Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 17:35

Gloriia · 09/11/2026 11:32

We all know dementia is horrible. We all all have experience of it one way or another.

No one is minimising or diminishing. The point is all chronic conditions can be horrible. We shouldn't encourage people to kill themselves because of whatever awful cards they are dealt.

Stop aggressive treatment for infections in those with dementia stop hospital admissions for deterioration and keep comfortable in a familiar place yes. Actually end a life no.

Edited

None of that would have saved my father from his last 6 months which were actually really grim despite the best care money could buy - AD would have. My mother and I spent his last 6 weeks praying for him to die (for his sake, not ours).

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 17:35

This is a moral minefield and if we get it wrong then we fail to safeguard our most vulnerable

As the thread has made clear this is one of the major points for many of us, @Wordsmithery, but unfortunately there are some who simply don't care about the measure's potential effect on anyone else as long as they get what they want

I realise this attitude is becoming ever more common with all manner of issues, but it really isn't my idea of how a civilised society should work

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 17:38

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 17:35

This is a moral minefield and if we get it wrong then we fail to safeguard our most vulnerable

As the thread has made clear this is one of the major points for many of us, @Wordsmithery, but unfortunately there are some who simply don't care about the measure's potential effect on anyone else as long as they get what they want

I realise this attitude is becoming ever more common with all manner of issues, but it really isn't my idea of how a civilised society should work

If you think what's happening now is keeping vulnerable people safe then you've not spent enough time around people at the end of life. What many are forced to endure is barbaric.

BIossomtoes · 09/11/2026 17:38

Well really sorry @Puzzledandpissedoff but I’m not prepared to be a martyr to protect society.

SidNut · 09/11/2026 17:58

I agree. When my Nana was diagnosed, she was adamant that when the time came she would choose to end her own life before the dementia progressed too far. Unfortunately for her, it creeps in and by the time she would have made that choice she was no longer aware or able to. It led to years of suffering for her and her family, the final year was absolutely horrific. I would sign a document right now just on the risk of if I was diagnosed I would want a dignified end on my own terms, not to pass the way my Nana did.

NightHeron · 09/11/2026 18:07

EmeraldShamrock000 · 09/11/2026 13:54

I know that. I am hopeful if the assisted dying bill is available that families can make the choice, like they can make the choice of a dnr.
With medical professionals and legal experts.
As in my cousins case, his parents can’t make that decision, he hasn’t got capacity so he has to live his life in a residential setting with no awareness about his surroundings.

The patient has to die or be close to it in order for no resuscitation. I believe it is the kindest thing to do. A lot of families confuse the dnr as no treatment for illnesses and refuse it.

I was not confused by the DNR on DD1 during Covid. I was sent a form, which asked me to choose between DD1 (in her 20s at the time) staying in the care home, if she were ill, or going to hospital. As being “ill” did not specify Covid, it could have meant, if she got appendicitis, they wouldn’t have taken her to A & E for treatment. They would have left her to die of peritonitis.

I was a witness at the Covid enquiry, and heard the owner of a nursing home, giving evidence that paramedics refused to take one of her residents, needing a transfusion of insulin for diabetes, to hospital during Covid.

If you look at the statistics for the treatment of people with learning disabilities and COVID in hospital, their death rates were much higher than “normal” people. It’s quite obvious a DNR did mean “no treatment”!

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 18:14

BIossomtoes · 09/11/2026 17:38

Well really sorry @Puzzledandpissedoff but I’m not prepared to be a martyr to protect society.

But you're happy to put other people at risk to enable your own choices?

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 09/11/2026 18:15

I appreciate everyone feels differently but personally I would rather an assisted death than just existing for the sake of it when I reach that point. I am disappointed that I don't have the choice. It seems my body my choice only extends to those who are fit and healthy. I would trust my children to make the decision knowing my wishes when the time came.

BIossomtoes · 09/11/2026 18:19

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 18:14

But you're happy to put other people at risk to enable your own choices?

I’m not remotely happy about any of this but it’s not my job to live a travesty of a life just in case someone somewhere makes the wrong decision.

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 18:24

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 18:14

But you're happy to put other people at risk to enable your own choices?

Well, you're happy to have thousands of people suffer to protect you from a theoretical possibility...

When abortion was legalised one of the arguments against it was that it was a slippery slope that would lead to newborn babies (and especially disabled newborns) being euthanised. It never happened
.

