Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop a family relationship? Is my moral barometer right? (SA)

104 replies

hnwis · 08/11/2026 08:27

Here’s the scenario: historic sexual abuse to a child in family. The person responsible was sent to prison over a decade ago, is now out & we have nothing to do with him. His step mum is my aunt. Up to now I’ve kept a relationship with her. I value her in my life, have always been close & she didn’t do wrong.. however she did visit offender in prison & have him back at her house for a time after prison because she is married to his father. I knew she felt uncomfortable about this & I certainly did too…but she did it as she loves the offenders father. The victim is my sister. She has always understood my relationship with aunt but not been 💯 happy about it, which I get. Sister has cut off all contact with aunt & her husband. Which I also totally get. It’s all bumped along for years. Recently aunt said to me that she saw everybody involved as equal victims. She also can’t understand why her husband, father of offender isn’t welcome to family events my sister is at. She believes everybody should ‘move on’ & she can not accept her & her husband’s support of the offender is a problem. I always thought she was stuck between a rock & hard place in this situation. I was of the mind that the horrific incident had caused enough family ruptures & my relationship with her was very boundaried (never included her husband). However since she’s disclosed these feelings I just can’t square it off anymore. I feel she should forever be respectful & indebted almost to my sister & therefore if it comes down to it, her husband should respectfully back away from family events my sister will be at. When I say family events, I mean the big emotional ones like funerals. I can see that having the father & supporter of your abuser pop up when you are at your most emotionally vulnerable is not on. It feels morally right to step away from my relationship with her on this basis now but emotionally wrong as life is too short to cut people out imo & I do miss her. But im fed up of being in the middle of the situation & I can’t honestly justify my relationship with her if she can’t see that time doesn’t erase the deep damage her husbands son caused. Should I keep a relationship with her or cut her off?

OP posts:
OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 15:25

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:15

He is not a child in any sense and not in the law!!

Sorry that wasn’t clear.

Yes by law he would have been adult but he still would have been treated differently than if the crime was committed when he say 30.

He would have been charged as an adult but the fact that he had just come out of adulthood and if it was a first offence would have allowed him to get off more lightly and therefore I wonder if his parents took this view too.

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:30

OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 15:25

Sorry that wasn’t clear.

Yes by law he would have been adult but he still would have been treated differently than if the crime was committed when he say 30.

He would have been charged as an adult but the fact that he had just come out of adulthood and if it was a first offence would have allowed him to get off more lightly and therefore I wonder if his parents took this view too.

Again incorrect

Once someone is deemed as an adult in law - it doesn’t matter if 18 or 58

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:30

The fact that @hnwis initially told us he was a child indicates to me that she also massively underplays this sexual abuse

saraclara · 08/11/2026 15:33

Your aunt and her husband are victims in this. They're being ostracised from their family because of someone else's actions, to the extreme of not being welcome at funerals. I see where she is coming from.

Me too, up to that point. But when she later called the abuser a victim, she completely blew it.

And you're right to have told her that, and stepped back from the relationship at that point, @hnwis

Chilihealer · 08/11/2026 15:37

Your aunt sounds like a very weak woman, if my partners son hurt my niece like that I’d blow my full family up in a heartbeat. I wouldn’t be visiting him in prison I know that. I’m sorry you’ve been put in this position but your absolutely correct it’s time to make a stand, your aunts clearly made her choice and it isn’t her flesh and blood.

UnbeatenMum · 08/11/2026 15:38

I guess the situation feels more nuanced to your Aunt if the perpetrator has a learning disability, although obviously he was considered fit to stand trial and serve a sentence. I don't think you're unreasonable to end the relationship. A custodial sentence means a serious crime was committed, however your Aunt tries to minimise it.

TMess · 08/11/2026 15:47

We have a very similar situation in our family. In my opinion anyone who supports an offender or downplays SA is an unsafe person to have around my children, we’ve cut them off.

hnwis · 08/11/2026 16:27

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:30

The fact that @hnwis initially told us he was a child indicates to me that she also massively underplays this sexual abuse

Why are you coming for me & judging me so harshly here? He was a very immature 18 year old who had himself been the victim of a very tough childhood. No learning disabilities. I have nothing but contempt for him & what he did. There are no excuses for it. I am of the mind that there is only one perpetrator in this. Him. My moral dilemma was how much should my aunt suffer the consequences of his actions. I have clarity on that from this thread now but do feel a little attacked too. As I’ve said before, I’m only trying to navigate an awful situation with as little collateral damage to my family as possible.

OP posts:
OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 16:27

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:30

Again incorrect

Once someone is deemed as an adult in law - it doesn’t matter if 18 or 58

You are naive if you think someones age and previous behaviour, doesn’t influence their sentencing.

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:28

hnwis · 08/11/2026 16:27

Why are you coming for me & judging me so harshly here? He was a very immature 18 year old who had himself been the victim of a very tough childhood. No learning disabilities. I have nothing but contempt for him & what he did. There are no excuses for it. I am of the mind that there is only one perpetrator in this. Him. My moral dilemma was how much should my aunt suffer the consequences of his actions. I have clarity on that from this thread now but do feel a little attacked too. As I’ve said before, I’m only trying to navigate an awful situation with as little collateral damage to my family as possible.

Excuses excuses

He was a man (despite you previously saying he was a child) who sexually abused your sister.

OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 16:30

hnwis · 08/11/2026 16:27

Why are you coming for me & judging me so harshly here? He was a very immature 18 year old who had himself been the victim of a very tough childhood. No learning disabilities. I have nothing but contempt for him & what he did. There are no excuses for it. I am of the mind that there is only one perpetrator in this. Him. My moral dilemma was how much should my aunt suffer the consequences of his actions. I have clarity on that from this thread now but do feel a little attacked too. As I’ve said before, I’m only trying to navigate an awful situation with as little collateral damage to my family as possible.

Not sure why you’re being judged here.

You have done nothing but be fully supportive of the victim and you’re now in the horrible position where you may potentially have to remove someone from your life, even though they weren’t the ones that committed the crime.

I guess it’s much easier to be so judgmental from behind a screen.

OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 16:30

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:28

Excuses excuses

He was a man (despite you previously saying he was a child) who sexually abused your sister.

You are sick in the head!

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:34

But your aunt has done a whole lot more than just remain in contact with him. She actually thinks that everyone involved is equal victims

hnwis · 08/11/2026 16:44

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:34

But your aunt has done a whole lot more than just remain in contact with him. She actually thinks that everyone involved is equal victims

Which is why I’m now cutting her out. Also I apologised up thread my wording was wrong - she thinks everybody is a victim, not everybody is an equal victim. Still bad enough for my gut to react as it has, but important to clarify. Like the child / adult distinction. I saw an immature & troubled 18 year old as a kid. I understand in the eyes of the law he was a man. I was not trying to conceal / reduce any part of this & your bitter comments suggesting I was are well out of line.

OP posts:
Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:46

The entire drip about him
being a child
Then not being a child
Then having endured abuse himself
The. having been “immature” and “troubled”

has been dripped to us.

Anyway you’ve cut her out. So job done

OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 17:01

hnwis · 08/11/2026 16:44

Which is why I’m now cutting her out. Also I apologised up thread my wording was wrong - she thinks everybody is a victim, not everybody is an equal victim. Still bad enough for my gut to react as it has, but important to clarify. Like the child / adult distinction. I saw an immature & troubled 18 year old as a kid. I understand in the eyes of the law he was a man. I was not trying to conceal / reduce any part of this & your bitter comments suggesting I was are well out of line.

Don’t even engage with that poster,

They obviously have an ulterior motive.

Stayandfight · 08/11/2026 17:03

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:46

The entire drip about him
being a child
Then not being a child
Then having endured abuse himself
The. having been “immature” and “troubled”

has been dripped to us.

Anyway you’ve cut her out. So job done

Job done - the job will never be done.

Posters looking for simple clean solutions are kidding themselves. This is a complicated case with conflicting emotions that the OP is trying to navigate. It will echo down the years and the OP has to make a decision she can live with for years.

Posters want this to be clear but when humans are involved things rarely are. It sounds like the OP has worked out a position that works for her, the job is not ‘done’ though as I’m sure the OP is far too aware.

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 17:15

The stepson is in no way a victim, he just faced the consequences of his actions.

