you how to parent if there are no major safeguarding issues.

Is there any chance she feels controlled/criticised by her partner, so is passing that on to you?

You can't seriously think having shit parents means you can never be a good parent yourself? Many people parent their children differently after their parents messed up.

hooverthefloor · 11/11/2026 13:21

SerenaCat93 · 11/11/2026 13:14

You can't seriously think having shit parents means you can never be a good parent yourself? Many people parent their children differently after their parents messed up.

Is there any evidence the OP is actually a bad parent? I said if there weren't major safeguarding issues. You don't have to be perfect; just good enough. And there are lots of ways to do that.

And I didn't say that anyway. I said if the eldest daughter was a good parent despite the bad parenting she may think she received (i.e. yes people can do a better job than their own parents), there would likely be no point trying to convince her mother of that at this point.

Swipe left for the next trending thread