Notonthestairs · 09/11/2026 18:32

No assisted dying legislation will ever pass until the safeguarding concerns are explored and dealt with. I think there is a suspicion on this thread that safeguarding concerns are the product of an overactive imagination. They are not.

I refer to this letter to the BMJ from assorted senior judges-
“What is striking is not simply what the letter says, but what it omits. It makes no acknowledgement of the substantial evidence submitted to Parliament by the medical Royal Colleges, other professional bodies, legal experts, disability organisations, ethicists and clinicians who identified those concerns, nor of the complexity involved in creating legislation that is safe, equitable and capable of commanding public confidence.
In this respect, the letter illustrates one of the central problems that contributed to the bill’s failure. Rather than engaging with the difficult questions raised during scrutiny, supporters presented assisted dying law reform as a largely settled matter, with concerns raised by professional and expert bodies too often minimised, misrepresented or denied. Yet the scrutiny process revealed the opposite: that fundamental questions remain unresolved about safeguards, oversight, coercion, capacity assessment, clinical responsibilities and the relationship between assisted dying and healthcare.
The bill did not fail because its critics were unwilling to engage with reform. It failed because too many of its supporters were unwilling to engage with the complexity of developing a law that is genuinely safe, equitable and compassionate. Any future attempt at legislation must begin with a serious assessment of these challenges and a willingness to address them, rather than denying that they exist.”
https://www.bmj.com/content/393/bmj.s810/rr-3

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 18:42

That has, arguably, happened in this country. Google it if you don’t believe me. And it has definitely happened in other countries.

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 18:44

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 18:24

Well, you're happy to have thousands of people suffer to protect you from a theoretical possibility...

When abortion was legalised one of the arguments against it was that it was a slippery slope that would lead to newborn babies (and especially disabled newborns) being euthanised. It never happened
.

And I meant to add, if you consider forced euthanasia to be only a ‘theoretical possibility’, you’re being rather naive about human nature.

Cheese55 · 09/11/2026 18:45

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 16:51

Ok, I do think common sense goes a long way in medicine and personally I am up for eating a few more veggies and playing some tennis if I can postpone Alzheimer’s even for a few years but each to their own.

a more sciencey one that is fairly far along the track is Cognito Spectris, a sort of headband that fires gamma waves into the brain. I don’t know if it will get through all its trials of course but I like it because it sounds a bit like giving your head a wobble which is always good.

what is really interesting from the point of view of this discussion is the exploration of early testing to see who has the protein in their brain that is likely, but not certain to lead to Alzheimer’s plaques. If you google Roche clinical testing you can see more about it, I won’t share a link as it feels a bit weird to share info about a clinical trial! And I’m not a doctor, just a bit obsessed. So this is all with that caution.

the early testing they are offering now to people in clinical trials shows if you are prone to Alzheimer’s but it could be decades before any signs appear. so the thinking is to deal with the protein while it is still possible before the symptoms start. But that causes lots of ethical questions, by evidence of this thread lots of people would be queuing up to hand out the Assisted Dying forms. So in a few years time we might be seeing diagnosis BEFORE the disease has taken its toll, so yes, that person might be competent to make the AD decision but that would basically be supporting the deaths of healthy people. That is just so far from the Assisted Dying bill which was all about situations where someone only has six months to live. I think if people are going to find out if they are on a track likely to lead to Alzheimer’s, they need support and care.

What is the purpose of knowing? If you're worried about developing and then living with it, make your wishes known and get LpoA in place.
Some years ago I worked in a hospital and the older people with dementia were routinely 'left comfortable and died. There was very little 'aggressive treatment' quite the opposite.

godmum56 · 09/11/2026 18:46

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 15:32

I think it is right tbh - you could ruin your kids' lives with a very early diagnosis and healthy body.

no. totally wrong and opens the door to coercion.

XenoBitch · 09/11/2026 18:49

godmum56 · 09/11/2026 18:46

no. totally wrong and opens the door to coercion.

Yep, AD should not be used to spare other people trauma. It should be 100% up to the person considering it.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/11/2026 19:15

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 14:09

I know and totally agree with that statement. However my point is they should not have to go through up to 12 days of slow sometimes uncomfortable or painful death

Why should they not have an alternative

Painkillers can still be provided even if no food or drink is being taken.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 19:38

Notonthestairs · 09/11/2026 18:32

No assisted dying legislation will ever pass until the safeguarding concerns are explored and dealt with. I think there is a suspicion on this thread that safeguarding concerns are the product of an overactive imagination. They are not.

