Problem is by year 4 to 6 they're old enough to understand that making a fuss won't change it and put up with it. They're also much more likely to complain to parents and friends than the afterschool provider.
Two of mine needed to get downtime when they got home. One in particular needed to get away from everyone and would spend 30-60 minutes alone. On the times he did do afterschool club, which would have been until about 5, his behaviour after pick up showed the stress he had been under. He did quite enjoy the activities offered, but the extra 90 minutes of being there put him under a lot of strain.
It does depend on the child but declaring they all.love it, or if they're well organised it is great, doesn't allow for the individuals concerned.
Even as adults we are different. I went from part time to full time a few years ago and find that when I arrive home ( dc are now adults) I need that time alone for a bit. If I work late, I sleep less well and am definitely easier to get frustrated etc.
Dh prefers to do what to me are very long days, as long as he gets Saturday to recover, and then gets time if in lieu later.
Dd1 keeps mostly to hours, but every now and then will do a super long day or two. And dd2 works better with a day off in the middle of the week and working Saturday than a weekend.
We're individuals, so are children.
Now the OP knows her dc, and how important her work is, so she needs to make a decision for them, that may not be the best for each one of them, but overall has the best outcome.