Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Seagulldancing · 09/11/2026 10:31

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 10:19

Well, actually, you are looking at the exceptions and are trying to portray that as the bigger picture.

The bigger picture is allowing mercy to people who want it.

But people with dementia have already lost reasoning skills before diagnosis. My own DM has gone from wanting "to be put out of misery" to fighting to keep alive and well post dementia diagnosis.
The argument is about who can override a person's decision and how to assess consent in a person with severe dementia. And thats almost unsolvable, as no matter how bad my mother gets, Im not going to agree to her being put down. I'll let her slip away with illness, but I couldn't let anyone just decide it was too hard and say thats it.
Cases where people have capability is a whole other issue.

BIossomtoes · 09/11/2026 10:39

Mine were exactly the same. The healthiest life style you could imagine. My mum died of dementia after several miserable years, my dad was sharp as a needle to his dying breath at 99. It’s a genetic lottery.

kitex · 09/11/2026 10:40

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 10:19

Well, actually, you are looking at the exceptions and are trying to portray that as the bigger picture.

The bigger picture is allowing mercy to people who want it.

“The bigger picture is allowing mercy to people who want it.”

This!

MaeshoweDragon · 09/11/2026 10:41

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 09:54

It is what people do when they have no real argument to deny the truth of what is being said. Unfortunately you see this across social media which means it is very different for serious debate on a topic. Sure you know this anyway but very frustrating sometimes isn't it.

Trouble is, as seen on this thread (quite spectacularly at times) people's view of what a life that is so poor as to ask someone if they want to die, or to consider them burdensome enough to want it to be available - varies somewhat.

Being incontinent and unable to feed yourself ? Superficial care needs, and people want them/themselves dead?

I find the whole thing disturbing.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 10:42

feellikeanalien · 09/11/2026 00:26

If you look at some of the posts from OP on other threads you will see that she is not particularly keen on children with SEN either.

I wasn't aware of this but it comes as no surprise, feellikeanalien

The bigger picture is allowing mercy to people who want it

This is also true, @LetMeButterYourParsnips, but if we're to retain any humanity at all we can't just ignore those "exceptions" you mentioned - not when it becomes ever clearer that some are quite relaxed about coercion.
It's not outright refusal of AD which some of us want, but to have it available as an option, and if that's ever to happen it'll need to come with the safeguards which were so carelessly being discarded in the last bill

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 10:42

Seagulldancing · 09/11/2026 10:31

But people with dementia have already lost reasoning skills before diagnosis. My own DM has gone from wanting "to be put out of misery" to fighting to keep alive and well post dementia diagnosis.
The argument is about who can override a person's decision and how to assess consent in a person with severe dementia. And thats almost unsolvable, as no matter how bad my mother gets, Im not going to agree to her being put down. I'll let her slip away with illness, but I couldn't let anyone just decide it was too hard and say thats it.
Cases where people have capability is a whole other issue.

Edited

I never had, if you like, a formal conversation on that subject with my parents before their diagnoses. I do remember years and years ago, round about the time Dignitas came into being, my mum saying something to the effect that she would rather be euthanised than live with severe dementia - but I don't know whether that would have been her view 20 years later, nearer to her condition becoming apparent.

I don't recall my dad ever discussing it. From what I know of his attitudes generally, I think he would be opposed to AD for any one, in any circumstances. There is no point in asking him now because he is not reliable and wouldn't remember any conversation we had, his short term memory seems to be down to less than 60 seconds now although his long-term memory is still very good.

What I do know and can be certain of are my own wishes on the subject and I would like to be able to make provision for myself, before it is too late. I might change my mind, I might later want to revoke any AD consent, but at the moment I would like a process to have it in place for myself.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 10:45

MaeshoweDragon · 09/11/2026 10:41

Trouble is, as seen on this thread (quite spectacularly at times) people's view of what a life that is so poor as to ask someone if they want to die, or to consider them burdensome enough to want it to be available - varies somewhat.