I refer to this letter to the BMJ from assorted senior judges-
“What is striking is not simply what the letter says, but what it omits. It makes no acknowledgement of the substantial evidence submitted to Parliament by the medical Royal Colleges, other professional bodies, legal experts, disability organisations, ethicists and clinicians who identified those concerns, nor of the complexity involved in creating legislation that is safe, equitable and capable of commanding public confidence.
In this respect, the letter illustrates one of the central problems that contributed to the bill’s failure. Rather than engaging with the difficult questions raised during scrutiny, supporters presented assisted dying law reform as a largely settled matter, with concerns raised by professional and expert bodies too often minimised, misrepresented or denied. Yet the scrutiny process revealed the opposite: that fundamental questions remain unresolved about safeguards, oversight, coercion, capacity assessment, clinical responsibilities and the relationship between assisted dying and healthcare.
The bill did not fail because its critics were unwilling to engage with reform. It failed because too many of its supporters were unwilling to engage with the complexity of developing a law that is genuinely safe, equitable and compassionate. Any future attempt at legislation must begin with a serious assessment of these challenges and a willingness to address them, rather than denying that they exist.”
https://www.bmj.com/content/393/bmj.s810/rr-3

Yes I was aware of the BMJ letter, from the judges, Notonthestairs, and while agreeing with the points it makes I wouldn't expect it to be welcomed by those it called out for refusing to engage on a very complex subject

You'd think the passage "The bill did not fail because its critics were unwilling to engage with reform. It failed because too many of its supporters were unwilling to engage with the complexity of developing a law that is genuinely safe, equitable and compassionate" would encourage them to do better if and when this comes up again, but frankly I'm not confident

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 19:45

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/11/2026 19:15

Painkillers can still be provided even if no food or drink is being taken.

Yes a syringe driver with morphine is often used at this stage

However been through this twice and it isn't 100% effect all the time. Still some pain gets through at times and still a certain amount of discomfort

You are looking at things like mouth, tongue and lips drying out badly. This can be gently swapped with little sponge things on sticks but if you do it too much you are potentially delaying the death because they are getting water this way. It is truly a horrible balance to have to access. I have seen two people I love spend thier last days slowly turning in something from a horror film, the changes in their faces, rapid weightloss and stiffening of their bodies will remain an image in tmy head when I think about them. I would have preferred to remember them as they were before their death beds. Pretty sure they would have preferred that too.

There are other things that happen with home deaths too but think probably best not upset people here.

I don't think it is fair to put anybody through end of life care if they would prefer to die quicker, with less discomfort and likely more peacefully

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 20:58

It isn't REALLY complicated. The status quo condemns many (most?) of us to a bad end over which we have no control. That's something I think you'd have to be very religious to accept.

The pro life script is always the same

"Oh I see your point but

Safeguards (unspecified) are needed!

I was with you up until (insert thing here)

Very complicated"

It isn't complicated

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 09/11/2026 21:01

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 20:58

It isn't REALLY complicated. The status quo condemns many (most?) of us to a bad end over which we have no control. That's something I think you'd have to be very religious to accept.

The pro life script is always the same

"Oh I see your point but

Safeguards (unspecified) are needed!

I was with you up until (insert thing here)

Very complicated"

It isn't complicated

A lot of other conditions means a grim end. And not all people with dementia have one.
It just seems like you want AD to be offered immediately, not to spare someone with dementia suffering, but to spare you, the relative.
That is not what AD is about.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 21:25

XenoBitch · 09/11/2026 21:01

A lot of other conditions means a grim end. And not all people with dementia have one.
It just seems like you want AD to be offered immediately, not to spare someone with dementia suffering, but to spare you, the relative.
That is not what AD is about.

No, to spare me the person who doesn't want my mind and dignity completely violated because some people are too slow to anticipate horror.

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 21:27

I think some people get off on the idea of how much suffering is out there (maybe even choose jobs that allow them to see it close up). Others are stupid or deluded. I don't think any of these groups should dictate my fate.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 09/11/2026 21:27

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 21:25

No, to spare me the person who doesn't want my mind and dignity completely violated because some people are too slow to anticipate horror.

Unless you are the person experiencing dementia, you don't get to say what they are going through.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 21:29

XenoBitch · 09/11/2026 21:27

Unless you are the person experiencing dementia, you don't get to say what they are going through.

If only people with dementia get to dictate policy there will be no policy. I guess you don't think it will be you or that it won't be that bad if it is.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread