Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop a family relationship? Is my moral barometer right? (SA)

104 replies

hnwis · 08/11/2026 08:27

Here’s the scenario: historic sexual abuse to a child in family. The person responsible was sent to prison over a decade ago, is now out & we have nothing to do with him. His step mum is my aunt. Up to now I’ve kept a relationship with her. I value her in my life, have always been close & she didn’t do wrong.. however she did visit offender in prison & have him back at her house for a time after prison because she is married to his father. I knew she felt uncomfortable about this & I certainly did too…but she did it as she loves the offenders father. The victim is my sister. She has always understood my relationship with aunt but not been 💯 happy about it, which I get. Sister has cut off all contact with aunt & her husband. Which I also totally get. It’s all bumped along for years. Recently aunt said to me that she saw everybody involved as equal victims. She also can’t understand why her husband, father of offender isn’t welcome to family events my sister is at. She believes everybody should ‘move on’ & she can not accept her & her husband’s support of the offender is a problem. I always thought she was stuck between a rock & hard place in this situation. I was of the mind that the horrific incident had caused enough family ruptures & my relationship with her was very boundaried (never included her husband). However since she’s disclosed these feelings I just can’t square it off anymore. I feel she should forever be respectful & indebted almost to my sister & therefore if it comes down to it, her husband should respectfully back away from family events my sister will be at. When I say family events, I mean the big emotional ones like funerals. I can see that having the father & supporter of your abuser pop up when you are at your most emotionally vulnerable is not on. It feels morally right to step away from my relationship with her on this basis now but emotionally wrong as life is too short to cut people out imo & I do miss her. But im fed up of being in the middle of the situation & I can’t honestly justify my relationship with her if she can’t see that time doesn’t erase the deep damage her husbands son caused. Should I keep a relationship with her or cut her off?

OP posts:
Hugasaurusrex · 08/11/2026 20:53

@hnwis you are getting all of this very black and white advice but you, having first hand experience, you know that the very definitive answers you are getting here are not how families handle CSA in the family.

It is not straight forward. It is messy and confusing and the level of rupture can be unparalleled.

I have family members who are teachers, nurses, doctors and other professionals extremely well versed in safeguarding and protecting children.

Their reaction to abuse was largely to carpet sweep it. People do not generally react appropriately to CSA in their own family.

You are doing your best and you are trying to limit the damage from this situation but I definitely think it is time to revise your original approach and end contact with your aunt.

70sgal · 08/11/2026 23:27

hnwis · 08/11/2026 08:38

She thinks the stepson is a victim too… those were the words that shifted everything for me. He has wrecked his life for sure. But he chose to do that. My sister didn’t get a choice.

If she includes the stepson as being a victim she’s deluded and doesn’t understand the gravity of what he has done to your sister. No length of time will ever make this go away. Because of this you should absolutely have no more to do with her.

In addition to this, your relationship with your aunt has not helped your sister move on from this either. She’s forever reminded of it when those close to the perpetrator are mentioned. She deserves a clean break from all of them.

Katemax82 · 08/11/2026 23:34

If my stepson abused my niece I'd no longer be married to his father let alone supporting both of them

Valeriekat · 10/11/2026 06:05

You are being unreasonable by having ANYTHING to do with your aunt.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page