Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you feel sorry for children in breakfast and after school club every day?

596 replies

numberblockhead · 05/11/2026 16:20

Just wondering. Considering career change but would involve y2 and yR age children doing the above every day.

OP posts:
metellaestinatrio · 10/11/2026 05:42

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 08:41

Where are all these careers where you can comprise the working day and start late and finish in the middle of the afternoon?

Well I have a senior professional job and manage to pick my kids up at 3.30 four days out of five by working part-time hours spread across the week and mainly from home. I have been at my firm a long time and have sufficient goodwill and autonomy for my boss to agree this arrangement. I will do calls (e.g. with people in the US) later in the evening but 3.30 - 7 is kept free so I can collect the children and take them to their various activities, do homework, play dates and so on. They much prefer this to after school club at school (which they didn’t mind when younger but now would rather avoid if possible).

Maisymouse2 · 10/11/2026 05:44

Good idea
If the kids are happy to go and no ones climbing the walls having a meltdown .
Is this a extra service or option for less fortunate kids or any kids?

metellaestinatrio · 10/11/2026 05:45

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 09:00

Neither DH or I worked in careers like that (one medicine, one corporate finance).

Sure, but that doesn’t mean they don’t exist, as you were implying in your previous post.

OrangeSlices998 · 10/11/2026 06:01

My DH and I have purposefully arranged our work weeks to ensure the kids aren’t in ASC everyday, our kids ask to go more days which is lovely but they’re also exhausted on a whole different level the days they do go (5 & 7). I love my days to pick them up and go to the park or just go home, they want to play with their own toys and have various clubs etc. I’d rather take some financial hit for now personally and have a NWD and an early finish another day - luckily work are very flexible. Yeah it’s playing but it’s not their toys in their house, and I love that they love ASC but I don’t think they’d cope very well 5 mornings in BSC and 5 afternoons in ASC, especially with their various clubs and activities.

metellaestinatrio · 10/11/2026 06:13

Parker231 · 07/11/2026 19:35

It’s a pity that all after school clubs are organised to a higher standard, then the children posters have said don’t enjoy them, might.

That generally means more funding, and then parents complain to the school about the cost and how the clubs are not sufficiently inclusive. I assume, given your high flying careers, that your children went to either a private school or a state school in a “naice” area where parents were able to afford to pay more for after school club and therefore the club was well staffed, had decent quality food and plenty of supplies for varied activities. That’s not the case at all after school clubs.

Circe7 · 10/11/2026 09:27

metellaestinatrio · 10/11/2026 06:13

That generally means more funding, and then parents complain to the school about the cost and how the clubs are not sufficiently inclusive. I assume, given your high flying careers, that your children went to either a private school or a state school in a “naice” area where parents were able to afford to pay more for after school club and therefore the club was well staffed, had decent quality food and plenty of supplies for varied activities. That’s not the case at all after school clubs.

I think the quality of it is key.

My children are at prep school and a huge factor in this is the availability and quality of the wraparound care.

There is a choice of clubs everyday until 4.45, often taught by external coaches. Younger children have the option to go to a special club where they just have a snack, story, play, CBeebies in a small group. I don’t think it’s hugely more onerous than being at home though obviously still a group setting.

They can then stay until six and have a cooked dinner at school, which they usually really like.

The wraparound care is well used because most parents work so they are almost always with friends from their year.

baftaagain · 10/11/2026 10:03

Children really need proper time to decompress after school at home for their mental well being I agree

What a ridiculous state of affairs.

villadicance · 10/11/2026 11:05

Circe7 · 10/11/2026 09:27

I think the quality of it is key.

My children are at prep school and a huge factor in this is the availability and quality of the wraparound care.

There is a choice of clubs everyday until 4.45, often taught by external coaches. Younger children have the option to go to a special club where they just have a snack, story, play, CBeebies in a small group. I don’t think it’s hugely more onerous than being at home though obviously still a group setting.

They can then stay until six and have a cooked dinner at school, which they usually really like.

The wraparound care is well used because most parents work so they are almost always with friends from their year.

This is exactly what my kids state school is like. The quality of it makes such a difference.

My kids feel like they get decompression time if they need it but can also be active if they need it. They also really enjoy being with kids from other years.

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:15

ThankYouNigel · 09/11/2026 21:12

No it is not. I taught Reception for 10 years, have you actually taught it yourself? I have spent hours and hours with hundreds of 4-5 year olds observing how they behave through the day, they get tired. I also collect my own children every day after school, the school day is long enough and academically rigorous, there is no way need to be there any longer, certainly not every day. They’ve had enough and should not be expected to do the same length of day as a working adult. They are not adults.

But they arent 'there' any longer. After school care isnt school. They arent doing lessons, they are playing lego, reading, playing basketball, doing stickers etc.

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:18

metellaestinatrio · 10/11/2026 05:32

Do you feel sorry for those on this thread who had to go to full-time wraparound as children and say they hated it?

Its not the same situation though. Childcare standards have improved markedly in 30 years.

Parker231 · 10/11/2026 12:29

villadicance · 10/11/2026 11:05

This is exactly what my kids state school is like. The quality of it makes such a difference.

My kids feel like they get decompression time if they need it but can also be active if they need it. They also really enjoy being with kids from other years.

I remember how excited DS was at getting a party invite from a boy a year older - he loved doing football with different age groups

ThankYouNigel · 10/11/2026 22:41

TheAmberKoala · 10/11/2026 12:15

But they arent 'there' any longer. After school care isnt school. They arent doing lessons, they are playing lego, reading, playing basketball, doing stickers etc.

Hmm, consider when you finish work, would you then like to be forced to stay another couple of hours ‘relaxing’ in your workplace, still around others you have no real choice to be around, over having far more autonomy in how you choose to properly relax in your own home. I remember as a child having my own book and puzzle I wanted to get back to at home, my own garden to play in, my own friends down the road to knock for. Adults would never stand for it, hence why many more now actually choose to work from home, because they feel more comfortable and have greater autonomy in their own environment.

Parker231 · 10/11/2026 23:07

ThankYouNigel · 10/11/2026 22:41

Hmm, consider when you finish work, would you then like to be forced to stay another couple of hours ‘relaxing’ in your workplace, still around others you have no real choice to be around, over having far more autonomy in how you choose to properly relax in your own home. I remember as a child having my own book and puzzle I wanted to get back to at home, my own garden to play in, my own friends down the road to knock for. Adults would never stand for it, hence why many more now actually choose to work from home, because they feel more comfortable and have greater autonomy in their own environment.

They aren’t with strangers - they’re with friends having fun! Loads of different activities to choose from. Hanging out with friends.
Most of the class at DT’s school went to after school club. Those who didn’t were unhappy as they saw they were missing additional time to play with friends.

TheAmberKoala · 11/11/2026 10:26

ThankYouNigel · 10/11/2026 22:41

Hmm, consider when you finish work, would you then like to be forced to stay another couple of hours ‘relaxing’ in your workplace, still around others you have no real choice to be around, over having far more autonomy in how you choose to properly relax in your own home. I remember as a child having my own book and puzzle I wanted to get back to at home, my own garden to play in, my own friends down the road to knock for. Adults would never stand for it, hence why many more now actually choose to work from home, because they feel more comfortable and have greater autonomy in their own environment.

Well the thing is, they have a pile of options at ASC. They dont have to socialise with other kids, they can chill out in the corner. They can play with different kids to the ones in their class. They have certain toys that only come out at osch.
Loads of people on here have given you proof that most kids like going to after school care.
And lots of kids go to activities after school, mine did basketball and there were quite a number of the kids from school at training. Not so different to the osch kids playing scratch match on the basketball court.
Kids are all different. Some struggle with busy or noisy environments, and others thrive. A good asc will give the kid an option that works for them.

TheAmberKoala · 11/11/2026 10:28

Parker231 · 10/11/2026 23:07

They aren’t with strangers - they’re with friends having fun! Loads of different activities to choose from. Hanging out with friends.
Most of the class at DT’s school went to after school club. Those who didn’t were unhappy as they saw they were missing additional time to play with friends.

isnt it funny how people take digs at childcare workers by calling them 'strangers' yet take digs at after school care by saying 'stuck with the same people'.
I think really, its a dig at working mums.

TheAmberKoala · 11/11/2026 10:31

baftaagain · 08/11/2026 09:03

Poor little kids nodding off. I can just imagine the overload and then the calls for some sort of test and diagnosis.

PP was talking about school, not asc. Are you saying that school causes fake diagnosis in children, because it sounds like thats what you are implying.
I have multiple friends who teach reception and they dont have this happen. But like I said, its play based where I am.

baftaagain · 11/11/2026 11:09

TheAmberKoala · 11/11/2026 10:31

PP was talking about school, not asc. Are you saying that school causes fake diagnosis in children, because it sounds like thats what you are implying.
I have multiple friends who teach reception and they dont have this happen. But like I said, its play based where I am.

Your last sentence says it all. Play and so it should be. I feel that some people are very quick to reach for a diagnosis when given time and age appropriate expectations, children can and do develop and change.

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 12:37

TheAmberKoala · 11/11/2026 10:26

Well the thing is, they have a pile of options at ASC. They dont have to socialise with other kids, they can chill out in the corner. They can play with different kids to the ones in their class. They have certain toys that only come out at osch.
Loads of people on here have given you proof that most kids like going to after school care.
And lots of kids go to activities after school, mine did basketball and there were quite a number of the kids from school at training. Not so different to the osch kids playing scratch match on the basketball court.
Kids are all different. Some struggle with busy or noisy environments, and others thrive. A good asc will give the kid an option that works for them.

And some children do not like going, and are there because it suits their parents, not them. I was asked only yesterday to pick a friend’s child up to come round after school while she takes her other child somewhere important, as her child doesn’t like going to ASC and made that clear.

One of mine actually goes 1 day to ASC to play with a close friend who has to go. That is my child’s choice though, he is old enough to tell me he likes seeing his friend there, and is not there for my own convenience.

Let’s agree to disagree. These things are optional for all parents to decide if/when they would like to use them.

numberblockhead · 11/11/2026 12:39

We went past a school the other day and ds asked why it was still open. Explained some schools are open until late doing ‘club’ and he replied they were really lucky 😂

OP posts:
TheAmberKoala · 11/11/2026 12:48

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 12:37

And some children do not like going, and are there because it suits their parents, not them. I was asked only yesterday to pick a friend’s child up to come round after school while she takes her other child somewhere important, as her child doesn’t like going to ASC and made that clear.

One of mine actually goes 1 day to ASC to play with a close friend who has to go. That is my child’s choice though, he is old enough to tell me he likes seeing his friend there, and is not there for my own convenience.

Let’s agree to disagree. These things are optional for all parents to decide if/when they would like to use them.

'suits the parents' is a sly insult the privileged like to sling from their high horses.
Yes, it suits the parents to have a roof over the kids head and food on the table.
Children of working mothers do better in social, health, emotional and educational outcomes, but dont let that get in the way of a good showing off of how much of a superior parent you are, will you now?

ladygindiva · 11/11/2026 12:50

Not if it's a good provision. The one at ours is brilliant, they play games, do craft and play outside. Mine have learnt to knit and play chess there, they love it .

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 12:59

TheAmberKoala · 11/11/2026 12:48

'suits the parents' is a sly insult the privileged like to sling from their high horses.
Yes, it suits the parents to have a roof over the kids head and food on the table.
Children of working mothers do better in social, health, emotional and educational outcomes, but dont let that get in the way of a good showing off of how much of a superior parent you are, will you now?

They really do need to bring back that 😂 emoji…you keep on telling yourself that 👌🏻😂

Parker231 · 11/11/2026 13:08

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 12:37

And some children do not like going, and are there because it suits their parents, not them. I was asked only yesterday to pick a friend’s child up to come round after school while she takes her other child somewhere important, as her child doesn’t like going to ASC and made that clear.

One of mine actually goes 1 day to ASC to play with a close friend who has to go. That is my child’s choice though, he is old enough to tell me he likes seeing his friend there, and is not there for my own convenience.

Let’s agree to disagree. These things are optional for all parents to decide if/when they would like to use them.

“Suits their parents “. Going to work is a part of life, not suitable parents, having a good career is something to aspire to. Providing a better life for your family is suiting everyone.

Parker231 · 11/11/2026 13:09

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 12:59

They really do need to bring back that 😂 emoji…you keep on telling yourself that 👌🏻😂

You don’t think providing better health, social and emotional and educational outcomes is something working parents don’t provide?

ThankYouNigel · 11/11/2026 15:02

Parker231 · 11/11/2026 13:09

You don’t think providing better health, social and emotional and educational outcomes is something working parents don’t provide?

No, Stay at Home Parents have the time to care for their children properly when they are ill and run down, quickly seeking GP appointments and much overlooked rest where needed. They don’t send obviously sick children to school, their health comes first. They also have the time to teach their babies/toddlers how to speak properly by speaking to them a lot themselves, then to oversee homework and ensure it is done as they get older (studies have proven this is a benefit educationally). By being present, they can best support their children emotionally, young children like to have someone to listen to them share news after school which feels big to them about their day. Two working parents can throw more money at their children and buy them more expensive things, but modern day rush and hustle culture means so much more is lost that only buying less to free up proper time can provide.