I don’t think I could have the same relationship with someone after they said that about an abuse victim.

childrenaremyworld · 08/11/2026 17:22

I’m sorry but I personally couldn’t have a relationship with aunt or her husband, they have supported the offender. My sister would have to come first every time

FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 18:33

OffTheMap · 08/11/2026 15:22

It simply isn’t possible to ‘move on’ from SA.

Your aunt has to accept that, SUPPORT your sister’s boundaries and understand / empathise with the forever fractured line between her husband’s family and hers, or be on the far side of your family’s line.

She has made her position clear.

Stand with your sister.

It’s astonishing to me that anyone has to be told this: to stand by the victim of SA and cut off anyone who associates with abusers.

it’s really easy to grasp. Regardless of any family complexities.

FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 18:48

OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 12:51

It’s pretty black and white I’m afraid.

Associating with people who defend and spend time with sex offenders is rank and indefensible.

I don’t think it is black and white.

I know of someone whose 11yo assaulted their 13yo family member.
The 11yo was 100% in the wrong but he also emotionally young and vulnerable.

The 13yo ‘let it happen’ because she froze/ didn’t want to look weak but his defence was that he was therefore unable to understand to understand that she wasn’t a willing participant.

The mum felt she had failed him in some way and her options were to support him, have him live with her and try and teach him to not do it again or put him in care, mess him up even more and potentially lead to hurting other girls.

As a parent it’s an awful situation to be in and it’s not always black and white.

What a ludicrous example to provide.

Children vs an adult male abusing a young woman / girl.

🙄

andweallsingalong · 08/11/2026 19:01

hnwis · 08/11/2026 15:05

apologies if not clear. It all happened many years back. Over a decade ago he pled guilty & was sentenced to a short prison spell. He served his time & has been released for a few years now. He was 18 when the crime was committed but older when it came to light & he was sentenced. Him, my aunt & her husband accept he did what he did, indeed took him to the police, but downplaying it certainly makes it more comfortable for them & everybody in the family to some extent. Except the victim. The feeling I get now it’s all come up again is that enough time has passed that we should all be able to move on. That I can’t agree with. I thought my aunt understood it would never be ok. I think she has had to reduce the reality of what happened in order to live with it. I’m sad I’ll lose my relationship with her now when I thought we’d found a way to navigate round it some years back. But I can’t get past these comments.

With this in mind - that they took him to the police and didn't try and minimise or sweep under the carpet. I wouldn't have ostracised either of them and would have kept inviting both of them to family functions. Unless you feel they are responsible for his behaviour by abusing him as a child?

I would struggle if it were in my family, but rationally I understand that by standing by him, housing him and supporting him post release they lower his risk of reoffending and so would not judge them for that. Particularly, as they seem to have accepted him being excluded from family events and do not appear to have tried to get anyone else to accept him.

I do think her comments were insensitive and unacceptable. I can understand her thinking it, because their lives are all massively adversely affected and it's not her fault, but out of respect for the actual victim who was the real innocent I don't think she should have dreamt of saying it.

LaidOnYourBackWithTheBoyWithTheArabStrap · 08/11/2026 19:05

As soon as she started her shit about “everyone involved are victims” I would have cut her out of my life and told her exactly why. She’s not been stuck in the middle all this time, she’s made her choice: she chose her husband, his sexual predator son and she chose to “move on” from the crime he committed. Your sister didn’t get a choice in being abused and I know from experience you don’t get to choose if and when you move on from being abused.

OneHazelBird · 08/11/2026 19:49

FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 18:48

What a ludicrous example to provide.

Children vs an adult male abusing a young woman / girl.

🙄

OP said they were both children and didn’t give their ages at that point.

My reply was in response to a poster wondering why his parents didn’t kick him out of the house and wash their hands of him.

Its reasonable for a parent to feel that their child under a certain age is still their responsibility.

Blueseaurchin · 08/11/2026 19:57

TMess · 08/11/2026 15:47

We have a very similar situation in our family. In my opinion anyone who supports an offender or downplays SA is an unsafe person to have around my children, we’ve cut them off.

Agreed.

Anyone who describe a sex offender as a 'victim' and supports them is not worth having in your life.

I would cut her off OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread