Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 11:31

If there was a way (like a "when it gets to xyz stage" legal declaration that I could make now, while fully compos mentis), I would 100% sign that and take great comfort in its existence

There is, @EmeraldDreams73; as just mentioned that's what Advance Directives are for, and while as things stand they don't allow for AD they can prevent a great deal of intervention which might otherwise force people to suffer for longer

Gloriia · 09/11/2026 11:32

We all know dementia is horrible. We all all have experience of it one way or another.

No one is minimising or diminishing. The point is all chronic conditions can be horrible. We shouldn't encourage people to kill themselves because of whatever awful cards they are dealt.

Stop aggressive treatment for infections in those with dementia stop hospital admissions for deterioration and keep comfortable in a familiar place yes. Actually end a life no.

ThatLilacTiger · 09/11/2026 11:34

I think assisted dying should be accessible through easy to identify routes and with quick support offered (i.e. not a 2 year waiting list) but it shouldn't be offered at the point of diagnosis. Just like if your doctor informed you that you're pregnant, they might outline next steps and let you know there are options to either continue or not continue and then let you seek advice when you're ready.

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 11:58

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 10:55

Are you being obtuse on purpose? The point is to allow exit while someone still knows themselves. If that point is missed or the person changes their mind obviously it wouldn't go ahead. It's not a binding contract to die? Jesus.

Don't worry you are being clear about this, as are others

Thank you for thread this is an important conversation that people do need to continue to have until common sense and humanity happens

kitex · 09/11/2026 12:05

@Gloriia “We shouldn't encourage people to kill themselves because of whatever awful cards they are dealt.”

I never understand this. If someone wants to
die, let them. There are so many things worse than death.

Loveofeclairs · 09/11/2026 12:05

I’ve always been in favour of legalising assisted dying. This thread has convinced me that society is not ready for it. The amount of posters who see it as an easy out when people are no longer able to consent is worrying. What about the HCPs who’d have to carry out the procedure on patients while they’re kicking and screaming, incapable of understanding what was happening? Also, such a system could be abused by unscrupulous relatives who don’t want their inheritance wasted on grandma’s care.

Then there are those PPs who’d happily get rid of anyone who’s a ‘burden’ to society. I think there’s a name for that 🤔

Assisted dying should be available to consenting adults only or not at all.

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 12:10

Gloriia · 09/11/2026 11:32

We all know dementia is horrible. We all all have experience of it one way or another.

No one is minimising or diminishing. The point is all chronic conditions can be horrible. We shouldn't encourage people to kill themselves because of whatever awful cards they are dealt.

Stop aggressive treatment for infections in those with dementia stop hospital admissions for deterioration and keep comfortable in a familiar place yes. Actually end a life no.

Edited

Have you ever experienced what happens with a home death

When someone choses to stop treatment for something like say terminal cancer

I have experienced this with both my father and grandmother. Not something I would wish on anyone.

My father actually always said he would go to Dignitas if the worst happened. However he got pancreatic cancer that hit fast and hard. He became to sick to travel before it could be arranged and therefore suffered a few months of hell.

Frankly if terminally ill people or people with dementia want to die it is cruel to deny them there wish. If someone has made an advance directive whilst in good health then that directive should be followed, with the caviat that it isn't if they change their mind once sick.

Valeriekat · 09/11/2026 12:13

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:44

Taking it is the rational choice in that situation, though. Everyone is free to be irrational but the sane should not be denied an escape from the horror.

I don't think that you understand the nature of dementia.

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 12:14

kitex · 09/11/2026 12:05

@Gloriia “We shouldn't encourage people to kill themselves because of whatever awful cards they are dealt.”

I never understand this. If someone wants to
die, let them. There are so many things worse than death.

Stop aggressive treatment for infections in those with dementia stop hospital admissions for deterioration and keep comfortable in a familiar place yes. Actually end a life no.

They also said this

So basically don't help them to die in a quickly and relatively painless way. Stop giving them treatment so they die slowly and potentially in agony because pain relief isn't always effective.

Please make that view point make sense because I am lost with this one

HPFA · 09/11/2026 12:14

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 11:58

Don't worry you are being clear about this, as are others

Thank you for thread this is an important conversation that people do need to continue to have until common sense and humanity happens

What's also clear is that the OP thinks a person ought to decide to kill themselves as soon as the diagnosis is made.

No matter how many years they might have had with a decent quality of life.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 12:18

I think assisted dying should be accessible through easy to identify routes and with quick support offered (i.e. not a 2 year waiting list) but it shouldn't be offered at the point of diagnosis

I honestly wouldn't worry about waiting lists, @ThatLilacTiger
When you consider the savings to be made on all that expensive treatment I've not the least doubt some would regard this as an absolute priority Sad

Stop aggressive treatment for infections in those with dementia stop hospital admissions for deterioration and keep comfortable in a familiar place yes. Actually end a life no.

Spot on, @Gloriia, but again this is where hospital obs enter into it
As it was explained to us with my late FIL, if they see it and it's treatable then they have to treat it, which is why a hands off approach (And an Advance Directive) can be so valuable

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 12:21

HPFA · 09/11/2026 12:14

What's also clear is that the OP thinks a person ought to decide to kill themselves as soon as the diagnosis is made.

No matter how many years they might have had with a decent quality of life.

I do not have dementia symptoms, I am in my 50s. My parents both succumbed in their late 70s.

If I had the opportunity now, at this very moment, I would sign a declaration requesting assisted dying if I later develop dementia and when my symptoms have deteriorated to very specific levels.

The whole problem with dementia is that, unlike terminal illness where mental capacity is unaffected, by the time you've got it and been diagnosed, it may be too late to make this most important decision.

Newsenmum · 09/11/2026 12:22

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 22:44

It isn’t. Unless there’s evidence that disabled children are diagnosed with dementia.

Why is it only dementia when endorced dying should happen?

Newsenmum · 09/11/2026 12:23

HPFA · 09/11/2026 12:14

What's also clear is that the OP thinks a person ought to decide to kill themselves as soon as the diagnosis is made.

No matter how many years they might have had with a decent quality of life.

Yep and that is what is sickening.

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 12:24

HPFA · 09/11/2026 12:14

What's also clear is that the OP thinks a person ought to decide to kill themselves as soon as the diagnosis is made.

No matter how many years they might have had with a decent quality of life.

If that is what a person chooses to do after a cooling off period I have no problem with that. They have no idea how fast their condition will progress and may not want to get to a place where they can no longer make a rational decision. Time frames given are educated guesses and statistics based rather than fact. Everyone will progress at different speeds.

Ought is tea key word here obviously. Has the op said they ought to be able to do so (as in be allowed) or have they said a person ought to do so (as in they should)?

HPFA · 09/11/2026 12:26

My daughter's rheumatologist has decided she needs a biological drug, which is expensive.

She's now received a letter from the NHS telling her how much this will cost.

As she says What message am I supposed to get here? Am I supposed to feel guilty?".

Thinking that an "offer of assisted dying" is somehow a neutral message is absurd.

If you think it should be "available on request" then I think you have a case to argue but anyone who thinks it should be "offered" has basically already decided that people should be encouraged to take it up.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 12:26

Newsenmum · 09/11/2026 12:22

Why is it only dementia when endorced dying should happen?

Edited

This thread is about assisted dying for people diagnosed with Alzheimers.

If you want to discuss assisted dying for other conditions, why not start a thread about it?

EmeraldShamrock000 · 09/11/2026 12:27

It is definitely something to be considered. My Dsis is a care home manger, often the dementia patients are treated for all sorts of health issues that would otherwise kill them prolonging an already awful existence. It is sad to see. Who knows what the answers are.
Some patients are happy enough in their own world, others are absolutely terrified and live in a constant fear state.

WhyStopThere · 09/11/2026 12:28

Why do people assume that if you're not into "assisted" dying that you don't know the horrors of dementia or other chronic/terminal illnesses/disease?

Some of us know way more than we ever wanted to know.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 09/11/2026 12:28

Having had dreadful post concussion syndrome symptoms that were, to me, as terrifying as dementia (but obviously i don't know how terrible having dementia actually is), I genuinely would take a look at assisted dying when I had capacity to say yes.

I'd hate to put my children or husband through the pain and devastation of watching me become a shell of myself, and nor would I ever want to burden anyone so much.

Having had a neurological involuntary movement disorder that was caused by an off label antipsychotic prescribed after the head injury, I've had experience of a different problem with my poor old brain too. Sometimes, it's far kinder to let someone go when they want to, but I also believe someone's worth is deeper, not deleted, after they have conditions like dementia etc

Dreadful things. So sorry for anyone dealing with it all.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/11/2026 12:30

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 12:18

I think assisted dying should be accessible through easy to identify routes and with quick support offered (i.e. not a 2 year waiting list) but it shouldn't be offered at the point of diagnosis

I honestly wouldn't worry about waiting lists, @ThatLilacTiger
When you consider the savings to be made on all that expensive treatment I've not the least doubt some would regard this as an absolute priority Sad

Stop aggressive treatment for infections in those with dementia stop hospital admissions for deterioration and keep comfortable in a familiar place yes. Actually end a life no.

Spot on, @Gloriia, but again this is where hospital obs enter into it
As it was explained to us with my late FIL, if they see it and it's treatable then they have to treat it, which is why a hands off approach (And an Advance Directive) can be so valuable

I don’t see that they HAVE to!

A favourite aunt of mine (80s with dementia) was refusing food and drink during the umpteenth UTI. I was asked by care home staff whether we wanted her taken to hospital for ABs and fluids in drips, - otherwise she would very likely, very soon, die.

I could only ask the GP what he’d do if it were his much loved aunt. He said he’d leave her where she was, where they’d keep her comfortable. The situation was only going to arise again, probably very soon, since she’d always been prone to UTIs.

It ws a horrible decision to have to take, but I knew it was almost certainly what my aunt’s former self would have wanted.

Plus there’s the fact that hospital is in any case a terrible place for anyone with dementia, when they can’t understand what is going on or why, and are endlessly e.g. trying to pull drips out and/or dressings off.

My aunt continued to refuse food and drink. I sat with her a lot during that last week, she was apparently asleep and unresponsive nearly all the time, and she drifted away quite peacefully. The care home staff were wonderful, and did whatever they could to keep her comfortable - keeping her mouth moist, etc.

I would do exactly the same again, in similar circumstances.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 09/11/2026 12:30

WhyStopThere · 09/11/2026 12:28

Why do people assume that if you're not into "assisted" dying that you don't know the horrors of dementia or other chronic/terminal illnesses/disease?

Some of us know way more than we ever wanted to know.

Absolutely this. I've been through more than enough hell with my movement disorder symptoms and post concussion syndrome symptoms, so much so that I am basing a fictional character on it. I want to portray the human experience through fiction. Many people are fortunate enough to never experience these horrors, thankfully.

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 12:33

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 12:18

I think assisted dying should be accessible through easy to identify routes and with quick support offered (i.e. not a 2 year waiting list) but it shouldn't be offered at the point of diagnosis

I honestly wouldn't worry about waiting lists, @ThatLilacTiger
When you consider the savings to be made on all that expensive treatment I've not the least doubt some would regard this as an absolute priority Sad

Stop aggressive treatment for infections in those with dementia stop hospital admissions for deterioration and keep comfortable in a familiar place yes. Actually end a life no.

Spot on, @Gloriia, but again this is where hospital obs enter into it
As it was explained to us with my late FIL, if they see it and it's treatable then they have to treat it, which is why a hands off approach (And an Advance Directive) can be so valuable

This hospital having to treat or at least keep people alive longer via feeding tubes, fluid drips is the reason why so many uncomfortable home deaths happen

If at home you can choose along with the GP to have no intervention bar pain relief. However this is essentially starving and dehydrating someone to death. It has happened in the end with the majority of home deaths I know. The person stops eating then no intervention. It can take up to 12 days for someone to die like this. I want to be able to choose how I die thanks.

JumpLeadsForTwo · 09/11/2026 12:35

INeverReallyLovedYouAnyway · 08/11/2026 13:56

Here’s another thing I’d stop. Invasive, expensive operations and treatments to lengthen the life of 90+ year old dementia sufferers who have absolutely no quality of life in the first place. I have several recent examples of this.

If I’m 95 with advanced dementia and I need cancer treatment or a hip replacement…please just don’t bother. Just make me comfortable and let me slip away.

In the midst of this with a parent and absolutely agree with this. I have mixed views about assisted dying, but not prolonging suffering - unless you have experienced this from a carer’s point of view, I think you can have rosy tinted specs on the realities of living with dementia. It’s brutal for all involved

Rootsinmydreamland · 09/11/2026 12:50

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 12:24

If that is what a person chooses to do after a cooling off period I have no problem with that. They have no idea how fast their condition will progress and may not want to get to a place where they can no longer make a rational decision. Time frames given are educated guesses and statistics based rather than fact. Everyone will progress at different speeds.

Ought is tea key word here obviously. Has the op said they ought to be able to do so (as in be allowed) or have they said a person ought to do so (as in they should)?

Before you leap to the OP's defence, please may I recommend reading all of her posts on this thread in which she appears to suggest that it is a person's moral duty to kill themself as soon as they become ill or disabled in any way in order not to become a burden to their loved ones. Just thought you may wish to be fully aware of the extent of the OP's views before you endorse them.