Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work?

737 replies

howdypartnerrr · 16/02/2024 11:45

I worked full time until having DC, and part time since youngest DC was a few months old.

I just don't want to do it anymore. The amount I bring home is minimal.. and I find I'm spending my days off doing housework and just not having the energy to take DC to toddler groups etc. my youngest would start school in sept 2026.. so I'm thinking about just quitting until then. DH says it's up to me as my money just goes into my bank, I don't contribute to any bills so it wouldn't affect the household. My job is quite stressful.. and other more relaxed jobs involved working weekends etc and I did that with eldest dc, working weekends, Christmas Eve, Easter Sunday etc. don't want to do it again.

What do you think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
matrixxx · 23/02/2024 18:06

Anyway, I'm out for dinner this evening, but thanks for the chat and good luck with thd twins.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 18:05

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 17:58

That's fine as long as you realise real equality will never be achieved by guilt-tripping mothers into working (if they don't need to), any more than it was about guilt-tripping them into being at home. It also won't be achieved by pretending women are identical to men in every respect. If women struggle more with being separated from their children (which they do, on the whole), that doesn't make them weak or silly or anti-feminist or whatever. Those feelings are real and valid, always were and always will be. This is important for real equality.

Talking about societal issues surrounding sexism, gender stereotyping and equality isn't guilt tripping mothers into working. I've also never claimed that SAHM's are weak or silly so I'm not sure where that is coming from.

Bintastic · 23/02/2024 18:01

tryingtoenergise · 23/02/2024 11:30

@SouthLondonMum22 - forgive me if I have this wrong, but are you the poster whose baby went into full-time nursery at 12 weeks? And you have been very honest that you hated SAH in those 12 weeks because you found it extremely boring.

No judgement from me. However, I understand your point that, in society, you are more likely to feel judged for this rather than your husband. I completely get that.

However, going on and on about 'sexism' to women who feel the opposite to you - ie. they couldn't imagine NOT being with their baby - is a total irrelevance. Having a full time job with a young baby is not less 'sexist' - it just means (in your case) you were not cut out to SAH and oreferrrd ti work. In other cases, women are forced to return to work before they are 100% ready. It's obvious that everyone is different and this derailing of every thread with chants of 'sexism', gets nobody anywhere.

Its not as simple as 'sexism.' It's women acting instinctively and yes, in many cases, this may be different to their men. It's not all about 'socialisation', it really isn't. If you know that, you know it. Other women are just as independent-thinking as you - they are just different in this respect. That's ok.

If you're happy with your DH and using childcare from 12 weeks, that's absolutely fine and it's great you can be honest. You need to do what makes you happy. But you can't dictate this for everyone because, you must realise, many (most?) women would never choose to live like that because they have different priorities and it would make them very unhappy indeed. Would a society where all babies were in childcare at a young age be any happier? I don't think so. Choice and respecting other women's choices is always preferable - on an individual and societal level. You have made your choices, let other women make theirs. Women who feel an urge to SAH are, like you, just being honest with themselves. I don't want to get into this any further because it just goes nowhere but surely you can understand this. If another woman tells you how she feels and what she wants for her children and in her marriage, just believe her and accept it.

So accept the gender pay gap and the status quo? Er no thanks.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 17:58

That's fine as long as you realise real equality will never be achieved by guilt-tripping mothers into working (if they don't need to), any more than it was about guilt-tripping them into being at home. It also won't be achieved by pretending women are identical to men in every respect. If women struggle more with being separated from their children (which they do, on the whole), that doesn't make them weak or silly or anti-feminist or whatever. Those feelings are real and valid, always were and always will be. This is important for real equality.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 17:19

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 17:04

If it's about 'all our wants and needs', then why castigate parents whose wants and needs differ from the 'two working parents / kids in childcare' model.

If you say your DH would be the one to give up work if necessary, because he is the lower earner, then why castigate women who have done just that because they are the lower earner?

Maybe women who don't want their children in childcare gravitate to the type of men who earn enough, or who wouldn't expect their kids to be in childcare? Nurseries and nannies are hardly the default course of action! You would say that's 'sexist' but so what? Better to have choice than no choice. A society in which all women would have to rush back to work as soon as their babies were 12 weeks, might be less 'sexist' by your definition, but it would be very dire for most.

Care to point out where I said that all women should go back to work at 12 weeks just because that's what I did? Or that I believe that women shouldn't have any choice at all? I have never said either of those things.

I'd just like things to be more equal in society, that's all. No double standards when it comes to mothers working vs fathers working and for society to see childcare as both parents responsibility, not just a mothers responsibility.

I don't think that's too much to ask.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 17:04

If it's about 'all our wants and needs', then why castigate parents whose wants and needs differ from the 'two working parents / kids in childcare' model.

If you say your DH would be the one to give up work if necessary, because he is the lower earner, then why castigate women who have done just that because they are the lower earner?

Maybe women who don't want their children in childcare gravitate to the type of men who earn enough, or who wouldn't expect their kids to be in childcare? Nurseries and nannies are hardly the default course of action! You would say that's 'sexist' but so what? Better to have choice than no choice. A society in which all women would have to rush back to work as soon as their babies were 12 weeks, might be less 'sexist' by your definition, but it would be very dire for most.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 16:47

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 16:22

I think once children come along, it doesn't do to define yourselves by who earns what or who is working and who is not. It's not actually about you anymore (as in the adults) - its about the children. There's no point in separate finances either because it all goes the same way ultimately - ie. mostly on the kids. What is the point? Legally, you are a financial unit, so why not just share money if it's all going the same way? It's not as if you're going to sit down when you're 80 and the kids have left and make a spreadsheet of who spent what and who earned what over the decades. It's all the same, either way. You are a family.

It's about managing all of our wants and needs, including adults because despite the fact that we are now parents, we are also still people with as pp said above career paths and the such like which continue to be important to us.

Separate finances works incredibly well for us. I wouldn't be with someone who expected to pool all finances.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 16:35

No but, if push came to shove, I'm sure you would prioritise your children over career paths. And the money you earn is for them primarily, not yourself.

BadCovers · 23/02/2024 16:32

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 16:22

I think once children come along, it doesn't do to define yourselves by who earns what or who is working and who is not. It's not actually about you anymore (as in the adults) - its about the children. There's no point in separate finances either because it all goes the same way ultimately - ie. mostly on the kids. What is the point? Legally, you are a financial unit, so why not just share money if it's all going the same way? It's not as if you're going to sit down when you're 80 and the kids have left and make a spreadsheet of who spent what and who earned what over the decades. It's all the same, either way. You are a family.

I find this deeply odd. DH and I are parents to DS, of course, but we’re also two individual adults with individual career paths, job satisfaction, professional achievements etc, not just interchangeable earning units generating a moneyflow for the sake of our offspring. We haven’t suddenly become nodes in the Borg just because we had a child.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 16:22

I think once children come along, it doesn't do to define yourselves by who earns what or who is working and who is not. It's not actually about you anymore (as in the adults) - its about the children. There's no point in separate finances either because it all goes the same way ultimately - ie. mostly on the kids. What is the point? Legally, you are a financial unit, so why not just share money if it's all going the same way? It's not as if you're going to sit down when you're 80 and the kids have left and make a spreadsheet of who spent what and who earned what over the decades. It's all the same, either way. You are a family.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 16:08

Rotebeete · 23/02/2024 15:54

if one of us had to give up work due to some catastrophic event then my DH would because it would be easier financially.

There may be non catastrophic events that would benefit from one of you to being at home for a while. I'd keep an open mind too.

What events are you thinking of?

I just can't see it due to our personalities and principles.

Rotebeete · 23/02/2024 15:54

if one of us had to give up work due to some catastrophic event then my DH would because it would be easier financially.

There may be non catastrophic events that would benefit from one of you to being at home for a while. I'd keep an open mind too.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 15:43

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 15:32

If I had had to work, due to some catastrophic event, then I would have had to. Like anyone else. If I'd felt like returning to work at some point, then I would have done that. People do change. The way you look at life at 20 or 30 will be different to when you are 40 of 50.

Like I said, if one of us had to give up work due to some catastrophic event then my DH would because it would be easier financially. By choice for either of us would be incredibly unlikely because both of us would have to drastically change our principles and I just don't see that happening any time soon.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 15:32

If I had had to work, due to some catastrophic event, then I would have had to. Like anyone else. If I'd felt like returning to work at some point, then I would have done that. People do change. The way you look at life at 20 or 30 will be different to when you are 40 of 50.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 15:26

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 15:16

"Neither of us wish to be solely responsible for providing financially."

When neither of you have slept properly for a year, or if one doesn't settle in nursery, you might feel differently. I remember having 3 kids under the age of 4, it's a lot. Every family has its breaking point and there's only so much headspace parents can have before you feel like you're just surviving as a couple, rather than thriving. Hardly surprising that different families find different balances.

You said that you never contemplated needing to use childcare of any form. I'm assuming that your feelings never changed, so why would mine?

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 15:16

"Neither of us wish to be solely responsible for providing financially."

When neither of you have slept properly for a year, or if one doesn't settle in nursery, you might feel differently. I remember having 3 kids under the age of 4, it's a lot. Every family has its breaking point and there's only so much headspace parents can have before you feel like you're just surviving as a couple, rather than thriving. Hardly surprising that different families find different balances.

Rotebeete · 23/02/2024 15:03

Neither of us wish to be solely responsible for providing financially.

That's fine, but other families are happy with sharing their income and supporting each other in other, non financial, ways.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 14:54

Rotebeete · 23/02/2024 14:48

Neither of us like the idea of the other one not working by choice and I don't see how that would ever change.

You seem to have a very narrow definition of 'working' - I assume you mean working in return for money?

There are so many more ways that a person can contribute to society.

It's very clear what was meant by working, especially in the context of the discussion I was having with pp.

I was meaning in regards to contributing financially which is why DH and I believe it should be both of us, not just one of us. Neither of us wish to be solely responsible for providing financially.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 14:52

You have been in many threads trying to argue that SAHMs = sexism, essentially. The priority in your marriage is that you and your DH both work because you equate this with equality. That's one type of marriage. Most people are not this rigid about such things.

I'm saying that equality comes in many different forms. What you call 'sexist,' other women call positive choice and / or necessity. Also, you never know what the future holds so good to keep an open mind
because one day you may feel differently or need to adapt. Same as anyone else.

Rotebeete · 23/02/2024 14:48

Neither of us like the idea of the other one not working by choice and I don't see how that would ever change.

You seem to have a very narrow definition of 'working' - I assume you mean working in return for money?

There are so many more ways that a person can contribute to society.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 14:38

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 14:33

Well that's your marriage @SouthLondonMum22. It's not a blueprint for anyone else. In my family, I never contemplated needing to use childcare of any form.

You have your principles and I have mine. Such is life.

I never said it was. You're the one who has just tried to tell me that I might want to suddenly take some time out of work just because I'll be a mother to 3 children.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 14:33

Well that's your marriage @SouthLondonMum22. It's not a blueprint for anyone else. In my family, I never contemplated needing to use childcare of any form.

You have your principles and I have mine. Such is life.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 14:16

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 13:51

You might find you want to take time out at some point in the future - for all kinds of reasons. Three kids is a lot - trust me. Nothing is ever set in stone.

DH is going to have three kids too. If anyone was to take some time out, it would be him.

However, it is incredibly unlikely that it will happen by choice. Neither of us like the idea of the other one not working by choice and I don't see how that would ever change.

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 13:51

You might find you want to take time out at some point in the future - for all kinds of reasons. Three kids is a lot - trust me. Nothing is ever set in stone.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/02/2024 13:37

matrixxx · 23/02/2024 13:30

Of course there are reasons you may need to take time out of the workplace in the future@SouthLondonMum22. Or your DH, whatever. What if one of your children is long-term or seriously ill (heaven forbid). What if they are school refusers, or anorexic, or suicidal . Nobody can assume these things won't happen. Life is more complicated than ever for teens now - so much influence from social media. So many teens and pre-teens who school refuse or isolate themselves because of mental health issues, gender confusion, bullying. A family member has recently had to leave work because her daughter is school refusing and at high risk from self-harm - this came out of nowhere. I hope none of this ever comes your way. But if your work plans do ever need to change, I hope you won't be too hard in yourself and I hope your DH won't be either because there are many times in life when there really are more important issues than who earns what in a family.

You only just mentioned my DH now. You worded it before like because I'm a mother, there may be a reason why I'd need to take time out of the workplace where as you've just said, it could just as much happen to my DH too.

In fact, it would be my DH that would take time out of work should anything like your examples ever happen because I'm the higher earner.