Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want this working pattern - DH disagreement

188 replies

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 14:19

Currently stuck in a disagreement with DH so would like to know what other people would do.

I am due to start a new role at work in a months time. It’s a promotion with a jump in salary, as I’m coming back off maternity leave I’ve been offered a few different options in terms of working pattern and the deadline for coming back to them with a final decision is this Tuesday!

Option A (DHs preference) -
WFH 4 days out of 5
Hours would be 9-3

Option B (My preference)
WFH 3 days out of 4
Mondays not working
Tuesdays - Friday working 9-4:30

Thankfully work have agreed to keep my salary the same on either option (full new amount) as the drop in hours isn’t that significant.

DH prefers option A as it means in a few months time when DD can start pre school we’d save a lot in nursery fees, as those hours match up more nicely with the school hours they stick to. I prefer the idea of having a full day off with DD though.

YABU - option A
YANBU - option B

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:18

MiddleParking · 03/03/2024 22:43

I’m 30 and I don’t care what hours you work or don’t work but as a manager and colleague of, among others, the odd naive pisstaker I can assure you missing an hour’s work every single day will definitely impact your performance and reputation in a way that will be more obvious to other people, and sooner, than you yourself would ever be able to assess.

This is just laughable

I am not aware of anyone I work with that does their full time hours allocation per week. Not one.

Thankfully in most corporate environments you’re hired to do a job, hit a certain target and move on. If meeting your goals takes less time than you’re contracted to work then you get time back.

It’s sad so many on here really just don’t get it!

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:19

Choux · 03/03/2024 22:22

I suspect if we heard from OPs manager it would turn out OP hasn't been performing as well as she thinks she has been.

By missing several hours when she should be working most weeks she may well be doing ok and she may have a lot of potential but she won't have been delivering as much as she could.

As you move up the ladder - she said the new role is a promotion despite the maternity cover still being in situ - the workload increases and slacking off regularly won't get the job done. Someone will cotton on that she is missing for the last hour of every wfh day and that that is impacting on her contribution to the company.

Yes, my director thinks I’m such a slacker he personally made sure I got this promotion whilst on maternity leave, to ensure I came back to the business, so much so he has bent over backwards to offer flexible working options at full pay and a 25% salary increase.

You’re a funny one

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:21

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 22:47

@FUPAgirl but they aren't though. They are offering her a contract of set days and a number of hours.

Flexibility is given on the basis that the contractual agreement is being met.

You are confusing flexing when those hours are done, as opposed to how many hours are done. Culturally you are both saying that the flexibility is there, but legally it isn't.

If they are truly offering flexibility then The contract will set out KPIs/performance measures or objectives that she is measured against, irrespective of how many hours it takes to achieve them. Or simply say xx hours over xx working days.

That's not what the OP has been offered. And she intends to breach that contract.

Theres something odd that they are retaining the mat leave cover for the other days and hours that they are not offering the OP. As well as adding risk because now her performance will be stacked up against someone else directly.

Nothing odd about it

I raised the issue around how some people go back part time but are expected to do full times worth of work and it was an offer to alleviate my concerns.

My mat cover is a very expensive agency resource. They weren’t able to cover me properly for maternity leave.

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:25

Teenagehorrorbag · 03/03/2024 23:31

I can't advise re your two options, but am wondering about a couple of other things you've mentioned, which you might want to double check before you make any plans?

You say you get two weeks paid parental leave every year? Parental leave is a statutory right but it is unpaid, and usually has to be planned well in advance. Now obviously if your employer is truly generous and amazing they may have decided to pay it, but that would presumably annoy the non-parents in the workforce - so you might want to just double check that before relying on it as an option?

And you said you get unlimited annual leave? Again - how does that work? Do you mean you can ask for additional unpaid leave on top of your holiday allowance? If so, that normally only works if no-one else is off and it's convenient for the employer etc.

And emergency time off for dependants is usually unpaid and only for a single day or even a few hours to allow you to find childcare. We once had to end the contract of a single Mum whose child had really poor health, because she kept having time off to collect him from school and look after him etc. Of course that was an extreme and tragic case, but has always stuck with me.

Obviously if your company does provide all those things with pay and at short notice, then that's amazing, but in my experience as an HR professional it would be quite unusual. But of course I don't know your line of work - obviously some jobs can allow far more flex than others. But I just thought I'd mention that you might want to check.

Odd you think I don’t understand my own workplace policies

Yes its fully paid parental leave

yes unlimited annual leave exists in many workplaces - not sure why you need it explained. It’s unlimited annual leave, not unpaid leave. It means I don’t get a fixed amount, for example the year before last I took 60 days annual leave.

Again, my employer pays for the emergency days off for dependents, I actually don’t know of any other businesses in my sector that don’t! (Many go on about it on LinkedIn as a sign they’re inclusive to parents)

Not sure why I’d need to check since I’ve worked at the company for 6 years and their parental package is well explained during pregnancy.

OP posts:
Bestyearever2024 · 04/03/2024 00:28

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 17:53

It was true though, on this site mainly women of a certain age fall into the category of posters who can’t understand the world of work has moved on

I agree that the world of work has changed

But if I understand you correctly, you're saying that you'd collect your daughter from nursery in work time, and you might or might not make up that time

The world of work HAS moved on, but if you don't make up that time, surely that is theft? Unless your employer knows and is fine with you doing this?

I guess if you're allowed unlimited annual leave, perhaps your employer IS fine with you skipping an hour a day and not making the time up?

Choux · 04/03/2024 00:53

What industry is this? The company seems to:
Not need apparently well thought of employees to work their contracted hours
Let staff take 60 or more days of annual leave per year
When an employee wants to work only 4 days a week they hire an 'expensive agency resource' to cover 'just in case'

The company seems to be over resourced if staff can regularly not work their full hours and still take 12 weeks a year off. That's a very inefficient and costly way to run a business. Does it have shareholders? Is its' goal to make money?

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:58

Bestyearever2024 · 04/03/2024 00:28

I agree that the world of work has changed

But if I understand you correctly, you're saying that you'd collect your daughter from nursery in work time, and you might or might not make up that time

The world of work HAS moved on, but if you don't make up that time, surely that is theft? Unless your employer knows and is fine with you doing this?

I guess if you're allowed unlimited annual leave, perhaps your employer IS fine with you skipping an hour a day and not making the time up?

Theft? Jesus wept 😅

and of course they are. Goodness me.

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 01:01

Choux · 04/03/2024 00:53

What industry is this? The company seems to:
Not need apparently well thought of employees to work their contracted hours
Let staff take 60 or more days of annual leave per year
When an employee wants to work only 4 days a week they hire an 'expensive agency resource' to cover 'just in case'

The company seems to be over resourced if staff can regularly not work their full hours and still take 12 weeks a year off. That's a very inefficient and costly way to run a business. Does it have shareholders? Is its' goal to make money?

I work for one of the worlds largest FMCG companies

Plenty of shareholders and plenty of money made each and every year.

But again please do explain why you think my director doesn’t think very highly of me, when he championed this promotion, and is leading the push to offer whatever it takes to get me back in after 14 months of maternity leave.

This is just amusing at this point.

OP posts:
MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 03:39

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:18

This is just laughable

I am not aware of anyone I work with that does their full time hours allocation per week. Not one.

Thankfully in most corporate environments you’re hired to do a job, hit a certain target and move on. If meeting your goals takes less time than you’re contracted to work then you get time back.

It’s sad so many on here really just don’t get it!

I work in a flexible corporate environment too - I don’t deny that with new ways of working people aren’t waiting for the clock to tick over to 5pm before they put their coat on and run for the bus, but that really doesn’t mean people won’t notice you disappearing at school run time and not returning until the next day. They might not pull you up on it, but that’s a different thing. Corporate environments are designed for people to be available to each other to aid collaboration and effective stakeholder engagement, and you can bet the people picking stuff up out of hours, delivering 120% of their objectives, will be getting noticed for it too, even if you’re not hearing about it. Your manager might value you but clearly he doesn’t quite have the unlimited faith in your ability to deliver in a fraction of your FTE hours that your latter posts attempt to convey, and nor do you; if he did they wouldn’t be considering keeping your maternity cover on and you wouldn’t need to be asking this question at all. I’d advise you as a returning new mother to be a bit more cynical about the ultra-modern-corporate-culture, unlimited-annual-leave, sunbathing-on-a-Friday shtick - that’s all a tool to serve them, not you.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/03/2024 05:11

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 20:59

I think I’ll take DHs word on his workplace requirements over someone on MN.

He is one of 3 consultant paramedics within our region and his days depend on availability of the other 2 and the snr response officers. He cannot fix his days.

Has he asked ? He has the right to requrst flexible working like everyone else. You accuse others of being old fashoined, I would argue that your ( or his) attitude that your DH's job is far too important to be able to commit to regular childcare is the most reggressive view on this thread. As they say the 1950's are calling. FYI I am over 40 my children are nearly grown and I have a full pension pot because my DH stood up to dinasour bosses ( with their talk of babysitting his own children) 20 years ago.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/03/2024 05:12

Apols for typos it's early.

3luckystars · 04/03/2024 05:20

Option b but don’t take Mondays off!

That’s a big mistake, don’t take Fridays off either.
Take a Tuesday off if possible, then after a bank holiday, you won’t be back to work until Wednesday.
I’ve worked loads of combinations and 4 days, combined with not working too many days in a row is the best option! Good luck.

BananaSpanner · 04/03/2024 05:53

I’ve worked 4 days since returning from my first mat leave 11 years ago, a day off in the week to spend time with your child, catch up with life admin and help cover school holidays and illnesses is invaluable.

I’m also public sector and bear in mind that your husband can ask for a flexi working pattern that allows him a regular day off eg every Tuesday. They could make it work and loads of emergency service workers do this, I suspect he just doesn’t want to. But you seem pretty happy with that so it doesn’t matter.

My DH is wfh for a major FMCG company. He finishes before his contracted hours 4 days a week to pick the kids up from after school club, and he will also do things like pop out during the day if he needs to. However, he will also log on in the evenings and sometimes at weekends or
starts early. He respects the flexibility and delivers beyond what he needs to. He is over 40 so maybe he’s old fashioned and doesn’t need to do as much but yet he’s been promoted several times so they must like his attitude. He also notices when team members aren’t working hard.

You’re obviously doing well and have a good relationship with your boss but you do seem naive to the possibility that while you’re coasting, you might start being outperformed by harder working colleagues who deliver beyond the bare minimum that is expected of them.

Changedforthetoday · 04/03/2024 06:27

Honestly the OP is such a smug know it all I wouldn’t waste your time sharing your advice or experiences - she knows better anyway!

HungryandIknowit · 04/03/2024 06:41

I'm amazed and jealous you can work under your contracted hours regularly tbh. My experience has always been the opposite along with nearly all peers in my field. That would be my concern with more days + shorter hours. I would end up working longer anyway. So would always go for fewer days. If that's definitely not a concern I would consider shorter days if the pre-school is connected with the school your child is going to, as they could make friends before they start.

Bestyearever2024 · 04/03/2024 06:58

Changedforthetoday · 04/03/2024 06:27

Honestly the OP is such a smug know it all I wouldn’t waste your time sharing your advice or experiences - she knows better anyway!

Yes

I'm guessing that she asked the original question to open up a thread to tell us all how marvellous she is

And I believe her 🙂

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 07:01

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/03/2024 05:11

Has he asked ? He has the right to requrst flexible working like everyone else. You accuse others of being old fashoined, I would argue that your ( or his) attitude that your DH's job is far too important to be able to commit to regular childcare is the most reggressive view on this thread. As they say the 1950's are calling. FYI I am over 40 my children are nearly grown and I have a full pension pot because my DH stood up to dinasour bosses ( with their talk of babysitting his own children) 20 years ago.

Edited

Of course he asked 😅

The moment we found out about DD he put in a statutory flexible working request

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 07:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 07:11

BananaSpanner · 04/03/2024 05:53

I’ve worked 4 days since returning from my first mat leave 11 years ago, a day off in the week to spend time with your child, catch up with life admin and help cover school holidays and illnesses is invaluable.

I’m also public sector and bear in mind that your husband can ask for a flexi working pattern that allows him a regular day off eg every Tuesday. They could make it work and loads of emergency service workers do this, I suspect he just doesn’t want to. But you seem pretty happy with that so it doesn’t matter.

My DH is wfh for a major FMCG company. He finishes before his contracted hours 4 days a week to pick the kids up from after school club, and he will also do things like pop out during the day if he needs to. However, he will also log on in the evenings and sometimes at weekends or
starts early. He respects the flexibility and delivers beyond what he needs to. He is over 40 so maybe he’s old fashioned and doesn’t need to do as much but yet he’s been promoted several times so they must like his attitude. He also notices when team members aren’t working hard.

You’re obviously doing well and have a good relationship with your boss but you do seem naive to the possibility that while you’re coasting, you might start being outperformed by harder working colleagues who deliver beyond the bare minimum that is expected of them.

Edited

Again, it’s not coasting when you can perform better than others in less time 🤷‍♀️

DH did put a flexi request in and it was rejected. So your suspicions there are also incorrect.

I am one of one doing my job at work, they struggled to find anyone to replace me for maternity so much so they had to pay 3x my salary for agency resource, it took them 18 months to recruit me - I think I’m fine

OP posts:
StealthMama · 04/03/2024 07:13

I could do 2 hours a day, as long as my work was done that’s it.

Then your contract should reflect that and you should ask your employer to accommodate that change. Everything you have described about 'mat leave cover that's actually an agency' makes that perfectly plausible.

If they are offering this level of flexibility it should be clearly stated.

You have no legal grounds for this. If they ever wanted you out, it will be very easy.

StealthMama · 04/03/2024 07:15

@Dutchairfryer if everyone here are just old buddies on Mn then why did you post here at all?

You're full of insults and self righteousness.

Mumoftwo2022 · 04/03/2024 07:16

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 14:41

I could pick up DD on option 2 and do an hour (tbh I most likely wouldn’t bother) when DH was home

And I’d like to keep DD off nursery on the Mondays to get some time together. She is currently in nursery 3 days a week so would just be adding an extra day for that option.

You wouldn’t bother doing the hour of work you are contracted to? No wonder companies are now re thinking the whole working from home thing. That’s a joke!

Bestyearever2024 · 04/03/2024 07:28

StealthMama · 04/03/2024 07:15

@Dutchairfryer if everyone here are just old buddies on Mn then why did you post here at all?

You're full of insults and self righteousness.

And ego

😊

PansyOatZebra · 04/03/2024 07:56

I’d do B until little one starts school then A in the meantime. It’s what I intend to do when our one starts school so I can do school pickups.

MiddleParking · 04/03/2024 08:07

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 07:11

Again, it’s not coasting when you can perform better than others in less time 🤷‍♀️

DH did put a flexi request in and it was rejected. So your suspicions there are also incorrect.

I am one of one doing my job at work, they struggled to find anyone to replace me for maternity so much so they had to pay 3x my salary for agency resource, it took them 18 months to recruit me - I think I’m fine

Isn’t it a new job on promotion you’re going back to though? So one in which you’ve got no track record yet, and you’ll be expected to deliver more and more stretching work in return for your significant pay rise. Also, having to pay more for agency cover for a maternity leave doesn’t really indicate anything about the staff member in question’s qualities or performance - it’s because of the relative lack of appeal of a short fixed contract without expensive employment benefits.