Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you feel sorry for children in breakfast and after school club every day?

596 replies

numberblockhead · 05/11/2026 16:20

Just wondering. Considering career change but would involve y2 and yR age children doing the above every day.

OP posts:
OtterlyAstounding · 06/11/2026 07:08

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 06:58

Primitive societies had much more "alloparenting" than is the case today. Women today spend more time on child care than ever before. I do not think this is good for either children or mothers. Mothers in the 21st century West are becoming exhausted, increasing numbers of young women are choosing not to become parents. Suggesting that the problem is that mothers need to spend more time with their children is entirely counterproductive.

Yes, of (extended) relatives generally. Primitive societies also didn't have 'jobs' and 'careers' in the way that we do, and likely did a lot of 'work' while keeping their babies strapped to them, and older children with them to help, as primitive societies do today, with only toddlers staying behind to be looked after by grandparents, aunts, etc.
But the sort of shared parenting duties that would've happened in primitive societies would be impossible for most people in modern societies, and whether better or worse, paid daycare is not the equivalent to it.

Anyway, my point was more that patriarchy has been around forever in all societies and isn't why modern nuclear families exist, and that the industrial revolution resulted in children being sent to work in factories, not having cosy time at home with mum (who was probably also working).

EndorsingPRActice · 06/11/2026 07:09

Mine went to a childminders in KS1 8am to 6pm who took them to and from school and fed them too. In KS2 my DS went to ASC but carried on at the childminders for breakfast. DD preferred the childminders and stayed on all through primary. Both enjoyed the childminders and the ASC. My childminder and the ASC were also happy to facilitate school based clubs so they went to quite a few of those too, football, netball, judo, choir. I'm not sure if they'd hated it what I would have done, though I need to work. No judgement here whatever you do OP.

Isadora2007 · 06/11/2026 07:12

Feeling sorry for the kids doesn’t necessarily mean you judge the parents. I’d like to say no one should be judging the parents who are doing what they can to keep a roof over their heads and keep their jobs!
But the two things can exist- a feeling for the fact that 8-6 is a long day whether spent working or spent in a care/education setting. It isn’t home and it’s not relaxing or with a primary/close caregiver. So if those choices were available I would always go there first eg family or friend or juggling work hours or taking shorter hours with young children. But nowadays I think many people feel they don’t have a choice.

SiegfriedSassoon · 06/11/2026 07:21

This was my childhood. Childminder > school > after-school club > childminder. They didn't have breakfast club at my primary in the 90s otherwise I'm sure I'd have been in that. My parents didn't have a huge amount of choice, they needed to work but it wasn't a brilliant childhood. I am an introvert and it was incredibly draining to me to be doing such long days with no quiet or downtime. I didn't know anything different however. My two siblings are different people to me but I can see looking back that we all struggled in our way. I have made very different choices for my own children.

AmusedMember · 06/11/2026 07:28

My kids never went, no need, and they always begged to go 🤣 this was 12 years ago now mind!

TheJoyousBiscuit · 06/11/2026 07:28

WHY WOULD you feel sorry for them! It’s an everyday thing that’s nothing to be ashamed off. should parents really just quit their job just so they can pick their kids up 3hours earlier.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 07:30

OtterlyAstounding · 06/11/2026 07:08

Yes, of (extended) relatives generally. Primitive societies also didn't have 'jobs' and 'careers' in the way that we do, and likely did a lot of 'work' while keeping their babies strapped to them, and older children with them to help, as primitive societies do today, with only toddlers staying behind to be looked after by grandparents, aunts, etc.
But the sort of shared parenting duties that would've happened in primitive societies would be impossible for most people in modern societies, and whether better or worse, paid daycare is not the equivalent to it.

Anyway, my point was more that patriarchy has been around forever in all societies and isn't why modern nuclear families exist, and that the industrial revolution resulted in children being sent to work in factories, not having cosy time at home with mum (who was probably also working).

Ok we will have to agree to disagree about whether the industrial revolution and the subsequent separation of work and home was patriachal and led to women being isolated at home. I do not think that a model of Mum at home with children is aspirational. Of course the quality of child care is important, but tbh being stuck at home from 3:30 pm onwards is a calustraphobic nightmare for me both as a child and as a mother. DS particularly needed a good hour of activity after the school day, incidentally there is very good evidence that outdoor play for children in the late afternoon promotes better sleep and concentration.

SparklingGlitteryWine · 06/11/2026 07:33

I feel sorry for them if they do every day breakfast and after school club and then all the school holiday clubs as well. Having worked for a childcare club I gathered that they enjoyed Breakfast Club but a lot of them didn't like After School, they would see their peers go home and have to go to another room with school type boundaries with other kids and adults they didn't really want to be with rather than go home and flop. Same with school holiday club, so many of them just didn't want to be there, I'm afraid I did feel sorry for the ones who were there every day of holiday club and also breakfast and after school club, as much as I understand it's necessary, I couldn't help but feel sorry for some of those kids. I understand it's necessary.

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 07:36

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 07:30

Ok we will have to agree to disagree about whether the industrial revolution and the subsequent separation of work and home was patriachal and led to women being isolated at home. I do not think that a model of Mum at home with children is aspirational. Of course the quality of child care is important, but tbh being stuck at home from 3:30 pm onwards is a calustraphobic nightmare for me both as a child and as a mother. DS particularly needed a good hour of activity after the school day, incidentally there is very good evidence that outdoor play for children in the late afternoon promotes better sleep and concentration.

You’re making completely unrelated points.
The Industrial Revolution did not mean women were isolated at home, nor does children not being in wrap around from 8-6 does not mean women are isolated at home.
Children not being in after school club doesn’t remotely suggest they aren’t active, doing activities or being outside.
These things are not linked, not sure why you’re raising them in an attempt to make it seem like they are.

OtterlyAstounding · 06/11/2026 07:41

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 07:30

Ok we will have to agree to disagree about whether the industrial revolution and the subsequent separation of work and home was patriachal and led to women being isolated at home. I do not think that a model of Mum at home with children is aspirational. Of course the quality of child care is important, but tbh being stuck at home from 3:30 pm onwards is a calustraphobic nightmare for me both as a child and as a mother. DS particularly needed a good hour of activity after the school day, incidentally there is very good evidence that outdoor play for children in the late afternoon promotes better sleep and concentration.

Really? You think the idea of your child getting home at 3.30 pm after a full day apart is a claustrophobic nightmare? Why couldn't you go outside, or into town, or to a friend's, or even kick a ball around at the park or actively play together outdoors in some other way (climbing trees, playing tag, or frisbee, etc)?

Additionally, I can understand many children love afterschool clubs (while equally many don't), and if your child loves it, that's great and it obviously works for you... but it's a little bizarre to me that you had children when you're open about the fact that you're trying to minimise the time you actually spend with them as much as possible Confused

(I mean, I fully understand not all parents can be home after school as they have to work to a keep a roof over their kids' heads, but just outright saying it would be a horrible nightmare to have your child home at 3.30 pm is a lot.)

Bestfootforward11 · 06/11/2026 07:42

I’ve already posted upthread that my DD has attended both. Mainly it was afterschool but she enjoyed it. I think the initial post is framed with the assumption that childcare is bad and being at home is better but I don’t think it’s quite so binary. Aside from those who have no option, being at home can be simply staring at a screen, being dragged along to take other siblings to clubs, watching mum (usually) do housework, feeling bored or lonely, and more. I think, like most things, there are pros and cons of both options and we all just have to decide where the balance falls based on what we feel is best for us and our kids.

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 07:45

SparklingGlitteryWine · 06/11/2026 07:33

I feel sorry for them if they do every day breakfast and after school club and then all the school holiday clubs as well. Having worked for a childcare club I gathered that they enjoyed Breakfast Club but a lot of them didn't like After School, they would see their peers go home and have to go to another room with school type boundaries with other kids and adults they didn't really want to be with rather than go home and flop. Same with school holiday club, so many of them just didn't want to be there, I'm afraid I did feel sorry for the ones who were there every day of holiday club and also breakfast and after school club, as much as I understand it's necessary, I couldn't help but feel sorry for some of those kids. I understand it's necessary.

Sounds like a poorly run After School club if they are just going into a room. DT’s had sports events, craft activities, chill out areas, lounge areas to sit with friends having done a cooking session making their own snacks.
Holiday clubs we chose were based on DT’s interests at the time - tennis club, football tournaments, science masterclass, theatre, art and design - this was a big success two years on the run as they got to print and bind their own books.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 07:52

OtterlyAstounding · 06/11/2026 07:41

Really? You think the idea of your child getting home at 3.30 pm after a full day apart is a claustrophobic nightmare? Why couldn't you go outside, or into town, or to a friend's, or even kick a ball around at the park or actively play together outdoors in some other way (climbing trees, playing tag, or frisbee, etc)?

Additionally, I can understand many children love afterschool clubs (while equally many don't), and if your child loves it, that's great and it obviously works for you... but it's a little bizarre to me that you had children when you're open about the fact that you're trying to minimise the time you actually spend with them as much as possible Confused

(I mean, I fully understand not all parents can be home after school as they have to work to a keep a roof over their kids' heads, but just outright saying it would be a horrible nightmare to have your child home at 3.30 pm is a lot.)

My "children" are 20 & 22. My days of afterschool activities are well behind me. My DCs only came straight home from primary school on Fridays- they had activities every other afternoon. Both settled at University now, none of us in our family have much need of " down time".

Cranx · 06/11/2026 07:55

I wouldn’t feel sorry for them in the same way I wouldn’t feel sorry for children whose parents both don’t have a full time job, or wouldn’t feel sorry for children going to sports clubs or craft clubs, or children going to the park and playing with friends.

OtterlyAstounding · 06/11/2026 08:11

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 07:52

My "children" are 20 & 22. My days of afterschool activities are well behind me. My DCs only came straight home from primary school on Fridays- they had activities every other afternoon. Both settled at University now, none of us in our family have much need of " down time".

My comments still stand.

Fivebyfive2 · 06/11/2026 08:17

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 05/11/2026 21:48

Just like they’d like not to attend school, eat vegetables and not tidy their rooms.

Christ that's a depressing outlook.

I was sort of with you - although we're totally opposite ends of the scale, I understood where you're coming from and I respect it. It sounds like your kids have and will have some amazing opportunities and that is down to you.

But viewing your kids maybe wanting to spend more time with you in the same vein as "tough shite, you'll tidy your room and go to school 10 hours a day like it or not" (as in them wanting to see more of you is somehow some ridiculous childhood dream territory) it a bit depressing.

Flymyprettiesflies · 06/11/2026 08:23

numberblockhead · 05/11/2026 16:20

Just wondering. Considering career change but would involve y2 and yR age children doing the above every day.

Honestly, yes for younger kids dependent on age and how long they’d be in. Had friends who ‘had’ to do this but they didn’t really, neither would compromise on their work day and the kids were in 8am-5.30/6pm all weeks and were BATTERED by the end of the week.
Too tired to do much else.
our kids had breakfast club 2 x a week and after school 3x til 4.30pm but not on the same days. And that was knackering enough for them.
can you swap with parents? Share pick ups or find someone to drop at a child minder for you?
its such a juggle when they’re little you have my sympathy!

baftaagain · 06/11/2026 08:29

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 05/11/2026 21:26

As it should be.

No. It's not.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/11/2026 08:40

mine go 5 days and normally when I pick them up they are having fun and don’t want to come home. I get sometimes they would prefer to be home and I would love to spend more time with them but sacrificing my career would be difficult. Dropping to half the hours would probably be a considerably lower pay than half of my current pay due to likely drop in seniority and career growth. However, they benefit a lot from us having a comfortable lifestyle - a house with space to play and garden, able to afford days out and holidays, we do still need to be careful with money but don’t need constantly stress about it and can get the unplanned lunch out etc. If needed later, we can afford a tutor or extra curricular activities and hopefully support them through university. This all benefits them. It’s necessary to make choices and sacrifice certain things and everyone needs to do what they think is right for their family.
Some people may feel sorry for them going to afterschool club but probably don’t when they get a day out to a theme park and probably think them lucky. I can’t give both and have decided what I think is right. Maybe it’s the wrong choose and will cause problems later but maybe it’s the right choice and will enable me to better support them later - I don’t know, it’s impossible to. All I can do is make an informed decision and make it work.

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 08:41

Flymyprettiesflies · 06/11/2026 08:23

Honestly, yes for younger kids dependent on age and how long they’d be in. Had friends who ‘had’ to do this but they didn’t really, neither would compromise on their work day and the kids were in 8am-5.30/6pm all weeks and were BATTERED by the end of the week.
Too tired to do much else.
our kids had breakfast club 2 x a week and after school 3x til 4.30pm but not on the same days. And that was knackering enough for them.
can you swap with parents? Share pick ups or find someone to drop at a child minder for you?
its such a juggle when they’re little you have my sympathy!

Where are all these careers where you can comprise the working day and start late and finish in the middle of the afternoon?

Nopenousername · 06/11/2026 08:42

No, need must. Been there, done that.

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 08:44

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 08:41

Where are all these careers where you can comprise the working day and start late and finish in the middle of the afternoon?

Being the CEO of My Little Family?

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/11/2026 08:45

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 08:44

Being the CEO of My Little Family?

That is not a career and doesn’t bring in a salary. Not saying it’s not wrong to do it if your family has another income but come on, this doesn’t answer the question

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 08:56

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 08:44

Being the CEO of My Little Family?

DH and I have always and will always be the CEO of our family. That alone doesn’t give DC’s the opportunities we wanted them to have.

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 08:57

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/11/2026 08:45

That is not a career and doesn’t bring in a salary. Not saying it’s not wrong to do it if your family has another income but come on, this doesn’t answer the question

I was being sarcastic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread