Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop a family relationship? Is my moral barometer right? (SA)

104 replies

hnwis · 08/11/2026 08:27

Here’s the scenario: historic sexual abuse to a child in family. The person responsible was sent to prison over a decade ago, is now out & we have nothing to do with him. His step mum is my aunt. Up to now I’ve kept a relationship with her. I value her in my life, have always been close & she didn’t do wrong.. however she did visit offender in prison & have him back at her house for a time after prison because she is married to his father. I knew she felt uncomfortable about this & I certainly did too…but she did it as she loves the offenders father. The victim is my sister. She has always understood my relationship with aunt but not been 💯 happy about it, which I get. Sister has cut off all contact with aunt & her husband. Which I also totally get. It’s all bumped along for years. Recently aunt said to me that she saw everybody involved as equal victims. She also can’t understand why her husband, father of offender isn’t welcome to family events my sister is at. She believes everybody should ‘move on’ & she can not accept her & her husband’s support of the offender is a problem. I always thought she was stuck between a rock & hard place in this situation. I was of the mind that the horrific incident had caused enough family ruptures & my relationship with her was very boundaried (never included her husband). However since she’s disclosed these feelings I just can’t square it off anymore. I feel she should forever be respectful & indebted almost to my sister & therefore if it comes down to it, her husband should respectfully back away from family events my sister will be at. When I say family events, I mean the big emotional ones like funerals. I can see that having the father & supporter of your abuser pop up when you are at your most emotionally vulnerable is not on. It feels morally right to step away from my relationship with her on this basis now but emotionally wrong as life is too short to cut people out imo & I do miss her. But im fed up of being in the middle of the situation & I can’t honestly justify my relationship with her if she can’t see that time doesn’t erase the deep damage her husbands son caused. Should I keep a relationship with her or cut her off?

OP posts:
OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 09:23

hnwis · 08/11/2026 09:17

I see that now. I was younger, in my own head & there are various other nuanced factors that are too complicated to explain on here, but yes.. I think I should have. There’s no training manual when a bomb like this goes off in a family.

Yes, things are much easier to see objectively than when you're stuck in the middle of them! Especially if you were young. I'm sorry if my comment came across a little harshly - probably because it strikes very close to home for me.

Anyway - I do think that your aunt doesn't seem like a beneficial person to have in your life anymore, given both the negative effect on your sister, and the fact that she's in contact with a sexual abuser.

Hugasaurusrex · 08/11/2026 09:24

MellowSubmarine · 08/11/2026 08:31

she saw everybody involved as equal victims

I couldn’t continue a relationship with a family member who thought that about a situation involving a child being sexually abused.

Who does she think is an equal victim with your sister? Herself? Her husband? Surely not her stepson???

My mother feels the same way in a very similar situation because she is quite a narcissistic woman. I don’t have anything to do with any of them in the direct family of the abuser.

Like you I’m willing to not let the rupture go beyond that but other people who themselves have behaved poorly responding to the abuse I don’t have in my life either.

Catdoorman · 08/11/2026 09:45

hnwis · 08/11/2026 08:38

She thinks the stepson is a victim too… those were the words that shifted everything for me. He has wrecked his life for sure. But he chose to do that. My sister didn’t get a choice.

That's a slap in your sister's face, I would have asked her how exactly was he victimised? I think you should back away from your aunt, she seems to be trying to gain sympathy for her vile step son. It means she has never taken the abuse seriously.

Chipsahoy · 08/11/2026 09:49

Yeah you should have done that a long time ago. How can you support your sister and have any contact.

I was the victim in a not too dissimilar scenario. I have nothing to do with any of those people who kept contact. It’s my side, or you’re out.

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 09:50

Your aunt and her husband are victims in this. They're being ostracised from their family because of someone else's actions, to the extreme of not being welcome at funerals. I see where she is coming from. I also completely understand why your sister can't be around any of them. You're in a really difficult situation and I don't think it fair of anyone to bring you in to it and have any expectations of you. You should be able to have separate relationships with them both.

Somerford · 08/11/2026 09:55

hnwis · 08/11/2026 09:11

AIBU to stop a family relationship.

No, not at all unreasonable to cut contact with someone who has shown themselves to be a reprehensible peice of shit. You say life is too short to be cutting people off, I say its too short to spend your time and energy managing horrendous situations like this one. Imagine the harm it does to your sister to have this awful woman insisting that your sister's abuser is also a victim in all of this whilst demanding that everyone move on.

Somerford · 08/11/2026 09:57

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 09:50

Your aunt and her husband are victims in this. They're being ostracised from their family because of someone else's actions, to the extreme of not being welcome at funerals. I see where she is coming from. I also completely understand why your sister can't be around any of them. You're in a really difficult situation and I don't think it fair of anyone to bring you in to it and have any expectations of you. You should be able to have separate relationships with them both.

They choose to continue to support the abuser and the aunt is trying to persuade OP and the wider family that he is also a victim in all of this. If they're unwelcome at family events its because of their own actions.

Ilikethatusername · 08/11/2026 10:00

I speechless you have maintained a relationship with this despicable woman. I mean… her view on all being victims can’t have come out of no where

Ilikethatusername · 08/11/2026 10:00

Your poor sister

Your “Moral barometer” is iffy at best

yeesh · 08/11/2026 10:05

You should have cut her off to hen she kept in contact with him, she is a terrible person. How she could stay with her husband is beyond me. Cut her off and apologise to your sister for not doing it sooner.

Stayandfight · 08/11/2026 10:05

Ilikethatusername · 08/11/2026 10:00

Your poor sister

Your “Moral barometer” is iffy at best

Your moral barometer could do with a check if you think making a comment like this is in anyway helpful. The OP is clearly struggling, willing to admit she made mistakes, is aware that when younger she may not have been who she now wants to be. Thats a very human position and she is now sorting out a way forward. Good for her.

You’re just reading a post and being a cow. No excuse.

Ilikethatusername · 08/11/2026 10:05

hnwis · 08/11/2026 09:17

I see that now. I was younger, in my own head & there are various other nuanced factors that are too complicated to explain on here, but yes.. I think I should have. There’s no training manual when a bomb like this goes off in a family.

It was a decade ago.

How old are you now?

blythet · 08/11/2026 10:09

I wouldn’t see the SA as a reason to exclude your aunt (and potentially her DH) as it’s not something they had any control over or were involved in.

however the fact they have since supported the abuser and had a relationship with him would mean they were dead to me!!

I could never associate with anyone who supported someone who SAd my sister, let alone include them in family functions

FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 10:10

Your aunt is crackers. An apologist for an abuser.

I would have absolutely nothing to do with her. In fact, I would have cut her and her husband off when they maintained relations with the abuser. It’s astonishing that you didn’t do that. If I were your sister I would have cut relations with you for that. Nobody is safe around her because she wouldn’t protect the victims.

Why are you not angry?

FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 10:11

Stayandfight · 08/11/2026 10:05

Your moral barometer could do with a check if you think making a comment like this is in anyway helpful. The OP is clearly struggling, willing to admit she made mistakes, is aware that when younger she may not have been who she now wants to be. Thats a very human position and she is now sorting out a way forward. Good for her.

You’re just reading a post and being a cow. No excuse.

No. This post is accurate.

The op’s moral barometer is really off.

FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 10:13

I mean she says she’s fed up of being the middle of a situation. Ffs. Defend your sister op. She was abused. And all you can think about is being fed up for being in the middle of a situation. Don’t be in the middle. Cut off the scum who defend abusers. You sound awful.

Your poor sister. Zero allies.

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 10:13

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 09:50

Your aunt and her husband are victims in this. They're being ostracised from their family because of someone else's actions, to the extreme of not being welcome at funerals. I see where she is coming from. I also completely understand why your sister can't be around any of them. You're in a really difficult situation and I don't think it fair of anyone to bring you in to it and have any expectations of you. You should be able to have separate relationships with them both.

No. They're not victims, they're bystanders who are choosing to continue to have contact with a sex abuser. Why should anyone sympathise with them?

Stompythedinosaur · 08/11/2026 10:15

You are in the right, and I'd feel the same.

Your aunt and her husband need to understand that those family gatherings were stolen from them by the offender, not the victim. I do understand supporting your dc, given when they're in the wrong, but putting blame on the victim is outrageous.

OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 10:50

hnwis · 08/11/2026 08:38

She thinks the stepson is a victim too… those were the words that shifted everything for me. He has wrecked his life for sure. But he chose to do that. My sister didn’t get a choice.

I’m guessing they were both kids.

Was the stepson a victim of SA from an adult at any point?

I would sort of understand if she or her DH wanted to reconcile with other family members, or to even suggest the they were impacted by his actions too, but to say the words that stepson was a victim is such a slap in the face!

I would need to clarify explicitly how she thinks that he, the perpetrator, can be a victim?

If his life is ruined because of his actions, then that still doesn’t make him a victim.

Do they actually believe what happened or do they think your sister lied?

Laurmolonlabe · 08/11/2026 11:35

There are some things you can't move on from, and your aunt is unreasonable to expect this. A sexual predator is not a victim, they may have been in the past but as an abuser they are not a victim- otherwise one one ever needs to be responsible for their actions, which offends natural justice and the concept of being human.

Stayandfight · 08/11/2026 11:47

FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 10:13

I mean she says she’s fed up of being the middle of a situation. Ffs. Defend your sister op. She was abused. And all you can think about is being fed up for being in the middle of a situation. Don’t be in the middle. Cut off the scum who defend abusers. You sound awful.

Your poor sister. Zero allies.

She sounds human. The OP, I would imagine has defended her sister, but she has also supported her aunt. You can do both. When new information emerged she has changed her position. This is all perfectly reasonable.

Looking back she is wondering if she made a mistake - this is really sensible. We often make decisions when we are young and then revise and change - that’s what growing up and evolving as a person is all about. It’s really important we allow people the space to admit mistakes and move on.

I am aware enough of my own frailties to know there are times I’ve made mistakes, not all of us can sit at a keyboard and believe we have never made mistakes. You sound awful.

hnwis · 08/11/2026 11:48

They were both kids. No situation is entirely black and white of course and looking back it would have been easier to cut off from the start but it was complicated by older family members and as a mother I can see why my aunts husband would support his son despite the horrendous act he carried out. In turn I can see how my aunt didn’t want to blow up her whole life too. It’s easy to make quick judgements when you’re not on the situation yourself but that said I do think I got it wrong originally and I appreciate the objectivity of everyone responding to this and laying out why I must stand firm now. I don’t appreciate the attacks on my character or my moral compass. I should know inevitably this forum by now though! We’re all only human and trying to do our best. And I think that mindset is my issue.. I can see all sides of this shit storm but now I need to be strong and take a stand. Thanks everybody.

OP posts:
hnwis · 08/11/2026 11:49

@Stayandfightthank you.

OP posts:
FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 11:53

Stayandfight · 08/11/2026 11:47

She sounds human. The OP, I would imagine has defended her sister, but she has also supported her aunt. You can do both. When new information emerged she has changed her position. This is all perfectly reasonable.

Looking back she is wondering if she made a mistake - this is really sensible. We often make decisions when we are young and then revise and change - that’s what growing up and evolving as a person is all about. It’s really important we allow people the space to admit mistakes and move on.

I am aware enough of my own frailties to know there are times I’ve made mistakes, not all of us can sit at a keyboard and believe we have never made mistakes. You sound awful.

It’s pretty black and white I’m afraid.

Associating with people who defend and spend time with sex offenders is rank and indefensible.

Especially when the victim is your own sister.

it is you who is awful with your namby pamby enabling views.

You imagine the op has supported her sister. You imagine? The op associating with her aunt who defends the abuser is not one but supportive.

It’s awful when people refuse to take the hardline on abusers and their supporters. Really awful.

whippersnapper55 · 08/11/2026 12:11

I can understand you wanting to still have a relationship with your aunt but given her attitude, I don't think it's possible. She and her husband are not victims and have chosen to support your sister's abuser. I think in her position I would have a) refused to have him in my home and b) told my husband that if he wants to see his son, he will need to do that alone and away from our home.

I have had experience in my wider extended family of finding out there was sexual abuse of a family member in childhood. It's a horrific shock and really does rock you to your core. But support for the victim is paramount and your sister deserves that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread