Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say “anxiety” is just low self esteem and confidence.

397 replies

Alondrada · 04/11/2026 12:47

I know anxiety disorders exist, which are genuine mental illnesses and generally life-long.

But when people avoid certain things and say “I can’t do that, I have anxiety” it’s because they have low self confidence and self esteem.

OP posts:
FairyInTheMossGarden · 05/11/2026 08:12

midnight4 · 05/11/2026 07:48

I’m talking about children. When there were fewer safety nets, people couldn’t afford to
lose their jobs due to anxiety. People just had to get on with it as their families depended on them.

If you're talking about children what jobs do you mean?
Paper rounds?

What year are you referring to when there were 'fewer safety nets'?

midnight4 · 05/11/2026 08:22

FairyInTheMossGarden · 05/11/2026 08:12

If you're talking about children what jobs do you mean?
Paper rounds?

What year are you referring to when there were 'fewer safety nets'?

Children used to leave school at 15, and then 16, to go straight into full time work.

FairyInTheMossGarden · 05/11/2026 08:26

midnight4 · 05/11/2026 08:22

Children used to leave school at 15, and then 16, to go straight into full time work.

What year are you referring to when there were 'fewer safety nets'?

holidayhelpneeded1 · 05/11/2026 08:30

midnight4 · 05/11/2026 08:10

You are one person. Anxiety and mental health difficulties have increased significantly among young people over the past decade.

Has it increased or are people just finally admitting it? You have literally had people tell you of multiple family members that suffer but are ashamed to admit its an issue because of the stigma surrounding it. You have been told of numbers of millions of people who were prescribed meds in times you keep banging on about not being an issue and you are being told about people who have had this so called resilient treatment that supposedly stopped anxiety being an issue, yet you seem incapable of listening to anything that doesnt fit your narrative.

Maybe just maybe you dont have all the answers you think you do and actually you may just not have the personal experience to understand what you are talking about, but rather than try and listen to those telling you the things that may show this isnt the facts you think, you would rather stick your fingers in your ears.

You are another one who I truly hope never has to deal with such issues, but if you do, I also hope you are not surrounded by people as ignorant as you are acting because believe me things can change at any moment for anyone.

Trippine · 05/11/2026 08:38

midnight4 · 05/11/2026 08:10

You are one person. Anxiety and mental health difficulties have increased significantly among young people over the past decade.

Why does my experience count as an outlier? It’s far from unique - forcing people to do things does not build resilience.

You can systematically discount every single person who says that’s their reality - but it weakens your argument each time.

midnight4 · 05/11/2026 08:38

holidayhelpneeded1 · 05/11/2026 08:30

Has it increased or are people just finally admitting it? You have literally had people tell you of multiple family members that suffer but are ashamed to admit its an issue because of the stigma surrounding it. You have been told of numbers of millions of people who were prescribed meds in times you keep banging on about not being an issue and you are being told about people who have had this so called resilient treatment that supposedly stopped anxiety being an issue, yet you seem incapable of listening to anything that doesnt fit your narrative.

Maybe just maybe you dont have all the answers you think you do and actually you may just not have the personal experience to understand what you are talking about, but rather than try and listen to those telling you the things that may show this isnt the facts you think, you would rather stick your fingers in your ears.

You are another one who I truly hope never has to deal with such issues, but if you do, I also hope you are not surrounded by people as ignorant as you are acting because believe me things can change at any moment for anyone.

Edited

It has been proven that when people have a task to do they are significantly less likely to suffer mentally because structured activity occupies cognitive bandwidth, breaks the cycle of negative overthinking (rumination), and provides a psychological boost.

Psychologists rely on this concept as a core evidence-based treatment known as Behavioural Activation.

holidayhelpneeded1 · 05/11/2026 08:46

midnight4 · 05/11/2026 08:38

It has been proven that when people have a task to do they are significantly less likely to suffer mentally because structured activity occupies cognitive bandwidth, breaks the cycle of negative overthinking (rumination), and provides a psychological boost.

Psychologists rely on this concept as a core evidence-based treatment known as Behavioural Activation.

You're describing a recognised psychological treatment, but you're misunderstanding what it demonstrates.

Behavioural Activation is an evidence-based approach, primarily used to treat depression. It uses meaningful activity, routine and engagement to help improve symptoms. Nobody is arguing that having structure and purpose can't be beneficial for mental health.

But that is an entirely different argument from saying that forcing children to push through anxiety prevents them from developing mental health difficulties.

A treatment that helps someone manage or improve their symptoms doesn't prove that the absence of that treatment caused their condition in the first place.

By that logic, we could argue that because exercise helps depression, people who become depressed simply haven't exercised enough. Clearly that would be an absurd oversimplification.

And perhaps most importantly, you're still confusing the ability to function with the absence of mental health difficulties. Previous generations had responsibilities, jobs and families to support, but that doesn't mean they didn't experience anxiety. Many simply had to carry on regardless, often without recognition, support or even the language to explain what they were experiencing.

Being forced to cope isn't the same as being mentally well.

You can absolutely teach children resilience, encourage independence, give them responsibilities and help them develop coping strategies. I agree those things have value. But none of that means anxiety is caused by a lack of resilience, or that forcing children through distress protects them from developing anxiety disorders.

You're taking evidence that one particular intervention can help and using it to justify an entirely different claim. They aren't interchangeable.

Coconutter24 · 05/11/2026 09:16

The problem we have is everyone is ‘anxious’ and suffers with ‘anxiety’. Now I know people do genuinely have it and suffer because of it but they are also overused buzzwords for a lot of people. Same as ADHD, again people have it of course but then you also get people that are ‘oh I’m so all over the place I’m sure I’ve got ADHD’

BusyGreySnail · 05/11/2026 09:17

What I think is that you don't understand anxiety. YABU

holidayhelpneeded1 · 05/11/2026 09:42

BusyGreySnail · 05/11/2026 09:17

What I think is that you don't understand anxiety. YABU

I think that sums up a bunch of people on this thread but that is what is boils down to. Although I think its clear that some people not only completely don't understand but are also unable to grasp that the have no clue and arent willing to try and understand.

BusyGreySnail · 05/11/2026 09:45

holidayhelpneeded1 · 05/11/2026 09:42

I think that sums up a bunch of people on this thread but that is what is boils down to. Although I think its clear that some people not only completely don't understand but are also unable to grasp that the have no clue and arent willing to try and understand.

Haha quite! It's a little bit like thinking people who are depressed are just a bit sad about something and need to cheer up.

Portmore · 05/11/2026 09:48

Alondrada · 04/11/2026 13:00

I would like to reiterate, that I am not talking about anxiety disorders, the mental illnesses which affect someone’s daily living and their ability to carry out everyday tasks.

It’s about people who avoid certain things and say they have “anxiety” about it. When they are fully capable but it’s their low confidence in themselves and the fear of being perceived which stops them from doing that certain thing.

You have just defined anxiety disorders in that sentence
It is 'low confidence in themselves & the fear of being perceived' that stops someone with anxiety from doing something.

Social anxiety is a spectrum of disability from mild to very severe.

Despositor · 05/11/2026 10:42

Im both a mental health professional and someone who experiences anxiety. Im also trained in behavioural activation which absolutely isnt based on forcing people to do stuff

In a dumbed down way (supported by neuro science), forcing people to do things that they find traumatic can increase the anxiety.

Take for example the example of being thrown in at the deep end swimming. For somepeople they swim and experience a sense of achievement that decreases their anxiety and makes them feel more confident

Others will more strongly associate the pool with the fact that the last time they were there they felt like they almost drowned because they were thrown in. It doesnt matter if nothing bad actually happened the feeling of panic is linked to the task. Their bodies will automatically begin into releasing adrenaline, as a result of that their heart rate will go up, they will feel physically sick. If they then have a panic attack then the cycle is definitely reinforced that this task makes me feel physically awful, and their body remembers that a bit earlier and earlier each time.

A bit like how the smell of certain foods that once made you sick makes you heave, and the heaving makes you feel sick even more.

Behavioural activation is about other adjacent activities that go well, and that give confidence. Nothing about forcing people. You have to make sure that you arent compounding the link between the situation and anxiety

holidayhelpneeded1 · 05/11/2026 11:11

Despositor · 05/11/2026 10:42

Im both a mental health professional and someone who experiences anxiety. Im also trained in behavioural activation which absolutely isnt based on forcing people to do stuff

In a dumbed down way (supported by neuro science), forcing people to do things that they find traumatic can increase the anxiety.

Take for example the example of being thrown in at the deep end swimming. For somepeople they swim and experience a sense of achievement that decreases their anxiety and makes them feel more confident

Others will more strongly associate the pool with the fact that the last time they were there they felt like they almost drowned because they were thrown in. It doesnt matter if nothing bad actually happened the feeling of panic is linked to the task. Their bodies will automatically begin into releasing adrenaline, as a result of that their heart rate will go up, they will feel physically sick. If they then have a panic attack then the cycle is definitely reinforced that this task makes me feel physically awful, and their body remembers that a bit earlier and earlier each time.

A bit like how the smell of certain foods that once made you sick makes you heave, and the heaving makes you feel sick even more.

Behavioural activation is about other adjacent activities that go well, and that give confidence. Nothing about forcing people. You have to make sure that you arent compounding the link between the situation and anxiety

Edited

And I think the perfect thing with this example would be the person who was thrown in the pool and it gave them confidence as they swam, would then turn around and go I had this happen and it built resilience therefore thats what it does. Some people fail to grasp that not all brains work in the same way so what works for one, doesnt work for another.

But I think thats what you see on this thread and in fact in life so much, people fail to grasp that their life experience given to someone else would not produce the same outcome.

kkloo · 05/11/2026 11:25

Despositor · 05/11/2026 10:42

Im both a mental health professional and someone who experiences anxiety. Im also trained in behavioural activation which absolutely isnt based on forcing people to do stuff

In a dumbed down way (supported by neuro science), forcing people to do things that they find traumatic can increase the anxiety.

Take for example the example of being thrown in at the deep end swimming. For somepeople they swim and experience a sense of achievement that decreases their anxiety and makes them feel more confident

Others will more strongly associate the pool with the fact that the last time they were there they felt like they almost drowned because they were thrown in. It doesnt matter if nothing bad actually happened the feeling of panic is linked to the task. Their bodies will automatically begin into releasing adrenaline, as a result of that their heart rate will go up, they will feel physically sick. If they then have a panic attack then the cycle is definitely reinforced that this task makes me feel physically awful, and their body remembers that a bit earlier and earlier each time.

A bit like how the smell of certain foods that once made you sick makes you heave, and the heaving makes you feel sick even more.

Behavioural activation is about other adjacent activities that go well, and that give confidence. Nothing about forcing people. You have to make sure that you arent compounding the link between the situation and anxiety

Edited

Yes, sometimes exposure therapy will make things worse because it relies on someones nervous system having the ability to regulate afterwards and relax and say 'that wasn't so bad after all'.

If someone has a very dsyregulated nervous system and they're pushed to do something scary, and their nervous system can't regulate afterwards then the experience can actually just confirms that is was in fact scary, and that it may have even been more scary than they thought it was to begin with, and then it all gets worse!

MrsPapillon · 05/11/2026 11:35

As someone with lifelong anxiety, it happens to me when my subconscious brain (wrongly) senses a life-threatening situation that my conscious brain hasn’t spotted, and alerts me to danger. My brain doesn’t understand that I’m not at risk anymore, and the reactions which kept me safe many years ago don’t apply now.

It’s got fuck all to do with low self-confidence or putting things off that I don’t want to do.

UncompromisingCat · 05/11/2026 11:50

@Despositor thank you for that, it's really useful to put my finger on why the 'just effing do it' school hasn't worked for me, no matter how much it appeals!

I truly want to try new experiences but find that the involuntary physical overwhelm confirms to me that, yes, this IS terrifying...

Plus early conditioning by my parents taught me that, if I feel a sense of achievement, that feeling isn't to be trusted, and I must have done something wrong or shameful somewhere that will be along any minute now to bite me in the arse... 😠

Are there any resources you can recommend for Behavioural Activation?

HappyLizard23 · 05/11/2026 13:15

Postjurywoes · 04/11/2026 14:51

Life limiting

Are you really putting it in the same bracket as Cancer, MND, MS?

OCD and PTSD are anxiety conditions. They are life limiting, as can be GAD. Would you say otherwise?

Idkrlly17844905 · 05/11/2026 14:28

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 04/11/2026 12:54

You sound terribly judgemental.

And ignorant.

AmbeeBambee · 05/11/2026 16:42

Postjurywoes · 04/11/2026 13:02

So you knew you could leave it and someone else would do it............
If you were in on your own an needed to ring, you would have had to, therefore proving my point.

If you had to you would.

Nope... this is not the case for me at all. do not have low self-esteem or confidence, but do get anxiety, which can be overwhelming. You say someone would have to make a phone call if no one else would; you clearly don't know how much people wth anxety can avoid phone calls, etc,

AmbeeBambee · 05/11/2026 16:44

BusyGreySnail · 05/11/2026 09:45

Haha quite! It's a little bit like thinking people who are depressed are just a bit sad about something and need to cheer up.

Exactly. Completely clueless. Lets be honest though, she got the attention she craved.

HappyLizard23 · 05/11/2026 17:16

@Postjurywoes is very quiet now. I wonder if she’s embarrassed or has been banned

XenoBitch · 05/11/2026 18:10

HappyLizard23 · 05/11/2026 13:15

OCD and PTSD are anxiety conditions. They are life limiting, as can be GAD. Would you say otherwise?

Life limiting is referring to conditions that have no cure and will shorten life (as in, it will eventually kill the person).

TeensNoMore · 05/11/2026 18:14

XenoBitch · 05/11/2026 18:10

Life limiting is referring to conditions that have no cure and will shorten life (as in, it will eventually kill the person).

Just checked and that is indeed the medical definition.

So 'life constraining' is probably better from a medical point of view, though GAD does limit a person's ability to live their life fully.

PinkyFlamingo · 05/11/2026 18:17

Alondrada · 04/11/2026 12:47

I know anxiety disorders exist, which are genuine mental illnesses and generally life-long.

But when people avoid certain things and say “I can’t do that, I have anxiety” it’s because they have low self confidence and self esteem.

Where did you get your degree in psychiatric disorders? You tube? 🙄