Being incontinent and unable to feed yourself ? Superficial care needs, and people want them/themselves dead?

I find the whole thing disturbing.

Incontinence being a superficial care need?

Would you like sitting in your own shit and then having to have someone clean your bum and genital area for you?

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 10:46

My friend who never married and is now single in her 60s has made a living will, this details what she wantsin certain situations and is legal so must be followedbe health professionals. She has also chosen her brother to be responsible for any decisions if she is unable to do so herself and fall outside the living will decisions.

I think something like this made by a person whilst still in sound mind before they even know if will get dementia or anything else would be the answer to a lot of the worries here. You would just go back ever few years and rewrite anything you feel differently about. That doesn't mean in a situation where someone changes their mind after diagnosis they should still be helped to die. It means those that have always wanted it and after diagnosis still wanting it should be able to access it.

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 10:50

Seagulldancing · 09/11/2026 10:31

But people with dementia have already lost reasoning skills before diagnosis. My own DM has gone from wanting "to be put out of misery" to fighting to keep alive and well post dementia diagnosis.
The argument is about who can override a person's decision and how to assess consent in a person with severe dementia. And thats almost unsolvable, as no matter how bad my mother gets, Im not going to agree to her being put down. I'll let her slip away with illness, but I couldn't let anyone just decide it was too hard and say thats it.
Cases where people have capability is a whole other issue.

Edited

Have you actually read the thread?

Or maybe even the OP?

This is about an advanced directive while the patient still has capacity should certain conditions be met.

PencilsInSpace · 09/11/2026 10:50

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 10:45

Incontinence being a superficial care need?

Would you like sitting in your own shit and then having to have someone clean your bum and genital area for you?

And people wonder why so many disabled people are opposed to AD.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 09/11/2026 10:52

I find it interesting that on so many threads where people are struggling with a myriad of horrific situations and circumstances beyond their control a significant cohort of posters will shout the rather facile rallying cry of "develop resilience" rather than address serious systemic failings etc.... yet when it comes to caring for our "burdensome" relatives with dementia and other conditions it is deemed perfectly acceptable to encourage the most radical of solutions to avoid the distress or inconvenience of shouldering said " burden".

We are community and tribal driven creatures yet we are living in ever increasing times of division and isolation to perpetuate an increasingly dystopian end stage capitalist nightmare.

Humans are complex, but are being increasingly portrayed as problems to be solved when they cease to be useful to the machine.

To be clear, as I know from personal experience, watching those you love dying horribly because "it's inevitable" so why bother improving things because "economics" does take a horrific toll and leaves lasting scars, so I am in no way suggesting carers should be berated for perceived "lack of resilience" when they are struggling. I'm trying to get at the perceived double standards that some people live by. And point out that writing people off as soon as something like dementia comes into play is a sad indictment of where we're at.

I am not in favour of prolonging life and by extension suffering by any means. My MIL likely had bowel cancer on top of dementia when she died. I had POA for health and welfare as her son, my beloved DP died three years before she did. She never knew. A kindness in its own way. She had severe muscle contracture and no cognition at all for the last few years, so I had long discussions about the cruelty and futility of investigation when the symptoms showed up with her GP. We decided that straight to palliative was the only compassionate option.

That, on top of my Dad's death, plus the residual from the death of my DP and the horrors of my Mums end has indeed all but broken me. But I can't imagine that exchanging one set of horrible options for another would have made me feel any better, and it's given me a wealth of insight into how things could be better managed.

I think what I'm trying to say is that we don't always get to choose what life throws at us. Sometimes we just have to deal with it because the alternatives are likely to do as much of a number on us as the immediate horrors, and if assisted dying becomes euthenasua implemented by the state and posed as a duty we are in sad and dangerous waters.

Seagulldancing · 09/11/2026 10:53

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 10:50

Have you actually read the thread?

