Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want this working pattern - DH disagreement

188 replies

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 14:19

Currently stuck in a disagreement with DH so would like to know what other people would do.

I am due to start a new role at work in a months time. It’s a promotion with a jump in salary, as I’m coming back off maternity leave I’ve been offered a few different options in terms of working pattern and the deadline for coming back to them with a final decision is this Tuesday!

Option A (DHs preference) -
WFH 4 days out of 5
Hours would be 9-3

Option B (My preference)
WFH 3 days out of 4
Mondays not working
Tuesdays - Friday working 9-4:30

Thankfully work have agreed to keep my salary the same on either option (full new amount) as the drop in hours isn’t that significant.

DH prefers option A as it means in a few months time when DD can start pre school we’d save a lot in nursery fees, as those hours match up more nicely with the school hours they stick to. I prefer the idea of having a full day off with DD though.

YABU - option A
YANBU - option B

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:12

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:08

@Dutchairfryer then you should just ask for your contract to state xx hours per working week where the working week is (presumably) Monday to Friday.

Then it doesn't matter when you work provided you are delivering your side of the contract.

Due to them needing to continue my maternity cover if I choose one option over the other this won’t fly

Again, my workplace is flexible so I don’t need to worry about the specifics too much, but a day off vs not is a change to consider

OP posts:
StampOnTheGround · 03/03/2024 21:21

My manager wouldn't care less if I finished early some days, nipped out sometimes etc. as long as all my work gets done (which it does!).

A day off a week with your DD will be lovely, maybe worry about school hours later down the line and enjoy the day off for now (is what I would do) 😊

CrazyHedgehogLover · 03/03/2024 21:27

I’d personally go with Option B.. for the sake of working an hour and a half later on them days (as opposed to the option A) but also you get an extra day with option B to spend with little one.. sounds absolutely fine personally I would jump at that choice!

however, if cost is the issue here.. then Option A would be more sensible.. I would go for Option B though until little one was starting school then I’d request the option A if possible? Take time to spend with your little one while you can!

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:28

StampOnTheGround · 03/03/2024 21:21

My manager wouldn't care less if I finished early some days, nipped out sometimes etc. as long as all my work gets done (which it does!).

A day off a week with your DD will be lovely, maybe worry about school hours later down the line and enjoy the day off for now (is what I would do) 😊

Precisely, it’s sad so many on here can’t grasp that not all workplaces are the same.

The amount of times at work during the summer I’d finish a few hours early every Friday to get some tanning done in the garden 😅

Work gets done, targets met - no issue

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 21:29

CrazyHedgehogLover · 03/03/2024 21:27

I’d personally go with Option B.. for the sake of working an hour and a half later on them days (as opposed to the option A) but also you get an extra day with option B to spend with little one.. sounds absolutely fine personally I would jump at that choice!

however, if cost is the issue here.. then Option A would be more sensible.. I would go for Option B though until little one was starting school then I’d request the option A if possible? Take time to spend with your little one while you can!

I’d not say cost is an issue, but it’s a factor (not helped by our mortgage going up so much at the same time!) it’s doable, but there is nearly £800 benefit every month once DD can start pre school if I did option a

OP posts:
StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:44

So is it a job share if they need someone to fill the hours you're not contracted for?

Or is the work divided between you both somehow?

Hercisback · 03/03/2024 21:44

If its so flexible and no one seems particularly bothered when the work gets done, why do they need your maternity cover to continue?

NewName24 · 03/03/2024 21:51

Who said I don’t pull my weight?

You did. You said you are planning to not work the hours you are employed to work.

Then you've added to it here
The amount of times at work during the summer I’d finish a few hours early every Friday to get some tanning done in the garden 😅

I'm 100% on board with flexibility if the work you do allows it. But that means doing the hours later in the evening or on a NWD if you've ducked out from your normal hours, which is completely different from accepting a contract for X hours, but actually doing X-5 or whatever it is.

Bournetilly · 03/03/2024 21:52

I’d go for option B at the moment, not sure if you’ve said how old your DD is (sorry) but assuming shes around 18months.

I wouldn’t want to put my DC in preschool until they were closer to 3 as they are less relaxed than a nursery setting (where I am anyway). Also if she’s in preschool would you need to find childcare for all school holidays? Whereas nursery is just year round childcare.

It would also be lovely to have an extra day off with your DD and means you can attend activities/ classes if you wanted to.

WorkCleanRepeat · 03/03/2024 22:03

I'd go with B (I do A and hate it)

You get to do every school pick, drop off and meal time with no day off. I'd rather pay the childcare.

spainspain · 03/03/2024 22:20

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 17:23

You're over 40 aren’t you Grin

Wow, ageist much?!

Choux · 03/03/2024 22:22

Hercisback · 03/03/2024 21:44

If its so flexible and no one seems particularly bothered when the work gets done, why do they need your maternity cover to continue?

I suspect if we heard from OPs manager it would turn out OP hasn't been performing as well as she thinks she has been.

By missing several hours when she should be working most weeks she may well be doing ok and she may have a lot of potential but she won't have been delivering as much as she could.

As you move up the ladder - she said the new role is a promotion despite the maternity cover still being in situ - the workload increases and slacking off regularly won't get the job done. Someone will cotton on that she is missing for the last hour of every wfh day and that that is impacting on her contribution to the company.

DisforDarkChocolate · 03/03/2024 22:26

B otherwise you are setting yourself up to be the default parent for all the pick ups, sick days etc. No wonder DH likes A.

FUPAgirl · 03/03/2024 22:29

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 15:40

imagine being in a workplace so rigid on hours.

Thankfully I’m hired for my brain not my bum being on a seat

Totally get this, your employer sounds like they value you and are paying you for productivity rather than exact minutes worked

MiddleParking · 03/03/2024 22:43

I’m 30 and I don’t care what hours you work or don’t work but as a manager and colleague of, among others, the odd naive pisstaker I can assure you missing an hour’s work every single day will definitely impact your performance and reputation in a way that will be more obvious to other people, and sooner, than you yourself would ever be able to assess.

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 22:47

@FUPAgirl but they aren't though. They are offering her a contract of set days and a number of hours.

Flexibility is given on the basis that the contractual agreement is being met.

You are confusing flexing when those hours are done, as opposed to how many hours are done. Culturally you are both saying that the flexibility is there, but legally it isn't.

If they are truly offering flexibility then The contract will set out KPIs/performance measures or objectives that she is measured against, irrespective of how many hours it takes to achieve them. Or simply say xx hours over xx working days.

That's not what the OP has been offered. And she intends to breach that contract.

Theres something odd that they are retaining the mat leave cover for the other days and hours that they are not offering the OP. As well as adding risk because now her performance will be stacked up against someone else directly.

Newbalancebeam · 03/03/2024 22:48

I don’t see why it’s solely your responsibility to cover school pick ups and drop offs.

WineIsMyMainVice · 03/03/2024 23:02

FUPAgirl · 03/03/2024 14:39

Oh cool!!

OK so another question - can you take option 2 but nip out and pick up dd and finish off your work later?

Can you keep dd home on Mondays or will she still have to go to nursery?

This “nip out” to get the kids mentality is exactly the reason employers are starting to ask employees back into the office! It’s ruining it for those employees who are at their desks every day for their contracted hours.
I’m all for flexible working arrangements but unless this is agreed in writing, it’s dangerous territory!

frequentlyfrazzled · 03/03/2024 23:08

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 17:53

It was true though, on this site mainly women of a certain age fall into the category of posters who can’t understand the world of work has moved on

I was going to post something relevant to your thread, but got sidetracked by your blatant ageism.
Personally I don't often see reference to, or make assumptions about, the age of posters on the threads I read.
Anyway, it sounds like you may not be aware that age has been a protected characteristic in equality law since (I think) 2010 - so I think it might be you that's behind the times...

Hoppityhophops · 03/03/2024 23:12

3 days for me without a doubt. It's worth paying for the after school club so you don't have to see any parents. 2 days seeing them is more than enough lol

Teenagehorrorbag · 03/03/2024 23:31

I can't advise re your two options, but am wondering about a couple of other things you've mentioned, which you might want to double check before you make any plans?

You say you get two weeks paid parental leave every year? Parental leave is a statutory right but it is unpaid, and usually has to be planned well in advance. Now obviously if your employer is truly generous and amazing they may have decided to pay it, but that would presumably annoy the non-parents in the workforce - so you might want to just double check that before relying on it as an option?

And you said you get unlimited annual leave? Again - how does that work? Do you mean you can ask for additional unpaid leave on top of your holiday allowance? If so, that normally only works if no-one else is off and it's convenient for the employer etc.

And emergency time off for dependants is usually unpaid and only for a single day or even a few hours to allow you to find childcare. We once had to end the contract of a single Mum whose child had really poor health, because she kept having time off to collect him from school and look after him etc. Of course that was an extreme and tragic case, but has always stuck with me.

Obviously if your company does provide all those things with pay and at short notice, then that's amazing, but in my experience as an HR professional it would be quite unusual. But of course I don't know your line of work - obviously some jobs can allow far more flex than others. But I just thought I'd mention that you might want to check.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:12

StealthMama · 03/03/2024 21:44

So is it a job share if they need someone to fill the hours you're not contracted for?

Or is the work divided between you both somehow?

Not really a job share, it would be just continuing to use an external agency resource on the one day a week I’d definitely not be working.

They weren’t able to find cover for me during mat leave so had to use an agency, so would just keep a few hours with them if I dropped the Monday

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:13

Hercisback · 03/03/2024 21:44

If its so flexible and no one seems particularly bothered when the work gets done, why do they need your maternity cover to continue?

They don’t, they’d just keep a few hours with the agency in case anything needed doing on the Monday if I dropped a day entirely.

It’s more a just in case over active cover

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:14

NewName24 · 03/03/2024 21:51

Who said I don’t pull my weight?

You did. You said you are planning to not work the hours you are employed to work.

Then you've added to it here
The amount of times at work during the summer I’d finish a few hours early every Friday to get some tanning done in the garden 😅

I'm 100% on board with flexibility if the work you do allows it. But that means doing the hours later in the evening or on a NWD if you've ducked out from your normal hours, which is completely different from accepting a contract for X hours, but actually doing X-5 or whatever it is.

It really doesn't

Always surprised at how little those on MN understand about how many businesses operate.

I could do 2 hours a day, as long as my work was done that’s it.

OP posts:
Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 00:15

Bournetilly · 03/03/2024 21:52

I’d go for option B at the moment, not sure if you’ve said how old your DD is (sorry) but assuming shes around 18months.

I wouldn’t want to put my DC in preschool until they were closer to 3 as they are less relaxed than a nursery setting (where I am anyway). Also if she’s in preschool would you need to find childcare for all school holidays? Whereas nursery is just year round childcare.

It would also be lovely to have an extra day off with your DD and means you can attend activities/ classes if you wanted to.

She is nearly 14 months, the pre school take from 18m locally.

Interesting about your comments regarding the pre school, I will have a deeper dig as yes if they’re not as safe or good as a nursery that will make that option moot!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread