Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want this working pattern - DH disagreement

188 replies

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 14:19

Currently stuck in a disagreement with DH so would like to know what other people would do.

I am due to start a new role at work in a months time. It’s a promotion with a jump in salary, as I’m coming back off maternity leave I’ve been offered a few different options in terms of working pattern and the deadline for coming back to them with a final decision is this Tuesday!

Option A (DHs preference) -
WFH 4 days out of 5
Hours would be 9-3

Option B (My preference)
WFH 3 days out of 4
Mondays not working
Tuesdays - Friday working 9-4:30

Thankfully work have agreed to keep my salary the same on either option (full new amount) as the drop in hours isn’t that significant.

DH prefers option A as it means in a few months time when DD can start pre school we’d save a lot in nursery fees, as those hours match up more nicely with the school hours they stick to. I prefer the idea of having a full day off with DD though.

YABU - option A
YANBU - option B

OP posts:
TheCloisters · 04/03/2024 08:09

B!
Life balance is important

BananaSpanner · 04/03/2024 08:13

MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 08:07

Isn’t it a new job on promotion you’re going back to though? So one in which you’ve got no track record yet, and you’ll be expected to deliver more and more stretching work in return for your significant pay rise. Also, having to pay more for agency cover for a maternity leave doesn’t really indicate anything about the staff member in question’s qualities or performance - it’s because of the relative lack of appeal of a short fixed contract without expensive employment benefits.

Don’t bother, she’ll just come back with a self satisfied reply. She’s just going to have to learn for herself.

shearwater2 · 04/03/2024 08:13

Bugger DH, do the one which is best for you.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 08:28

JustMarriedBecca · 03/03/2024 14:21

I would tell work you'd like pattern B until September when you'd like to move to pattern A. Surely it's not either or / forever.

I will ask them today, have a meeting with HR to discuss all my options coming back so will see if it’s possible to do one then the other in June (as it’s June when DD is able to go into pre school as they take from 18months)

I do think it will be beneficial being able to do all the pick up and drop offs and not rely on a childminder etc. I’m coming round to option A after reading all these posts :)

OP posts:
MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 09:01

BananaSpanner · 04/03/2024 08:13

Don’t bother, she’ll just come back with a self satisfied reply. She’s just going to have to learn for herself.

I suspect not, actually, given my points are quite hard to deflect or dismiss with an insult. I do hope it works out but I’d worry for anyone in any workplace who thought themselves irreplaceable or believed that the organisation was on their side, as it were.

Concestor · 04/03/2024 09:06

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:14

It really doesn't

Always surprised at how little those on MN understand about how many businesses operate.

I could do 2 hours a day, as long as my work was done that’s it.

OP what kind of work do you do? I'm intrigued. I've never had a job where the work is ever "done" except one contract role I did. I've done a variety of jobs and in all of them there's always been more to do and I don't know anyone who can say they are finished and can go home, there's always other things to do. So what do you do? I'm genuinely interested as this is a new concept to me and sounds very attractive.

Choux · 04/03/2024 09:06

*Again, it’s not coasting when you can perform better than others in less time 🤷‍♀️

I am one of one doing my job at work, they struggled to find anyone to replace me for maternity so much so they had to pay 3x my salary for agency resource, it took them 18 months to recruit me - I think I’m fine*

It sounds like you are in a slightly unusual situation where the company needs someone to do the type of work you do but the company doesn't really generate enough of that type of work for you to be needed full time and no one has found any other add on work you could do so that every hour of your contracted hours is busy (plus a long to do list that you never get near to completing like a lot of roles).

So you aren't better at working, managing your time than other staff. You just don't get given as much work as other people. In my company your manager would know you were not fully loaded work wise and would be looking for other responsibilities for you. Or would come under pressure to outsource your role or move it offshore to save money. But maybe you can get away with being paid for hours you haven't worked for a while before your company takes action.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 09:47

Concestor · 04/03/2024 09:06

OP what kind of work do you do? I'm intrigued. I've never had a job where the work is ever "done" except one contract role I did. I've done a variety of jobs and in all of them there's always been more to do and I don't know anyone who can say they are finished and can go home, there's always other things to do. So what do you do? I'm genuinely interested as this is a new concept to me and sounds very attractive.

I work in martech, my role is very much dependent on other people’s availability and change management, so many weeks if I’ve prepped all I can and those I’m meeting with aren’t free now for a couple of weeks I’m kind of done until then.

I design policy, and help the business prepare for changes 2-3 years in the pipeline. So it’s not a case of getting more work once the bits on my to do list are done. As there are many external factors that dictate my time essentially!

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 09:48

MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 09:01

I suspect not, actually, given my points are quite hard to deflect or dismiss with an insult. I do hope it works out but I’d worry for anyone in any workplace who thought themselves irreplaceable or believed that the organisation was on their side, as it were.

I never said irreplaceable, but considering the facts around my role I’m in a pretty good spot. And even if not I get messages from head hunters a few times a day.

Im pretty fine

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 09:50

Choux · 04/03/2024 09:06

*Again, it’s not coasting when you can perform better than others in less time 🤷‍♀️

I am one of one doing my job at work, they struggled to find anyone to replace me for maternity so much so they had to pay 3x my salary for agency resource, it took them 18 months to recruit me - I think I’m fine*

It sounds like you are in a slightly unusual situation where the company needs someone to do the type of work you do but the company doesn't really generate enough of that type of work for you to be needed full time and no one has found any other add on work you could do so that every hour of your contracted hours is busy (plus a long to do list that you never get near to completing like a lot of roles).

So you aren't better at working, managing your time than other staff. You just don't get given as much work as other people. In my company your manager would know you were not fully loaded work wise and would be looking for other responsibilities for you. Or would come under pressure to outsource your role or move it offshore to save money. But maybe you can get away with being paid for hours you haven't worked for a while before your company takes action.

Well considering I’ve been doing just that for 6 years I think it’s ok.

But yes please do continue embarrassing yourself

OP posts:
mindutopia · 04/03/2024 09:53

I would do B for now while you don't need to worry about juggling after school hours because you have full day childcare.

You will spend the next 10 years trying to work around that after school gap when most working people still need to be at work but school has ended. Save the school hours working for then when you need it. Make the most of having full day cover now while you have it.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/03/2024 09:58

Well I don't know why OP started this thread really, she has it all sorted aheaded of returning from her first maternity leave, there really isn't anything else to say except well done.

innerdesign · 04/03/2024 10:07

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:25

Odd you think I don’t understand my own workplace policies

Yes its fully paid parental leave

yes unlimited annual leave exists in many workplaces - not sure why you need it explained. It’s unlimited annual leave, not unpaid leave. It means I don’t get a fixed amount, for example the year before last I took 60 days annual leave.

Again, my employer pays for the emergency days off for dependents, I actually don’t know of any other businesses in my sector that don’t! (Many go on about it on LinkedIn as a sign they’re inclusive to parents)

Not sure why I’d need to check since I’ve worked at the company for 6 years and their parental package is well explained during pregnancy.

This might be the rudest OP I've ever come across in my years on MN. Someone took time out of their day to try to help you, and you've been so unpleasant.

Nobody gives a shit what days you go back, and we're all glad your mortgage has increased

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 10:25

innerdesign · 04/03/2024 10:07

This might be the rudest OP I've ever come across in my years on MN. Someone took time out of their day to try to help you, and you've been so unpleasant.

Nobody gives a shit what days you go back, and we're all glad your mortgage has increased

It’s not help if it’s not requested.

It’s incredibly bizarre to assume someone doesn’t know their own workplace policies. As a HR professional I’m also quite baffled how the concept of unlimited annual leave is alien to them as well since it’s becoming pretty common place.

If @Teenagehorrorbag was a man that comment would be considered mansplaining.

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 10:27

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/03/2024 09:58

Well I don't know why OP started this thread really, she has it all sorted aheaded of returning from her first maternity leave, there really isn't anything else to say except well done.

I started the thread to get a view on the two working patterns presented, thankfully I’ve had loads of helpful replies as requested on that subject. Especially from those who have done both and can comment from experience.

I didn’t request an opinion on my job, my husband, my Manager, my mortgage or anything else some people have decided to be dicks about.

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 10:28

mindutopia · 04/03/2024 09:53

I would do B for now while you don't need to worry about juggling after school hours because you have full day childcare.

You will spend the next 10 years trying to work around that after school gap when most working people still need to be at work but school has ended. Save the school hours working for then when you need it. Make the most of having full day cover now while you have it.

Thank you! Yeah I’m wondering if I’ll need the option A hours more as she gets older and whether it’s better to take advantage of them having the budget to use my cover for the extra day while I can Grin

OP posts:
StealthMama · 04/03/2024 10:47

@Dutchairfryer on any public online forum people can and likely will comment on any part of the information you share.

Just because you didn't ask for it doesn't mean it's not valuable consideration. Otherwise we add narrow mindedness to the extensive list of qualities you have demonstrated on this thread.

But i see your in marktech. You're right your skills are ten a penny so there's really very little drama about what hours you do or what your benefits are because anyone can do it from anywhere.

MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 11:05

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 09:50

Well considering I’ve been doing just that for 6 years I think it’s ok.

But yes please do continue embarrassing yourself

I suspect you know as well as everyone else here that that poster is doing nothing of the sort. And having been doing it for six years is a bit of a moot point since that isn’t the job you’re going back to, and no company promotes you with a big pay rise to expect you to deliver what you did before. Bear in mind you’re the one that’s come onto a massive internet chat forum, asked for advice on your working hours and then said you don’t intend to work them anyway (and doubled down and been incredibly and disproportionately rude when people have commented on it). There are very easy and free ways to not receive comments on your attitude to work from internet forums if that’s your preference.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 11:08

StealthMama · 04/03/2024 10:47

@Dutchairfryer on any public online forum people can and likely will comment on any part of the information you share.

Just because you didn't ask for it doesn't mean it's not valuable consideration. Otherwise we add narrow mindedness to the extensive list of qualities you have demonstrated on this thread.

But i see your in marktech. You're right your skills are ten a penny so there's really very little drama about what hours you do or what your benefits are because anyone can do it from anywhere.

Of course they can

and I am then more than able to respond in kind to those unwanted and often ignorant comments

It’s not a valuable consideration, or contribution when it’s not asked for or useful.

Your snark is just a bit pathetic, but yes ten a penny, it’s why they couldn’t hire for my maternity cover and took 18 months to recruit me into the position as they couldn’t find anyone with the requirements and experience for the role.

Bore off

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 11:11

MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 11:05

I suspect you know as well as everyone else here that that poster is doing nothing of the sort. And having been doing it for six years is a bit of a moot point since that isn’t the job you’re going back to, and no company promotes you with a big pay rise to expect you to deliver what you did before. Bear in mind you’re the one that’s come onto a massive internet chat forum, asked for advice on your working hours and then said you don’t intend to work them anyway (and doubled down and been incredibly and disproportionately rude when people have commented on it). There are very easy and free ways to not receive comments on your attitude to work from internet forums if that’s your preference.

Oh of course they are

its frankly embarassing

first to claim my manager doesn’t think I’m good at my job

when proven wrong has now pivoted to the next ridiculous assumption

Ive had 3 promotions since starting and yes have worked the hours required not hours on my contract for every single one of those roles as it’s quite common at my workplace and others in the sector.

So yes, stating sometime soon action will be taken is just silly at this point. When it’s the norm within the business.

OP posts:
newmum0604 · 04/03/2024 11:12

What is actually the point of this thread - be honest 🤣

If you're going to work 9-3 (or less) either way then why would you 'work' the extra day?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/03/2024 11:13

Have pattern B. It’s always beneficial to kids to have you off a day in the week

MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 11:24

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 11:11

Oh of course they are

its frankly embarassing

first to claim my manager doesn’t think I’m good at my job

when proven wrong has now pivoted to the next ridiculous assumption

Ive had 3 promotions since starting and yes have worked the hours required not hours on my contract for every single one of those roles as it’s quite common at my workplace and others in the sector.

So yes, stating sometime soon action will be taken is just silly at this point. When it’s the norm within the business.

Just saying the word ‘embarrassing’ on repeat doesn’t mean the poster is or should be embarrassed, even if you add ‘frankly’. Clearly neither you nor your manager are not as confident in your ability to choose your own work pattern and still deliver as you’re pretending to be, otherwise you’d be contracted and paid for full time hours and would have no cause to ask this question.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 11:33

MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 11:24

Just saying the word ‘embarrassing’ on repeat doesn’t mean the poster is or should be embarrassed, even if you add ‘frankly’. Clearly neither you nor your manager are not as confident in your ability to choose your own work pattern and still deliver as you’re pretending to be, otherwise you’d be contracted and paid for full time hours and would have no cause to ask this question.

I am paid for full time hours 😅

I am merely asking which flexible option offered others would gravitate towards

OP posts:
Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/03/2024 11:59

So to be clear, you are paid ft hours but don't work them or have any intention of doing so. Your boss is either unaware of this or accepts this and the question your asking is whether it is better to sack off an entire day your are paid for or a bit every afternoon ? But actually you think you can probably work 9-3 4 days a week and continue to be paid an increased ft salary ? Have I got that right ? Not clear what the question is tbh.