Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 09:08

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 08:59

What did her advanced directive say?

She didn’t have one.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 09:12

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 09:05

Ischemic heart disease is a very close second in terms of numbers of deaths. Should people with that diagnosis be offered ‘assisted dying’? There is no cure, it’s degenerative, there’s just treatment that prolongs the inevitable,

I don't think the number of deaths per year is a relevant factor in this debate.

I have no experience of ischemic heart disease, but generally, for any terminal condition, the decision should be made based on quality of life. E.g.

  • Is the person in continual severe pain that can't be managed with analgesia?
  • Is the person continually in a state of distress or anger?
  • Is the person continually in a vegetative state?

It isn't as simple as saying - if the person has X disease, AD is the right choice for them. But what we need to be saying is, there is a range of terminal diseases in which AD might be a choice the patient wants to make, depending on their symptoms as the disease progresses.

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 09:13

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 09:08

She didn’t have one.

Then euthanasia wouldn't be in the frame, would it?

Gloriia · 09/11/2026 09:15

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 09:05

Ischemic heart disease is a very close second in terms of numbers of deaths. Should people with that diagnosis be offered ‘assisted dying’? There is no cure, it’s degenerative, there’s just treatment that prolongs the inevitable,

Exactly.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 09:19

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 09:07

Voluntary euthanasia IS giving the person a choice if when to die. But you nicely managed to avoid my question like a practiced MP

The simple answer to the question 'at what point should she have been euthanised?' is - if and when she wanted to be.

The slightly longer answer is that, if, while of sound mind, she had laid down a set of symptoms and thresholds that were to be met in order for euthanasia to be considered by doctors, then, when she met those criteria.

From what you are saying about your grandmother's contented life and peaceful death, happily for all of you, she would never have met any thresholds that would have brought euthanasia into question.

kitex · 09/11/2026 09:21

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 09:07

Voluntary euthanasia IS giving the person a choice if when to die. But you nicely managed to avoid my question like a practiced MP

The point she should have been euthanised is when SHE said yes to it.

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 09:26

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 23:05

No. Everyone should have the right to die cleanly and easily. The counter to that is not "but what if some feel bad about being a burden" because it is ok to feel bad about being a burden, being a burden is a bad thing.

Are your parents still alive and healthy? And if so, would you write them off as a burden and a 'bad thing' if they developed a degenerative condition?

PencilsInSpace · 09/11/2026 09:30

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 07:38

It’s not about a duty, it’s about a free will decision made when one is still capable of taking one.

Personal attacks show you don’t understand that.

You may not be talking about a duty but have you somehow missed OP's posts? How else to interpret things like this:

And there is no greater burden than being a dementia patient. I think it's immoral not to care about that tbh.

It isn't sane to want to foist that version of yourself on them once the balance tips. If you loved them more than yourself.

And why should people expect to be a burden?

It's the only death really that involves potentially years of traumatising your closest loved ones with foul and erratic behaviour.

you could ruin your kids' lives with a very early diagnosis and healthy body.

I also find it incomprehensible that old people should be encouraged to stay alive because being a burden on their kids is fine

The counter to that is not "but what if some feel bad about being a burden" because it is ok to feel bad about being a burden, being a burden is a bad thing.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 09:31

I really feel this 'burden' argument is being given heavier weight than it should.

I have no one to burden when my time comes, unless you count the state, about which I couldn't care less.

I want the option of AD purely and simply for myself because I cannot bear the thought of being wholly incapable and utterly at the mercy of carers etc. to meet my basic needs.

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 09:32

BIossomtoes · 09/11/2026 08:50

There isn’t hope. Dementia is now the biggest cause of death in the UK. It’s a terminal disease. No amount of new treatment can prevent the horrible end that faces every dementia sufferer. There is no cure, the best anyone can hope for is a slowing down of its progression, ie prolonging the agony. By all means put safeguards in place but stop minimising it, there are people here with first hand experience you’re just not listening to.

Ok let’s leave aside the assumption that I have no first hand experience of dementia. (By which I assume you mean second hand unless you mean actual people living with dementia right now. If some of the commenters are living with dementia, their thoughts are obviously more interesting than mine. But I do keep a pretty close eye on Alzheimer’s research having seen two loved ones on the maternal side go that way.)

Let me google some of the recent advances in treating dementia for you, as this may be more positive for some of the people here, like me, with Alzheimer’s a strong presence in their genetic inheritance.

actually this is a pretty good overview but I am happy to put out more for anyone who is genuinely interested in prevention and treatment rather than just saying it’s a burden.

up to 45% of dementia risk can be prevented or delayed:

https://www.who.int/news/item/15-07-2026-new-who-guidelines--up-to-45--of-dementia-risk-could-be-prevented-or-delayed

as I say, happy to dig out more for anyone who is interested.

also - the reason that dementia is the leading cause of death is because we are all living older and the system has got better at things like cancer and heart disease. It’s mostly people over 80 being diagnosed. So as I said above I think there is absolutely a place for advance directives. Maybe even AD, I don’t know what I think about that yet. But there should also be more money for research into how to reduce the risk of it and also lessen its impact when it arrives.

But… I don’t want to derail the thread which was basically about AD rather than alternatives.

New WHO guidelines: up to 45% of dementia risk could be prevented or delayed

The World Health Organization (WHO) today released updated guidelines on reducing the risk of cognitive decline and dementia, providing countries with evidence-based recommendations to help prevent or delay the onset of dementia across the life course.

https://www.who.int/news/item/15-07-2026-new-who-guidelines--up-to-45--of-dementia-risk-could-be-prevented-or-delayed

PencilsInSpace · 09/11/2026 09:33

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 09:31

I really feel this 'burden' argument is being given heavier weight than it should.

I have no one to burden when my time comes, unless you count the state, about which I couldn't care less.

I want the option of AD purely and simply for myself because I cannot bear the thought of being wholly incapable and utterly at the mercy of carers etc. to meet my basic needs.

Take it up with the OP then but don't expect the rest of us to just skim past the apalling things she is saying.

biggreenbows · 09/11/2026 09:33

I have already seen one close relative suffer for years with dementia and now am watching my mother go through the same. I think there need to be a lot of changes to the way dementia patients are diagnosed and cared for. Until there are options for early diagnosis and suitable, affordable, care without putting a huge burden on family there will be too high a risk that decisions about assisted dying (if it was available) would be heavily influenced by financial/practical implications rather than a proper free choice. My experience is that currently in the UK there are very long waiting lists for diagnosis (so very often the disease has progressed quite far before any treatment can be offered) and unless the patient/family have resources to fund care privately people suffering with dementia are expected to remain in their own homes with carers visiting a few times a day unless they can meet very high criteria for needing residential care. This means lots of dementia patients spending long periods of time alone, confused and with limited ability to do things for themselves unless family are able to step in to help which even for a close family is difficult to manage with work/children etc to deal with too.
However, my experience is that no matter how well dementia patients are cared for these comes a time when their quality of life is at best low and at worst a sort of living nightmare where they don't know what's happening to them or who the people around them are. My personal wish, which I appreciate is unlikely to happen due to difficulties around being sure there is no coercion/the consent remains valid etc, would be that by the time I could face this I would be able to make an advance decision (whilst fit and well, I would do it now if it was an option) that if/when I am diagnosed with dementia and experience some specific symptoms I will be given medication to end my life. I wouldn't want to say that everyone should make that same decision, but I would want to encourage a more open discussion of what the disease is really like so that people can make their own informed decisions. I have see a lot of TV depictions etc where dementia is shown as a lovely elderly person living a rather innocent childlike life and just being a bit confused about who people are. Sadly that is a very long way from my experience of the disease.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 09:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 09:35

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 06:38

It's not as simple as that at all. My father had the best care and it didn't stop him having a miserable, degrading decline and drawn out death from Alzheimers. Its the nature of the disease.

I know and it's horrible, I'm going through it with my DM at present. My comment was directed more towards those on this thread who are advocating for people to be killed simply for being a perceived 'burden', or because care resources are scant, though.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 09:37

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 09:31

I really feel this 'burden' argument is being given heavier weight than it should.

I have no one to burden when my time comes, unless you count the state, about which I couldn't care less.

I want the option of AD purely and simply for myself because I cannot bear the thought of being wholly incapable and utterly at the mercy of carers etc. to meet my basic needs.

Yes I agree with that. Some people seem to think that only the state suffers when someone is a burden on it. The state has no ability to feel pain or panic or loneliness or humiliation. I do.

OP posts:
DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 09:46

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 09:32

Ok let’s leave aside the assumption that I have no first hand experience of dementia. (By which I assume you mean second hand unless you mean actual people living with dementia right now. If some of the commenters are living with dementia, their thoughts are obviously more interesting than mine. But I do keep a pretty close eye on Alzheimer’s research having seen two loved ones on the maternal side go that way.)

Let me google some of the recent advances in treating dementia for you, as this may be more positive for some of the people here, like me, with Alzheimer’s a strong presence in their genetic inheritance.

actually this is a pretty good overview but I am happy to put out more for anyone who is genuinely interested in prevention and treatment rather than just saying it’s a burden.

up to 45% of dementia risk can be prevented or delayed:

https://www.who.int/news/item/15-07-2026-new-who-guidelines--up-to-45--of-dementia-risk-could-be-prevented-or-delayed

as I say, happy to dig out more for anyone who is interested.

also - the reason that dementia is the leading cause of death is because we are all living older and the system has got better at things like cancer and heart disease. It’s mostly people over 80 being diagnosed. So as I said above I think there is absolutely a place for advance directives. Maybe even AD, I don’t know what I think about that yet. But there should also be more money for research into how to reduce the risk of it and also lessen its impact when it arrives.

But… I don’t want to derail the thread which was basically about AD rather than alternatives.

Sorry, but this falls under the 'tell us something we don't already know' heading.

From your link:

While there is no cure for dementia, up to 45% of the risks can be attributed to modifiable risk factors such as tobacco, alcohol use, social isolation, physical inactivity, air pollution and noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), including high blood pressure and diabetes.

Lead a healthy lifestyle and you're less likely to get ill. There's a surprise.

My parents -

  • neither of them smoked at all; or drank alcohol more than once or twice a year
  • they were extremely sociable until dementia shrank their worlds, active members of various clubs and societies including chairperson and treasurer positions
  • they were physically active - my mum used a gym and my dad cycled.
  • Neither has ever been overweight and their diet was healthy, home cooked food, very rarely fast food or takeaways, meat and two veg as was normal for their generation
  • Neither is diabetic
  • My mum had high blood pressure but it was controlled by medication
  • My dad has pretty much never had a day's illness in his life. He's never even had Covid even though he was going to the supermarket twice a week on the bus all through the height of the pandemic
  • Pollution is outside their control, but they don't live in a big city or heavy urban traffic area
  • Both retired early with the golden pensions common to their age group

Both now have dementia, my mum being at the end stages. So their healthy lifestyles were a fat lot of use, to put it bluntly. They might as well have drunk, smoked or eaten themselves to death, for my mum, at least the ending couldn't be any worse, my dad's progression is yet to be seen.

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 09:49

This thread is ridden with selective reading, wilful misunderstanding and whataboutery.

No one is advocating mass murder, all people want is to be able to choose a dignified exit for themselves should they need one.

One’s existence can be a burden on ourselves as well.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/11/2026 09:50

By the time my DM was diagnosed, fairly early on, she had completely forgotten what the GP had said by the time she got home around 15 minutes later. And just got angry if we tried to remind her - there was nothing wrong with her! So we soon stopped.

Previously she had often said that if she ever got dementia (like her sister) she’d take an overdose and would have some pills stashed away.
Roll on a few years, and she’d have completely forgotten that she ever said such a thing, or had any stash of pills - and anyway, why would she do such a thing when there was nothing wrong with her?

What we can all do, though, as dh and I have, after far too much experience of dementia, is to make very clear in an addition to a Health and Welfare Power of Attorney, in which circumstances (not just dementia) we would emphatically NOT want any life saving or life prolonging treatment.

I have honestly heard - with disbelief - of a 90 year old with dementia being fitted with a pacemaker. Apparently relatives had asked the medics what would happen if she didn’t have it - answer, most likely her heart would quietly give up in her sleep.
And they still went ahead. It beggars belief.

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 09:54

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 09:49

This thread is ridden with selective reading, wilful misunderstanding and whataboutery.

No one is advocating mass murder, all people want is to be able to choose a dignified exit for themselves should they need one.

One’s existence can be a burden on ourselves as well.

It is what people do when they have no real argument to deny the truth of what is being said. Unfortunately you see this across social media which means it is very different for serious debate on a topic. Sure you know this anyway but very frustrating sometimes isn't it.

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 09:56

Neverstopwondering · 09/11/2026 09:54

It is what people do when they have no real argument to deny the truth of what is being said. Unfortunately you see this across social media which means it is very different for serious debate on a topic. Sure you know this anyway but very frustrating sometimes isn't it.

I know.

It’s so frustrating though!

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 09:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Well, unlike you, I actually know something about this first-hand given that my mum is receiving care atm, and I have neither given up my job to 'change her and stop her wandering into the road', nor am I living in poverty. What I have done is arrange for her to be given the best care I'm able to source for her, and to help out myself as best I can.

What I wouldn't be doing, if I could turn the clock back to the date of her diagnosis and if assisted killing was available, would be coercing her to sign a form agreeing to be killed 'because you wouldn't want to be a burden to me, would you, mum?'

And you're being ridiculous about 'intimate care from an African male'. Women make up roughly 80% of the workforce in the UK care sector. I am curious as to why you think a carer being African makes the slightest difference, though.

Rootsinmydreamland · 09/11/2026 10:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I find your attitudes, expressed in this thread, to be extremely chilling and disturbing. It appears to have escaped your notice that, despite your troubling individualist dreams for the future, human beings have lived in communities for millennia, supporting each other in myriad ways. Individuals do not tend to thrive, either physically, psychologically or socially, when living entirely without human support.
The vast majority of humans, from all over the world and dating back to pre-historic times, have had help and support from their family and community, we literally would not have survived as a species without this social framework since none of us, no matter how physically strong or healthy, can do absolutely everything for ourselves. Even you, I imagine, rely on people to produce the food you eat, make the clothes you wear, build the property in which you live and staff and maintain a whole range of services and facilities you rely upon every day. However, if I am wrong and you are in fact somehow typing this on a home-made computer you've manufactured from some shells and twigs, having worked out how to create your own internet connection and are sat in a mud hut you built yourself on a deserted island then I stand corrected.
Your view that human existence becomes worthless and even immoral once someone becomes ill or disabled and requires any kind of physical or medical assistance is both upsetting and, to me at least, baffling.
There is another group in society who are extremely vulnerable, physically weak and who require constant care. They cannot feed themselves, are incontinent and have limited ability to communicate their needs. This group are babies and young children. Do you consider them to be a burden? How long do you think humankind would have lasted if we had failed to care for these most needy members of society? I would consider this when asserting that the disabled and elderly are all burdens who would be better off dead because, in your terrifying opinion, they can't offer anything useful to society and are only a drain.
I have been physically disabled since birth. I have a happy life, very happily married with a perfect toddler whom I adore and is my whole world, do a job I love and have a rich and full life generally. However, due to my severe disabilities, I do require extra care and support, both physically and through equipment and technology, to function daily. By your twisted logic, my family and friends would all be better off without me since I am a burden. Regardless of the fact I doubt they'd agree with that and I certainly don't want to be killed, thank you very much, even if you think I am a 'useless eater'.
The fact that MN allows long, rambling eugenicist threads like this to stand and flourish shows how seriously they take ableism, which is not very seriously at all!

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 10:03

I will just add to my post about my clean-living and healthy parents who are now in their early 80s with dementia.

By contrast, my late FIL was a smoker until his 50s, when he suffered a series of heart attacks. He gave smoking up but still enjoyed a daily beer, and whiskey at the weekend. He was a factory worker, working with machinery and exposed to pollution/chemicals, working till 65.

After recovering from his heart attacks he remained physically active, including playing his sport, and fully compos mentis until he was nearly 90, when he suffered heart failure, collapsed and died quickly and painlessly. The previous day he had been out and about with friends and playing his sport.

The moral of the story - it's all in your genes and there is very little you can do about it.

FIL was an absolutely lovely man, incidentally, I do not mean the above to siund grudging.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 10:13

We always get to this, don’t we? It’s tediously predictable

It's called looking at the bigger picture and asking the difficult questions, @Blossomtoes, which as @QiBengong explained so eloquently at 22:13 is exactly what the Lords were doing instead of vaguely hoping that the major potential issues would somehow resolve themselves or never happen - which from the attitudes we're seeing obviously isn't the case

It would have been better of course if this had been done by MPs in the first place instead of relying on assurances from those with clearly disturbing agendas, but at least they eventually woke up to the deceit around safeguarding which would doubtless have continued had it passed

As said before, many of us support AD made available as an option, but it has to be done in a considered manner and not just waved through carelessly because people want it. Something being popular doesn't always mean it's right, and I do worry - now some proponents' views are becoming so clear - that it may never pass

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 10:19

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 10:13

We always get to this, don’t we? It’s tediously predictable

It's called looking at the bigger picture and asking the difficult questions, @Blossomtoes, which as @QiBengong explained so eloquently at 22:13 is exactly what the Lords were doing instead of vaguely hoping that the major potential issues would somehow resolve themselves or never happen - which from the attitudes we're seeing obviously isn't the case

It would have been better of course if this had been done by MPs in the first place instead of relying on assurances from those with clearly disturbing agendas, but at least they eventually woke up to the deceit around safeguarding which would doubtless have continued had it passed

As said before, many of us support AD made available as an option, but it has to be done in a considered manner and not just waved through carelessly because people want it. Something being popular doesn't always mean it's right, and I do worry - now some proponents' views are becoming so clear - that it may never pass

Well, actually, you are looking at the exceptions and are trying to portray that as the bigger picture.

The bigger picture is allowing mercy to people who want it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread