Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work?

737 replies

howdypartnerrr · 16/02/2024 11:45

I worked full time until having DC, and part time since youngest DC was a few months old.

I just don't want to do it anymore. The amount I bring home is minimal.. and I find I'm spending my days off doing housework and just not having the energy to take DC to toddler groups etc. my youngest would start school in sept 2026.. so I'm thinking about just quitting until then. DH says it's up to me as my money just goes into my bank, I don't contribute to any bills so it wouldn't affect the household. My job is quite stressful.. and other more relaxed jobs involved working weekends etc and I did that with eldest dc, working weekends, Christmas Eve, Easter Sunday etc. don't want to do it again.

What do you think?

OP posts:
tattygrl · 21/02/2024 14:31

OP, despite what some posters on here would wish you to believe, you really can choose to experiment and shape your life based on what gives you the best quality of life, vitality and joy that's within your means. No choice has to be final.

carsharing · 21/02/2024 14:57

Honestly if you can quit, just do it. My husband pressured me to go back to work and I can't quite recover. Enjoy your time with your child

girlswillbegirls · 21/02/2024 17:12

greendaisie · 20/02/2024 14:25

With a stressful job and long hours, the added pressure of now also being the only provider must be such a bonus for him.

It's very likely that the earnings from one provider are higher than the combined earnings from both partners if they both worked.

By being able to focus on their career, being able to work late occasionally, being able to go on business trips etc without worrying about any of the household or childcare chores, really helps to get those promotions and higher salaries.

In other words, both partners can benefit from such a division of labour.

This is a total mistake.
Division of roles is great in theory if we can fix a situation as something permanent and guarantee it will stay that way.
But as we know things are out of our control. Illnesses, stress, one partner changing and being a total dick. We see it in MN every day.

What it really surprises me is that women keep saying this is MY particular situation and suits my family, for her to be at home and him earning the money.

It's not a particular situation. It's always the same story. Kids need care. Elderly parents need care. And women decide to sacrifice their security to do that. And men are clever enough not to risk their own security it doesn't matter the circumstances.

We need men to be more involved and share the domestic obligations. We don't need to opt out of the workforce. Its never a good idea.

Bintastic · 21/02/2024 17:53

girlswillbegirls · 21/02/2024 17:12

This is a total mistake.
Division of roles is great in theory if we can fix a situation as something permanent and guarantee it will stay that way.
But as we know things are out of our control. Illnesses, stress, one partner changing and being a total dick. We see it in MN every day.

What it really surprises me is that women keep saying this is MY particular situation and suits my family, for her to be at home and him earning the money.

It's not a particular situation. It's always the same story. Kids need care. Elderly parents need care. And women decide to sacrifice their security to do that. And men are clever enough not to risk their own security it doesn't matter the circumstances.

We need men to be more involved and share the domestic obligations. We don't need to opt out of the workforce. Its never a good idea.

Exactly. It is often followed by the blithe assertion that ‘if my husband wanted to stay at home, and I wanted to work, that would have been fine, too!’ But for some reason that rarely happens…

tryingtoenergise · 21/02/2024 18:00

Has anyone proclaimed you're not allowed to SAH yet OP? I wouldn't want you to be under the impression you can make your own decisions.

PoppiesandBumbleBees · 21/02/2024 20:06

FreeZor · 17/02/2024 23:04

This whole "enabling them to focus in their career" stuff is such nonsense. People do not need a SAHP to have a successful career! The desperate pushing of this twee little myth is a contortion of reality so extreme that you risk creating a wormhole. Many of us are living proof it is nonsense.

I have quite a few friends & family members where the woman is the main breadwinner & none of their husbands feel the need to be SAHPs looking after the kids & home to “enable” their wife to have a successful career — & none of the wives have any interest in their husbands doing that either.

Well, I know one of the husbands occasionally fantasises about quitting FT work as his wife earns so much, but he openly jokes that it would only be so he could have more time to play his PlayStation 😅

The idea that a full time homemaker is required to enable the other to have a successful full time job does seem to come up a lot more when the partner who needs enabling is the husband in my experience..

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 11:38

girlswillbegirls · 21/02/2024 17:12

This is a total mistake.
Division of roles is great in theory if we can fix a situation as something permanent and guarantee it will stay that way.
But as we know things are out of our control. Illnesses, stress, one partner changing and being a total dick. We see it in MN every day.

What it really surprises me is that women keep saying this is MY particular situation and suits my family, for her to be at home and him earning the money.

It's not a particular situation. It's always the same story. Kids need care. Elderly parents need care. And women decide to sacrifice their security to do that. And men are clever enough not to risk their own security it doesn't matter the circumstances.

We need men to be more involved and share the domestic obligations. We don't need to opt out of the workforce. Its never a good idea.

Well, like most things that offer reward there's a risk element. Maybe he leaves you for a younger model and you struggle financially. Or maybe he doesn't and you quit full time work at 30yo and get to really enjoy your life while he works another 35 years.

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 11:41

PoppiesandBumbleBees · 21/02/2024 20:06

I have quite a few friends & family members where the woman is the main breadwinner & none of their husbands feel the need to be SAHPs looking after the kids & home to “enable” their wife to have a successful career — & none of the wives have any interest in their husbands doing that either.

Well, I know one of the husbands occasionally fantasises about quitting FT work as his wife earns so much, but he openly jokes that it would only be so he could have more time to play his PlayStation 😅

The idea that a full time homemaker is required to enable the other to have a successful full time job does seem to come up a lot more when the partner who needs enabling is the husband in my experience..

Well, women are statistically much more likely to divorce a man who earns less or is a SAHP so it's not surprising men aren't too keen to be one.

Rotebeete · 22/02/2024 14:38

tryingtoenergise · 21/02/2024 18:00

Has anyone proclaimed you're not allowed to SAH yet OP? I wouldn't want you to be under the impression you can make your own decisions.

Grin
LorlieS · 22/02/2024 14:41

@FatPrincess I can only comment personally of course...
My ex-husband earned a six-figure salary but my marriage ended up being completely loveless; he was driven purely by money.
My husband now earns around £20k pa and I have never been so happy. I am finally treated with complete respect and feel very loved indeed ❤️

girlswillbegirls · 22/02/2024 17:58

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 11:38

Well, like most things that offer reward there's a risk element. Maybe he leaves you for a younger model and you struggle financially. Or maybe he doesn't and you quit full time work at 30yo and get to really enjoy your life while he works another 35 years.

Yes there is always a risk element to everything. It's about how much you are prepared to put up with if you are screwed.

Women don't want SAHD in general because they don't want to maintain an adult for life (talking about staying at home long term). But for some reason a big proportion of adult women feel perfectly entitled to stop contributing for decades.

We have to teach our girls not to be looking for price charming to look after them. We need to teach them to be capable, use their degrees and share both financial and domestic responsibilities. That makes more sense to me.

LorlieS · 22/02/2024 18:06

@girlswillbegirls Absolutely. To me it's total double standards here.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/02/2024 18:52

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 11:38

Well, like most things that offer reward there's a risk element. Maybe he leaves you for a younger model and you struggle financially. Or maybe he doesn't and you quit full time work at 30yo and get to really enjoy your life while he works another 35 years.

Surely the aim should be for both people to really enjoy their lives? I couldn't imagine opting out of financial responsibility to 'really enjoy' my life whilst watching the person I'm supposed to love work like a dog for 35 years.

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 19:52

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/02/2024 18:52

Surely the aim should be for both people to really enjoy their lives? I couldn't imagine opting out of financial responsibility to 'really enjoy' my life whilst watching the person I'm supposed to love work like a dog for 35 years.

Well, I agree. It's a massive female privilege to have that choice but say that on here and you'll be chased with pitchforks! 🤣

OneMoreTime23 · 22/02/2024 20:30

LorlieS · 22/02/2024 18:06

@girlswillbegirls Absolutely. To me it's total double standards here.

I’ve just been fish-hooked on another thread for suggesting the main earning mum continue working and dad go part time. 🤷🏻‍♀️

BananaPalm · 22/02/2024 21:38

@SouthLondonMum22 Surely the aim should be for both people to really enjoy their lives? I couldn't imagine opting out of financial responsibility to 'really enjoy' my life whilst watching the person I'm supposed to love work like a dog for 35 years.

Couldn't agree more. If a man said "is it ok for me to not to work and let my wife support me" I'm sure he wouldn't be met with all this "yeah, just quit your job and live off your wife".

Either you're an adult who has an equal responsibility for sustaining yours and your children's lives (emotionally, physically, financially, etc) or you're just another child yourself. I'm obviously excluding any disabilities or people just rich enough not to have to have to work.

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 22:04

BananaPalm · 22/02/2024 21:38

@SouthLondonMum22 Surely the aim should be for both people to really enjoy their lives? I couldn't imagine opting out of financial responsibility to 'really enjoy' my life whilst watching the person I'm supposed to love work like a dog for 35 years.

Couldn't agree more. If a man said "is it ok for me to not to work and let my wife support me" I'm sure he wouldn't be met with all this "yeah, just quit your job and live off your wife".

Either you're an adult who has an equal responsibility for sustaining yours and your children's lives (emotionally, physically, financially, etc) or you're just another child yourself. I'm obviously excluding any disabilities or people just rich enough not to have to have to work.

Once the finances are shared, though, it becomes 'our' money. The royal 'we'.

"We earn enough that I don't need to work".

Calamitousness · 23/02/2024 07:29

Here’s a thought. How about people
can be different and some split their outgoings equally with equal responsibility then save the rest as their own money ( which I don’t understand) some can proportionally represent their earning power to contribute to family outgoings (again to me bizarre but each to their own) or some families can operate as one and whatever income is completely shared whomever is working whatever hours and they decide amongst themselves if one chooses to stay home or both work full time or a full/part time combo. But ultimately it’s individual couples shared decision making how the household and finances work. That’s actual life. Nobody needs all the you should do it my way because it’s not fair to the other partner blah blah. Other partner is part of the shared decision making in how their family works. He/she doesn’t need a random on the internet being all paternalistic for them. So you do you. And if circumstances ever change for whatever reason then your shared decisions can change.

girlswillbegirls · 23/02/2024 08:09

@Calamitousness The OP posted a question here and people are giving different points of view. If she didn't have any doubt about what she is about to do, she wouldn't post it in a forum.

We have discussed risk, we have discuss responsibility. Also how men also deserve to enjoy their kids and not just be the sole breadwinners. It's deeper than "we made the decision as a couple". You can stop being a couple for various reasons and it happens, in fact all the time. It's for the OP and whoever is reading this that our point of view might be valuable.

BadCovers · 23/02/2024 08:14

FatPrincess · 22/02/2024 19:52

Well, I agree. It's a massive female privilege to have that choice but say that on here and you'll be chased with pitchforks! 🤣

Honestly, the only two places I’ve ever come across the (to me, deeply odd and reactionary) idea that women’s work/careers become optional once they give birth is (1) on here and (2) in a village I lived in for a few years where I was one of only two WOHMs in DS’s class of 27 kids, and considered ‘odd’ for working because DH had a ‘big job’.

Stats suggest just under three quarters of women with young children work, and that a significant number of those who don’t would prefer to work if they had good, reliable, affordable childcare.

Calamitousness · 23/02/2024 08:22

Really @girlswillbegirls
well I’ll be quite honest. It’s not being posted as ‘opinion and info’ it’s coming across very much like there is only one way to run your family life. I am trying to balance that by saying that yes it is actually as simple as both ‘competent. Sentient. Adults’ makai g their own choices how to live their life. Try it !

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 08:34

Calamitousness · 23/02/2024 08:22

Really @girlswillbegirls
well I’ll be quite honest. It’s not being posted as ‘opinion and info’ it’s coming across very much like there is only one way to run your family life. I am trying to balance that by saying that yes it is actually as simple as both ‘competent. Sentient. Adults’ makai g their own choices how to live their life. Try it !

There's been a variety of opinions, especially as it is such a long thread.

Of course people will ultimately do what they want, Mumsnet would be very quiet though if no discussion happened.

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 10:16

There's 'discussion' and then there's 'unhealthy obsession'. The second is very obvious to all except, sadly, the posters concerned. They are not giving 'advice' - its way beyond that. They are repeatedly trying to reassure themselves that their own decisions and marriages are really ok, which is quite sad. If you are truly happy, what other women do has no impact on you - that's the key. You can live and let live. People who moralise, patronise and whose thinking is inflexible and repetitive are quite evident. It comes from a place of insecurity, whether they can recognise it or not.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 10:40

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 10:16

There's 'discussion' and then there's 'unhealthy obsession'. The second is very obvious to all except, sadly, the posters concerned. They are not giving 'advice' - its way beyond that. They are repeatedly trying to reassure themselves that their own decisions and marriages are really ok, which is quite sad. If you are truly happy, what other women do has no impact on you - that's the key. You can live and let live. People who moralise, patronise and whose thinking is inflexible and repetitive are quite evident. It comes from a place of insecurity, whether they can recognise it or not.

Sexism has an impact on everyone. It's import to discuss it, I'm not sure why you seem to want to silence those who are interested in engaging and discussing when it's easy to simply not join in if you aren't interested.

Are those who argue that working mothers are selfish, materialistic and don't even raise their own children on this thread also insecure and are trying to reassure themselves that their decisions and marriages are really ok? Or does it magically only apply to those who wish to discuss the impact gender stereotypes and sexism has on society and equality in a wider context?

BadCovers · 23/02/2024 10:44

Thoroughly seconded, @SouthLondonMum22. Sexism and unthinking gendered assumptions in general, aren’t something that magically ends at the edges of an individual life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread