Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 12:56

Rootsinmydreamland · 09/11/2026 12:50

Before you leap to the OP's defence, please may I recommend reading all of her posts on this thread in which she appears to suggest that it is a person's moral duty to kill themself as soon as they become ill or disabled in any way in order not to become a burden to their loved ones. Just thought you may wish to be fully aware of the extent of the OP's views before you endorse them.

That is exactly why I was asking

Not got time to read whole thread and op answers on any thread can be taken out of context if you only read op post not person they are answering

Thank you for your own response

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 13:02

Valeriekat · 09/11/2026 12:13

I don't think that you understand the nature of dementia.

People with early stage dementia are still capable of making legally valid decisions.

OP posts:
Cheese55 · 09/11/2026 13:04

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:44

Taking it is the rational choice in that situation, though. Everyone is free to be irrational but the sane should not be denied an escape from the horror.

I've worked with people with dementia for 30 years. I'm not saying it isn't a horror for some, but some people can still experience pleasure and can be content . They're not all crying in the corner wanting to die.

Cheese55 · 09/11/2026 13:09

Loveofeclairs · 09/11/2026 12:05

I’ve always been in favour of legalising assisted dying. This thread has convinced me that society is not ready for it. The amount of posters who see it as an easy out when people are no longer able to consent is worrying. What about the HCPs who’d have to carry out the procedure on patients while they’re kicking and screaming, incapable of understanding what was happening? Also, such a system could be abused by unscrupulous relatives who don’t want their inheritance wasted on grandma’s care.

Then there are those PPs who’d happily get rid of anyone who’s a ‘burden’ to society. I think there’s a name for that 🤔

Assisted dying should be available to consenting adults only or not at all.

I think it would only be for those consenting to it, otherwise it is murder surely.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 09/11/2026 13:10

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/11/2026 12:30

I don’t see that they HAVE to!

A favourite aunt of mine (80s with dementia) was refusing food and drink during the umpteenth UTI. I was asked by care home staff whether we wanted her taken to hospital for ABs and fluids in drips, - otherwise she would very likely, very soon, die.

I could only ask the GP what he’d do if it were his much loved aunt. He said he’d leave her where she was, where they’d keep her comfortable. The situation was only going to arise again, probably very soon, since she’d always been prone to UTIs.

It ws a horrible decision to have to take, but I knew it was almost certainly what my aunt’s former self would have wanted.

Plus there’s the fact that hospital is in any case a terrible place for anyone with dementia, when they can’t understand what is going on or why, and are endlessly e.g. trying to pull drips out and/or dressings off.

My aunt continued to refuse food and drink. I sat with her a lot during that last week, she was apparently asleep and unresponsive nearly all the time, and she drifted away quite peacefully. The care home staff were wonderful, and did whatever they could to keep her comfortable - keeping her mouth moist, etc.

I would do exactly the same again, in similar circumstances.

They have to treat them as a duty of care. As long as they are not dying as in cardiac arrest. Most patients have a dnr in place but the illnesses and infections are treatable. A Doctor cannot decide to not treat a treatable illness.
I have a distant family member who was in a terrible accident 21 years ago. He is tube fed, in 24/7 care, he has no awareness or functioning body movements, his veins are damaged by antibiotic treatment but he hasn’t died and isn’t ready to die as he was extremely fit when the accident occurred. He has be treated for all kind of infections, daily physical therapy. His family knows that he wouldn’t want this but as a 42 man, he might have many years in that situation.
When do Doctor’s start the decision making? When they arrive by ambulance in a state that their quality of life is gone? Or in this case, 21 years later? There is so many grey areas.
This is the case either the patients my sister works with although they’re older.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 09/11/2026 13:12

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 13:02

People with early stage dementia are still capable of making legally valid decisions.

Sadly if they don’t want to do it immediately, the family can’t help when the time comes and the person won’t remember what they had planned. 😪

Scarlettpixie · 09/11/2026 13:16

While I agree in principle with assisted dying. Many people with dementia will have lost capacity before they are diagnosed. Then it becomes much more complicated. My mum had progressive vascular dementia. It had been coming on for a good while before she ended up in hospital with a UTI and deteriorated to the point that she could not return home. Despite regular attendance at clinics for the elderly, no one attempted to diagnose her. We just put steps in place to manage her cognitive issues. She lived with me for 2 years and would for example not know what to eat for dinner, even if there was only meal ready for her in the fridge so if I were to be late home, I would leave her post it. She was unable to accept change or understand new instructions. We had to look for simple phones, microwave and TV as she could not cope with change. At that stage though, she still had quality of life and would not have wanted to die.

When she was first in hospital she was asked about a DNR and refused. Later after she was much much worse, and after some time in a care home I put one in place. She didn't know what was coming. She did not decline slowly like some do, into a forgetful old lady, she was unreasonable, thought she could walk when she couldn't due to balance and signalling issues (so seriously at risk of falls and had a few), didn't know where she was, was angry, confused and frustrated sometimes resulting in aggression and violence. She repeatedly asked to go home and was under DOLs for many months. She would mistake people she didn't know for someone she did and be angry when they ignored her. She would ask strangers and other visitors to help her get to the bus stop. She thought everyone was being horrible.

She had frequent UTIs that caused her to shout for the toilet incessantly even when she had just been. Both in hospital and initially in care, she required round the clock 1:1 care and was unable to sleep. This improved with medication but at times she was barely functioning and it took time to get the balance right. The first year was hell. There was one visit where she became distraught and repeated said 'kill me, kill me, kill me'. I never told anyone but that has haunted me ever since. She later stopped recognising people, didn't know much of what was going on and as a result was much calmer. She was smiley at staff and glad to be back after a hospital visit. But - she was incontinent and on a soft diet so had thickened drinks and liquid medicines. She became distressed when people were trying to care for her and was not able to get pleasure from anything although sometimes, there would be a glimmer of recognition when I visited and my young son could usually raise a big smile.

So in answer to your question, yes I think people should be able to choose assisted dying when they get a diagnosis of dementia, while they still have capacity but this won't help a lot of dementia sufferers who will have lost capacity before diagnosis. I think it is a whole different bunch of ethics if you start allowing NOK or Drs to make those decision. I found agreeing to the DNR hard enough.

I also want to add that despite the difficult two years we experienced, my mum did have a peaceful death. I got a call to say the Dr had been out and she had pneumonia. She was awake but unresponsive when I arrived. The Dr called again later that day and we discussed hospital and agreed it was not in her best interests. They stopped her medication and plans were put in place to get out of hours to provide morphine if needed. It wasn't. I sat through the night watching her breathing change and slow, holding her hand and talking to her. She died the next morning. It was calm and peaceful. As death goes, it was probably as good as it gets.

I have told my son that I don't expect him to care for me if I can't look after myself. All I ask is that he find me a nice care home, come and see me now and again and never feel guilty.

If the law changes, it will be gradual but I suppose it may eventually reach a point where someone can pre-plan for assisted dying if they get to a certain point medically and no longer have capacity to decide in the moment. I think there would need to be additional safeguards so medical support and consent of the NOK would also be required. I think that would be reasonable. Having seen what my mum went through, I would be keen to have something like this in place if it was available.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 13:19

EmeraldShamrock000 · 09/11/2026 13:10

They have to treat them as a duty of care. As long as they are not dying as in cardiac arrest. Most patients have a dnr in place but the illnesses and infections are treatable. A Doctor cannot decide to not treat a treatable illness.
I have a distant family member who was in a terrible accident 21 years ago. He is tube fed, in 24/7 care, he has no awareness or functioning body movements, his veins are damaged by antibiotic treatment but he hasn’t died and isn’t ready to die as he was extremely fit when the accident occurred. He has be treated for all kind of infections, daily physical therapy. His family knows that he wouldn’t want this but as a 42 man, he might have many years in that situation.
When do Doctor’s start the decision making? When they arrive by ambulance in a state that their quality of life is gone? Or in this case, 21 years later? There is so many grey areas.
This is the case either the patients my sister works with although they’re older.

Edited

Yes - we have a DNR for my mum, but that doesn't mean her illnesses are not treated. On the contrary, we try to get treatment as promptly as we can because ensuring her physical comfort is one of the last things we can still do for her to keep her as contented as possible. She can't communicate pain or discomfort in words so we have to err on the side of caution.

The DNR as we understand it means what it says - if her heart stops beating, it should not be restarted by artificial means.

Otherwise she receives medical care as normal.

Scarlettpixie · 09/11/2026 13:36

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 21:17

kicking out, scratching, pulling my face away from them, clamping my mouth shut... followed by crying, screaming, begging them not to kill me, saying "I've changed my mind", "would you hold your own mother down and kill her", "murderers, you just like killing old ladies", "please, please don't kill me, I don't want to die....", "help me..."

Might cause a bit of distress to the person who is expected to just get on with it.

Some dementia patients including my mum act like this around medication anyway. My mum was on a covert policy for a while due to refusal. I had to consent to them hiding medication in her food. She thought people were trying to poison her. You can trick people under the currently laws but not hold them down and force them.

Newsenmum · 09/11/2026 13:41

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 12:24

If that is what a person chooses to do after a cooling off period I have no problem with that. They have no idea how fast their condition will progress and may not want to get to a place where they can no longer make a rational decision. Time frames given are educated guesses and statistics based rather than fact. Everyone will progress at different speeds.

Ought is tea key word here obviously. Has the op said they ought to be able to do so (as in be allowed) or have they said a person ought to do so (as in they should)?

As in they should.

Wordsmithery · 09/11/2026 13:53

I think you're oversimplifying the argument, OP.

I imagine most people would agree that it's kinder to give terminal (including dementia) patients the right to choose how and when they die. But the devil is in the detail.

When does the patient consent to euthanasia? If they consent after diagnosis, are they in sound mind? When do you administer the drug? Presumably you wait till the individual has little or no quality of life - but how do we know this?

This is a moral minefield and if we get it wrong then we fail to safeguard our most vulnerable.

So in principle yes I agree but at the same time I think it's right that our lawmakers debate long and hard.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 09/11/2026 13:54

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 13:19

Yes - we have a DNR for my mum, but that doesn't mean her illnesses are not treated. On the contrary, we try to get treatment as promptly as we can because ensuring her physical comfort is one of the last things we can still do for her to keep her as contented as possible. She can't communicate pain or discomfort in words so we have to err on the side of caution.

The DNR as we understand it means what it says - if her heart stops beating, it should not be restarted by artificial means.

Otherwise she receives medical care as normal.

I know that. I am hopeful if the assisted dying bill is available that families can make the choice, like they can make the choice of a dnr.
With medical professionals and legal experts.
As in my cousins case, his parents can’t make that decision, he hasn’t got capacity so he has to live his life in a residential setting with no awareness about his surroundings.

The patient has to die or be close to it in order for no resuscitation. I believe it is the kindest thing to do. A lot of families confuse the dnr as no treatment for illnesses and refuse it.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/11/2026 13:55

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 12:33

This hospital having to treat or at least keep people alive longer via feeding tubes, fluid drips is the reason why so many uncomfortable home deaths happen

If at home you can choose along with the GP to have no intervention bar pain relief. However this is essentially starving and dehydrating someone to death. It has happened in the end with the majority of home deaths I know. The person stops eating then no intervention. It can take up to 12 days for someone to die like this. I want to be able to choose how I die thanks.

As some. doctor once put it, ‘They are not dying because they are not eating and drinking. They are not eating and drinking because they are dying.’

At some point the body’s organs stop being able to process food and drink, but this is very often misunderstood by relatives, who try to insist on drips, tube feeding, etc., and protest that their loved one is being callously starved to death.

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 14:08

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 09:46

Sorry, but this falls under the 'tell us something we don't already know' heading.

From your link:

While there is no cure for dementia, up to 45% of the risks can be attributed to modifiable risk factors such as tobacco, alcohol use, social isolation, physical inactivity, air pollution and noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), including high blood pressure and diabetes.

Lead a healthy lifestyle and you're less likely to get ill. There's a surprise.

My parents -

  • neither of them smoked at all; or drank alcohol more than once or twice a year
  • they were extremely sociable until dementia shrank their worlds, active members of various clubs and societies including chairperson and treasurer positions
  • they were physically active - my mum used a gym and my dad cycled.
  • Neither has ever been overweight and their diet was healthy, home cooked food, very rarely fast food or takeaways, meat and two veg as was normal for their generation
  • Neither is diabetic
  • My mum had high blood pressure but it was controlled by medication
  • My dad has pretty much never had a day's illness in his life. He's never even had Covid even though he was going to the supermarket twice a week on the bus all through the height of the pandemic
  • Pollution is outside their control, but they don't live in a big city or heavy urban traffic area
  • Both retired early with the golden pensions common to their age group

Both now have dementia, my mum being at the end stages. So their healthy lifestyles were a fat lot of use, to put it bluntly. They might as well have drunk, smoked or eaten themselves to death, for my mum, at least the ending couldn't be any worse, my dad's progression is yet to be seen.

Thanks for reading the link! It might provide something a bit helpful when you have more time to process. There is a big push for investment on Alzheimer’s, my big worry is that it will only benefit the rich in America before it makes its way to people like me in time. There are other experimental treatments in the works too in Europe but I didn’t have time to go through and refresh my knowledge, and I don’t want to peddle false hope. But there is hope for the future.
I am truly sorry for the stage things are at with your mum, I have been at that bedside and it was traumatic. I’m not surprised you feel as you do, different members of our family went different ways on it. Some were more likely to say she would be better off dead, end of. Others felt a fair chunk of the previous decade had had some pretty good moments.

I continue to disagree that providing a standard “here’s your Assisted Dying application form” alongside every dementia diagnosis is either practical or desirable. But I understand why someone in the thick of it sees that as the best option.

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 14:09

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/11/2026 13:55

As some. doctor once put it, ‘They are not dying because they are not eating and drinking. They are not eating and drinking because they are dying.’

At some point the body’s organs stop being able to process food and drink, but this is very often misunderstood by relatives, who try to insist on drips, tube feeding, etc., and protest that their loved one is being callously starved to death.

I know and totally agree with that statement. However my point is they should not have to go through up to 12 days of slow sometimes uncomfortable or painful death

Why should they not have an alternative

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 14:17

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 14:08

Thanks for reading the link! It might provide something a bit helpful when you have more time to process. There is a big push for investment on Alzheimer’s, my big worry is that it will only benefit the rich in America before it makes its way to people like me in time. There are other experimental treatments in the works too in Europe but I didn’t have time to go through and refresh my knowledge, and I don’t want to peddle false hope. But there is hope for the future.
I am truly sorry for the stage things are at with your mum, I have been at that bedside and it was traumatic. I’m not surprised you feel as you do, different members of our family went different ways on it. Some were more likely to say she would be better off dead, end of. Others felt a fair chunk of the previous decade had had some pretty good moments.

I continue to disagree that providing a standard “here’s your Assisted Dying application form” alongside every dementia diagnosis is either practical or desirable. But I understand why someone in the thick of it sees that as the best option.

Thanks for reading the link! It might provide something a bit helpful when you have more time to process.

I have time, and it doesn't. It says nothing that is new and nothing that isn't common sense.

I think it would take a miracle for a cure to be developed in time for it to save me, so I am not factoring that into my thought process.

I do not think diagnosis is the right moment to provide such a form. If such a form were to be produced, it should be a standard thing that forms part of your medical records from the point at which you reach majority - like donor consent - and, similar to a Will, you would update it when you felt the need to or perhaps at the same points you'd need to update a Will such as marriage, having children.

Then it's there, it's normalised, it's not being forced on people at difficult moments and if created at the age of 18, the vast majority of people would have no idea who, if anyone, their care might impact in old age.

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 14:42

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/11/2026 13:55

As some. doctor once put it, ‘They are not dying because they are not eating and drinking. They are not eating and drinking because they are dying.’

At some point the body’s organs stop being able to process food and drink, but this is very often misunderstood by relatives, who try to insist on drips, tube feeding, etc., and protest that their loved one is being callously starved to death.

True. But let's not pretend intentional food and water deprivation doesn't sometimes happen, as in the various abuses of the Liverpool Care Pathway.

Jacobolordy · 09/11/2026 15:29

In the thick of this situation. I had to watch one parent die of dementia several years ago, and now watching my other parent suffer with the same disease.

I am generally pro choice when it comes to assisted dying, and feel sad that the law change being debated recently had no cover for those who can no longer give informed consent, as is the save with dementia.

It's catch 22 - once you no longer have quality of life, you're too ill to be able to make decisions.

BUT - I can't support your assertion that people should sign up more or less for euthanasia on diagnosis. Even with quite advanced dementia, having been in a care home for several years, I would say DF still has some quality of life. His cognition is very poor - can't hold a conversation, not sure if he knows who I am, but he still enjoys my visits, enjoys nice food and music, sitting in the garden etc, and is physically comfortable. however, I can't bear to watch him decline and die the way my lovely mum (starving to death over 2 weeks).

Its a minefield as i think some relatives would push to end someone's life potentially prematurely out of fear, wanting to keep inheritance etc. So I can only think it should be for carers/ medics to decide when someone has no quality of life and is actively suffering, if they have an advanced directive in place that they would wish to have assisted dying in x circumstances. How it's done and by who is very problematic though.

Loveofeclairs · 09/11/2026 16:16

Cheese55 · 09/11/2026 13:09

I think it would only be for those consenting to it, otherwise it is murder surely.

The idea of consenting in advance is very problematic. What if the patient becomes upset or struggles? Would that be considered withdrawal of consent or would HCPs be expected to go through with it regardless?

MaeshoweDragon · 09/11/2026 16:29

Do you really mean assisted dying OP, or do you mean voluntary euthanasia.

They are different.

OffWith · 09/11/2026 16:36

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 14:09

I know and totally agree with that statement. However my point is they should not have to go through up to 12 days of slow sometimes uncomfortable or painful death

Why should they not have an alternative

There are people who have taken past seven days to die with assisted suicide. I think it is around 12.5% taking far too long to die.

