Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sis said no to plus one at Xmas?

443 replies

Menopausalinsommniac · 09/11/2026 07:33

This Xmas we having lunch at a family members house then they will come to my house for the evening. Food etc at both events and workload are shared between us. They are a family of five (mum, dad & kids). My side there’s me & my kids (I’m single). I had mentioned to a friend who is on alone that they may be able to join us for the day but my family members have said that they can’t come to their house for lunch but it’s ok if I want them at mine in the evening. I feel that I should be able to bring a plus one, even if it’s not a partner? I know I should have asked first but isn’t that a bit unreasonable of them?

OP posts:
Talkingtomyhouseplants · 10/11/2026 20:05

Aluna · 10/11/2026 20:01

Right. I don’t even know where that’s a thing.

I think it’s just people making things up to suit the narrative of “it can’t possibly be done”. Most things can be done if you want to, they just don’t want to.

Anarchy99 · 10/11/2026 20:32

AnotherAnnie · 10/11/2026 18:07

You are right that my use of 'ours' was wrong, apologies. We do a similar shared welcoming Christmas in my family. Sisters, shared workload, food, and household switching. No-fault provisional plus-one invites, even. So I doubt the OP's sister meant to be unkind to the OP or her friend about the plus-one; it sounds to me like even if the reason is not shared, the OP can trust her sister has made a good call for her place.

The OP has explained that the friend is free that day. I'm wondering why so many read it as pity. OP could have made many other suggestions if she had not wanted her friend there.

Finding out the friend is free and instantly wishing to include them seems to demonstrate that the friend is someone they want to spend time with, and that they are welcome and valued. It honestly reads to me as a spontaneous moment, not a dutiful "let's invite poor Rolando" exercise.

There’s a difference between ‘I wonder what Rolando is doing for Christmas as I would love to
host him if he’s alone - he’s a great bloke’ and ‘Oh Rolando is alone, I will invite him to my sister’s house because I feel sorry for him, even though the host hasn’t suggested people being randomers with them’.

Anarchy99 · 10/11/2026 20:36

Momtotwokids · 10/11/2026 18:21

My son asked to bring a female friend and her 3 kids and the answer was of course. So many of you are so uptight. It is Christmas and being kind costs nothing.

Well hosting another five people would have cost, if they ate or drank anything. It sounds like an arseache but I’m sure you looked like a saint for doing it.

You invite strangers if you like,
but judging people for doing things differently seems a little unkind as well 🤣

Newname26 · 10/11/2026 21:46

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 10/11/2026 18:28

It doesn’t really at Christmas - people always have way more food than they need anyway

You are the only person who thinks that, I cater for the numbers I have and a bit extra to cover boxing day.

I was disgusted the year the food bin was filled with enough food to feed a family.
It was a pure waste in terms of food, and a pure waste of money.
I cut back the year after that, dead easy to look back at what you ordered last year and adjust as necessary.

Newname26 · 10/11/2026 21:55

Aluna · 10/11/2026 19:16

That’s rather my point. Life isn’t predictable so don’t put in a non-updatable Christmas order at the start of November.

I don't think you can add 2 pints of human blood to the Christmas order.

However Santa did manage to deliver it.
And thats part of the serious blessing not the serious shit.

After the order was collected, different events on different years.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 10/11/2026 22:11

Newname26 · 10/11/2026 21:46

You are the only person who thinks that, I cater for the numbers I have and a bit extra to cover boxing day.

I was disgusted the year the food bin was filled with enough food to feed a family.
It was a pure waste in terms of food, and a pure waste of money.
I cut back the year after that, dead easy to look back at what you ordered last year and adjust as necessary.

I don’t know why you think that just because there is extra food, it goes in the bin? I assure you I am not the “only one” and it is in fact perfectly normal to have lots of food left over at Christmas - it’s why there are whole sections of recipe websites and books dedicated to it

Newname26 · 10/11/2026 22:53

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 10/11/2026 22:11

I don’t know why you think that just because there is extra food, it goes in the bin? I assure you I am not the “only one” and it is in fact perfectly normal to have lots of food left over at Christmas - it’s why there are whole sections of recipe websites and books dedicated to it

Well you aren't doing anything else with it if it has been on plates.

Harry12345 · 11/11/2026 00:28

NormasArse · 10/11/2026 18:27

Ahhh, the season of goodwill!

Goodwill can come in different ways. I work in social care, cared all my life for an autistic child, caring now for unwell parent, give to charity, litter pick, donate to foodbanks and Xmas parents appeal but I don’t want a stranger in my home for dinner, it makes me uncomfortable and that’s ok, doesn’t mean I’m unkind

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 11/11/2026 03:37

Harry12345 · 11/11/2026 00:28

Goodwill can come in different ways. I work in social care, cared all my life for an autistic child, caring now for unwell parent, give to charity, litter pick, donate to foodbanks and Xmas parents appeal but I don’t want a stranger in my home for dinner, it makes me uncomfortable and that’s ok, doesn’t mean I’m unkind

But you would be being unkind in that specific circumstance

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 11/11/2026 03:37

Newname26 · 10/11/2026 22:53

Well you aren't doing anything else with it if it has been on plates.

Don’t put it all on plates then?

DeftGoldHedgehog · 11/11/2026 03:59

Aluna · 10/11/2026 19:16

That’s rather my point. Life isn’t predictable so don’t put in a non-updatable Christmas order at the start of November.

I booked my Christmas slot with Tesco last week. The delivery be amended up to midnight the day before. Which are these supermarkets with "non-updatable" orders, please? The only orders you can't amend are usually for specific things like the actual turkey. Ordering in advance doesn't necessarily mean more waste.

Dontevenlookatme · 11/11/2026 04:07

YABU to offer someone else’s hospitality. Leave your sister’s family to have the Christmas they want. Invite the friend to yours for the whole day.

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 11/11/2026 04:17

I am not rich, but I have an open door policy for those who want or need somewhere to go in the holidays.

I have a 1000 sq foot condo and host around 30 people every year.

I didn’t have family around growing up ( in care ) so I have a soft spot for people who are alone. One day it might be me who once again wants somewhere to go. Or maybe one day my kid will?

Pinkissmart · 11/11/2026 06:42

What a shame. Flies in the face of what Christmas is all about. I hope they never have to be alone at Christmas. You’re a lovely friend for caring

Newname26 · 11/11/2026 07:30

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 11/11/2026 03:37

Don’t put it all on plates then?

We no longer do, but we also cut back how much we order.

You keep saying everyone has loads food. You probably have only experienced Christmas in a few households or families you actually can't say that everyone has loads of food.

And as I say it might appear that families have tons left, they may well have planned it that way, it's not unusual to buy a bit extra to cover Boxing Day.

Extra folk on Christmas Day means I'd need to buy more for Boxing Day.

Newname26 · 11/11/2026 07:44

DeftGoldHedgehog · 11/11/2026 03:59

I booked my Christmas slot with Tesco last week. The delivery be amended up to midnight the day before. Which are these supermarkets with "non-updatable" orders, please? The only orders you can't amend are usually for specific things like the actual turkey. Ordering in advance doesn't necessarily mean more waste.

I said I've never had enough warning to do anything with my order.

What I was hinting at is I've had serious shit & serious blessing on Christmas Eve, (and minor shit on Christmas Day)
All different years.

Dontevenlookatme · 11/11/2026 08:31

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 11/11/2026 03:37

But you would be being unkind in that specific circumstance

Oh what nonsense. It isn’t unkind not to want a stranger at your Christmas dinner. It very much depends on the stranger.

My late grandmother, a widow with two young daughters, was someone to take pity on people at Christmas and often invited them to join.

Her daughters hated it, what they wanted was to spend Christmas as their small family unit with their mother, not make awkward conversation with someone they didn’t know.

Harry12345 · 11/11/2026 08:48

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 11/11/2026 03:37

But you would be being unkind in that specific circumstance

I disagree, it’s a very normal boundary to have, putting yourself out and affecting your own mental health wouldn’t be kind to my children that day. I get very nervous with people in my home, being kind to myself and family is more important than a strangers needs

AnotherAnnie · 11/11/2026 10:06

Anarchy99 · 10/11/2026 20:32

There’s a difference between ‘I wonder what Rolando is doing for Christmas as I would love to
host him if he’s alone - he’s a great bloke’ and ‘Oh Rolando is alone, I will invite him to my sister’s house because I feel sorry for him, even though the host hasn’t suggested people being randomers with them’.

Edited

I disagree with this perspective. To me it wouldn't be seen as impolite or high-stakes for sisters to confer about whether to bring a plus-one.

"Food etc at both events and workload are shared between us."
There is no problem with buying food, and the sister's house is described as "They have a huge home, there will be more than enough food.." Both sisters have a say in both the day and evening guest lists as they share the food and work. That includes a right to both ask and decline. The OP explains everyone is fine with a provisional invitation and then checking—including the sister:

"I don’t think the issue is that I didn’t ask first. My sis wasn’t bothered about that. And we are typically an informal, very social, big family."

The OP explains that on finding the friend was free she wanted them to be her plus-one, so she impulsively asked:
"The conversation/invitation was spur of the moment and the friend understands that I needed to ask my sister and that it might not happen so no awkwardness there."
That reads to me as the OP didn't have to check first out of worry for feelings if it didn't happen, as it was equal friends wondering if they can hang out, not about supporting a vulnerable person or anything like pity.
The OP could have easily kept the conversation going, or shared commiserations or ideas to do other things, without an invitation ever being needed.

Newname26 · 11/11/2026 10:34

AnotherAnnie · 11/11/2026 10:06

I disagree with this perspective. To me it wouldn't be seen as impolite or high-stakes for sisters to confer about whether to bring a plus-one.

"Food etc at both events and workload are shared between us."
There is no problem with buying food, and the sister's house is described as "They have a huge home, there will be more than enough food.." Both sisters have a say in both the day and evening guest lists as they share the food and work. That includes a right to both ask and decline. The OP explains everyone is fine with a provisional invitation and then checking—including the sister:

"I don’t think the issue is that I didn’t ask first. My sis wasn’t bothered about that. And we are typically an informal, very social, big family."

The OP explains that on finding the friend was free she wanted them to be her plus-one, so she impulsively asked:
"The conversation/invitation was spur of the moment and the friend understands that I needed to ask my sister and that it might not happen so no awkwardness there."
That reads to me as the OP didn't have to check first out of worry for feelings if it didn't happen, as it was equal friends wondering if they can hang out, not about supporting a vulnerable person or anything like pity.
The OP could have easily kept the conversation going, or shared commiserations or ideas to do other things, without an invitation ever being needed.

Edited

Its not impolite to ask, she asked was told no, end off.

We only have the Ops thoughts we don't have the Sisters or BILs (remember its his house too) thoughts.

There could be tons of reasons to say No and actually its probably a combination of reasons, not just one.

sammylady37 · 11/11/2026 12:39

I spend Christmas alone now, by choice. I love it. It’s peaceful, quiet and there’s nobody to be pandered to. Every year, I get multiple invitations to people’s houses. It’s very easy tell which are genuine ones and which are offered out of pity, with a ‘oh we hate to think of you on your own’ preface, and a ‘waifs and strays’ attitude. I will never accept a pity invite, I can think of nothing worse than sitting around a dinner table knowing I was not genuinely wanted there.

Timeforachange26 · 11/11/2026 18:30

KilkennyCats · 09/11/2026 17:21

No, of course you don’t bring a “plus one”, (aka complete random) to someone else’s home.
Partners are completely different.

Why would it be different? If the OP had met their partner 6 months ago and the sil have never met them it would be ok ? Yet a friend the SIL has met is a no no?

Anarchy99 · 11/11/2026 19:09

Newname26 · 11/11/2026 10:34

Its not impolite to ask, she asked was told no, end off.

We only have the Ops thoughts we don't have the Sisters or BILs (remember its his house too) thoughts.

There could be tons of reasons to say No and actually its probably a combination of reasons, not just one.

It absolutely is impolite to ask.

I was taught that you don’t ask for yourself or someone else to be invited somewhere, and you don’t attend if you are just being asked for the sake of politeness.

If in doubt - don’t do it!

KilkennyCats · 11/11/2026 19:27

Timeforachange26 · 11/11/2026 18:30

Why would it be different? If the OP had met their partner 6 months ago and the sil have never met them it would be ok ? Yet a friend the SIL has met is a no no?

Edited

Because partners are a unit who would presumably be spending Christmas together so you can hardly just ask one half?

Newname26 · 11/11/2026 21:18

Anarchy99 · 11/11/2026 19:09

It absolutely is impolite to ask.

I was taught that you don’t ask for yourself or someone else to be invited somewhere, and you don’t attend if you are just being asked for the sake of politeness.

If in doubt - don’t do it!

Maybe it depends how the question is asked.

I've been in the sisters shoes and asked was it ok if friend came, if its an issue they'd host, we normally split the food bill anyway. They are pretty hands on guests so not really adding to my work load.

I've also had someone, weeks after the invite, say they'd come if they could they bring another family of 4, no softening it with offer of chipping in or not to worry if it doesn't work etc.
They aren't the sort to volunteer to put the kettle on or fill a crisp bowl, they are sit back and be hosted sort of people.

One I said yes to the other I said no to.