Or maybe even the OP?

This is about an advanced directive while the patient still has capacity should certain conditions be met.

So what happens when the person with dementia changes their mind? Who's forced to kill off the elderly dementia sufferer who don't want to die?
Have you read the thread? We covered this a few pages ago. There is no good solution for those with dementia.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 10:53

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 09:58

Well, unlike you, I actually know something about this first-hand given that my mum is receiving care atm, and I have neither given up my job to 'change her and stop her wandering into the road', nor am I living in poverty. What I have done is arrange for her to be given the best care I'm able to source for her, and to help out myself as best I can.

What I wouldn't be doing, if I could turn the clock back to the date of her diagnosis and if assisted killing was available, would be coercing her to sign a form agreeing to be killed 'because you wouldn't want to be a burden to me, would you, mum?'

And you're being ridiculous about 'intimate care from an African male'. Women make up roughly 80% of the workforce in the UK care sector. I am curious as to why you think a carer being African makes the slightest difference, though.

I think it would all be awful but I'm telling you what my mother would find most distressing (which she has told me).

You're very lucky to have found available care.

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 10:55

Seagulldancing · 09/11/2026 10:53

So what happens when the person with dementia changes their mind? Who's forced to kill off the elderly dementia sufferer who don't want to die?
Have you read the thread? We covered this a few pages ago. There is no good solution for those with dementia.

Are you being obtuse on purpose? The point is to allow exit while someone still knows themselves. If that point is missed or the person changes their mind obviously it wouldn't go ahead. It's not a binding contract to die? Jesus.

OP posts:
MaeshoweDragon · 09/11/2026 10:56

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 10:45

Incontinence being a superficial care need?

Would you like sitting in your own shit and then having to have someone clean your bum and genital area for you?

A way of life for some people.
I have a neice (in her 30s) who will need that sort of care forever.

Would I like it... no, would I let my embarrassment kill me, also no.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 10:57

PencilsInSpace · 09/11/2026 10:50

And people wonder why so many disabled people are opposed to AD.

I do not regard double incontinence as a 'superficial care need' and in the context of dementia, being unable to communicate my continence needs or maintain my own dignity during intimate care, is not a way I would want to live.

I am not getting into strawman whataboutery in relation to every condition or disability that might exist.

I am talking specifically about Alzheimer's and what I would want to be available for me if, or more probably, when, I developed it.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 09/11/2026 10:59

I don’t think some people on here understand what the reality of dementia can be. It’s great that one poster’s grandma lived happily into their 90’s in a care home with clothes calmer version of dementia. Great that another has been happily managing a completely different disability with care from their family and is living a happy life. Good. My mother’s experience of dementia was very different, the early years were a white knuckle ride, I was basically managing her life but being accused of stealing constantly, she did however have good quality of life and was able to enjoy music and outings and shopping. It was stressful but I’d have those days back in a heartbeat. Her later stages were the stuff of nightmares, constantly distressed, hallucinating people in her room that terrified her and made her scream, then zone out, then scream, then zone out, repeat repeat repeat. She was in a care home with doctors visiting every week but they were sl slow to give her medication for this she actually died on the day her prescription came in. She screamed through washing and dressing, she screamed in the communal tv room, in the dining room, she had no connection with the other residents, every time she saw a carer she thought she was meeting them for the first time, so there was no bonding. Activities were irrelevant to her, she tolerated the singing, but it wasn’t really to her tastes (she liked indie and dance music). The staff have no idea of the clever, funny and kind woman she was, only this screaming nervous wreck. When she was active she would go into the wrong room and climb into bed with other residents, sometimes she would attack them, sometimes she was go to toilet in their bins. She had a horrible, horrible time, there were very few good days, and those were the days she was zoned out. She died at 68. I don’t think my DM should have died the minute she was diagnosed but those last few years were torture and I wish I could have taken them away from her, I wish I hadn’t witnessed it and I wish I didn’t dread it myself. I’ve had counselling and I have PTSD. I simply refuse to put my loved ones through what I went through and I refuse to live my last few years in terror and pain.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 11:00

MaeshoweDragon · 09/11/2026 10:56

A way of life for some people.
I have a neice (in her 30s) who will need that sort of care forever.

Would I like it... no, would I let my embarrassment kill me, also no.

Edited

It's not "embarrassment" that's the issue, it's soul-destroying reliant indignity. It would be terrifying.

OP posts:
Bikenutz · 09/11/2026 11:02

Firstly, a diagnosis of dementia is a big shock and a lot to take in, even if it’s expected. So no, I don’t think assisted dying should be a part of that particular conversation unless the patent specifically raises it.

What I do think we should normalise is making these decisions when we are fit and well, getting them legally documented, and telling those who need to know what our wishes are should we find ourselves with such a diagnosis.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 11:02

MaeshoweDragon · 09/11/2026 10:56

A way of life for some people.
I have a neice (in her 30s) who will need that sort of care forever.

Would I like it... no, would I let my embarrassment kill me, also no.

Edited

I'm sorry your niece has a lifelong condition affecting her continence.

I can't speak for other posters, but I am posting here solely in relation to the topic of the thread - assisted dying for Alzheimer's sufferers.

I don't feel qualified to comment on other conditions, disabilities or diseases.

StandFirm · 09/11/2026 11:03

kitex · 08/11/2026 14:29

You have to face reality. There is a huge shortage of carers in the UK. The number of people needing care is increasing substantially. Adult Social Care is in severe crisis. It can be an awful burden for family to have to become carers What do you propose?

I would propose moving away from a terribly utilitarian view of human life. Have you watched Soylent Green? If not you should. It's old but a dystopian classic and not a million miles from what society will turn into soonish if we consistently place those considerations above the value of individual human lives. I fully respect the right of elderly people to be a burden. I'd personally rather have my own parents around until the end and make sure they're as comfortable as can be (and yes, I witnessed the toll it took on them both to care for their own parents when I was younger). My grandparents' existence had value to us until the very last day.

MaeshoweDragon · 09/11/2026 11:06

Could be, not would be.

MIL did not care. By the time she was physically failing, her brain had already checked out.

EmeraldDreams73 · 09/11/2026 11:07

I'd like to see assisted dying legalised but I can also see problems. I wouldn't want it to be offered on diagnosis because it could easily feel like pressure. That said, if there was a way (like a "when it gets to xyz stage" legal declaration that I could make now, while fully compos mentis), I would 100% sign that and take great comfort in its existence.

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 11:09

PencilsInSpace · 09/11/2026 10:50

And people wonder why so many disabled people are opposed to AD.

It can be both though.

What is embarrassing for some can be life destroying for others.

No one likes it, but what you have a lifelong condition and it’s part and parcel of it then you have something to look forward to. You have your life ahead of you.

With dementia and end of life conditions don’t have this, you look back at your life and your memories and you don’t want it to be what it is. Many of your friends and family are gone.

We all have different thresholds for what we perceive as too much to bear.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 11:25

Bikenutz · 09/11/2026 11:02

Firstly, a diagnosis of dementia is a big shock and a lot to take in, even if it’s expected. So no, I don’t think assisted dying should be a part of that particular conversation unless the patent specifically raises it.

What I do think we should normalise is making these decisions when we are fit and well, getting them legally documented, and telling those who need to know what our wishes are should we find ourselves with such a diagnosis.

Superbly put, Bikenutz

I fully appreciate that, for various reasons, some may be unable to arrange things like advance directives, but do also wonder how many simply haven't bothered

One benefit of such things is that they can be done as part of normal life planning before illness even strikes, which can take a lot of emotion out of the issue, and if we can have a campaign encouraging people to donate their organs why not this?