There have been concerns and reports where the patient was left fully concious but in significant distress as their respitory system shut down.

People have died in agony.

It really isn't the magic pill/injection/drink it is made out to be. There is no guarentee of a quick/painless death.

MaeshoweDragon · 09/11/2026 16:45

The medical portal sets it all out in plain English for UK medical interviewees...
https://www.themedicportal.com/application-guide/medical-school-interview/nhs-hot-topics/euthanasia-and-assisted-dying/

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 16:51

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 14:17

Thanks for reading the link! It might provide something a bit helpful when you have more time to process.

I have time, and it doesn't. It says nothing that is new and nothing that isn't common sense.

I think it would take a miracle for a cure to be developed in time for it to save me, so I am not factoring that into my thought process.

I do not think diagnosis is the right moment to provide such a form. If such a form were to be produced, it should be a standard thing that forms part of your medical records from the point at which you reach majority - like donor consent - and, similar to a Will, you would update it when you felt the need to or perhaps at the same points you'd need to update a Will such as marriage, having children.

Then it's there, it's normalised, it's not being forced on people at difficult moments and if created at the age of 18, the vast majority of people would have no idea who, if anyone, their care might impact in old age.

Ok, I do think common sense goes a long way in medicine and personally I am up for eating a few more veggies and playing some tennis if I can postpone Alzheimer’s even for a few years but each to their own.

a more sciencey one that is fairly far along the track is Cognito Spectris, a sort of headband that fires gamma waves into the brain. I don’t know if it will get through all its trials of course but I like it because it sounds a bit like giving your head a wobble which is always good.

what is really interesting from the point of view of this discussion is the exploration of early testing to see who has the protein in their brain that is likely, but not certain to lead to Alzheimer’s plaques. If you google Roche clinical testing you can see more about it, I won’t share a link as it feels a bit weird to share info about a clinical trial! And I’m not a doctor, just a bit obsessed. So this is all with that caution.

the early testing they are offering now to people in clinical trials shows if you are prone to Alzheimer’s but it could be decades before any signs appear. so the thinking is to deal with the protein while it is still possible before the symptoms start. But that causes lots of ethical questions, by evidence of this thread lots of people would be queuing up to hand out the Assisted Dying forms. So in a few years time we might be seeing diagnosis BEFORE the disease has taken its toll, so yes, that person might be competent to make the AD decision but that would basically be supporting the deaths of healthy people. That is just so far from the Assisted Dying bill which was all about situations where someone only has six months to live. I think if people are going to find out if they are on a track likely to lead to Alzheimer’s, they need support and care.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 17:28

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 16:51

Ok, I do think common sense goes a long way in medicine and personally I am up for eating a few more veggies and playing some tennis if I can postpone Alzheimer’s even for a few years but each to their own.

a more sciencey one that is fairly far along the track is Cognito Spectris, a sort of headband that fires gamma waves into the brain. I don’t know if it will get through all its trials of course but I like it because it sounds a bit like giving your head a wobble which is always good.

what is really interesting from the point of view of this discussion is the exploration of early testing to see who has the protein in their brain that is likely, but not certain to lead to Alzheimer’s plaques. If you google Roche clinical testing you can see more about it, I won’t share a link as it feels a bit weird to share info about a clinical trial! And I’m not a doctor, just a bit obsessed. So this is all with that caution.

the early testing they are offering now to people in clinical trials shows if you are prone to Alzheimer’s but it could be decades before any signs appear. so the thinking is to deal with the protein while it is still possible before the symptoms start. But that causes lots of ethical questions, by evidence of this thread lots of people would be queuing up to hand out the Assisted Dying forms. So in a few years time we might be seeing diagnosis BEFORE the disease has taken its toll, so yes, that person might be competent to make the AD decision but that would basically be supporting the deaths of healthy people. That is just so far from the Assisted Dying bill which was all about situations where someone only has six months to live. I think if people are going to find out if they are on a track likely to lead to Alzheimer’s, they need support and care.

Sadly, I don't think I need a protein test to tell me I am likely to develop Alzheimers.

My mum has it, my dad has it, three out of my four grandparents had it, my only uncle had it and my great aunt had it.

I might strike lucky, I suppose, but the odds are stacked against me.

I already have moments when my short term memory completely fails me - I hope it is just menopausal brain fog but I live in fear.

Gamma rays into the brain is all very interesting but until it's proved as a treatment and actually available I struggle to be enthused about it.

To be honest this thread has done nothing more than inspire me to consider my DIY exit plan when the time comes, assuming AD remains off the table.

BIossomtoes · 09/11/2026 17:31

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request