Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you feel sorry for children in breakfast and after school club every day?

596 replies

numberblockhead · 05/11/2026 16:20

Just wondering. Considering career change but would involve y2 and yR age children doing the above every day.

OP posts:
Parker231 · 11/11/2026 15:18

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 15:02

No, Stay at Home Parents have the time to care for their children properly when they are ill and run down, quickly seeking GP appointments and much overlooked rest where needed. They don’t send obviously sick children to school, their health comes first. They also have the time to teach their babies/toddlers how to speak properly by speaking to them a lot themselves, then to oversee homework and ensure it is done as they get older (studies have proven this is a benefit educationally). By being present, they can best support their children emotionally, young children like to have someone to listen to them share news after school which feels big to them about their day. Two working parents can throw more money at their children and buy them more expensive things, but modern day rush and hustle culture means so much more is lost that only buying less to free up proper time can provide.

All those things you have mentioned working parents do - DH and I certainly did
Working parents care for their children as well as any parent - you aren’t a worst parent by working full time. My DT’s have benefited hugely (both with all A grades and 2st class honours degrees) - and they loved breakfast and after school clubs.

Parker231 · 11/11/2026 15:27

Parker231 · 11/11/2026 15:18

All those things you have mentioned working parents do - DH and I certainly did
Working parents care for their children as well as any parent - you aren’t a worst parent by working full time. My DT’s have benefited hugely (both with all A grades and 2st class honours degrees) - and they loved breakfast and after school clubs.

1st class degrees - both of the DT’s - not 2nd class!

IsThisJustLifeInTheSouth · 11/11/2026 17:18

This is just inflammatory trolling 🤣

The reality is that working parents do miss out on somw things with their kids. But unless one parent is an unusually high earner, children with a SAHP miss out on things too. Like seeing both parents enjoy a career, and absolute equality in a relationship.

working parents love and care for their kids just as well as you do yours. I’ve always taken them to a gp as soon as needed, give them cuddles when they are sick, don’t send them anywhere ill and my kids are incredibly articulate thanks very much (despite being in nursery from 9 months old 😱). I love hearing about their day and they confide in me.

. My kids are tucked up by one of us most nights, and when it’s not us, it’s a beloved grandparent. We have all the things you do AND we can throw money at them and treat them to wonderful experiences. I get it, you’re mean because it hurts. Jealousy isn’t a good look though 😘

baftaagain · 11/11/2026 17:44

"throw money at them", nice.

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 18:15

IsThisJustLifeInTheSouth · 11/11/2026 17:18

This is just inflammatory trolling 🤣

The reality is that working parents do miss out on somw things with their kids. But unless one parent is an unusually high earner, children with a SAHP miss out on things too. Like seeing both parents enjoy a career, and absolute equality in a relationship.

working parents love and care for their kids just as well as you do yours. I’ve always taken them to a gp as soon as needed, give them cuddles when they are sick, don’t send them anywhere ill and my kids are incredibly articulate thanks very much (despite being in nursery from 9 months old 😱). I love hearing about their day and they confide in me.

. My kids are tucked up by one of us most nights, and when it’s not us, it’s a beloved grandparent. We have all the things you do AND we can throw money at them and treat them to wonderful experiences. I get it, you’re mean because it hurts. Jealousy isn’t a good look though 😘

Definitely not jealous, just absolutely sick of people making out they do exactly the same whilst working FT. They don’t, I can’t listen to the utter rubbish. Clearly trying to make themselves feel better. Also sick of the ‘equality’ rubbish, having a job doesn’t define you, every human being has inherent, equal, worth and value. Just like the strongest businesses, the strongest marriages and families actually thrive when Mum and Dad know their roles, play to their strengths, and stop wasting so much time bickering over each person doing exactly half of everything, ridiculous! People need to grow up, stop point scoring and put their children first!

malloryknox123 · 11/11/2026 18:29

Why? Because their parents have to start work at 9 and finish at 5? The bastards!

ByKindOpalPoet · 11/11/2026 18:37

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 18:15

Definitely not jealous, just absolutely sick of people making out they do exactly the same whilst working FT. They don’t, I can’t listen to the utter rubbish. Clearly trying to make themselves feel better. Also sick of the ‘equality’ rubbish, having a job doesn’t define you, every human being has inherent, equal, worth and value. Just like the strongest businesses, the strongest marriages and families actually thrive when Mum and Dad know their roles, play to their strengths, and stop wasting so much time bickering over each person doing exactly half of everything, ridiculous! People need to grow up, stop point scoring and put their children first!

oh fuck off

yes we fucking do. we do everything you do and WE FUCKING DO IT WHILE WORKING FULL TIME. It is NOT utter rubbish at all. Im sick of people like you making out we don't.

We also look after our children properly when they are ill and run down (we take unpaid days off to do this btw which reduces our pay), we also quickly seek GP appointments - again taking unpaid days off to do this. We also don’t send obviously sick children to school, as yes their health comes first (see above about unpaid days off). We also teach our babies/toddlers how to speak properly by speaking to them a lot themselves (its insulting to suggest that working parents don't speak to their children and can't teach their children to speak properly), we also oversee homework and ensure it is done as they get older. We are also present, and support tour children emotionally, and listen to them share news after school. That is NOT unique to SAHM no matter how much you lie to yourself to make yourself feel better, to justify your decision.

'People need to grow up, stop point scoring and put their children first!' - DO THIS YOUR BLOODY SELF!!!! Maybe SAHM and mothers who work school hours should grow up themselves, stop point scoring, stop making out that they are soooooo much better than working mothers and put their own children first instead of slagging working mothers and acting like they are superior and 'perfect parents'

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 19:18

ByKindOpalPoet · 11/11/2026 18:37

oh fuck off

yes we fucking do. we do everything you do and WE FUCKING DO IT WHILE WORKING FULL TIME. It is NOT utter rubbish at all. Im sick of people like you making out we don't.

We also look after our children properly when they are ill and run down (we take unpaid days off to do this btw which reduces our pay), we also quickly seek GP appointments - again taking unpaid days off to do this. We also don’t send obviously sick children to school, as yes their health comes first (see above about unpaid days off). We also teach our babies/toddlers how to speak properly by speaking to them a lot themselves (its insulting to suggest that working parents don't speak to their children and can't teach their children to speak properly), we also oversee homework and ensure it is done as they get older. We are also present, and support tour children emotionally, and listen to them share news after school. That is NOT unique to SAHM no matter how much you lie to yourself to make yourself feel better, to justify your decision.

'People need to grow up, stop point scoring and put their children first!' - DO THIS YOUR BLOODY SELF!!!! Maybe SAHM and mothers who work school hours should grow up themselves, stop point scoring, stop making out that they are soooooo much better than working mothers and put their own children first instead of slagging working mothers and acting like they are superior and 'perfect parents'

Edited

You can swear all you like, but I am free to disagree with you. That’s life, part of being an adult is coping with people living differently and completely disagreeing with you. You don’t get to dictate that everyone thinks the same as you.

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 19:22

IsThisJustLifeInTheSouth · 11/11/2026 17:18

This is just inflammatory trolling 🤣

The reality is that working parents do miss out on somw things with their kids. But unless one parent is an unusually high earner, children with a SAHP miss out on things too. Like seeing both parents enjoy a career, and absolute equality in a relationship.

working parents love and care for their kids just as well as you do yours. I’ve always taken them to a gp as soon as needed, give them cuddles when they are sick, don’t send them anywhere ill and my kids are incredibly articulate thanks very much (despite being in nursery from 9 months old 😱). I love hearing about their day and they confide in me.

. My kids are tucked up by one of us most nights, and when it’s not us, it’s a beloved grandparent. We have all the things you do AND we can throw money at them and treat them to wonderful experiences. I get it, you’re mean because it hurts. Jealousy isn’t a good look though 😘

Oh yes, it’s always the same women who couldn’t possibly be dependent on their husband who have no issue palming off their own parental duties onto either their own mother or MIL. Wonderful, how independent to be a grown woman still relying on Mummy to pick up your own kids, put them to bed, cook dinner, wash your clothes, do homework, take them to A & E (!), yes all things women in real life tell me so proudly! Seriously, take your own kid to A & E, I was appalled. How very independent of them! 🤣

Arbourimage · 11/11/2026 19:35

yes we fucking do. we do everything you do and WE FUCKING DO IT WHILE WORKING FULL TIME. It is NOT utter rubbish at all. Im sick of people like you making out we don't.

I’m not sure why people still try to claim this.
You literally can’t possibly do what a SAHP does while working full time though. It’s not physically possible, it’s a stupid thing to claim is reality.
From this thread many people who work full time have their children in wrap around for about 4 hours a day, that’s often more time than the parent even has awake with their children on a school day.
You might do all the normal parenting stuff for them when you are with them, but the window in which you actually do that is greatly reduced.

IsThisJustLifeInTheSouth · 11/11/2026 19:52

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 18:15

Definitely not jealous, just absolutely sick of people making out they do exactly the same whilst working FT. They don’t, I can’t listen to the utter rubbish. Clearly trying to make themselves feel better. Also sick of the ‘equality’ rubbish, having a job doesn’t define you, every human being has inherent, equal, worth and value. Just like the strongest businesses, the strongest marriages and families actually thrive when Mum and Dad know their roles, play to their strengths, and stop wasting so much time bickering over each person doing exactly half of everything, ridiculous! People need to grow up, stop point scoring and put their children first!

I think what I (and presumably others) is your assertion that a SAHP puts their children first in a way that working parents don’t. That is inflammatory. We both have different views about what is best for our children. For me, my children having a fulfilled parent who enjoys a career and still parents them well (albeit over less time than a SAHP) is the right choice for our family. Stop calling us selfish.

numberblockhead · 11/11/2026 20:28

IsThisJustLifeInTheSouth · 11/11/2026 19:52

I think what I (and presumably others) is your assertion that a SAHP puts their children first in a way that working parents don’t. That is inflammatory. We both have different views about what is best for our children. For me, my children having a fulfilled parent who enjoys a career and still parents them well (albeit over less time than a SAHP) is the right choice for our family. Stop calling us selfish.

I agree with you and I also think those statements were purposefully provocative.

OP posts:
Parker231 · 12/11/2026 13:35

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 15:02

No, Stay at Home Parents have the time to care for their children properly when they are ill and run down, quickly seeking GP appointments and much overlooked rest where needed. They don’t send obviously sick children to school, their health comes first. They also have the time to teach their babies/toddlers how to speak properly by speaking to them a lot themselves, then to oversee homework and ensure it is done as they get older (studies have proven this is a benefit educationally). By being present, they can best support their children emotionally, young children like to have someone to listen to them share news after school which feels big to them about their day. Two working parents can throw more money at their children and buy them more expensive things, but modern day rush and hustle culture means so much more is lost that only buying less to free up proper time can provide.

As two working parents we didn’t throw money at them or buy expensive things. We provided them with a high quality education, Uni debt free and deposits for their first homes. They didn’t have lots of ‘stuff’ but opportunities and experiences.

This I think is the opposite of being selfish but the characteristics of a good parent, putting their DC’s first and ensuring they have a great start in life. If that involves attending breakfast and after school club, which they enjoyed, a win all around. Happy children and happy parents providing the best for their DC’s and being able to enjoy and continue with their careers.

VioletsTale · 12/11/2026 19:59

Arbourimage · 11/11/2026 19:35

yes we fucking do. we do everything you do and WE FUCKING DO IT WHILE WORKING FULL TIME. It is NOT utter rubbish at all. Im sick of people like you making out we don't.

I’m not sure why people still try to claim this.
You literally can’t possibly do what a SAHP does while working full time though. It’s not physically possible, it’s a stupid thing to claim is reality.
From this thread many people who work full time have their children in wrap around for about 4 hours a day, that’s often more time than the parent even has awake with their children on a school day.
You might do all the normal parenting stuff for them when you are with them, but the window in which you actually do that is greatly reduced.

Well let’s see. Wake DD up, make her breakfast, help her get dressed, do her hair , get everything ready , take her to school (at 7:45).Pick her up at 4, home by 4:10. Sometimes later if she did an activity after school club which she chose.Got changed, talked through her day, messed around. She then got half an hour/hour quiet time-through choice. Make dinner while she read to me , we did homework etc. Eat together. She played while I tidied up and did the dishes. Normally all done and settled by 6:30. Play or chill together. Then bedtime routine and reading books in bed by 7:30 (this got later as she got older). Some days would be playdates, or events or whatever , but that was the normalish routine. What exactly did I miss out? Or what did she miss out on by me working rather than being a SAHM? I guess the extra 2 hourish a day, but let’s be honest, mornings, even with a SAHP aren’t all sunshine and rainbows and bonding. As for the afternoons, I would’ve lost that anyway as she really wanted to do those clubs and she always had at least 2/3 on the go.

TheJoyousBiscuit · 13/11/2026 18:47

Yes it’s totally norm

Parker231 · 14/11/2026 09:31

TheJoyousBiscuit · 13/11/2026 18:47

Yes it’s totally norm

What I don’t get is why some people think it’s selfish using a breakfast and after school club . It’s not like you are abandoning your children whilst you go on holiday without them.
Going to work doesn’t stop just because you became parents.

TheJoyousBiscuit · 15/11/2026 13:35

Parker231 · 14/11/2026 09:31

What I don’t get is why some people think it’s selfish using a breakfast and after school club . It’s not like you are abandoning your children whilst you go on holiday without them.
Going to work doesn’t stop just because you became parents.

Area agreeing with me or disagreeing because if ur disagreeing u have totally mis understood my point

Parker231 · 15/11/2026 14:57

TheJoyousBiscuit · 15/11/2026 13:35

Area agreeing with me or disagreeing because if ur disagreeing u have totally mis understood my point

Agreeing - breakfast and after school clubs were the norm for DT’s and their friends. A positive and not any negatives.

TheJoyousBiscuit · 15/11/2026 18:26

Parker231 · 15/11/2026 14:57

Agreeing - breakfast and after school clubs were the norm for DT’s and their friends. A positive and not any negatives.

Ok thanks for confirming! I was unsure!

metellaestinatrio · Today 09:09

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:18

Its not the same situation though. Childcare standards have improved markedly in 30 years.

Perhaps (although some might only be talking about 15 or 20 years ago). But children haven’t changed, and while some will be very happy to be charging about with their friends at ASC, there are others who would much rather be relaxing in their own quiet space at home. For those children ASC every day is awful. Only OP knows her children’s personalities and how they are likely to react.

Those who have spent the whole thread insisting that every child has the time of their life at breakfast and after school club either have no understanding that children have different personalities or are protesting too much because their own kids were in school 50 hours a week.

metellaestinatrio · Today 09:13

Parker231 · 10/11/2026 23:07

They aren’t with strangers - they’re with friends having fun! Loads of different activities to choose from. Hanging out with friends.
Most of the class at DT’s school went to after school club. Those who didn’t were unhappy as they saw they were missing additional time to play with friends.

@ThankYouNigel didn’t say they were with strangers, she said they were with people they didn’t choose to be around (the equivalent of work colleagues, which is exactly right - some will be friends, others neutral acquaintances, others they won’t like). For example, at my children’s school a notorious bully was at ASC every day which made other kids not want to go. Obviously it’s down to the school to deal with that, but while they are doing so it’s understandable some children would rather go home.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread