Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My eldest daughter thinks she can tell me how to raise MY own children??

266 replies

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 14:16

my eldest daughter has really annoyed me today 🙄

she has been having a go at me about how i raise the younger ones, apparently they need more routine and apparently im too soft with them??

she has got children herself so now she thinks shes some sort of parenting expert lol

i have raised my children and i know what im doing. im not saying im perfect because nobody is but they are fed, clothed, loved and looked after so what exactly is the problem??

what annoys me most is she seems to forget who was there when she had her first child. who was up with her, who helped her, who dropped everything when she needed somebody and who was there when she didnt know what she was doing 🤷‍♀️

i certainly wasnt standing over her criticising every little thing she did.

now shes got a few years of being a mum under her belt she thinks she can lecture me about my own household. she was happy enough to come running to me when she needed help but apparently everything i do is wrong now 🙄

ive told her if she doesnt like how i do things then she can stay at her own house. i dont go round telling her how to raise hers so why does she think she can tell me how to raise mine??

at the end of the day im still their mum and i know my own children better than anybody else does.

AIBU to think your grown children shouldnt constantly criticise your parenting??

or am i just expected to sit there and take it because shes my daughter??

OP posts:
JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:40

oh here we go now apparently everything is my fault because my daughter had children young

she was 16 and 18 when she became a mum to her older 2. i had “boundaries” but what exactly was i supposed to do, lock her up??

she is now 22 and makes her own decisions. im not going to sit here and discuss her personal life to satisfy people on a forum.

ive always helped her with the children and still do. they come here regularly, have tea, stay over and have breakfast here on school mornings. ive never turned them away.

but does that mean i should accept constant criticism from her? apparently im responsible for everything she does now as well as raising my own children.

you can disagree with my parenting without dragging my grandchildren into it.

some of you really do love making assumptions about a family you know absolutely nothing about.

OP posts:
MarcellaGrace · 09/11/2026 18:40

Periperi2025 · 09/11/2026 18:31

I'd say it is a factor in all but a tiny few, and she was not just pregnant at 16/17 she was pregnant AGAIN before she was out of her teens.

16/17 is legally a child in the UK, therefore the parents have a duty of care to that child, and children having children is not a good thing.

Edited

That’s what strikes me here. I would say that having a child, not once but twice, in your teens was a terrible idea.

ChorizoDog · 09/11/2026 18:41

My 23 year old often tells me how to parent my 13 year old. She isn’t a parent but still thinks she’s an authority on the subject 😁

Honestly, I’d pick my battles. Let it go over your head. Or did she touch a nerve?

BillieWiper · 09/11/2026 18:43

Just ignore her. It's her way of trying to kind of level the playing fields and basically criticise the way she parented you, but in real time! She may find it cathartic in some way.

But don't let it annoy you, or pay much heed. As you say, you will parent your remaining kids as you please.

If there is any advice she's giving that might be useful, then it's a shame as you won't listen to it! But presumably you don't want to give advice, nor receive it. Which is up to you.

ICanBuyMyOwnFlowers · 09/11/2026 18:44

OMG! We need to meet up and start a commiserating group. I have 4 kids ranging 10 years in age. The 23 year old is home and has many many many (keep going) opinions on how badly I am parenting my 16 year old. Said 16 year old is, of course, over the bloody moon.

Unlike yours she doesn't even have children of her own, which I have pointed out! But, of course, she knows best!

She's home from Uni and working to save money to go travelling. She plans to get a rental place the moment she gets back. Honestly!!! I'm gritting my teeth. I'd really like her to have the experiences but......

You have my full understanding and sympathy. Sorry for being a late joiner.

SerenaCat93 · 09/11/2026 18:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Periperi2025 · 09/11/2026 18:49

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:40

oh here we go now apparently everything is my fault because my daughter had children young

she was 16 and 18 when she became a mum to her older 2. i had “boundaries” but what exactly was i supposed to do, lock her up??

she is now 22 and makes her own decisions. im not going to sit here and discuss her personal life to satisfy people on a forum.

ive always helped her with the children and still do. they come here regularly, have tea, stay over and have breakfast here on school mornings. ive never turned them away.

but does that mean i should accept constant criticism from her? apparently im responsible for everything she does now as well as raising my own children.

you can disagree with my parenting without dragging my grandchildren into it.

some of you really do love making assumptions about a family you know absolutely nothing about.

Your DD had a child when she was a child, that is very different to 'had children young'. Your parenting will have influenced her risk of teen pregnancy.
Maybe she is trying to tell you something with her constant criticisms, and her insights as a parent herself, why not listen to what she has to say and learn something so that you don't make the same mistakes again with your younger kids.

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:52

SerenaCat93 · 09/11/2026 18:05

Why have you both got primary school age children? That's odd.

my son is only about 9 months older than my eldest granddaughter so what exactly do you expect me to do?? 😂

he was already born when i found out dd was pregnant. i cant exactly change the dates can i??

yes its an unusual situation but they are both my children/grandchildren and i love them both. not really sure what you want me to say.

this is supposed to be about my daughter constantly criticising my parenting, not everybody investigating our family tree

OP posts:
AltitudeCheck · 09/11/2026 18:52

PenelopeFlipFlop · 09/11/2026 17:25

How are you still a band 4 😂

Each job in the NHS is given a pay band (or bands) you don't just keep going up the bands, if the job you do is a band 4 job, then that's what it is.

lifedilemmasmakemetired · 09/11/2026 18:53

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 14:22

its not even big things though its little things like what they watch on tv, what they eat, what time they go to bed etc 🙄

apparently everything needs to be done differently and she doesnt agree with how i do certain things.
but what gets me is shes soon quick enough to ring me when she wants somebody to have the children or pick them up from school isnt she??

if im that bad at raising children why am i the first person she contacts when she needs help??

Why can't it be both?

Why can't she share her honest options with you, and then you say 'oh yes interesting, however I find that...:

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HAHAHA chavvy because im not middle class is it?? 😂😂

honestly some of these comments are ridiculous. apparently because i dont write like im submitting an essay and dont live some picture perfect middle class lifestyle that makes me a bad mum??

my daughter made her own decisions. ive never claimed she made every decision right but shes an adult now and im not going to spend my life taking responsibility for everything she does.

and whats wrong with my daughter coming round?? shes my daughter, those are my grandchildren. sorry for actually having a relationship with my family and helping each other out.

youve decided my whole family are badly brought up because of our ages and the way we speak.

you dont know us so perhaps stop pretending you do.

OP posts:
Bushmillsbabe · 09/11/2026 19:00

PenelopeFlipFlop · 09/11/2026 17:25

How are you still a band 4 😂

All band 4 means is that someone doesn't have a degree/isn't qualified. They may still be an able experienced, skilled therapy assistant/nursing assistant.

Not everyone gets the chance to go to uni, or could get in. A full time B4 post pays around 30k, not much lower than national average salary

Isthisit22 · 09/11/2026 19:05

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:59

HAHAHA chavvy because im not middle class is it?? 😂😂

honestly some of these comments are ridiculous. apparently because i dont write like im submitting an essay and dont live some picture perfect middle class lifestyle that makes me a bad mum??

my daughter made her own decisions. ive never claimed she made every decision right but shes an adult now and im not going to spend my life taking responsibility for everything she does.

and whats wrong with my daughter coming round?? shes my daughter, those are my grandchildren. sorry for actually having a relationship with my family and helping each other out.

youve decided my whole family are badly brought up because of our ages and the way we speak.

you dont know us so perhaps stop pretending you do.

The more you type the worse a parent you sound.
16 is a child. She was too young to ‘make her own decisions’ to have a child. It’s your job to bring your children up with aspirations and guide them to good choices.
It sounds like she’s trying to warn you that your lax parenting, lack of boundaries and guidance will lead to the same not great outcomes that she’s had.

MsPrufrockk · 09/11/2026 19:07

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:40

oh here we go now apparently everything is my fault because my daughter had children young

she was 16 and 18 when she became a mum to her older 2. i had “boundaries” but what exactly was i supposed to do, lock her up??

she is now 22 and makes her own decisions. im not going to sit here and discuss her personal life to satisfy people on a forum.

ive always helped her with the children and still do. they come here regularly, have tea, stay over and have breakfast here on school mornings. ive never turned them away.

but does that mean i should accept constant criticism from her? apparently im responsible for everything she does now as well as raising my own children.

you can disagree with my parenting without dragging my grandchildren into it.

some of you really do love making assumptions about a family you know absolutely nothing about.

I suspect that now she's a mother, she sees where you went wrong with her, and wants her siblings to have a better chance of doing things differently. I'm sure it's annoying, but why not use it as an opportunity to have a real soul search about where this might be coming from.

SerenaCat93 · 09/11/2026 19:09

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:59

HAHAHA chavvy because im not middle class is it?? 😂😂

honestly some of these comments are ridiculous. apparently because i dont write like im submitting an essay and dont live some picture perfect middle class lifestyle that makes me a bad mum??

my daughter made her own decisions. ive never claimed she made every decision right but shes an adult now and im not going to spend my life taking responsibility for everything she does.

and whats wrong with my daughter coming round?? shes my daughter, those are my grandchildren. sorry for actually having a relationship with my family and helping each other out.

youve decided my whole family are badly brought up because of our ages and the way we speak.

you dont know us so perhaps stop pretending you do.

No, chavvy because of the way you come across and your family circumstances/behaviour.

Nothing to do with not middle class. I know plenty of working class people, I wouldn't describe any of them as chavvy. I knew some chavvy families at school though.

MarcellaGrace · 09/11/2026 19:10

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 18:59

HAHAHA chavvy because im not middle class is it?? 😂😂

honestly some of these comments are ridiculous. apparently because i dont write like im submitting an essay and dont live some picture perfect middle class lifestyle that makes me a bad mum??

my daughter made her own decisions. ive never claimed she made every decision right but shes an adult now and im not going to spend my life taking responsibility for everything she does.

and whats wrong with my daughter coming round?? shes my daughter, those are my grandchildren. sorry for actually having a relationship with my family and helping each other out.

youve decided my whole family are badly brought up because of our ages and the way we speak.

you dont know us so perhaps stop pretending you do.

If she had a child before she stopped being a child herself, that’s on you, though.

Metromayhem · 09/11/2026 19:11

Bushmillsbabe · 09/11/2026 19:00

All band 4 means is that someone doesn't have a degree/isn't qualified. They may still be an able experienced, skilled therapy assistant/nursing assistant.

Not everyone gets the chance to go to uni, or could get in. A full time B4 post pays around 30k, not much lower than national average salary

Thank you. I got the impression that poster was sneering at me, I gave her the option to clarify which she’s chosen to ignore, so I assume I was correct in my initial assumption.
Being a band four is my own choice. I am in a position in life now where I feasibly could go to uni, but decided the training and additional responsibilities weren’t worth the (IMO) minimal pay increase. I love my job, I take my hat off to the HCPs I work with, but am happy where I am. I think I earn ok, too- not megabucks by MN standards but I can afford to pay my own rent 😉 😊

Periperi2025 · 09/11/2026 19:17

Bushmillsbabe · 09/11/2026 19:00

All band 4 means is that someone doesn't have a degree/isn't qualified. They may still be an able experienced, skilled therapy assistant/nursing assistant.

Not everyone gets the chance to go to uni, or could get in. A full time B4 post pays around 30k, not much lower than national average salary

It's £10k less than national average salary, it was in the news today that it is now over £40k. Which means you need to be mid point of Band 6 (assuming no unsocial hours) to be earning above the national average now!! Which is shocking.

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 19:17

Isthisit22 · 09/11/2026 19:05

The more you type the worse a parent you sound.
16 is a child. She was too young to ‘make her own decisions’ to have a child. It’s your job to bring your children up with aspirations and guide them to good choices.
It sounds like she’s trying to warn you that your lax parenting, lack of boundaries and guidance will lead to the same not great outcomes that she’s had.

yes she was 16, i am not disputing that she was young. but it was still her body and her decision. what exactly was i supposed to do, force her to live the life you think she should have had??

i guided her as best i could at the time. hindsight is a wonderful thing isnt it. she is 22 now and has her own children, and i have always been there to help her.

you seem to think every decision my daughter has made is proof that ive failed as a parent. i dont agree.

OP posts:
ColdAsAWitches · 09/11/2026 19:17

Error404FucksNotFound · 09/11/2026 17:00

Tell her to pack it in.
The only bigger expert in child rearing than a new parent is someone who's never had any.

I cringe when I remember some of the bullshit I came out with when my sister had her baby.

She was delighted to be able to remind me of it all as my own kids grew up.

She's not a new mother though, she's got THREE of her own. So given her experience of her own kids, and how she was brought up by her mother, I wouldn't automatically discount everything she says, the way you think should happen.

zingally · 09/11/2026 19:19

Next time she does it, I'd just give her a faintly quizzical look and just say, "This is the way I've always done it... I did it like this with you, and you turned out okay."
And from that point on, ignore.
It's not worth falling out over, and likely will stop the next time she enters one of the trickier stages of parenting, like the teen years. It sounds like her kids are in the primary years, when it is actually pretty easy, compared to the baby and teen eras.

Metromayhem · 09/11/2026 19:19

Periperi2025 · 09/11/2026 19:17

It's £10k less than national average salary, it was in the news today that it is now over £40k. Which means you need to be mid point of Band 6 (assuming no unsocial hours) to be earning above the national average now!! Which is shocking.

I think she was just defending me from a poster who was sneering at me for being a band four. I do agree with you about skilled/qualified HCPs earning below average earnings is shocking.

Periperi2025 · 09/11/2026 19:20

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 19:17

yes she was 16, i am not disputing that she was young. but it was still her body and her decision. what exactly was i supposed to do, force her to live the life you think she should have had??

i guided her as best i could at the time. hindsight is a wonderful thing isnt it. she is 22 now and has her own children, and i have always been there to help her.

you seem to think every decision my daughter has made is proof that ive failed as a parent. i dont agree.

It's how you raise kids all through childhood that protects them at 16, this is what she is trying to tell you NOW while her younger siblings are still little.

So what 'hindsight' have you learnt from?! It doesn't sound like much form this thread.

CaffeinatedMum · 09/11/2026 19:24

zingally · 09/11/2026 19:19

Next time she does it, I'd just give her a faintly quizzical look and just say, "This is the way I've always done it... I did it like this with you, and you turned out okay."
And from that point on, ignore.
It's not worth falling out over, and likely will stop the next time she enters one of the trickier stages of parenting, like the teen years. It sounds like her kids are in the primary years, when it is actually pretty easy, compared to the baby and teen eras.

I wouldn’t call three kids by 22, and becoming a mum at 16 ok….

DressOrSkirt · 09/11/2026 19:25

JustAskingReally88 · 09/11/2026 19:17

yes she was 16, i am not disputing that she was young. but it was still her body and her decision. what exactly was i supposed to do, force her to live the life you think she should have had??

i guided her as best i could at the time. hindsight is a wonderful thing isnt it. she is 22 now and has her own children, and i have always been there to help her.

you seem to think every decision my daughter has made is proof that ive failed as a parent. i dont agree.

As you say, hindsight is a wonderful thing. Use it while raising your younger children.